Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Need quick help

Posts

Need quick help

#1

Need quick help

Dean Lapinel

>I'm at this moment, taking a break from selecting wood from my stock pile of woods.

The project is Simon Watts Library Steps as depicted in FWW July/August 1979, No. 17 page 80.

Bubinga is probably too heavy for a piece that gets moved about quite a bit so I was going to use some walnut...of which I have an excess.

As I was looking at my stock and studying the template on page 81 I became concerned with the grain orientation as selected by Mr. Watts. I noticed that David Marks made a similar (simpler) version but had the grain perpendicular to the floor.

Mr. Watts approach may be correct but it doesn't seem intuitive to me and...wood selection is more difficult.

Thanks to those that will take the time to pull this design from their library or DVD and offer opinions!

I'll sit here and wait instead of facing my shop mess :)

Dean

Re: Need quick help

#2

Re: Need quick help

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I remembered the steps, but did not realize they were done by Watts. I think he has the best grain orientation for his design (sure looks like 70's stuff!). I think he glued up two or three cherry boards to make the 21 in width. I would round or chamfer the toes a bit because they would be short grain ready to break off. Kinda looks like fun with all the angles, good luck.

Re: Need quick help

#3

Re: Need quick help

Dean Lapinel

>But doesn't it seem that there is a sacrifice of the rear legs to accomadate the grain in the front? Once your're on the second step the force vectors are distributing a significant amount of weight to the rear.

Re: Need quick help

#4

(sure looks like 70's stuff!)

Dean Lapinel

>I missed that comment.

I'm not sure I know what part of the style looks like 70's stuff. It looks like a "still" common style to me.

Would you do me the favor of clarifying what I'm missing?

Re: Need quick help

#5

Re: Need quick help

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>You have to have the grain on the sides vertical to avoid having them cross-grain with the steps. Without vertical grain the dovetails and the tenons will not work. If you are worried about the rear legs, you could tilt the grain slightly to favor them, or as Watts suggests, alter the bottom cutout to give them a little more beef. Many traditional benches with board feet have cutouts on the bottom and scrollwork on the sides and have held up well. The style is not bad, just very reminiscent of the times.

Re: Need quick help

#6

Re: Need quick help

ThomD

>It says in the book to adjust the angles to favour the rear legs in the joint you are using to piece up the sides (asumes you can't find full width piece, though an inverted crotch would be nice). In theory you could go as much as 1 to 8 in the joint, probably more, to piece the back in. If by chance you are required to use three pieces you could build in more. You do want to be a little subtle about it though, so that it doesn't look like pieces of pie.

Keep in mind also that the loads are being born across a fairly wide piece of wood. Any break would have to be a split and even with the wood coming in a near vertical direction, you would have more than 5 inches of hardwood to shear through. If your board was parallel to the front it would actually be a longer split. This is one fourth of the weight caried, though I suppose one needs to consider all of the weight coming on one leg only, but it is still a big split. Mostly women seem to use these things, since I can reach an 8' ceiling, anyway, without stepping off the ground. Wy wife can stand on the corner of a cardboard box, the type with less than 1/4" of coragated carcboard in it. So I don't see her shearing this baby.

By the way, Watts is a wooden boat builder. Normally that means a guy who thinks of wood in structural terms, and has a feel for scantlings and dimensions. That would be good enough for me.

As far as the style is concerned, well it isn't Arts and Crafts, so you should slink off in shame. Actually that is one of my favourite FWW books. There is a lot of furniture in it, and Watts builds a lot by hand, he has one hand crippled. A lot of the furniture at least in B&W where the wood doesn't speak up much, is a little simple and boxy. But there are some very beautiful pieces in there and I built a few of them in early days. I suspect his furniture is much better today, since at least as far as the craddle is concerned he since developed a masterpiece, it would be interesting to know if he has brought many of the pieces up from these earlier examples.