Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

China trip

Posts

China trip

#1

China trip

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>(also posted on Main board)

I'll be in Shanghai and Beijing next month and will have a lot of free time. Unfortunately, I know virtually nothing about the two cities. What woodworking sights are there to see? Does anyone know of any dealers of antique woodworking hand tools?

Thanks.

Best, Ted

Re: China trip

#2

Re: China trip

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Ted,

My wife and I travelled to China in 1998 to adopt our daughter. We travelled with seven families, one of the dad's was a woodworker like I. We spent time in Beijing and Hangzhou. During free time we looked all over the place for tools, we came up dry. What we found though was that we were looking with a different value with our eyes, we were missing a lot of the obvious. They have a different view on tools, most that we saw were home made and very basic, I will always remember a small home made table saw made with a plywood top and a motor and pullies. We found no tools that most western people would value....but many unique tools and all hand made.

Take care,

Jim

Re: China trip

#3

One way...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Well, Ted...

Let me give you my approach to 'tourism' which sometimes works well in developing countries. You have a unique opportunity, the 2008 Olympics and all, to find China on its best behavior (okay, Tibet's kinda rocky, buy 'hey'), 2008's as close as they're getting to sycophancy antime soon.

I'd first call the DOC (or write, but calling's better) and ask for either the country expert/s for People's Republic of China or the industry expert on things-to-do-with-wood-and-tools. Remember, you're a taxpayer, and if approached politely, DOC country and industry experts, who routinely interact with PRC's Ministry of Commerce, have been known (in my experience) to go the extra mile in helping you do whatever it is so long as it's in their bailiwick.

Anyway, they should know just who to call at State to contact the appropriate cultural attach� in your destination cities to set up a truly customized travel experience. (Okay, you could directly call State first, but... I'd call Commerce first). Just tell them you'll blog it all up when you get home. They like that.

Seriously. Explain how little we handtooler's know about traditional Chinese hand woodworking, toolmaking, building, whatever, archeological, modern, again whatever. Maybe explain that you don't mind seeing handtools being manufactured, but you're NOT interested in powertools. If there's anything along these lines, don't be surprised if you get guided tours (with translator). Tell them museums are fine, of course, but small workshops would be nice, too. If you don't strike it lucky, at least you should get a few solid leads.

Ask before taking pictures (it'll be okay). Try not to say "back in Langley" when you're drinking the local grog.

Re: China trip

#4

Re: China trip

Joel

>I have not been to China. Went I went to Viet Nam I just asked around and eventually I learned the right questions and got good answers. Most tourist agencies have no idea how to treat unusual requests.

I would however find a copy (it's out of print) of "China at Work" from the 1930's it's the best work ever written in English on Chinese crafts. My guess is almost all of what's in the book has disappeared but a little background might help you figure out what you are looking at when you see it. About 1/3 of the book is on woodworking.

Re: China trip

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: China trip

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Ted,I know absolutely nothing about China. However,a client of mine collects and has a houseful of Chinese furniture. These pieces all appear to have been crafted with hand tools. No signs of machinery,uniformity,anywhere.Alot of carving.Interesting useof dovetails.Alot of mortise/tenon joinery.Whole pieces made to resemble animals. There must be examples of the tools used somewhere.Have fun.---Jack

Re: China trip

#6

Chris Scholz

Re: China trip

Chris Scholz

>Ted,

I traveled to various locations in China; I manufacture woodworking tools in a small shop in a remote village in China using traditional methods.

Usually I stay away from laowai tours and travel like the locals; gives a whole new meaning to the saying about the journey and the destination.

A few things to keep in mind when looking for hand tools in China:

1) Although I doubt that Hommel was a woodworker, his book is outstanding; the Mercer Museum in Doylestown, PA supposedly hosts Hommel's collection, most likely the only such collection worldwide. I also recommend Gustav Ecke's book (no information on tools), as well as Ruitenbeek's annotated translation of the Lu Ban Jing (very little information about tools). FWW had an article on Chinese woodworking, I believe it was issue #37 (a shout-out to Jeff Schmidt for sending me a copy of the article!)

2) You can purchase woodworking tools at many hardware stores in China. It takes a bit of walking around though. When you get to the neighborhood where you see many stores that sell nails, screws, and other hardware you might find a store that stocks a few cases of planes, blades, wedges, saws, and such.

3) Sometimes you can find tools at the open-air street markets. Many of 0the tools sold there are blanks and will require major tuning.

4) In the old Confucian society the social status of woodworkers was (and to some extend still is) very low. Only business people and entrepreneurs ranked lower. My experience is that locals simply do not believe you when you ask them for information on woodworking tools.

5) The tool cult that we developed during the last Century does not exist (yet). A tool is just that: a tool. Most of the Chinese tools are outstanding when used by a skilled craftsman.

6) Many tools were (are) made by the craftsmen to meet a specific need. Since there is a thousand-year long tradition of standardization, apprenticeship and strong labor unions, most tools end up looking pretty much the same.

7) Traditionally the woodworkers lived in the household where they made the furniture. Furniture was custom made/custom fit on the spot to the specification of the owner. Very often the owner supplied the wood, more often than not he also supplied the tools.

8) Traditional woodworking is all but gone in the cities, to see real woodworking in action you need to go the the countryside. This can be rather difficult for a tourist with limited time and lack of language skills.

9) It is close to impossible to photograph craftsmen at work in China. Today's China is hyper-capitalistic and hyper-competitive; craftsmen are afraid that the competition in the the neighboring booth might learn some trade secret.

10) In my experience only place you might find workshops in the cities are furniture restoration shops. Some of the anonymous folks in these workshops are absolute masters of their craft with skills that far exceed that of our own heroes. Some of them can fake antiques so well that even well-known experts get fooled on a regular basis. For obvious reasons getting access to these shops requires more than excellent local contacts.

11) If you visit Shanghai, don't miss the trip down to Suzhou. Suzhou is famous for its gardens and you will see plenty of "Ming-style" furniture. In China furniture was never considered art; today collectors are going bananas over this type of furniture. High-end NY condos and super-expensive properties tend to feature a few of these pieces of furniture.

12) There are plenty of antiques stores in Shanghai. There are plenty of books geared towards collectors that have extensive address lists.

You will have a hard time fining any tools in these stores though. Furniture you buy at the tourist spots is fake, some fakes are rather excellent and well worth the money.

Don't hesitate to contact me if you need more information. Our phone number is in the contacts sections of the galoot-tools website. But most importantly, enjoy your trip.

Chris

Re: China trip

#7

Re: China trip

ThomD

>"I will always remember a small home made table saw made with a plywood top and a motor and pullies."

That has been on my list for some time, ever since FWW published the wooden saw plans. I don't use a TS enough to have it in my current shop, I used to have a 3HP General, but if I ever go larger I will make one for sure. In fact, making the arbor is on my immediate to-do list.

Re: China trip

#8

Re: China trip

ThomD

>Chris, that's an interesting sumary. That article is an all time favorite of mine. The Author wrote a second article later on that was about a chair he designed based on what he took away from the experience in 37. As far as I know the guy is still in Oregon, and it would be interesting to know if he took it any further.

Those articles set me about making and trying to find chinese tools. That is now pretty easy, and I am no longer as interested as I was at the time. What is interesting about what little that has come to use from China versus Japan, is that the Chineses stuff is mostly related to very hard woods. The Japanese use hard woods, but it isn't in the frame of temple carpentry and shoji that largely describes the Japanese projects that get exposure here.