Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

What to do about stripped threads?

Posts

What to do about stripped threads?

#1

What to do about stripped threads?

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Gentlemen:

Just received a plough plane of'n the bay. Stupid me, I didn't ask the seller if the depth stop mechanism was working. It ain't--threads stripped. So this plane has become a project.

Facts. It's an A. Mathieson and Son plane (Glasgow & Edinburgh vintage). Wedge arm. Actually what attracted me to the plane was how perfect the arm wedges and main wedge are.

But anyway, the depth stop is the familiar one that has a brass thumbscrew which turns a steel drive screw. Down in the body of the plane, this steel drive screw is threaded into a brass plunger. The brass plunger has a steel shoe on the bottom, which alights on the work when you are at depth. As the brass thumbscrew is turned CW or CCW, it pulls or pushes the brass plunger up or down, raising or lowering the plunger/shoe assembly.

Now the steel drive screw is in great shape. But the matching threads inside the brass plunger are stripped useless. Someone forced this thing so badly, that the drive screw slides easily in and out of the plunger--the threads are not close to engaging. I'm searching in the UK for a replacement part, but realistically that's not gonna happen. So am trying to figure out if there is a fix using the original parts as much as possible.

What the heck is this steel drive screw? It mikes 0.290" major diameter, the pitch is right at 1/16", or 16 threads per inch. It's a pretty deep thread--I estimate the minor diameter is about 0.20".

What to do? In a perfect world, there would be a way to drill out the stripped brass threads in the plunger, fill the hole with round brass stock, re-tap and re-thread to match the drive screw. (There isn't enough width in the plunger block to accommodate a threaded insert.) But I can't imagine finding a tap or an insert to match that drive screw.

A crazy idea...It occurred to me that maybe I could buy some brass shim stock, cut the right-size piece of it and work that piece into the stripped recess in the brass plunger, with some adhesive behind it. Then run the steel screw in, and let the screw cut its own new threads in the shim stock lining.

Can any of you folks follow this?? Any thoughts on how to fix this depth adjuster would be appreciated. Yeah, I know the plane will work without it.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#2

could be BSW

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>The threads are likely to be british standard whitworth. If so you best bet may be someone who is into restoring old british cars.

Robin

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#3

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Bob Hackett

>If I had the proper tap on hand I`d just braze up the stripped shoe then drill and retap.

Mainely,Bob

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#4

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Alan DuBoff

>Yes, I think it would work to re-die the thread and/or add a sleeve over the top after you do so. In order to add a sleeve, you would need to make enough clearance by removing some from the threaded screw portion, and some from the threaded nut portion. Without seeing a pic, hard to tell. Wylie should be able to find a machinist in SoCal, they're a dime a dozen down there, could be the machinists capitol of the U.S.

Wylie, If you try it yourself, remember to continue to lubricate as you cut, WD40 should be ok for that, it is commonly used by machinists. Also, don't try to cut too much, only take 3/4 to a full turn, and back it off before you continue to cut more. Taps and dies are easily broken, I have a tap stuck from one such similar event on a fixture I use on my mini-mill. Lubricate after ever few turns at minimum. It might be possible to buy a threaded sleeve, I don't know. Otherwise you could jb weld or epoxy a sleeve in place so you could tap it.

Can you post a pic?

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#5

Re: could be BSW *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>BSW pitch doesn't get to 16 until the dia. gets to 3/8"


Whitworth sizes

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#6

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wiley

Here's what I would try as a last resort (it is reversable, so you have nothing to lose).

Fill the female section with epoxy or JB Weld. Add a release agent to the male section, the thread (a cooking spray would work). Then insert the male section and leave until the epoxy hardens. Unscrew the bolt, and Bob's your uncle.

My preference would be to rethread, as per your original idea. If you cannot find the correct tap, how do you feel about replacing the steel rod and using an alternative thread?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#7

Re: What they did about stripped threads?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

Here is a traditional method that might work for your application. First remove the brass part, heat it up and quench it to anneal the brass. Then place the iron threaded part into the hole and with a round faced small punch, upset the brass near the iron thread (avoid damaging the iron threads). Continue around the hole until the brass meets the iron.

You can then unthread the piece, heat up the brass and place it in ashes or hot sand and let it cool slowly to harden the brass.

Stephen

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#8

machine shop

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You have the advantage of living in a large populated area which means lots of machine shops. Just because the thread size looks strange, don't give up on the idea that someone can fix in the way you describe. Visit a machi8ne shop that does small stuff and ask them if they can fix or if they know who can fix it. There will be a shop somewhere that will not think this a difficult task.

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#9

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Ace Karner

>This is what I would try first.

http://store.summitracing.com/partdetail.asp?part=lct-37390

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#11

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

A good way to solve your stripped thread problem is to use what is called a "Heli-Coil". This is a spring shaped device that is screwed into a special thread size on the outside diameter of the coil with a thread to match your screw on the inside. There are special tools made for inserting the coil. Most qualified machine shops will have the capability to do this for you. If your screw is not an American standard, some machine shops might not have Heli-Coils for all applications. However, Heli-Coils are made in metric sizes. It is common practise to use Heli-Coils in soft metal. Call around to your local machine shops and explain your situation. It is not a complicated process for those who do it with regularity.

Marv

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Marv's comment about metrics brings up a good poing. ~20tpi would be a metric pitch of 1.25 - or one turn in 1.25mm. You may be able to find a metric nut that you can solder or epoxy into the stripped part.

Jim D.

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#13

Calling Bugbear!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>who has Whitworth taps.

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#14

Thanks everyone!

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Very good ideas from all. Going to a machinist would surely work; also fitting the helical threads and turning down the shank of the steel screw and rethreading it to match would also do.

But first I think I'll do something real simple--simple-minded anyway. I just furled up a little piece of paper which is approx. 0.004" thick; furled it up like a cigarette paper; stuck that into the brass recess; ran the steel screw in, and that thickness of paper created a decent fit.

So what I am going to try, before going to a machinist, is to get some 4- or 5-, and 8-thou brass shim stock, repeat the experiment to see which makes the best fit, and try to reline the brass recess with it. Once the adhesive sets to anchor the relining, run the steel screw in with some cutting oil on it, and try to recut a new set of threads using the original steel drive screw. If it doesn't work, haven't lost anything. And it'll be fun to do.

Thank you all very much!

Wiley

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#15

Re: Thanks everyone!

John Veerkamp

>Wiley,

if you cut a small grove in your screw at right angle to the threads, maybe three threads across you make a poor man's tap. This works in soft metals like brass and in cleaning up buggered threads.

John

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#16

Re: Thanks everyone!

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>John,

Thank you very much. That's the way I'll do it.

Wiley

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#17

Re: old brass

paul womack

>I suspect these threads may be old enough that they're fully custom, sadly.

BugBear

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#18

Re: old brass

ThomD

>Precision machinery, or for that mater my Ford truck, do not feel the need to be limited in the size of threads they specify. My belt tensioner uses an easily available 8.7 MM star drive cap screw.

Probably there was a time when 37/128th was standard. :) If it is whitworth the threads will be 55 degrees with more rounding on them than the American which is 60. So if it looks a more acute thread that may be what it is.

You really can't measure a machine cut thread (if that is what it is) by the outside diameter. The machinist can't do the rounding of the threads with a single point tool so he will probably hand finish the external diameter to get the correct fit. So the outside diameter means nothing. You can measure the exact thread by using know rods that fit into three of the valleys and running the numbers. Good luck with that. If your fix doesn't work, you might try running a few pictures up the flagpole. Sounds like a simple thing, but it might require some custom work.

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#19

Re: What to do about stripped threads? -Make a tap

John Aniano in NJ...

>Wiley,

In the bow restoration world I live in, we come across wild sizes of threads for the button screw and frog eyelet of a bow - the two in combination give the adjustment to tighten the hair. 19th century bow hardware had no standards until near the end of the century.

When all else fails, and this has happened more than once, I turn to my trusty South Bend metal lathe, turn a short piece of water-hardening steel to the proper diameter (in your case 0.290"), set the quick-change gear bow to cut a 1/16" pitch thread, and go at it. When done with the threading, use a saw sharpening file to cut two flutes into the steel bit, relieve the edges so it will cut and finally file a square shank on the opposite end. Harden and temper and use the tap!

Works for me...

John

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#20

Now, if Wiley can just remember

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>where he left that metal lathe he picked up at a garage sale and put somewhere in the shop...

Re: What to do about stripped threads?

#21

LOL!!

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>You're so right Bill! I did go to the bay and make a quick check on the going rate for South Bend metal lathes, as a result of John's post. There was a little one for around $800 and a larger one for around $1,500, and in both cases the shipping cost was listed as "You come get it". Long way to Indiana from here, though.

I think John ought to show us a picture of his, since this is a gloatworthy beast.

Wiley