Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Darn you, Chris Schwartz

Posts

Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#1

Darn you, Chris Schwartz

Edward in Vancouver

>Now why did you guys have to go and do that for? You know what I'm talking about, that "little article" on Gerstner toolchests.

Can I afford one? noooo

Even if I did, are there any Cdn distributers? nooo

Do I want one? Well, you guys are to blame. Can't blame a guy like me for wanting one, just like you can't blame a kid in a candy store for wanting what's in the showcase

My cheap side of me is fighting with my practical side. If I can't afford one then I'll have to make one. And that means I'll have to break down and actually go and buy REAL wood, not that recylable palet wood I've been collecting and hoarding (actually some decent maple, oak and mahogany--if you can pull all of the nails out...) I'll have to buy quarter-sawn oak, AND I'll have to fork out for plans, AND hardware, AND...

Do I have the skills and experience to undertake this? Dunno....

Will I butcher my stock and wish I never though about it? Dunno...

Have I been fantasizing about this project for the last week? Yup

Am I going to do it? Yup

Shoulda never bought that magazine.....

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#2

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

John Aniano -- in Central NJ...

>Edward,

Another option - go to an old tool swap or flea market, and these tool chests are often available for pretty good prices. I've seen genuine Gestners for around $100-$150 or so for the basic sized ones. I got a Gerstner look-alike, some Ohio firm I can't remember, for $45 at an Ohio flea market two years ago. It is missing the front panel, but it will be a simple repair project for the future. Another machinist box, no-name, followed me home for ~$50 from a tool auction. They are out there, you just have to look.

John

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#3

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

Guy

>Edward,

Gerstner tool chests are not all that great. I'm a bit disappointed in the quality of mine. True, the quality is better than the Chinese copies that I've also bought. My main disappointments are;

Very simple machined joinery (no dovetails, not even routed DTs)

Face grain on the drawers does not match.

Sized more for machinist tools. For example, chisels are too long or have to thick of a handle for most Gerstner drawers.

The top lid compartment collects dust when open, and collects misc stuff when closed.

When I build my own tool chest, it will not be from a plan. It must be built around the tools you need and use.

Just my opionion, YMMV, etc.

rick

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#4

I'm with you, Guy

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I had wanted one for years, but never got a round tuit. Then my BIL asked for one for his reloading tools, so I built one based on a standard Gerstner-type chest, sans the front thingie. It turned out very well and suited his needs perfectly.

HOWEVER, as much as I liked how it looked, it just won't work for the kind of tools I use. When I make one for myself it's going to be more like the Gerstner work station model, tailored to fit my tools, at about the same height as my bench so it can be used as additional support. I just can't afford $4000 for a tool box (although just the drawer supports will probably run several hundred $)

Bruce

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#5

Re: 3rd

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I 3rd the motion that the Gerstner is a neat tool chest and has an interesting history but is not that great for a tool chest. I don't see much reason to build from a plan but do see the need to measrure the tools you have, figure out what you want to put where, then build accordingly. Unless you make a fairly long chest it would not fit saws anyway. So perhaps this type of chest would be for measuring and marking tools, bench chisels, files & rasps, drill bits, misc. plane irons and parts, and any carving tools you plan on having. Did I miss anything? Measuring would include the squares which should include a 12" combination square with an additional 18" rule, an adjustable 4" square, a 6" or 8" try square, and a sliding t-bevel, and perhaps a larger 12" try square. I have a large square in my tool box that I never use becuase whenever I need a large square I grab my carpenters square which I have checked to make sure is dead on, and the carpenters square doesn't fit in the tool box.

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#6

Re: 3rd

Edward in Vancouver

>What I have now is about a 1/2 sheet of pegboard on the walls, a work bench, and two banks of drawers under the bench salvaged from old steel desks. My grand collection of planes(all 4 of them...) are on a shelf above the bench.

I guess what I really want to organize is my layout tools, smaller hand tools, oh and the chisels. I've had to hide the "good chisels" in a shoe box and keep out some garage sale ones on the bench, as "someone" invariable uses whatever is handy to open up paint cans.

True, I really think the Gerstner style is neat, maybe not ultra practical, but neat. What I really want to do is actually make one. My layout skills and accuracy have improved over the last few projects, made a tolerable chest of simple dovetailed drawers, some decent small boxes, and now I want to try something a little smaller and finer. My designing skills are nil however, and a project like a toolchest requires the designer to have a fair amount of experience, which I don't have, hence the need for plans. Plus I want to do a project that doesn't use common spruce building lumber or salvaged palet wood, as this project is something that I figure I'll be putting around 100 hours into.

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#7

Re: 3rd

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>What I did, Edward, is go to the Gerstner site to get an idea of the overall size of the chest that they designed for shooters. Then I got a set of plans from Rockler. I didn't use the dimensions, but got it more for the ideas. Then I started roughing out what I thought would work. I drew up at least 3 full size drawings, but in the end I pretty much did it by what seemed right. My BIL likes it and uses it and I guess that's all that counts.

What I'm saying is, don't be bothered so much by a lack of plans. You can do it.

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#8

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

Slav Jelesijevich

>Hey Edward don't worry about being a butcher, take it from an experienced butcher of fine wood. When you do your cutting list, make lots of extra pieces, so when you screw up you have another one waiting. Worked for me all these years. Like everyone was saying make it to fit your tools, they designed it for machinists not woodworkers. Their new boxes they are making are not up to the quality of the old ones and the international line is made in China or somewhere like that. The roll around is the way to go. Good luck and cut some extra pcs.

Slav

Re: Darn you, Chris Schwartz

#9

Re: 3rd

Edward in Vancouver

>Well, I've got one foot in already. Got a decent set of plans (veritas) and bought some 8/4 quarter sawn oak. Have some very nice kd maple that I've been hoarding for drawer sides and backs and some teak for the slides and turned knobs/pulls.

First step is to work out my cutting list (yes I'm accounting for a few screw ups...)

Second step is to find some one with a bandsaw...