Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

Posts

Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#1

Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

Alan DuBoff

>I'm curious, it seems that checkering is a great technique to use, and could be tastefully done on handsaw handles.

I haven't seen it on handsaw handles though, even though it has been prominent on gunstocks for ages...

I think it would be something I would have to try to understand if I liked it or not on the grip, but even on the cheek does seem like an area to add some detail with checkering that wouldn't effect the actual grip on the handle, should the checkering annoy me.

I was also thinking that a scroll inlay through the handle sides could be cool...

Would love to hear comments from others on this, so feel free to toss any out here!

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#2

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles *LINK*

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I bought a set of checkering tools with this thought in mind a few years back. I like the looks of a clean handle better than a busy one but I think a checkered handle could be a neat feature.


wheat carving

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#3

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

L. Hanson

>I've considered it - haven't done it yet, but considered it. I think it could be a very cool thing... Checkering, at least on my part, would take a substantial amount of practice, but I think it would look good.

A handsaw handle is different than a gun, though. You want to hold a gun steady - whereas you use the handle to move the saw back and forth, so heavy use might become uncomfortable, I don't know... The inlay might not stand up to use on the grip, though that wouldn't be an issue on other parts of the handle - but it's something one should consider.

Leif

www.norsewoodsmith.com

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#4

Re: Economics

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>So there may be an economic factor here, too.

A top line, respected maker dovetail saw runs $125 and up, but very few are over $250, in my limited experience.

Handguns, shotguns, and rifles, on the other hand, typically start at those prices, and the top end is in the thousands. And the 'best' are collected by those who really have budgets unknown to many of us.

To do a few for our own enjoyment might make sense, but there is limited prospect of getting your time back out of the effort, monetarily. Maybe I'm wrong. That happens regularly.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#5

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

Alan DuBoff

>Leif wrote:

"I've considered it - haven't done it yet, but considered it. I think it could be a very cool thing... Checkering, at least on my part, would take a substantial amount of practice, but I think it would look good."

This is what I had thought also, but in discussing this with Ron Reil through email, he said it's not that hard, and the tools can be forged fairly easily. Online one place wanted about $80/ea for the checkering tools, but Ron said he can teach me how to make them easily.

There are all different levels of the checkering and much of it gets very involved, but I like the stuff that has designs in it, like diamonds, or diagonals, etc...some of it looks pretty cool.

This is something I might just have to try out, since nobody has really done it on handsaw handles, it could be a nice tough to set my saws apart from the rest.

Leif wrote:

"A handsaw handle is different than a gun, though. You want to hold a gun steady - whereas you use the handle to move the saw back and forth, so heavy use might become uncomfortable, I don't know...The inlay might not stand up to use on the grip, though that wouldn't be an issue on other parts of the handle - but it's something one should consider."

Exactly why I made comment in my original post that even if it was uncomfortable, it's possible to add some checkering to the cheek for instance, or the side of the top horn, but to use it as decoration in areas that are not effected by the "grip".

BTW, hopefully you made out ok through the snow, Ron lives over in Garden Valley, ID, and they sure got pelted with snow this year...Several homes had problems with snow loads, several had roofs unload on them and hurt/kill them, and in general it's been a tough winter for you folks in Idaho...hope you're hangin' in ok...9 counties were declared as a disaster area last month and could be more now.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#6

But that can change...

Alan DuBoff

>All the sawmakers need to do is start doing the work and charging more. Look how much people pay for a hand plane, saws have never reached that type of tool porn yet, but they have the potential.

Yes, I'm talking about inlaying exotic woods, gems, stones, just like they would do on a fine guitar. Using highlighting with mother of perl, abalone, etc...For those not familiar with guitars, most have heard of Martin guitars. The Martin line had numbers that would represent the woods used, the amount of inlay work, and the higher end models had a LOT more work done on them. As an example, a D is designated as a dreadnought shape, a D-18 was a mahogany dreadnought, a D-28 was a rosewood dreadnought, and more extreme would be a D-45, also rosewood I believe but much more inlay on the neck and around the rosette and trim. Nice models had gold tuners, etc...tools could be crafted in a similar way, for those tool sluts that prefer, and don't mind spending the $$$s, they should have an opportunity to spend the big bucks to buy the type of quality that other toolmakers have incorporated in planes, or other quality hand tools. Really crazy musicians have their names and other stuff inlayed on the fingerboard. This has nothing to do with economics, there are people willing to pay for that work and I believe they would for handsaws also.

Another thing I'm looking into is milling the backs and split-nuts out of Bronze Alloy 932. This is much stronger than brass, will mill fairly easily, and looks great! However, it's about twice the cost as Brass Alloy 360. Again, for the discerning tool slut, they would have the option to use the Bronze Alloy 932 at their own expense.

The realization here is that nobody should expect anything for free, it is all time and cost in the end, if someone wants extra work, sawmakers should provide them the option, but those people will have to pay for it. You think $1000 for a handsaw is out of the question? I think it's possible to prove you wrong, if that is the case. Just might take some time...;-)

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#7

$1000 for a saw is nothing new

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>When he was still active Yataiki charged $1500 for his top of the line saws. And that's without "decoration" on them AFAIK.

I'm pretty sure there is a market for what you suggest, however when it comes to high-end planes there is an expectation of superior performance on top of all the eye candy. A "fancy" western saw would have to offer superior performance too, the question is, how do you improve on the performance of the current top of the line offerings? I'm not an expert, but it seems to me that the crop of current offerings is as good as western saws can be.

DC

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#8

No, but what I talk of is...

Alan DuBoff

>I think the Japanese have done a wonderful job at marketing in the sense that you're not paying only for craftsmanship. An exception is the pattern welded stuff, and that is cool in itself. I have a lot of respect for the great Japanese craftsmen, many whom have been exploited and most of who have not reaped the profits that the marketing and/or sales people have. But there are exceptions, and the pattern welded chisels are one such example. I have seen them in the $125/ea range, and think that's a decent value for craftsmanship, that takes time to pattern weld the steel.

I don't feel anything else needs to be done with the current handsaw to see the price go up, someone needs to do some of that type of work and see if people are willing to pay for it, and some will if it's good quality. Current steel cut fine, handsaws do the job they're intended to do. It's all a matter of having a personalized set of tools, or tools that a craftsman would take pride in not only owning, but hopefully using.

Several years ago when Mike Wenzloff started to make handsaws, I mentioned it would be nice to see new panel and larger handsaws available new, and he first suggested that people wouldn't spend the $$$s for them as they are plentiful on the vintage market. Look how many he sells today! Mike sells a lot of large handsaws.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#9

$80 each for tools is kind of steep.... *LINK*

John in New Mexico

>They more typically run half that for a starter kit (3 tools) and less than $60 for a more duluxe kit.

They are easy to make, I wouldn't think you need to forge anything, its little more than making a tiny float and filing it to a v.

I've done a small amount of checkering, working up to doing some work on stocks and pistol grips. Its VERY tedious! Gentle curves such as those found on gunstocks aren't too bad, but tighter curves are going to be tricky keeping the lines straight.


Checkering tools

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#10

In the right thread now...

Alan DuBoff

>Moses, I inadvertently put the reply in the old thread...oops...replying here for clarity to this thread:

Looks wonderful, and I have to say once again, your wheat leafs look wonderful. You could make some great handles, you have more talent than most.

You amaze me, as you have the milling experience and know-how to really make some quality saws. I hope we'll see some of your own in the future.

That handle looks wonderful, although a small tear rolls down from my eye in knowing that a vintage saw was modified.:-(

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#11

Those are more reasonable John!

Alan DuBoff

>yes, that is more reasonable in cost, and sure, you wouldn't need to forge them, but I think that would make better tools than the available ones.

You say that work is tedious, what makes you believe that some of the other handle detail is not? :-/

At the end of the day it all gets down to the amount of work and time involved in doing something, but it will obviously have to cost more in order for a toolmaker to even offer it as an option, IMO.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#12

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Checkering a saw hand would be appropriate for an amputation saws. Wooden handled medical instruments always had checkered handles to prevent the hand from slipping when the handle is covered in blood.

Stephen

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#13

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Something to consider.....

Wheat carved saw handles is done only on one side and only done for decoration. If checkering, it would only make sense to do both sides.

The checking could be done while the handle is in it's rough cut shape. Do the radiusing after. This way you wouldn't be dealing with contours. Some of the checkering would be removed but the V,s would just taper out and blend into the radius.

Also when doing the checkering in the rough cut shape, it could be done using a dovetail saw that is filed to saw a V. This would easily give you straight and accurately spaced V,s and no risk of chipping at the small pointed corners.

As for gripping a checkered handle, it wouldn't be as uncomfortable as some of the rough, coarse, sloppy wheat carving we see on most old handsaws. Keep the V,s shallow in depth and it would be quite comfortable and probably not even feel it much.

I like the idea but wouldn't consider it all that unique. I would not do it on the horns, only on the grip area.

Marv

PS.....Hey Leif, nice ta see ya!

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#14

Re: $1000 for a saw is nothing new

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That's not exactly true. Yataiki charged $20,000 for his tamehagane version.

Pam

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#15

Marv, how 'bout a brief tutorial?

Tom Colligan

>I realy marvelled at your wheat carving shown on an earlier post. Would it be a chore to briefly describe what tools you used and how you go about carving an existing handle? That is, do you pencil a sketch first and that what carving tools, just one veiner? Tia, Tom.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#16

One thing...

John in New Mexico

>Those Dembart tools cut nice clean checkering, but I find them really slow (hence the tedius remark!). I've some others that though commercially made are more like what you would make for yourself. They cut faster, but I find they require more concentration to keep the lines straight and even. My impression from honing the more aggressive tools is that the steel is fairly soft, more like a float than a file. The only book I have on the subject indicates that at the time it was written (1940's) most professional checkerers (is that a word?) prefered to make their own tools.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#17

Yeah, I'd like to hear how Marv does it also!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#18

Re: $1000 for a saw is nothing new

ThomD

>"When he was still active Yataiki charged $1500 for his top of the line saws. And that's without "decoration" on them AFAIK."

They forge them though, or in some cases even make the steel. Whether that maters to anyone or not it certainly would reep a well known maker more money than just buying some shim stock. If it was the knife market that might be the difference between Spyderco and Don Fogg, though in the case of Spyderco their designs tend to be innovative.

That's what I like about the Japanese tools they are real (if you buy the right one) not just tarted up. I think western makers can take rightful pride in good ornamentation, it is very much part of our craft tradition. Personally (ierrelevance alert) I neither like ornamentation that much, and particularly not if the ornametation goes beyond the worth of the object. Do what you want on a Holland and Holland, but if it's more like a highschool project, give me a break.

I don't really like checking on a guns from a practical perspective, though it can be very beautifully done. It has little to do with holding guns steady, and more to do with not dropping them, or controlling them. A patch of checkering at the ballance point of a rifle can add to security of carry, and certainly on pistols it can help maintain the grip through recoil and target reaquisition, probably true for other similar situations, but I don't shoot that stuff. For target rifles most doen't want a surface grab since it makes it more difficult to find real neutrality of position, and build from that point. The equivalent there is you want the saw handle in the zero torque position, and it is normally easier to set that up with a smooth surface which is why bows tend not to be checkered. It may help perspiration though in certain environments. Perspiration aside I don't see the application to a saw handle, but it could look pretty for the person who first makes it look like it belongs.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#19

Re: But that can change...

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Mother of pearl inlay, gems, etc.... sorry but I am starting to get a little sick in my stomach. There is a great deal of beauty in the saws that Mike builds which some would say are just plain saws. There is a whole lot of unnecesary time spent on these though just to make them look nice. They really could look bad, but instead they look good. In fact they look great, fantastic, awesome, exceptional, supreme, cool, bad, rad, etc., etc., etc. (Yep, the lack of modern slang definitely dates me). I am not sure how you could add gold leaf and rubies to these and make them look better although you could definitely make them glitter. I am pretty sure Mike could choose to sell his saws starting at $2500 and sell some. The thing is he would probably not sell a lot. So he chooses to sell them at $250 or whatever so he can stay busy I guess, or perhaps he feels it is a fair price for the time he spends on them. There is a great deal of beauty in a clean looking saw that is highly functional. The same beauty is present in a Clark & Williams plane. Just a plain plane that is really a high art form.

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#20

Re: $1000 for a saw is nothing new

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Thom,

I can see no practical purpose in checkering (also referred to as crosshatching) a saw handle or wheat carving for that matter. A more important aspect of the tote is it's shape and how well it fits your hand. Anything added is merely decoration. Same can be said for the nib that you see on some straight back regular size handsaws, right Stephen?

If I were in the business of making saws, I would offer plain handles along with a couple of specific variences as did all the major saw makers of years gone by. The sale price would be commensurate with the added labor and it would be a special order type thing. Some people prefer cars with just a plain paint job while others want the chrome. It's strictly eye appeal when talking handsaws.

When I offer a wheat carved saw on eBay it will usually sell for at least twice what a plain handled saw sells for. The picture I posted in another thread is a Disston D-8 that originally had a clunky squared off handle that was made around the early forties when Disston was trying to reduce hand labor and cutting cost. That saw sold for over $100. Without the wheat carving and reshaping the handle it might have sold for $25 if it sold at all. D-8,s are one of the most common old saws around. The extra cost didn't buy anything that made the saw cut better.

In conclusion, I guess it boils down to the thickness of a person's wallet when it comes to impracticalities.

Marv

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#21

Re: $1000 for a saw is nothing new

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"The picture I posted in another thread is a Disston D-8 that originally had a clunky squared off handle that was made around the early forties when Disston was trying to reduce hand labor and cutting cost."

Isn't that what Disston did the entire time he was in business for the most part? Seems to me that Disston amassed his empire by making saws for the masses, at the expense of craftsmanship. Before that point in time, handsaws were at the peak of craftsmanship.

Having handsaws readily available to the masses was not without sacrifice of craftsmanship for that to happen. Even the nicer handles around the turn of the century which Disston made were done on machines.

If there is any consolation, it was machines that eclipsed Disston's very own empire that was amassed through the use of them. Sure, Disston laughed last with his pockets full, but the last laugh was really on him...by companies like Crescent, Yates-American, Fay & Eagan, etc...but it was really companies like Delta that moved to the small shop and home woodworkers to change things forever...

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#22

Sure, one side of me sais the same...

Alan DuBoff

>Moses,

I feel the same on one side, but OTOH, without exploring what could be, what is possible, we will never know. Maybe just simple pieces of inlayed abalone or mother of perl in the saw nuts, or around them, or an inlay for a small logo on the cheek...

Personally, speaking for myself, if I was selling handsaws for $2500/each, I probably wouldn't care how sick you were...*wink*

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#23

Re: Marv, how 'bout a brief tutorial?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Tom,

Thank you very much for the compliments.

I'm not quite ready to do a tutorial at this time, perhaps at a later date.

email me..

Marv

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#24

Tom, Leif Hansen has one if you're interested *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Tom,

Leif Hansen does in fact have a nice tutorial on doing the wheat leaves, I was curious how Marv does them also as his look nice.

I'll put a URL to the one on Leif's site...

And I have to say, I haven't been to Leif's site in a bit, and boy has he really gotten it into shape, you can search and it has a login, and tons of info, way more than ever...even I shamefully admit asking him recently about his shop, and there is a TON of info there, even framing the roof...all I can say is WOW! And not only that, but Leif is always very helpful online and in email.


Adding Some Detail - Chip Carving

Re: Checkering and inlay on handsaw handles

#25

Re: $1000 for a saw is nothing new

ThomD

>That's an interesting point about your ebay sales and the wheat. Wheat is actually quite beautiful, it obviously speaks volumes to some. I agree about custom handle fit, or just better handles. It can be individual, but the right one is so much nicer, and may also have other practicalities like the hand positions on rip saws.