Ebay 'completed listings'
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Hello Dan,
The main retail market place for old planes (and other hand tools) is Ebay.
You can use Ebay's 'completed auctions' listings to find out what particular items, in excellent, good, fair, poor condition have been selling for.
For example, say it's a Stanley No. 5 jack plane you want a value for. Go to ebay, and click on the 'search' function. Use 'Stanley 5' for the search string. When you type in the search string, right underneath is a box you can check for 'completed auctions only' (or something like that)--check that box. This search will pull up a ton of completed auctions. Look through these auctions, and you will get a feel for what a Stanley No. 5 in a given state of repair will sell for at retail on ebay.
If it's in average to pretty good condition but with some visible rust on it, $20 or $25 is about right. If it's been spiffed up in dandy shape, or is a real desirable model, it may bring around $50 + or -. If it's 'new old stock (NOS) or 'mint in box' (MIB)--it may go $100+.
You can get a feel for prices fast, just by looking at what item sold for what.
Main idea: Condition, condition, condition. Condition is the ballgame. Sometimes a person will have a common plane (like a No. 4 or No. 5) with lots of red rust and a broken tote, and they heard about 'one like this' going for $75 somewhere. Well, the one they heard about was probably in pristine condition, or else it was a 4-1/2 or 5-1/2 in real nice condition, with everything right on it.
Check ebay's completed auctions.
Wiley