Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

old planes etc

Posts

old planes etc

#1

old planes etc

Daniel

>I wonder if anyone could point me to a reference for the value for old planes. there is a hardware store locally that we use for most of our plant supplies, and the owner died recently and his son now runs the place. The plant mechanic told me there are a bunch of old tools and I need a plane or two and wondered where to get pricing information, in order to make an offer.

Thanks for any advice

Dan

Re: old planes etc

#2

Ebay 'completed listings'

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hello Dan,

The main retail market place for old planes (and other hand tools) is Ebay.

You can use Ebay's 'completed auctions' listings to find out what particular items, in excellent, good, fair, poor condition have been selling for.

For example, say it's a Stanley No. 5 jack plane you want a value for. Go to ebay, and click on the 'search' function. Use 'Stanley 5' for the search string. When you type in the search string, right underneath is a box you can check for 'completed auctions only' (or something like that)--check that box. This search will pull up a ton of completed auctions. Look through these auctions, and you will get a feel for what a Stanley No. 5 in a given state of repair will sell for at retail on ebay.

If it's in average to pretty good condition but with some visible rust on it, $20 or $25 is about right. If it's been spiffed up in dandy shape, or is a real desirable model, it may bring around $50 + or -. If it's 'new old stock (NOS) or 'mint in box' (MIB)--it may go $100+.

You can get a feel for prices fast, just by looking at what item sold for what.

Main idea: Condition, condition, condition. Condition is the ballgame. Sometimes a person will have a common plane (like a No. 4 or No. 5) with lots of red rust and a broken tote, and they heard about 'one like this' going for $75 somewhere. Well, the one they heard about was probably in pristine condition, or else it was a 4-1/2 or 5-1/2 in real nice condition, with everything right on it.

Check ebay's completed auctions.

Wiley

Re: old planes etc

#3

Something important I forgot

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>The prices and considerations above are for vintage tools, i.e., with rosewood totes and keyhole-shaped cutouts on the lever cap.

Now if the planes these folks have are the newer ones, like made in the past 25 years or so, and especially if they have plastic handles--the prices go down.

Wiley

Re: old planes etc

#4

Re: Something important I forgot

Daniel

>Thanks thats exactly what I needed to know.

Dan

Re: old planes etc

#5

Re: Something important I forgot

Todd Hughes

>You should really get the person selling the stuff to give you the price that they want for it instead of making them an offer. It is their job to tell you what they think thier stuff is worth and what they want...it is your job to know what you will pay and what it is worth not to tell them what it is worth or what they should sell it for.

....As a buyer it very hard to come out ahead by telling people what you will pay for somthing....Todd

Re: old planes etc

#6

Re: Something important I forgot

dcockey

>And a seller might say it's very hard to come out ahead by offering a price. That why openning offers are frequently higher or lower than the expected agreed price will be. But sometimes it works to your advantage. I've both bought and sold items when what I thought was an openning price was accepted.

We once had a sofa to sell and took it to a used furniture store. The owner and his wife came out, and stood and looked at for a minute along with my wife and I. The owner made some comments about not knowing what to offer since he hadn't had one like it before, and I said I had no idea. After some more looking the owner and I spoke almost simultaneously - about a second before I said 75 he said 80. We both looked at the two wifes, and they agreed the owner spoke first so he agreed to $80.