Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

Posts

French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#1

French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

Paul Kierstead

>After padding on a coat of shellac (using essentially a rubber) and reading Stephen's French Polish instructions (as well as others of course, but his was the one that prompted this...), it made me wonder at the essential difference -- in results, not process -- between padding/wiping on shellac and French Polishing, particularly if pore filling isn't performed.

Any thoughts, or real-world comparisons you have done?

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#2

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

Paul Kierstead

>Sorry, that should be after padding on quite a few coats of shellac ... certainly one coat isn't much basis for anything :)

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#3

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

I got some linen at the local fabric store, only cost me $1.25 for 1/8th of a yard, the smallest they would sell. That gives me a 4"-5" piece, about 3-4 feet long. The one thing that trip'd me up so far is the wood balls. I can get some at Tandy, but that's an hour away. I can use cotton if I need to, Stephen listed that as well.

I have only brushed on shellac, but to me the polishing makes sense as it also builds up the same way, at least that I can tell, and polishes the finish as one does it. It's the polishing action that creates that deep lustrous finish. I'm still sorting out some of the materials/issues...:-/

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#4

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac *LINK*

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>The main difference between padding and French Polishing is the amount of Shellac put on with each coat. When padding you wipe the surface and then let it dry before putting on another layer. When French Polishing you make many passes over the area before you let it dry. French Polishing should give you a deeper shine because it is built up of many reflective layers. At least that is the theory. I don't know if anyone has put it to an objective test.I have only done a few small projects with French Polish, but have had good results. French Polishing is one of those areas of woodworking that has a lot of Zen and Voodoo attached to it. There are many sworn by techniques that get the same results. I learned from the site I linked to. They do some things a little differently than Steven. I would bet that you couldn't tell the end results from the two methods apart. I started out using Olive oil for my oil I'm used to the feel and am hesitant to switch. See I am already getting sucked into a preferred method. Now I will duck and run for cover, because I implied someones favorite technique may be equaled by someone else's favorite technique.


http://www.milburnguitars.com/frenchpolish.html

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#5

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Pieces of old wool socks will work for the inside of the rubber or tampon, as the French call it. OH Yeah, wash the socks first!

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#6

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

Paul Kierstead

> French Polishing should give you a deeper shine because it is built up of many reflective layers.

In theory, there shouldn't really be much difference since one of the big selling points of shellac is complete burn-in (or at least very close to it). That should make layering non-existent. It is an interesting area.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#7

how the thickness is built matters not

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The only factors that affect appearance are its thickness and the surface smoothness. Alf Sharp, this years Cartousch winner and expert finisher, sprays his shellac to build the surface and then polishes. He did a demo on his process recently that I attended. He claimed, and I agree from first principals, that it didn't matter how the thickness got built up. I have heard folklore about orienting the shellac molecules, but this notion is not supported by what is known about plastic molecule mobility.

I think French polishing is an example of solvent polishing which is a process for putting a lustrous finish on plastic. In this case the plastic is shellac, but it could be polycarbonate or acrylic. The solvent, in this case ethanol , dissolves a tiny amount of the plastic surface and smears it around which results in a glass-smooth surface.

I have no doubt that one can achieve the same result with abrasives if they are fine enough to make the scratches smaller than the wavelength of light, but French polishing would be quicker if one knows how to do it. Because a small amount of dissolved plastic is being smeared around the wetness of the pad is of great importance to success to get the viscosity of this dissolved material just right.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#8

Where to get wool

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have quite a bit of it standing around the pasture right now. In a few weeks it will be coming off and put in bags for market. I would have even more had the dogs not reduced the herd some last month.

If anyone wants wool send me postage to cover a Priority mail box and I will fill it with raw wool.

Raw wool is the clothes sheep have worn for the past year, camping out. Additionally, it is water proofed with about 50% lanolin. Hence, expect to need to wash the wool 2-3 times in ample water before using. I am unsympathetic to complaints that raw wool looks and smells like sheep's clothing. It was a desperate wolf that wore it.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#9

I absolutely agree with you, except...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

The application of the shellac is irrelative. I strain out my seed lac with a brass screen cage, and while I let it drain, I recently placed it on a scrap of pine, while I attenuated the decoction. When I was finished there was a puddle of thick shellac. I could not resist.

I spread it around, fixed up a fad and did a polish. I actually spray using a mouth atomizer on small projects, larger ones 'wind' me, so I usually brush it on.

As for orienting the molecules of shellac, well arn't they all in circles? That makes my head spin. Maybe it is a Feng Shui thing? But there is something between Zen and Voodou getting the rubber to that 'right' point.

When it starts to work, the shine builds up, the trailing streaks vanish and the luster and gloss begin to shine, is a magic moment.

Now as to what I find exception to is being able to accomplish the same shine with abrasives. Nothing matches the shine of French Polish, polished silver comes close.

Stephen

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#10

Chris Scholz

So is shellac yin or yang?

Chris Scholz

>

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#11

Re: how the thickness is built matters not

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I'll have to try building the shellac by another method and then just doing French Polish as the last step. It sure will save on labor. It takes a lot of elbow grease to build up a French Polish from bare wood. Even with padding a base coat, it still is a lot of work. The layers theory may be hogwash, but it sure gets repeated. I try not to get to dogmatic in my methods. That would hinder my ability to learn new methods or improve old ones. Thanks for the offer of raw wool, but I think I'll stick to using old socks. I only have to wash them once.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#12

Re: how the thickness is built matters not

Paul Kierstead

>So, get it on (by whatever means), level it out if necessary (and my lack of technique makes it necessary) and "spirit off" and we have the same end-result?

It meets the thoughts in my head, but I wonder if anyone has pursued it more rigorously just to check if the voodoo has a purpose.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#13

yes, Alf Sharp has checked it

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>And there is no one more qualified to determine equivalence. When I get to it I will post his whole procedure that ends with sanding it level and then polishing with a final coat. He buys shellac by the 50 pound lot so one would expect he has experience.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#14

there is an addition

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>just checked and we have another woolly addition. Note the time. they usually lamb in the middle of the night, this time, luckily, without problems.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#15

Qualified? Impartial?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have never seen Alf Sharp's work in person, so I am unable to comment on his work. However, I am not sure I would call someone with a financial interest an impartial judge. I think a lot of the public cannot discriminate between shellac and lacquer, or between sprayed and polished, so one can get away with a lot here. Also there is a big difference between one fellows "French polish" and another. It could easily be that Sharp's French polish is indistinguishable from his spray and polish.

I have many times heard someone say they make reproductions by machine and then cover their tracks with hand tools. They say they are indistinguishable from handmade. When you look at their work, however, some look good and some look like crap. And some cost more than handmade.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#16

There is a difference...

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>First of all, congratulations Bill on the new addition. Now for the question at hand. Is there a difference between polishing and padding. The answer is yes. At times the results are subtle but usually the results are obvious if you are looking for them. The difference can be characterized by the term, uniformity. It is very difficult to get the color and tone to match on different pieces of wood on the same project. Achieving this uniformity is evidence of polishing. The final spiriting off of a project should achieve a uniformity of shine that mere padding will not achieve. There are many different ways to polish (or pad) but achieving a uniform color, tone, shine and fill by whatever means is polishing. Padding on a finish that is good enough is ok, but the odds of achieving this uniformity are reduced. To clarify, I would say that padding is polishing that one does with the intention of not expending the effort necessary to achieve the uniformity of a finely polished piece. The piece is finished and still looks great but it's not up to the standards of French polishing. All of my shellacked projects are padded. While I've tried to polish them I have yet to achieve that wonderful uniformity. They still took a long time to do and I think they look pretty da** good but I'm not conceited enough to think that they look professional.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#17

Re: There is a difference...

Paul Kierstead

>I am not sure I understand your answer. Just about all finishes need some kind of "finishing", whether it be abrasives, solvents, whatever. Rubbing out, spiriting off, what have you. I expect polishing is as good a term as any, unless you explicitly trying to knock down the finish in which case I expect polishing is not a good term. Sheesh, I can't help myself sometimes...

The question is: Does the process of French Polishing (specifically that process, not just polishing in general, and particularly the bit of rubadub with oil) visibly add anything to the result which would not be achieved otherwise (with shellac). Implicit in this is both jobs are done by people of equal, and high, skill. And, more to the point, has someone done any serious, careful and impartial comparisons of the results? One would think it would be something of sufficient importance and interest that someone would have given it a swing.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#18

to clarify the question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I think the question is comparing these alternatives:

Build the coat with spray gun or brush (Alf Sharp approach) ,grind it flat, and then "French polish" the final coat.

Or

By French Polishing, build the entire finish.

If for no other reason, the properties of shellac suggest there can be no difference.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#19

You misunderstand my response

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>When you start thinking about the results you wish to achieve and the different techniques that you can use to get there then you see there is a subtle difference between french polishing and just padding it on. The same highly qualified person can do both. What separates what they do is based on the level of perfection desired, the time and treasure needed to do it and the appropriateness for the piece at hand. Padding and polishing are the same thing. It's the attention to detail that makes the difference. The spiriting off is what brings out the shine. It's also one area that a person can cut corners. I am saying that the difference is in the process. The fussiness produces better results; results that are subtly better. By the way you ask the question my answer to you would be there is nothing different between the two. My experience has been that for me to improve my finish I have to use various techniques that I can fudge on or skip altogether to just get it finished but must do to achieve that beautiful uniformity that is the holy grail of French polishing. Gnostic? Esoteric? Unknowable? Logic defying? Yes, yes, yes and yes. So just do it. Fads? We don't need no stinking fadses. Get yourself a wad, some alcohol and shellac. Put on the finish. Note shortcomings. Adjust technique as necessary. Stop adjusting when you're satisfied with the finish. Sit back and admire. That's all there is to it.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#20

Re: to clarify the question

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Bill, I agree with you, I think. I don't think how you build up is important except that you can't have drips, ridges, unevenness. (That's why he sands) Building up by hand allows for the difference in the various parts of a piece. A good polisher can blend the tones and colors of the woods with just the shellac. For me, this would be more difficult by spraying. If I didn't care I would just pad on, or spray on the finish and then hand polish to a shine. How you build up doesn't matter unless it has a negative effect on the final product. That's what I meant by my other post. You can do it however you want if you know the results from what you do will be satisfactory. I think that some results can best be done by certain processes.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#21

Re: You misunderstand my response

Paul Kierstead

>I thought I might have misunderstood the response. I see your point now; note I didn't use the term "just" in reference to padding on shellac; I would consider doing it well to be a highly skilled job requiring considerable care.

However, I am totally with you on the concept that particular processes can improve the outcome by altering the state of mind of the worker (as opposed to some inherent advantage to the process); for example, I continue to take vastly better composed and shot pictures with my view camera then my digital camera not due to any inherent technical superiority (though there are differences) but because digital camera's tend to foster sloppieness in me. I suppose it is quite possible or even likely that french polishing vrs other methods could have the effect. Of course, some people can be fussy on anything; they might able to short circuit the process more reliably.

Thanks for your thoughtful reply.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#22

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The signature Highboy piece in the Philly museum was conserved and colored only by tinting the shellac so as to not do anything to the wood that would not be reversible. However, Alf alluded to, but didn't demonstrate, that he does the coloring and shading with dye before shellacing. He does rely on the color of the shellac to evenly color the wood. He has some tricks on the moldings to highlight them but it only involves manipulating the final French Polished coat and not the main coating thickness.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#23

Re: to clarify the question

Paul Kierstead

>I think that does sum it up well, Bill. Many thanks for your input here.

I actually like padding it on as I am much less likely to get excess build up then when using a brush, where my poor technique tends to lead to excess build-up at the edges. Spraying in winter isn't terribly practical for me.

An interesting and useful discussion.

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#24

Re: You misunderstand my response

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I continue to take vastly better composed and shot pictures with my view camera then my digital camera not due to any inherent technical superiority...

Aaaaarrrrgggghhhhh, just can't let this go, Paul. There are significant composition diffferences between looking at an object/scene in a view camera (upside down and left-to-right flop) and an slr/digital (right side up and left-to-left). My guess is that you know that, not sure everyone who reads your message does.

Pam

Re: French Polishing vrs. Padding on Shellac

#25

Re: You misunderstand my response

Paul Kierstead

>Heh, yes, there certainly are differences in seeing between an SLR and view camera, but I was kinda glossing over that because I also shoot better (artistically speaking at least) pics with a simple SLR (or range finder, which I tend to prefer) then a digital because I can't chimp and can't iterate the shot. This means I have to get it right first and, once shot, it is done with (until the darkroom, digital or otherwise). This gives -- for me -- a different approach and different results beyond the technology differences. Another interesting idea is shooting colour and converting to black and white vrs shooting black and white in the first place. Outside of the tech differences, I think many people will shoot differently if they *know* they cannot alter the filtering after the fact, and they know there is no "I'll leave it in colour".

One might think that since I am aware of it I can overcome it, but it is not so easy to override ones own psychology. I suspect this plays fairly strongly in many area's of woodworking too.