We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm watching a small item that's moderately well-described, but with pictures that have NO relationship to the item described (well, except that auto body hammers are hand tools). I've sent the seller a message pointing out the discrepancy and asking for pictures of the item described, but had no response yet.
At the moment, the item has no bids.
I'm considering putting in a bid and sending the seller a message that my bid is contingent on my receiving pictures of the item and finding it satisfactory and consistent with the description. Is this legal, and does it seem kosher?
>Little confused here about why you need to bid right now befor you really know what the seller is selling. I imagine the photos are not the right ones for the auction and this can be pretty easy to do [I've done it a few times] but imagine it could be the wrong description for the photos but i think this would be harder to do by mistake.
Speaking from experance as a seller if I have an auction with the wrong photos up and I find out about it I of course want to fix it. If an auction has a bid I don't think you can do this very easy if at all so I would stop the auction and re list it. If no bids you can change the auction....In your case I would just wait to see what the seller does. Think this isn't much of a real problem.....Todd
I used to spend a lot of time on a forum devoted to mountain bikes, and after a while, we noticed that pictures of bikes we posted on the forum would find their way into ebay auctions. So, we started watermarking or stamping the photos we posted. It's entirely possible that this guy lifted his text from somewhere else, too.
Not every seller is kosher, but ebay is very clear that a bid is a legally binding contract. And before you bid, you're met with the following:
"By clicking on the button below, you commit to buy this item from the seller if you're the winning bidder."
"You are agreeing to a contract -- You will enter into a legally binding contract to purchase the item from the seller if you're the winning bidder. You are responsible for reading the full item listing, including the seller's instructions and accepted payment methods. Seller assumes all responsibility for listing this item."
If the item you receive isn't what they listed, or if you don't receive anything. But there's no way to withdraw your bid, once it's been placed, without mutual agreement from the seller. If he's not answering your emails so far, good luck getting him to let you off the hook when it comes to paying the bill.
Rule number one when dealing with online auction sites: if the seller isn't communicative, if the pictures don't match the text, if the seller can't send you pictures of the same item from a different angle to prove actual possession, (on the bike site, we used to ask for pictures of the serial number stamp on the bottom bracket)... if the listing is in any way "fishy," then don't place a bid.
It's nice to think that buyers are able to withdraw an offer if they're unhappy for whatever reason. The truth is, you can only do that up to and until the moment when you actually click the button. If I have a concern, and you can't meet my (very, very loose) criteria to qualify as a communicative or trustworthy seller, I won't pull the trigger.
I can understand the desire to have your money put down on something that sounds great, and in theory is a good deal... if it's real. But there's no way to hedge your bet on ebay. So it's your call. If you still think it's worth the risk to put money down on a fishy listing, I say go for it, especially if the seller in question has a solid, established reputation reflected in his feedback rating. But be aware, bidding is binding, and if you place a winning bid, you have to pay up if you want to follow the rules.
I wouldn't make a contingent bid, if I were you. Ebay doesn't contemplate contingent bids--as James says, they are very clear that you are committing to buying the item # at the moment you place the bid, and your recourse comes later, if it turns out there are problems.
The other thing is that ebay is a beautiful thing when everyone does their part properly. But it'll get your stomach in a knot when you're trying to untangle a mess. Don't bid until and unless the seller straightens it out.
>This whole subject of the buyer being unconditionally committed at the moment of bid also applies to making a 'Best Offer'. If you make a 'best offer', you're not opening a negotiation--the seller can invoice you in the next email for your 'best offer', and you own that item. Found this out through experience, which seems to be the only way I ever learn anything.
>untill he gets his act together. If he doesn't . . . walk away. Good commo is one of the hallmarks of a good seller. And a good buyer for that matter.
>"But there's no way to withdraw your bid, once it's been placed, without mutual agreement from the seller"
This is absolutly not correct. A bidder can retract or withdraw his bid up till I think the last 12 hours of an auction and the seller doesn't have any say in it. I sell stuff on the ebay and I have had dozens of bidders retract thier bids and the first I ever know about it when ebay sends me an email telling me that they did. Most times it is because they put the wrong emount in, or so they say, Somtimes I think it is because they are fishing to see what the other guys high bid is or what your reserve might be, Also maybe as a way to discourage other bidders....but again bidders with drawing thier bids is not rare or hard to do. I think ebay keeps tracks of it and if a buyer does it alot then maybe he will get a warning...don't know.
As to harvesting others photos have to say I have had my ebay photos used by several web sites who never even contacted me. Once had a friend email me saying a very simular musical saw as the one I was selling on ebay was featured in this web site...I look and simular heck it IS my saw ! Hadn't been sold yet and here it is with the web site guy talking all about it and then saying not to email him about it because it's not for sale....at least if he was going to steal my photos he could have pointed the people toward me to buy it.....Todd
>Yes you can retract a bid, but ebay tracks that action also, and will suspend your activities if you do it more than a few times. I retracted a bid once before, because I put the decimal in the wrong place, and that still shows on my activity record...it was 5 years ago when it happened.
>In general, when a seller doesn't respond to questions.....it's a good sign that the seller will not respond later should you have a problem with the item. Steer clear, no item is worth the hassle.
>this was the item. I realized today that an auto body hammer could make some pretty good divots in a finger, so maybe it is a finger router, in the sense that one of the purposes of a carpenter's hammer is to ensure that thumbs are not excessively thick.
Like all these planes people keep talking about for planing rabbits (how do you keep the bunny still while planing? I would think bench dogs would have trouble not slobbering).
>A few years back, I had bid on and won a VB36 Lathe that was within driving distance of my house for pick-up. My winning bid was at least $3000 under fair market value, but I couldn't bid myself up, and no one else did. I contacted the seller, and she started with:
"Well, I didn't know how Ebay works."
I countered "I had a much higher bid, but no one else bid on it. I can add another $2K."
"Um, uh, the lathe is gone. I gave it to the local school."
Obviously lying, I asked "My bid wasn't high enough, so you gave it away?"
"Yeah, for the tax write-off."
And I said, "But you'll only get 0.25 on the dollar for it that way back on your return, which is even less than my winning bid"
"Um, it's too late, the lathe is gone..."
click...
I contacted Ebay, and they said "we'll suspend her account (rating 0)"
Ebay is not a legally binding anything... It is a handshake between two parties to do business together. Both parties have some risk, and like everything in the world, you've got good and bad...
If the little voice in your head is telling you "it ain't right", you should listen...
>I'm not sure where this stands now either, but didn't ebay just remove the ability of the seller to nuke you back with a rating, so if you don't fulfil your part of the "contract" what is the current sanction (just asking).
The other part of the legal action here is what is the binding part of the description? The current assumption seems to be that the bid will be binding on the bider (except as under limits mentioned in other posts). But what is one bidding on, the photo or the written description? If it is the written description then he still owes the vise not auto body tools. Not saying this is an attractive way to enter into an ebay deal but at least you aren't getting tagged if the description is the binding part.
I agree there is little reason to bid on an auction where the seller is not comunicative, but it amazes me the number of people who put something on ebay then go to Hawaii etc... for the rest of the period...
Re: Not a legally binding contract...(Long, Boring
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Hi Thom,
Bill reported back that he decided not to bid the item, so that's where it stands.
Your question about legality was 'what is it that you're bidding on, the picture or the description?'
What we're really talking about here is not law, it's Ebay policy. Here's some of the practicality of the situation....The seller posts an auction, with some description and/or pictures. That auction has a number on the books, and Ebay expects to be paid for the outcome, if the auction is not cancelled.
Now let's say the auction description/listing is all screwed up. For whatever reason--confusion, computer mishap, power lines down. Whatever. And let's say someone comes along and bids that item, but refuses to pay until the seller straightens out the obvious questions that the buyer has.
Under Ebay policy, the seller is entitled after 7 days have passed (or maybe before, if the buyer outright states he/she won't pay), to file an Unpaid Item Dispute with Ebay. The buyer is accused of Not Paying. Ebay will then write the buyer with a reminder to pay, and give the buyer some options to respond to, and there are branching possibilities from there. But the point is this: If the buyer refuses to pay, then the buyer will land in the position of having to defend themselves against an Unpaid Item dispute, and if the buyer's eventual behavior runs against Ebay policy, that dispute will become an Unpaid Item strike against the buyer. This is why you don't want to make a conditional bid, however justified it may be in your own mind. If you bid, you're expected to pay, and seek recourse afterward.
Now the buyer has more than one option prior to placing a bid. Rather than either bidding or not bidding, the buyer can "Report this Item"--there is a report link at the bottom of every single auction. If such a report is filed, Ebay will look into the matter within a day or so, and perhaps intervene with the seller to get things straightened out. If the seller doesn't communicate with ebay, then the issue lands on the seller, but if the buyer makes a conditional offer and refuses to pay, then the onus shifts to the buyer, in the form of an Unpaid Item dispute.