Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

Posts

What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#1

What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

Alan DuBoff

>Curious which woods some of you folks like to work. In discussing the cocobolo, it got me to thinking once again of my 3 favorite woods to work. Not that I always get the pleasure to work them, but we do pick our own destiny for the most part...

My 3 favorites are:

1) Walnut - could possibly be my favorite wood to work, for me it does a lot of things well. It cuts, it rasps, shaves, planes well, even turns well on the lathe. It looks great most of the time. While it is not as hard as some other hardwoods I work, it is a good all around compromise. It is not inexpensive wood to use for large projects, possibly the only deterrent for me. But since it's commonly available it's often a good choice.

2) Cherry - also works well for most tasks, and also very nice in most cases. It is not as forgiving as walnut for me, but I like the lighter color, and it is a good choice for many projects I'll work.

3) Maple - have always liked working maple, and love the way it shaves, and planes. Less forgiving than walnut for me, and workability seems similar.

With that said, I am a very spontaneous type person, and often I'll go looking for a nice piece of wood, and find something else. I do have a lot of maple, as I got a nice deal on it, and like to work it. That in itself is a good combination for stock on hand. I have also liked working various mahoganies.

But I do prefer spectacular figure and grain, and willing to pay extra for it. Even willing to work some less desirable woods for the look. I like purple heart but hate to work it as it splinters a lot. Love the looks of hickory, and it's often cheap, but it's really hard on edge tools and requires more sharpening when using it.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#2

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Great question, I like:

(1) Pine because I can paint it to look like Walnut.

(2) Pine because I can paint it to look like Cherry.

(3) Pine because I can paint it to look like Maple.

(4-.....) Pine because I can paint it to look like mahogany, rosewood, birch crotch, marble, granite, &c.

Or I can just paint it a solid color or to look like something else.

So Pine are all of my favorite woods.

Stephen


img

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#3

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>Sounds like someone living in the state of deseret, without much access to hardwoods.

For cabinets and tables, maple, cherry and walnut are my favorites. For three different reasons. For making chairs; pine, butternut or tulip poplar for seats. Maple or cherry for legs. Ash, oak or hickory for spindles. I hate to gloat, but they're all available readily 'round these parts, and each have their own fort� in different aspects of chair making. Then there is black locust, fussy in some respects but hard, bendable and durable. Also available, since I have a couple acres of it. Nothing like whacking a tree and making something of it with hand tools.

greg

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#4

I actually do like pine quite a bit myself...

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

I must admit that I actually do like pine quite a bit myself, but I normally use it when I want it to look like pine. It seems to require less painting that way, but look at how good I did painting this project, I really take pride in how much I painted the wood to resemble knotty pine, the resemblance was really uncanny to me....:-/


For some reason, paint is not in my woodworking vocabulary, and I will very rarely paint wood, even if it's plain like poplar.

Pine is also pretty forgiving, in the sense that you can cut a 3" square and pound it into a 2" round hole. OTOH, it can require some patience and careful handling so one doesn't ding it up, although I do like the distressed look. In that sense you can take a chain to it and make it look distressed, but I fear that some olde tyme cabinetmaker might come along and paint it to look like MDF, that would be a shame...*gd&r*

I do like it enough to think about building some timberframe for a house out of it, here's some of the logs that will be used...Eastern White Pine, 30"-32" at the butts, 24"-28" at the tops. The center of my home will be 4 of these timbers, forming a 16'x16' dining room and extending up 3 floors with a 16'x16' lookout on the 3rd floor.


I think I'm going to paint those to look like EWP.

Will be using round white oak logs for the full wrap around porch though...I think I'll paint those to look like white oak.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#5

How do you match the realistic look

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>of those knots? Great painting job. :-)

I'd like to get ahold of those logs, too.

Bruce

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#6

Well, I'll tell you...

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce wrote:

"of those knots? Great painting job."

I'll fill you in on one of my best kept secrets. You seem to know how difficult it is to get the realistic look of wood when you paint it, and the best advice I can offer is to use "clear" paint.;-)

On my shed interior, I experimented with a modern water based paint, which was a shade of clear, Sansin's "Purity Clear Arctic Satin". I picked the satin finish as knotty pine is not normally shiny when I have seen it growing and milled, otherwise I would have used the gloss.*vbg* I could have used the flat, but I like the satin finish. I also wanted to try this product out before I used it on the home I plan to build, and even though the timber will be a different species of pine, I will also paint those logs with clear paint as well, possibly just a pinch off clear...to darken up the knots. As you must know from your comment, knots are hard to paint. I think it's key to have a nice clear paint that doesn't show the brush marks in order to get good knots. And herein lies the key to "clear" paint. It really is the best at hiding the brush marks, and no matter how hard you try there is always going to be some brush marks if you paint.;-)

One of the reasons I try to never add much tints or dyes to my paint, is that I can always pick a nice figured wood that I can paint on top of (clear of course) to get the color I want. The colors and figures in most of the available wood provide for textures that fit, without using any tints or dyes. Again, those tints and dyes tend to show the brush marks, and I *HATE* when that happens.

Another thing, have you seen those shaker style workbenches where they rubbed shoe polish on the wood? I saw that in a recent magazine article, and the bench was a beauty! I decided not to do that on my most recent workbench as I don't wear my workbench as shoes, and hope I don't need to shine like them...again, I think I'm going to use a clear paint on it as well, but I haven't painted it yet.*yikes!*

Bruce wrote:

"I'd like to get ahold of those logs, too."

Yeah, you and me both. That is one of the greatest log and timber craftsmen in that picture. All the log work will be mortise and tenoned with wood pins. Not to get you too excited, I have only come close to completing the design, it will be a couple years most likely before I can break ground. This is what it will look like from the walkout, but 300 ft. to the left, so the pine tree on the left will actually be on the right. *LOL*

Oh and BTW, that reminds me Bruce...I'm gonna paint the window glass clear also, it also hides the brush marks!*wink*


img

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#7

Re: Well, I'll tell you...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Ya see, I could envision myself getting one of those wood grain thingies from Wally World, and maybe doing the beams for your house. That's within the realm of possibility. Had a buddy who did that with his front door. He didn't use the clear paint, though. I'll have to key him in on that clear paint trick.

Howsomeever, that panorama you painted on the picture window is beyond my skills, unless I could get someone to develop a "paint-by-numbers" template. My free-hand skills are just not there.

Bruce, who's darn near ready to go to bed.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ditto..

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Alan,

My choices are exactly the same as yours,in the same order.I build alot of clock cases and walnut is my wood of choice for that.I love that smell.Easy to shape.Costs a bit though.My only source is 3 hours away,good selection,but high priced.With cherry I got lucky.Awhile back I traded some no longer needed shop equipment(compressor,welder,torches)for a big pile of cherry planks milled from a large local tree. With clock cases this pile will go a ways before I need to buy any. I love the look of cherry.It's a little tough to work at times though. Maple is just a good standby where color and figure aren't requirements. For tool handles and small accessories (latches,knobs,etc..)I keep a small stash of rosewood.I'm not sure of the species but it is dark brown with black swirls running through it.I wish I had enough to build a clock with,but I believe that would run into some large money.---Jack

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: I actually do like pine quite a bit myself...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I hate sheetrock. The whole interior of my house is white pine planks graded as #5.(except the floor). They were cheap at the time($.19 BF) and plentiful.Alas, the mill that supplied them got shut down by OSHA. They couldn't afford the upgrades needed to comply with modern safety standards.---Jack

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#10

Re: cherry

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Cherry is my favorite wood to work. Nothing else even comes close. I enjoy working with walnut but most of the projects I do are just not meant to be that dark. So the reason I like cherry is #1 the color, #2 the way it works, being hard enough but still soft, & #3 the way the end grain planes. I am working on a hickory side board right now, which I actually thought would require much more teeth knashing than it has. Perhaps I lucked out on the wood but it is working good and planes a lot better than I remember. So my #2 most favorite wood is whatever happens to be on the bench at the moment. I would list pine as my least favorite wood in spite of Stephen's uproar about it.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#11

Painting it to look like wood.

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>Sorry, the pic is not that great. My shop door used to be double doors on the front of the house. I think they were trying to paint the doors to look like oak.

greg

(Now the doors are strapped together and slide sideways on a barn door track to open. The shop is the stable area of the carriage shed.)


img

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#12

...and the way it smells

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>Cherry smells wonderful, an odor strong enough to still be appreciated by someone (such as myself) who has had the olfactory senses damaged from living near a paper mill for >20 years.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#13

Port Orford Cedar

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>There is no other wood with such a heavenly smell as port orford cedar. It is not a true cedar as I am very allergic to all cedars. Some books will describe the scent faintly lemon like. I find it to have a faint citrus tone with hints of mint with the dominat scent of cardamom.

yesterday I was planing out a bunch of stock for some drawers and guides. I planed about 20 bf of monterey cypress which smells like cedar and then ran one 2' x 6" board of Port orford cedar thrugh and the whole shop smelled like the port orford cedar. that board by the way has 35 anular rings/inch. It is exceptionaly stable moderately hard for a soft wood and carves well.

I very rarely work with Port orford cedar as most of my work is with hard wood but if I could I would work with it exclusively.

Robin

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#14

I'm alot like you, kinda sorta

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond

>"ceptin I like cherry the best walnut the 2nd. Maple is nice, but it's to light for a lot of the things I make. Mohog would be my 3rd choice. I realy like Ebony too but it's pricey.

btw, PINE SUCKS! imho.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#15

Hum

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>You wrote:

'btw, PINE SUCKS! imho. '. I find that particularly offensive and I am sure a number of people who use or can only afford pine may be equally bothered.

Do you hold the same opinion about all conifers? If so, your state tree and 14 other state trees many of them pine are conifers. How do you feel about those states?

Not sure it is a 'humble opinion' either.

Stephen

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#16

Hey now!

Bob Hackett

>It`s not Scott`s fault that pine sucks.

The way I heard it pine sucked for a very long time before Scott pointed it out.

Mainely,Bob

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#17

Re: Hum

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Stephen I think probably everyone here has a great deal of respect for your opinion. Our response to your love of pine is mostly in jest because we know it will get your dander up. I really enjoyed your thoughts on pine. The main reason I dislike pine is due to my lack of woodworking skills. The tools have to be so darn sharp in order to work well in pine. The dovetail sample that Frank Klausz gave me is made in pine and has always been an inspiration for me to get better.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#18

Is cost really an issue?

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen wrote:

"I find that particularly offensive and I am sure a number of people who use or can only afford pine may be equally bothered."

If cost was that much of an issue, those folks could always go get oak pallets for free, clean the nails out and make decent stuff with it.

I know that many folks have a dislike for pine, but I'm not one of them, and I find that it works well enough for me. EWP is a premium wood, and I'm told traded on the exchange, so there is certainly demand for it. EWP is one of the premium timbers in the U.S., most certainly. There's a lot of different species of pine, and SYP is quite different than EWP, which I'm sure you know.

Either way, here's a ice cold one shootin' down the virtual suds highway...swwwwoooooooooooossssssssssshhhhhhhh...I don't think Scott meant any harm, possibly you were missing that virtual emoticon that he put on his message...I saw it...you just have to look hard!*wink* And none the less, and man's deserving of an opinion, isn't he? We all don't have to agree with each other, but there's always space in the world for all of us. That something not to loose sight of...

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#19

Show off your skill!

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think white pine (Pinus strobus) is a wood which really shows off a woodworkers skills. If one has great skills it has depth and lustre to match any other wood. Moldings made on straight grain white pine approach perfection. For years I told people that white pine was a poor turning wood, but then found that flawless technique yielded a fine surface.

If you are one who reaches for a high angle smoother or a scraper when you get into trouble, you will be disappointed in white pine. And forget sanding, because that will destroy the magic.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#20

or better yet learn your skills

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>As a patternmaker I used a lot of sugar pine. While it works very diferent from some of the other types of pine the need for sharp tools and good techniqe are still necessary. I think pine is an excellent wood to learn on. it will teach you the importance of keeping your tools well tuned and will let you know how often to touch up the edge. Then when you transition to hard woods you will have good techniqe and your work will progress faster than if you learned on hard woods where you will be rewarded to some extent with poor techniqe and a less than sharp edge. work with pine for a while and you will get corrected rather quickly for using poor technique or less then sharp edges. and this I am sure will lead many to have a poor opinion of pine.

The challenge is to learn what the tree has to teach us, and it may be diferent for each tree and each person.

Robin

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#21

Re: Port Orford Cedar

Hank Knight

>"I find it to have a faint citrus tone with hints of mint with the dominat scent of cardamom."

You been spending too much time in Napa. ;)

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#22

Yes, and to further your point...

Alan DuBoff

>When I was doing the interior of my shed, framing the windows turned out to be one of the more challenging pieces to get correct. A small 60 1/2 block plane I have was invaluable, though...when it was sharp. When sharp, it could take off the nicest curly from the edge of pine, but if the edge wasn't sharpened, it would just rip up and tear the edge apart.

Also, speaking for myself, a cheap dozuki was handy to resaw a 3/4" thick piece of pine. It was really nice for that, and made me realize how nice the Japanese saws are for working softwoods. I know the Japanese use a lot of cedar, and that's probably one reason. My experience using a Japanese saw on hardwood is less than stellar for most of the disposables. A friend has some nice Mitsukawas and they have a rip blade that will do hardwoods nicely, but that is in the minority of dozukis on the market. Most of what people buy, Razer included, don't cut hardwood worth a darn. OTOH, my western style saws don't re-saw anything that well, pine or otherwise. Sometimes it really is as simple as using the right tool for the job.

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#23

Or too much time in Naptha!*wink*

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: What's your favorite wood to work, and why?

#25

Glad to offend...8^)

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Just kiddin'. Let me 'splane Lucie�

If you can afford pine, then you can afford poplar. At least in these parts. A far superior wood for any indoor application over pine IMO. I can't see using either one for exterior applications.

The pine we get around here is awful stuff. All heart wood for the most part. Warped and twisted (a bit like me) and full of knots. Not that I mind some knots but dang, this stuff is full of them. The cathedral grain splits and raises causing nightmares only Ambien or a nicotine patch can rival.

It's blotchy when finished no matter what you use except clear finishes. No, I am NOT a painter of most woods.

I can make poplar look like pretty much any tight-grained hardwood with out any paint at all.

As far as the other conifers go, pine is the only one I truly despise after all you can�t even use it for firewood with out screwing op your fireplace.

I love working with Redwood, after all I live in awe of them and underneath them as well. My house is built completely from it. The only drawback to redwood is the splinters hurt like hell.

Let�s see how long an Adirondack chair made of pine lasts on my front deck compared to redwood of cedar one, regardless of finish.

Doug fir, a wood hated by some that hang out here is what I�m making my new bench out of. It has some issues in working it, but none compared to pine.

Now I have never see or used SYP or any of the Eastern varieties, so I have no comment on it. I just hope it�s better than the crap out here.

Trust me here, pine has humbled me enough times that yes, it is my humble opinion.