Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Pye's "Workmanship"

Posts

Pye's "Workmanship"

#1

Pye's "Workmanship"

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Megan pre-ordered David Pye's "The Nature and Art of Workmanship" for me sometime in January and Amazon claimed it would be printing sometime this summer. The good news is I just received my copy today even though Amazon still lists it as not available. I read "The Nature & Aesthetics of Design" a few months ago and enjoyed it. Mostly I wanted to read the books because they are hailed as a landmark in the philosophy of design and craftsmanship and I think they are worth adding to any library. Another interesting book I read through recently is "Country Furniture" by Aldren A. Watson but I don't think it's worth spending $50 for a first edition hardback in fine condition. It is a nice edition to the book shelf though and I consider it as having done my share to stimulate the economy. Adding a few books every year soon adds up to having a much better selection of woodworking reading material than the local library does.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#2

Yes, a very good book

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I found it one of the clearest discussions of so many things, without some of the frou-frou stuff you find in philosophy of art and crafts discussions.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#3

Re: Yes, a very good book

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>...without some of the frou-frou stuff you find in philosophy of art and crafts discussions.

Bill, what do you mean by this?

T.O.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#4

I am open to getting yelled at here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I think that some discussions of the arts and crafts at the philosophical level involve assertions of whether something is good or not based on value judgments made by the writer/speaker; or vague statements like "this uses negative space well" (I recognize those two statements are similar and perhaps related).

Pye, in my opinion, is rather more grounded. For instance (I am doing this from memory and plead being 60 this summer if I'm mangling his argument), he makes the point that part of what we perceive in looking at something is its texture, by which he means both subtle irregularities and the evidence of human involvement in the making of the thing; and that at each level of scale, the scale of the texture should be appropriate to our ability to perceive it. Thus, at close range, the textural irregularities should be relatively small, but still present; at the distance with which we look at a building facade, such small irregularities will be invisible.

He was not a fan of what he called "hairy shirts and lumpy pots" - he wanted to see work being done well, but not perfectly, and was equally not a fan of the industrial everything-polished-dead-smooth school.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#5

Re: I am open to getting yelled at here

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>he wanted to see work being done well, but not perfectly, and was equally not a fan of the industrial everything-polished-dead-smooth school.

Just what Todd refers to when he says "Don't be a Machine Man".

Thanks for the expanded explination Bill.

I don't think anybody is going to yell at you.

T.O.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#6

Re: I am open to getting yelled at here

ThomD

>Though the whole idea of not being a machine arises from the false idea that machine work and hand work are inherantly different in the results they produce. That in turn relies mostly on the ignorance of people who don't understand the hierearchy or history of stuff, or who are quite naturally responding to passing fads in hand work.

A lot of that on the part of the makers is economic, or sucking up for praise. One won't as easily gain recognition for making things that machines can mass produce. It works out nicely for some makers that some of the easier paths also produce the best returns.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#7

I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT ON!

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#8

Re: I am open to getting yelled at here

ThomD

>"this uses negative space well"

You want to see a good example of that, come to my shop, I have a lot of negative space stuffed into pretty much every corner.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#9

I don't think so Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>There are not a lot of black t-shirt wearing designers sporting beret hanging out here.8^)

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#10

I was talking with my son this last week

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>about the plasterers I saw at work years back now, in an old school building in which I was doing custodial work. They were repairing a section of wall (if I recall correctly, after the electricians had torn it up to run some new circuits), and their finish coats gave the impression that they could be used for surface plates - smooth and stunningly flat.

I think Pye's distinction between the workmanship of risk (the worker exercises maximum control but with full responsibility for the outcome) and workmanship of certainty (the worker's range of control is limited by fences, jigs, etc., but his/her responsibility for outcome is correspondingly reduced) may have been one of the most illuminating approaches to the whole hand/machine discussion ever. It takes the whole conversation away from the hand = rough/machine = smooth over-simplification.

Re: Pye's "Workmanship"

#11

Re: I was talking with my son this last week

ThomD

>I agree with you. You can have risk or certainty with either type of tool. It's hard to avoid certainty in any tool that is more or less the definition of a tool, something that confers certainty in some regard, though you can choose to ignore that attribute to greater or lessor extents if you don't happen to need them. You can use two cuts of a 3/8 chisel to get into a socket even if you own the perfect 3/4" chisel.

The plasterer is certainly using the certainty of his tools; the sharp edges, the smooth surfaces, and adjusting the working consistance of the plaster to get the results he wants. But if he wants to add a swirl patern he can do that with his wrist, though it relies on the length of the tool to establish a given swirl radius.

People need stuff and it isn't always clear what is going on. Someone needs a widget for something. And the guy just making one chucks into an engine lathe a piece of the "wrong" rod, the only stuff he has on hand, and he knows it's going to have to go just right to hit the numbers with the carbide cutters he has on hand. He choses his tooling and sets up for the cut, grasping the dial in both hands and feeling the cutter work in the sound, look, or vibe. He smoothly advances the cutter, and the part comes out shinny and perfectly dimension within 1/10 of a thou. To someone watching this happen it looks about as certain as a train timetable, afterall the guy just made a stud. But to the guy doing the work it was a viceral experience, though being a pro he could probably repeat the result every time. What really happened? An engine lathe is about as certain a tool as they come, but even a computer has to make running estimates for tool sharpness and material type, and probably doesn't even know what to allow for the part to work in the place it is going into.

Maybe another way of looking at it is that there are processes people understand and others they don't. The workmanship of inside understanding and the workmanship of the outside amazement.