Re: I was talking with my son this last week
ThomD
>I agree with you. You can have risk or certainty with either type of tool. It's hard to avoid certainty in any tool that is more or less the definition of a tool, something that confers certainty in some regard, though you can choose to ignore that attribute to greater or lessor extents if you don't happen to need them. You can use two cuts of a 3/8 chisel to get into a socket even if you own the perfect 3/4" chisel.
The plasterer is certainly using the certainty of his tools; the sharp edges, the smooth surfaces, and adjusting the working consistance of the plaster to get the results he wants. But if he wants to add a swirl patern he can do that with his wrist, though it relies on the length of the tool to establish a given swirl radius.
People need stuff and it isn't always clear what is going on. Someone needs a widget for something. And the guy just making one chucks into an engine lathe a piece of the "wrong" rod, the only stuff he has on hand, and he knows it's going to have to go just right to hit the numbers with the carbide cutters he has on hand. He choses his tooling and sets up for the cut, grasping the dial in both hands and feeling the cutter work in the sound, look, or vibe. He smoothly advances the cutter, and the part comes out shinny and perfectly dimension within 1/10 of a thou. To someone watching this happen it looks about as certain as a train timetable, afterall the guy just made a stud. But to the guy doing the work it was a viceral experience, though being a pro he could probably repeat the result every time. What really happened? An engine lathe is about as certain a tool as they come, but even a computer has to make running estimates for tool sharpness and material type, and probably doesn't even know what to allow for the part to work in the place it is going into.
Maybe another way of looking at it is that there are processes people understand and others they don't. The workmanship of inside understanding and the workmanship of the outside amazement.