Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Straight Razors?

Posts

Straight Razors?

#1

Straight Razors?

ThomD

>Not woodworking, unless you are Pinochio. Still if you like sharpening fine steel and working with your hands it would seem a natural for woodworkers. It is also one of those things where the old technology still works better by and large. Any other users at Woodcentral.

Re: Straight Razors?

#2

A2 Steel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used a straight razor for almost forty years. I sharpen on an Arkansas stone and strop on canvas and leather.

I wonder if anyone has tried a razor made of A2 steel. Anybody sharpen with diamonds? sandpaper? Shaptons? Has anyone ever done a type study for Techmatics? Does anyone get free upgrades from Gillette in return for reviews? Anybody have a collection of 18th century? Anyone ever design a razor till? Anyone use both power shavers and razors?

Re: Straight Razors?

#3

Does it look like I use one?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Great response Warren.

Stephen


img

Re: Straight Razors?

#4

Re: A2 Steel *LINK*

BobStrawn

>I use diamond powder on a steel plate to sharpen mine.

Bob


OverkillSharp

Re: Straight Razors?

#5

A good place to start *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Try Badger&Blade for those questions. There are lists of Gillette codes for almost all safety razors (mine's a double-edge J2 1964 Gillette Slim adjustable). Since the recent wet-shaving renaissance, I'm more involved in stacking and hand-knotting badger hair and don't know a whole lot about modern razor steels, but you could ask artisan razor-maker Tim Zowada* if he's tried A2.

*http://www.tzknives.com/Razors.html


Badger & Blade forum

Re: Straight Razors?

#6

Jack uses my Arkansas stone to sharpen his.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Straight Razors?

#7

Re: A2 Steel

r payne

>Based on my limited knowledge of metallurgy, A2 would make for an inferior razor. In general a plain carbon steel or low-alloy tool steel will take a finer edge, and thus a better shave, than higher alloy steels.

For what it's worth, when I shave it is with a Dovo straight.

ron

Re: Straight Razors?

#8

Re: Razor Freakout!!

ThomD

>OK, well forty years of shaving has me beat regardless of method. I have only been doing it pretty much as my only method for about 10 years. I tried it but didn't get comfortable with it over the years before. I use trad straight razors.

OK here are the "freakout" elements that would normally cause controversy:

I have a German replaceable blade one for travel, now that HS has determined that straight razors are bad. Think Rali plane, though nicer. Makes the nails curl, right?

I also have experimented with the Lee Valley straight razors from Japan, these are disposable (the shame)

I just got some URLs from my Japan living cousin, and there are some awesome Japanese integral razors out there. Scary sharp doesn't begin to say it!!!!!! My experience with the Lee Valley disposables leads me to the sure knowledge the learning curve will be sharpish.

Hey A2! Good one, that should set some tongues a wagging!

As far as sharpening is concerned I think I would first have to rule out anything I don't want to get lodged under my skin! Diamond particles in petroleum paste, Hmmm... let me think about it.

Re: Straight Razors?

#9

Re: Straight Razors?

paul womack

>The cutting action is most interesting, since (by present woodworking standards) the stones used for sharpening razors are quite coarse.

Either the razor strops work by magic, or the killer-low cutting angle, and micro fine bevel angles are the key.

BugBear

Re: Straight Razors?

#10

Razor Hones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thanks, David. I enjoyed the Zowada site. Interestingly, under Razor Maintenance he lists Norton 4000 and 8000 as preliminary hones. For finishing (polishing) he has Belgian, Translucent Arkansas, Spyderco Ultrafine, Shapton 30,000, and two I am unfamiliar with, Escher and 12K Chinese.

Re: Straight Razors?

#11

Both 12k Chinese and Escher hones... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...are discussed in this thread from Badger & Blade. I've used the UF Spyderco and it's very nice, but I should qualify that I've not used it on woodworking tools -- only gravers, both high carbon and HSS, and 1/4" HSS tool bits.

Interesting to see the similarities and differences between the cutthroat razor community and woodworkers when it comes to getting an edge. No lack of keenness and esoterica in either group.


Razor hone comparison thread (PICS)

Re: Straight Razors?

#12

Re: A good place to start

ThomD

>Zowata is a cool source. He has a very good welding forge kit. It is very reasonably priced, only problem is the home made versions are cheaper still if not as elegant. he seems to be using O1 for his razors, I am assuming the L6 is getting ground out of the edge (?).

Here is a Japanese website for straight razors:

http://www.geocities.co.jp/HeartLand-Asagao/8971/sonotajapan.html

I'm just posting this Geocities site because one of the other sites opened and simultanously all my email archive disappeared...

Re: Straight Razors?

#13

? for David

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Where are you getting your badger hair? I'm looking for a cheaper source.

Re: Straight Razors?

#14

All creatures great and small... and dead *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...can be bought cheaply from Cascade Biological Supply if domestic badger (Taxidea taxus) skins are what you're wanting. Appearance not being terribly germane (missing an ear or a patch of belly fur, say), parts is parts pretty much, so I'd stick with the lower price offerings. Of course, for proper shaving brush 'loads' you'll likely want Chinese or hog badger (Arctonyx collaris), which is not protected and apparently a grocery item throughout its Southeast Asian range.

The advantage of this species for shaving brushes is the especially long and well-tapered neck hairs which make soft yet resilient super-badger and silvertip brush loads with the expected and desired dark banding. American badger brush loads, unless one knows their skins, can turn out plenty soft but floppier on the silvertips and somewhat 'scritchy' on the lower grade hair ('pure' or 'best'). Because of the different hair profile, they are said to bloom differently, too. Some of this I know firsthand and some is hearsay. You might want to experiment. I think the longer imported hair is easier to knot and set in the resin. As most Chinese exported hair is already washed, sorted, graded, and banded - not sold as hides - it's more convenient and far less, ah... 'musky' than working from the skin.

Unfortunately, recent DNA testing has allegedly turned up both hair and brush loads of the Bern-Convention-protected Eurasian badger (Meles meles), so I am doing my utmost to resupply my dwindling stash with the non-protected variety. Also, because of the record cold winter, I'm waiting to find out if this harvest will present denser coats than previous years.

By the way, UK badgers are protected since 1992, so I'm told sporins now sport Canadian heads. Heresy. Badgers are not protected in the U.S. except in national parks and forests.

Drop me a line about two months from now and I'll let you know what I've found out.


Raw, Tanned, or Frozen

Re: Straight Razors?

#15

Re: A good place to start

Dan Donaldson

>Where would you find info on making a shaving brush? It might be interesting to do it yourself as you could make the handle however you wanted.

Re: Straight Razors?

#16

Re: All creatures great and small... and dead

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>David... talk about hardcore. Are you really making these yourself from the hides? Next thing you know, I'll be hearing about you running off to China to become a mountain man and trap your own. I just want to buy some heads. I've found one source on the internet and was wondering if there were better-priced options out there. My wife has put up with the garage and office being taken over by me with the arcana and minutae of hand tools, tool making, metal working and the zen of craft, but I don't believe she's ever going to let me start dealing in hides. Of course I did have a girlfriend right before I met her who helped her father raise chinchillas. I could disguise the creature as a pot-bellied pig. No, no, no. The kids would get attached and would never consent to butchering and then I'd be stuck with yet another member in the menagerie. What am I talking about?! I'm too lazy to get this involved. I don't want a dog, let alone some Chinese badger. Oh just forget it. I'll buy an electric razor.

Re: Straight Razors?

#17

Re: A good place to start *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Dan, go to this link and then look around.


http://www.turchetta.com/goldennib/brushes.htm

Re: Straight Razors?

#18

But that's the fun part! *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Although Wikipedia states: "A shave brush's value is determined more by its bristle load than any other factor. Prices range from $5 synthetic brands to $1200 top-of-the-line brands made of the finest badger hair."

I'd say, however, once you get (or make) a brush past the $200 mark, I suspect diminished returns on discernable badger hair quality when ascending to those more stratospheric price points. Beyond that hundred or so dollars you're paying for top-notch badger loads, it's gonna be handle craftsmanship, materials and product placement that turns the trick.

You can purchase, as you suggested to Dan, bristle loads from Turk, and these will make a decent brush indeed. Truth be told, my everyday brush is a well-made little 'best badger' by Edwin Jagger for Crabtree & Evelyn. Cost: $35. I prefer a slightly 'scritchy' brush rather than the softer silvertip or plush super-badgers, and small rather than eyepopping collosal brushes that whip up mountains of lather.

If your goal is to turn a few nice brushes to sell or give away, I think Turk's brush loads are just the ticket and reasonably priced. I've seen loads sell for more on eBay and I'm not so sure about the quality. One real bargain is the Tweezerman 100% badger brush. Obviously, it's not a silvertip but at seven to ten dollars you could use them just for the loads and toss out the cheap handle.

If, on the other hand, your goal is to make a very few exquisite brushes from unusually talented badgers, loads knotted & shaped to perfection, mounted in handles of precious materials with high-carat gold and gems you've faceted for the purpose, then priced out of all reason, I'd say buy your loads from the best German or English brushmakers or knot them yourself.

Frank Pollaro's offering brushes with bristle loads made to his specs and turns the handles from cocobolo and macassar ebony. Very pretty. Much nicer than some brushes I've seen for more than his $550 price.


Pollaro's cocobolo brush

Re: Straight Razors?

#19

Thanks for the link!

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Really impressive, but I'm still chicken. Those blades bring workmanship-of-risk a little too close to my face and throat for comfort. About as close as I can manage are those Japanese 'Feather' double-edge blades for my vintage* Gillette adjustable. Some people even claim those are too sharp to be safe.

*Strange when you read 1964 Gillettes described as 'vintage' or even 'antique' on eBay and you realize you were 13 when it was made.

Re: Straight Razors?

#20

Besides, they make such great pets *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Just a good brushing everyday and you'll have an endless supply of brush material.


See? They just blend right in.

Re: Straight Razors?

#22

Is this a k�an? Semantic minimalism? Impressive.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>

Re: Straight Razors?

#25

This is your brain on Zen

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Spank me with that big bamboo, Sensei! Yessir! May I have another, sir!