Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

Posts

Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#1

Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

Dave Mount

>Over the past year or two I've been playing around with making side escapement planes. I orginally got Todd Herrli's video and it was great for getting me going. After reading some of Larry Williams info on planes and planemaking here and elsewhere, then hearing positive comments about his new DVD, I decided to buy that DVD too. Having viewed them both from the perspective of someone actually doing this hands on, I thought I might offer some thoughts on what the two alternatives have to offer.

For convenience, I�m going to refer to both gentlemen by their last names. I mean no disrespect in doing so. I would have used first names but that implies a false familiarity.

First and foremost, they are both excellent in my opinion and in that respect, they have much more in common than they have differences. As those who have read his comments before will know, Williams has made quite a study of the history, form and function, of these planes and shares quite a bit of this in his video, which is very interesting. Not to put words in his mouth, but it seems Williams� basic mantra is that the molding plane reached it's pinnacle in the 1700's and it's been downhill ever since. Great care is given to recreating the features and form from the 1700's.

Herrli's approach is a little looser with respect to history. For example, he suggests laminating stock to create beech blanks with a QS grain orientation, whereas Williams has expressed disdain for this approach on the basis of glue interfering with moisture transfer (and perhaps on aesthetics as well). Based on my own limited experience, my gut hunch is that both folks are right in their own way. I'm willing to believe that if one is demanding the ultimate in performance from their planes, there might be an advantage to solid blanks (though thick QS beech is famously difficult to find). At the same time, I think you can make an excellent plane with laminated stock, and if laminating stock gets you going actually making a plane sooner, then it makes more sense to do that than to delay while you search around for suitable stock. As has been discussed here before, whether or not solid blanks are actually superior in some way, there are some very highly regarded wood planes made using laminations (e.g., Krenov, Knight). If your position on the learning curve is that you�re watching videos to figure out how to make planes, then you�ve got more important things to learn and worry about than whether your blank is solid or laminated. Leave that argument for those at the pinnacle of the art and spend your time in the near term figuring out how to properly bed an iron. Your first plane probably won�t be among your best anyway, and will in the long run likely be more of a keepsake than your go-to plane.

Floats are key to the process in both videos. Herrli actually shows you how to make your own floats, while Williams shows you how to sharpen floats, which are those Lie-Nielsen sells. The Williams video was shot at LN and there is prominent product placement in some cases, though I don�t recall any specific pitch for LN products. I don�t find this offensive in the least � good for them for making some of these tools and materials (irons) available commercially and I don�t begrudge them some low key infomercialism along the way. Besides, LN products are pretty to look at anyway (as is Williams� rosewood bench plane by the way. . .).

The overall video quality is excellent in both videos. That said, I think the Herrli video wins by a small margin in this category. The Williams video lacks close ups at some obvious points where they would have been good. It�s not crippling, but I felt the Herrli video had really good close-ups of key aspects of the process. In fact, I can�t think of anything offhand that Herrli doesn�t fully explain and show in more than adequate detail to actually do it yourself. That�s not to say the Williams video is inadequate, just that Herrli�s seems a better in this regard. Herrli�s approach kind of makes me think of the way Woodsmith approaches project articles � it�s a real step by step �recipe� for doing it.

There was one thing I didn�t know about H&Rs that Herrli explained very clearly but Williams did not. That was the way that the interaction of the plane profile and iron profile works to create, effectively, a depth stop in the plane. Herrli explains how the exposed iron should die away at the edges of the profile so that the plane stops cutting once it has cut to full profile depth. To start the plane cutting again, you tilt the plane and that starts it cutting deeper if that�s what you want. This seems like a pretty important point that was not mentioned at all in the Williams video. I�m not sure if that was just an omission, if he has different views on this, or if it is just assumed that the viewer is knowledgeable enough to know that already (I didn�t).

As an aside, I found it amusing that both Herrli and Williams missed their intended target with they drilled the wedge mortise (both errors were recoverable).

I have the Herrli video in VHS and the Williams on DVD. The Williams DVD has very convenient chaptering that allows you to go back to any point in the process. Now that Herrli�s video is available in DVD, I�m guessing they did the same, but I don�t know that -- perhaps someone with the DVD can comment. The VHS presentation did break the process up into the same basic elements, there�s just no convenient way to find those spots on VHS.

Before I conclude, I should re-emphasize that I viewed the Herrli video a year or more before I saw the Williams video; that might color my impressions as I already knew a lot of things and had some planemaking experience under my belt before I saw the Williams video. It would be interesting to know what my impressions would have been if I had seen them in reverse order.

Well, let�s try to bring this to a bottom line. The first conclusion is that both are very good videos and I don�t think anyone interested in making side escapement planes would be sorry they bought either one of them. In fact, I�m not sorry I own both of them and I will keep both of them. While probably 80-90% of the material is identical between them, there are some interesting differences if you�re into those interesting differences. Because I see Larry Williams writings here and elsewhere, it was very interesting to me to see him in person, hear him explain things orally, and see him work. If you�re just going to buy one of the two, I guess it depends one what you want most. If your priorities include the tradition and historical aspects of the planes and planemaking, or the connection to Larry Williams, then I�d opt for the Williams video. If you just want to �git �er done� and start making tools, then I think the Herrli video has a small edge � it is just a little better done from a purely instructional viewpoint (Joel at TFWW notes that it is clear that Herrli is a teacher). For the penny pinchers, Herrli gets an additional advantage on cost too � Herrli�s DVD is $21.99 from Tools for Working Wood (www.toolsforworkingwood.com) or $24.95 (only $3 shipping) from ALP productions (http://members.bellatlantic.net/~vze2nwp6/planes/hollow.html) and Williams� is $40 at LN (www.lie-nielsen.com). If you�re into it though, I think you might be happy having seen both.

For the record, no affiliations with anyone with any interest in either DVD.

Dave

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#2

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R D

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Great review Dave!

I concur with all your comments. Having put together a few to-do articles to date, and having watched the DVDS of both Larry and Todd, I am reminded how easy it is to omit bits of information. I think both these DVDs are truly excellent. I heartedly recommend them for those that plan to build planes and for those who simply want to know how it is done. It is really helpful to watch the construction process and to know that these guys are human ... since this brings the construction of these planes within the reach of us mere mortals! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#3

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R D

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Very good write-up Dave--tho I can't fully support that statement as I have not seen the Williams DVD only Herrlis'

I am curious as to why you felt that drilling the wedge mortice was an error. Wouldn't it seem feesible to drill it first, then squre it afterwards with floats?

It did occur to me while reading your review that perhaps when making such a plane if it would be easier to start with a much wider block of wood then the finished plane will be to offer stability while cutting the mortice--unless of coarse your doing the lamination style then it wouldn't be necessary.

I watched the Herrli video some time ago, but the thing I remeber the most is that he was answering questions as I was asking them, and that he did do close-ups of the important points. I do need to re-watch sometime tho.

T.O.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#4

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R D

ThomD

>"I am curious as to why you felt that drilling the wedge mortice was an error. Wouldn't it seem feesible to drill it first, then squre it afterwards with floats?"

He isn't saying it isn't a valid technique, he is saying they didn't drill straight, missed their targets, goofed.

On the glued up stock, there are dangers to that, I think at the very least you will get returns which destroys all profit to a professional. I am thnking of constructed blanks, not the wear strips on finish planes. Also, there is plenty of beech out there the suppliers just don't know we need it. Oneo f our better hardwood su0ppliers doesn't have it, but he has guitar woods from all over, and Osage, and various forms of bamboo, etc... In one of the places I have familly they have whole river bottoms of beech, and it gets burned in the local fireplaces. I could have got some easily 10 years back, but I wasn't interested in beech at the time, and since then I am not making progress in securing any as some farms got sold out of the family.

Since the solid stock is available it's crazy to glue it up and then buy expensive floats the main purpose of which are to create reference surfaces that a glued up plane would not need created in that way.

I would be interested in knowing whether a beech plane with glued up bady is more or less stable than a maple plane in one piece. beech is said to have an advantage in moving moisture out of the pores evenly in two crossgrain directions. But if one of those is blocked with glue it could make a difference as Williams suggests.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#5

Re: Laminations etc.

Dave Mount

>I agree Thom, there is plenty of beech growing out there, the issue is just finding someone that will cut it in a way that yields good plane blanks. I live in the wrong part of the country to find such a source (northern Minnesota).

With regard to the stability of other species, Larry Williams does comment in his DVD about the suitability of other species, like yellow birch, cherry, and apple (I don't remember if he says anything about maple). Even for widely available species, the difficulty is finding thick QS stock.

I don't claim to know the answers on the lamination debate, but there are several subtleties to the issue. First, if one accepts that a glue line is indeed an interference to moisture movement, it makes a difference what kind of lamination it is. In Herrli's lamination approach, the glue lines are in planes parallel to the plane's sole, so moisture migration out the ends and out the sides is not altered; it is only "vertical" migration that would be affected. Most molding planes are very narrow compared to their height, so a "stacked" lamination may not be that big a deal as the shortest distance out of the blank isn't affected by the glue line.

On the other hand, I've heard it claimed that rays are an important conduit for moisture out wood on non-endgrain surfaces of wood. If a molding plane blank is glued up in QS orientation, then the "ray pathway" out of the blank is obstructed by the glue lines.

All of these issues would be reversed for a lamination as in a Krenov-type plane. In fact, with a more or less square cross section, and if moisture movement does largely follow the rays, one could argue that a Krenov-type lamination in a bench plane would not influence moisture movement that much.

Another factor for moisture movement is that wood bodied planes have substantial end grain exposed in the mortise. Since moisture moves faster to/from endgrain than edge/face grain, there is some innate differential that is created that way; not sure that would be affected by whether the body is laminated or not, since there are no glue lines across end grain.

Personally, I'm on the fence. I much prefer the aesthetics of a solid body plane. However, I've built side escapement planes with both a Krenov-style lamination (the wedge mortise is cut as an open mortise) and by drilling through a one-piece blank and using floats to shape the wedge mortise. From my experiences, it is one heck of a lot easier to get a nicely shaped wedge mortise with the blank laid open than it is working down a hole you can't see into. It's clearly not a problem for someone like Larry Williams, but for a newbie, it is not a cakewalk to get wedge mortise that is straight, tight, and and perfectly in line with the bed and breast cuts at the mouth. The comparison between two perfectly constructed planes, one with a laminated body and one solid is one thing. The comparison between a laminated plane with a nice tight/straight wedge mortise and bed line, and a solid body plane with some hollows and gaps in the mortise and bed might look different.

I can say one thing for sure: building these planes has taught me a lot about how they work (or are supposed to work) -- even the failures teach.

Best,

Dave

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#6

Re: Laminations etc.

ThomD

>I think the main thing for me with hollows and rounds is that the amount of work involved to make a set really calls for getting everything right. Whatever that means to each person.

Lining up the cuts is actually pretty easy, coming from both ends, if the layout is right and the ramp is flat your done. Getting the ranp perfectly flat, and other surfaces, calls for a float, and that is the nub of the mater, cost and tool wise. On some planes you have access for chisels, but in confined spaces that is tough.

One thing with the krenov style planes is that you can make them so as to eliminate moisture movement, it takes a bit of thought, but for some of the longer finishing planes they can shift out of the cut at times.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#7

Excellent review Dave.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I have Todd's DVD and have wondered about Larry's. Thank you for taking the time to write this up. Yet another DVD on the buy list.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#8

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R D

Larry Williams

>Hi Dave,

I had decided I wouldn't comment when the inevitable comparisons between these videos would surface. In this case though, I feel there are some factual issues I should address.

"...There was one thing I didn�t know about H&Rs that Herrli explained very clearly but Williams did not. That was the way that the interaction of the plane profile and iron profile works to create, effectively, a depth stop in the plane. Herrli explains how the exposed iron should die away at the edges of the profile so that the plane stops cutting once it has cut to full profile depth. To start the plane cutting again, you tilt the plane and that starts it cutting deeper if that�s what you want. This seems like a pretty important point that was not mentioned at all in the Williams video. I�m not sure if that was just an omission, if he has different views on this, or if it is just assumed that the viewer is knowledgeable enough to know that already (I didn�t). ..."

I actually did comment on this. I said the irons must cut the full width of the sole and plane's profile. Anyone who actually tries to use these planes will soon realize the folly of shaping and sharpening the irons as you suggest. Even the most basic ovolo or ogee will include at least one fillet which requires working completely to the edge of the profile. In order to place the plane's profile next to any other element of a molding it must work all the way to the side of the plane.

There's also the issue of depth of cut. Especially on the mid sized and larger hollows and rounds, it's important for the plane to function as both a roughing and very fine cutting finishing planes. With the iron shaped and sharpened as you suggest the planes need to be set for only one depth of cut.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#9

Re: Thanks for the additional info

Dave Mount

>Hello Larry--

Thanks for clarifying my misunderstanding -- your explanation makes sense. Thanks also for taking the time to share your knowledge here and elsewhere. I guess the plus side of my error is that it does show how influential putting woodworking knowledge in DVD form can be. I'm a handtool island up here in NE Minnesota, that is to say that I don't know any woodworkers that routinely use handtools; as a result, things like DVDs and forums are two of very few mechanisms I have to learn things like H&R construction or their use.

Another plus of me seeing your DVD was that it finally convinced me to buy floats and use a solid construction for making molding planes. Up until recently I had been cutting wedge mortises by splitting the blank and cutting it as an open mortise. I've now converted over to drilling and floating out the mortise, though I've been using a drill press instead of a brace for drilling and, as yet, haven't put a "lean" into my mortises. Baby steps, I guess.

Anyway, thanks for the additional info and apologies for any unintended inaccuracies in my DVD comparison.

Best,

Dave

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#10

Re: And a ? -- shaping side bead irons

Dave Mount

>As long as you're here. . .

I'm in the middle of making some side bead planes. Last night I was working on the initial shaping of the blanks for two 1/4" side bead irons (I think the sizing terminology is right -- the arc has a 1/4" diameter). I was shaping the concavity in the iron with a 3/16" diameter round file -- I don't have any grinding tools that would help with this small a profile. While the 1/16" difference in diameter between the profile and the file gave me a little lateral room, it's hard to cut in much side clearance on sides of the profile without buggering the opposite edge. How much bevel (clearance angle) is appropriate on the sides of this kind of profile? I used 30 degrees at the bottom of the concavity, but that tapers quickly to "not much" up on the sides of the spurs.

I suppose this is a place where an abrasive cone would be useful. . .

Thanks for any advice,

Dave

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#11

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R D

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Hi, Larry--

Todd demonstrated that disappearing profile on a hollow, where tilting probably could get you to where you need to be. I don't think he meant it for anything more complex. Difficult enough on a hollow. : )

Looking forward to seeing you at Marc Adams this summer.

Best, Ted

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#12

Stylish moldings

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have a motley collection of hollows and rounds that I bought individually in the 1980's. I have four different pitches and probably all different makers. I am glad that some of them were sharpened the way Dave describes with feathered edges because I learned how to do it.

Larry, if you want to make a bland sixty degree arc, the sharpening is fine as you describe. But if you want a stylish 18th century molding, say a 70,80,90 degree arc cove, you must use a round that is narrower than the cove and tilt the plane to get the full arc. If it is sharpened the way you describe, it will leave tracks where the edge of the iron is in the middle of the cove. A feathered iron eliminates this problem in the same way that cambered edge on a smoothing plane leaves a fine surface. I can assure you that no one wants to sit around scraping or sanding their moldings because of tracks.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#13

Re: And a ? -- shaping side bead irons

Larry Williams

>Dave,

A five degree bevel on the sides would give enough clearance and still allow you to maintain the flat face with each sharpening without opening up the profile too much. I'd transition from about five degrees on the vertical edges to about 30 degrees on the top or most horizontal portion of the profile.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#14

a couple questions

Larry Williams

>Warren,

Is it possible you're tuning and sharpening your hollows and rounds with the assumption you can't refine the edge of the iron well enough to take a finish cut? I agree that heavy slightly offset cuts will result in unacceptably uneven surfaces. A fine finish cut is a different matter.

Starting out with low expectations may well guarantee mediocre results.

Re: Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs

#15

Re: a couple questions

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am saying that I have used both methods and I prefer the method outlined by Dave in his original post. Since I was already proficient with a smoothing plane when I started using hollows and rounds about 1980, I have never had a problem taking a finish cut or getting a refined edge. The feathered sharpening is most helpful when cutting an arc greater than 60 degrees or when making a complex molding where the curve of one plane has to transition into the curve of another. For molding planes other than hollows and rounds, a uniform depth of cut across the cutting edge is more appropriate.