Comparison/review of Herrli and Williams H&R DVDs
Dave Mount
>Over the past year or two I've been playing around with making side escapement planes. I orginally got Todd Herrli's video and it was great for getting me going. After reading some of Larry Williams info on planes and planemaking here and elsewhere, then hearing positive comments about his new DVD, I decided to buy that DVD too. Having viewed them both from the perspective of someone actually doing this hands on, I thought I might offer some thoughts on what the two alternatives have to offer.
For convenience, I�m going to refer to both gentlemen by their last names. I mean no disrespect in doing so. I would have used first names but that implies a false familiarity.
First and foremost, they are both excellent in my opinion and in that respect, they have much more in common than they have differences. As those who have read his comments before will know, Williams has made quite a study of the history, form and function, of these planes and shares quite a bit of this in his video, which is very interesting. Not to put words in his mouth, but it seems Williams� basic mantra is that the molding plane reached it's pinnacle in the 1700's and it's been downhill ever since. Great care is given to recreating the features and form from the 1700's.
Herrli's approach is a little looser with respect to history. For example, he suggests laminating stock to create beech blanks with a QS grain orientation, whereas Williams has expressed disdain for this approach on the basis of glue interfering with moisture transfer (and perhaps on aesthetics as well). Based on my own limited experience, my gut hunch is that both folks are right in their own way. I'm willing to believe that if one is demanding the ultimate in performance from their planes, there might be an advantage to solid blanks (though thick QS beech is famously difficult to find). At the same time, I think you can make an excellent plane with laminated stock, and if laminating stock gets you going actually making a plane sooner, then it makes more sense to do that than to delay while you search around for suitable stock. As has been discussed here before, whether or not solid blanks are actually superior in some way, there are some very highly regarded wood planes made using laminations (e.g., Krenov, Knight). If your position on the learning curve is that you�re watching videos to figure out how to make planes, then you�ve got more important things to learn and worry about than whether your blank is solid or laminated. Leave that argument for those at the pinnacle of the art and spend your time in the near term figuring out how to properly bed an iron. Your first plane probably won�t be among your best anyway, and will in the long run likely be more of a keepsake than your go-to plane.
Floats are key to the process in both videos. Herrli actually shows you how to make your own floats, while Williams shows you how to sharpen floats, which are those Lie-Nielsen sells. The Williams video was shot at LN and there is prominent product placement in some cases, though I don�t recall any specific pitch for LN products. I don�t find this offensive in the least � good for them for making some of these tools and materials (irons) available commercially and I don�t begrudge them some low key infomercialism along the way. Besides, LN products are pretty to look at anyway (as is Williams� rosewood bench plane by the way. . .).
The overall video quality is excellent in both videos. That said, I think the Herrli video wins by a small margin in this category. The Williams video lacks close ups at some obvious points where they would have been good. It�s not crippling, but I felt the Herrli video had really good close-ups of key aspects of the process. In fact, I can�t think of anything offhand that Herrli doesn�t fully explain and show in more than adequate detail to actually do it yourself. That�s not to say the Williams video is inadequate, just that Herrli�s seems a better in this regard. Herrli�s approach kind of makes me think of the way Woodsmith approaches project articles � it�s a real step by step �recipe� for doing it.
There was one thing I didn�t know about H&Rs that Herrli explained very clearly but Williams did not. That was the way that the interaction of the plane profile and iron profile works to create, effectively, a depth stop in the plane. Herrli explains how the exposed iron should die away at the edges of the profile so that the plane stops cutting once it has cut to full profile depth. To start the plane cutting again, you tilt the plane and that starts it cutting deeper if that�s what you want. This seems like a pretty important point that was not mentioned at all in the Williams video. I�m not sure if that was just an omission, if he has different views on this, or if it is just assumed that the viewer is knowledgeable enough to know that already (I didn�t).
As an aside, I found it amusing that both Herrli and Williams missed their intended target with they drilled the wedge mortise (both errors were recoverable).
I have the Herrli video in VHS and the Williams on DVD. The Williams DVD has very convenient chaptering that allows you to go back to any point in the process. Now that Herrli�s video is available in DVD, I�m guessing they did the same, but I don�t know that -- perhaps someone with the DVD can comment. The VHS presentation did break the process up into the same basic elements, there�s just no convenient way to find those spots on VHS.
Before I conclude, I should re-emphasize that I viewed the Herrli video a year or more before I saw the Williams video; that might color my impressions as I already knew a lot of things and had some planemaking experience under my belt before I saw the Williams video. It would be interesting to know what my impressions would have been if I had seen them in reverse order.
Well, let�s try to bring this to a bottom line. The first conclusion is that both are very good videos and I don�t think anyone interested in making side escapement planes would be sorry they bought either one of them. In fact, I�m not sorry I own both of them and I will keep both of them. While probably 80-90% of the material is identical between them, there are some interesting differences if you�re into those interesting differences. Because I see Larry Williams writings here and elsewhere, it was very interesting to me to see him in person, hear him explain things orally, and see him work. If you�re just going to buy one of the two, I guess it depends one what you want most. If your priorities include the tradition and historical aspects of the planes and planemaking, or the connection to Larry Williams, then I�d opt for the Williams video. If you just want to �git �er done� and start making tools, then I think the Herrli video has a small edge � it is just a little better done from a purely instructional viewpoint (Joel at TFWW notes that it is clear that Herrli is a teacher). For the penny pinchers, Herrli gets an additional advantage on cost too � Herrli�s DVD is $21.99 from Tools for Working Wood (www.toolsforworkingwood.com) or $24.95 (only $3 shipping) from ALP productions (http://members.bellatlantic.net/~vze2nwp6/planes/hollow.html) and Williams� is $40 at LN (www.lie-nielsen.com). If you�re into it though, I think you might be happy having seen both.
For the record, no affiliations with anyone with any interest in either DVD.
Dave



