Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Moses, Care to Expound?

Posts

Moses, Care to Expound?

#1

Moses, Care to Expound?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I would agree that we would be much better off trying to make some progress instead of trying to recreate what we imagine the past was like. Although there is nothing wrong with recreating history. Maybe we can chew on that for a while. I'm just going though a stage now where I don't believe the past was nearly as good as we think it was.

I lifted you're quote from the violin thread below in order to give it a life of it's own. To me, not knowing jack about violins I found this to be the most inquisitive statement of the entire thread.

Kinda' funny, but I was thinking somewheres along the same lines just the other day. I was wondering just how long we "moderns" are going to be so deeply enamored with the past, namely the 18th and 19th centuries. Come the 28th and 29th centuries will the 18th and 19th still be the darlings that are today?

So, what's going thru your mind Moses?

T.O.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#2

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Hank Knight

>Many of us, maybe most of us, who were born in the middle of the 20th Century have experienced that dreaded trip to the outhouse at 4 A.M. on a February morning. Some of us may still have to endure that journey. That alone should be enough to convince anyone that the "good old days" live largely in our imagination and that real life in the old days was not all it is now cracked up to be.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#3

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Yeah Hank, I used to make those trips back in my youth, and I was born in '61!! No Ernie, not 1861! How many times do I have to tell you that my hairline has nothing to do with my age? ;~)

T.O.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#4

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Chuck Nickerson

>If woodworking is one's hobby, one gets to choose their methods. I know someone who makes and uses bows and arrows made without using electricity or metal. A high percentage of his enjoyment flows from his aboriginal approach. If people using other methods don't get it, that's their problem, not my friend's.

If woodworking is one's occupation, one can still choose to use older methods. Work can be more than just a way to pay the bills. One way to make it such is to use older methods to connect with past generations of craftsmen.

Everyone gets to choose their own path, and a lack of understanding from the other paths does not invalidate the choice.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#5

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

A. Sender

>It�s surprising to find so many questioning the value to be had from researching historical craft techniques. The rediscovery of the efficiency and esthetic value of hand work which has been going on these last 3 decades is something I would have thought hard to ignore. Such information may not be of interest to everyone, but to argue that it is not worth pursuing at all flies in the face of the experiences and judgment of a lot of craftsmen.

Painting the issue as an all-or-nothing conflict between �luddite� and �practical modern person� just sets up a false alternative and clouds the issue for the sake of rhetorical impact.

Apparently it needs to be pointed out that someone who finds a Roubo bench or an 18th century style single-iron plane to be useful isn�t into the past for mere romantic reasons which would also lead them to prefer dentistry with no anesthesia or an absence of modern plumbing.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#6

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Dave Anderson NH

>My short take on this is that "the good old days.....weren't." Life up until the 20th century was short and often brutal from a medical and often a living condition perspective. We always tend to romanticize based on the perceptions we developed at a youny age from watching Davey Crockett, Johnny Tremain, etc. None of these mental pictures developed during our impressionable years showed the use of outhouses, freezing in front of the fire in uninsulated buildings, generally unsanitary conditions, death from disease and working conditions, etc. Life was not good for most folks then except in the sense that it was usually better than a century before.

While the above is all true, it doesn't mean that there aren't things to learn from the past. In hand tool woodworking this is particularly true.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#7

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Greg Forster

>Is this focus on 18/19th c more of an American thing or is it universal?

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#8

Re: Expound

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There is a great value in researching old methods of working wood. I agree with that, and I think most people do. It takes all kinds of people to make the world function and we have different interests. While I enjoy learning from people who have researched the past doing research is not what keeps me awake at night. My thoughts on the past have been pretty well voiced by some of the other posts; it's just not as good as some think it was. We have it better today than at any other time in history. We have both the tools for learning from each other and the leisure time and money to pursue those interests. This isn't really connected with the original request for information on planes used by Antonio Stradivari, the thoughts just kind of dribbled out from the attached conversation. I just tend to believe that Stradivari was not nearly as good as we think he was. I really don't intend any disrespect for the man. It's just that my opinion of putting someone on a pedestal and worshipping them ranks pretty low. I'm sure people will take that in a wrong way, which will be their problem and not mine. I hope to make some violins someday. My daughter is practicing the violin and it would be neat to make a violin that she would play. But I have already decided if I do make an instrument I will not be trying to recreate what was in the past, I will be finding out how I can make the best with what I have today. This is the key to a successful and happy life; doing the best we can with what we have. (You will have to add some religion to that in order to make it work but this is not the correct forum for that discussion).

I'm just an average man stating my opinion, not a professor lecturing at a university. Anyone who dislikes what I write can send me a note of discouragement and I will immediately refund the price of admission.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#9

Re: Expound

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

> We have it better today than at any other time in history.

Trust me, trust me, I am not taking issue with anything Moses, nor trying to incite a riot, but I've got to disagree with the above statement a little.

I heard on the news the other night where they think they can have water go from toilet to table in two days!?!?

We've got poisons everywhere we turn, air,land, water, food.

I think at one point we did have good, but we've past that point IMO and are fast declining on the whole.

T.O.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#10

Re: Moses, set-point?

ThomD

>"how long we "moderns" are going to be so deeply enamored with the past, namely the 18th and 19th centuries."

Apparently there is a psychological division between people who are forward looking or rearward looking. You are born that way, or something equally definitive. Neither camp has any more claim to rationality, it's hard wired. Then you have Buddhists, who are in the present.

Anyway, I have been wondering recently how long the hold on the imagination is also. In particular is it a constantly moving set-point. There are always going to be items that have greater or lesser hold, religions being an obvious example. But outside that, stuff moves on, I think.

I had actual real contact with many of the things I am interested in. Anyone who has seen my photos of the bench in our lakeside shop knows what I mean. I grew up with a great uncle who lived and farmed the land and used hand tools from hay rakes to hand planes, because nothing better had yet been invented for individual ownership.

My father grew up in a cabinet shop where the men ripped out the stock by hand, and used a foot powered mortiser. I'm not convinced that stories from my generation will have the same hold as that real contact. Maybe because I am OD on this stuff, but the average person wouldn't pass much of this on, and it should loose it's hold.

Ask yourself how far back the average person knows their family history, really can put a face on it from family albums and word of mouth stories. I think that is about as far as it goes.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#11

Re: Expound

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

> "We're past that point IMO and are fast declining on the whole"

There are a variety of different facets to life. I think perhaps a very big book could be written on the subject. First of all is the life of the individual versus the life of the community versus the life of the whole world. As individuals we have never had better opportunities than we have today. This is due to increased knowledge in medicine/science, which is due I think in large part to increased speed of communication. The faster the communication the faster we make advances in science. Individuals can still make stupid decisions which will send their life right into the crapper. So they might end up trying to dig themselves out of a hole and find plenty of blame to shovel around. I won't go into it too much on a woodworking forum but I agree that more individuals are making stupid decisions today than ever before in history. However my dad at age 72 or so is still alive due to advances in medicine. If he had the heart problems even 15 years earlier there is a good chance he would not have survived because they would not have found the blockage. He is the oldest living of his family because the other siblings chose not to take care of themselves.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#12

Re: cabinet shop

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I am curious about the shop your father worked in where they ripped the stock by hand. I am 40 and my father was born in 1930 or thereabouts. I find it hard to beleive there would have been any cabinet shops working in 1930 that would have ripped their stock by hand. Or even in the early 1900's. Some of my relatives used steam powered saw mills, and my father did also. A few of my relatives died when the boiler blew up; I will have to dig up that story and post it. There are some aspects of that life that greatly appeal to me but I think I am better off just apreciating and taking advantage of what we have today.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#13

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Mike Fitterling

>Here's my rambling thoughts, for what its worth.

I'd say there were good things about the past and bad things, as there are today. Obviously, medical advance has made life much better for many people. On the other hand, the move from manual labor to information processing, for those who like to be actively creative, may not be better.

I feel, like many in the Arts and Crafts movement during the peak of the industrial revolution, that something was lost when work was removed from the hands of man to his machines. Now, even that machine work is disappearing, leaving us only with "brain work." Now, I love using my intellect to solve problems and to learn or teach things, but there is something about working with my hands, too. It has not beeen many years, historically speaking, since our world has changed from an almost primitive one to the artifical one we live in day to day. There is something nice about taking a primitive material, like wood, and primitive tools that are basically no more than wood and a scrap of iron, and making something useful.

What the modern world has done is make us dependant; dependant on things beyond our control. Not only that, but many have become dependant on dubiously "essential" things like TV, telephones, computers, air conditioning, etc. For example; I once, in a time of financial crisis, got rid of our cell phones to save money; only to have a fury of disapproval by in-laws for doing so and not keeping my family "safe," as if cell phones were an essential part of life.

If the power grid went down tomorrow, how would we get on? If money became useless tomorrow, how would we continue to work? Being able to create useful things by hand keeps me in touch with the "real" world. Hunting is similar to this to me, too, and is a major attraction in it to me. Unlike the millions who go to McDonalds and have their quarter pounders, who at the same time decry the "violence" of hunting; the hunter is in direct touch with the most primal need and takes responsibility himself for satisfying that need. There is an attraction for me to these things that are "independant" of modern life. Even if I use power tools for some of my work, I know what they are doing and how to do it manually if need be.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#14

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Well put Mike!

As an example,I tried to live without television for a number of years, but it's a losing battle. Inevitably the partner wants the tv, etc.. We watch it sparingly now, but I can easily do without it.

Seems like we increasingly add complexity to our lives. What began as instruments to make our lives simpler ... we have now becomes slaves to:

Cell phones, the Internet, television, Crackberries, etc.

We went from essential communication to an abundance of forms of electronic communication.. the verdict is still out on whether this is a good thing or a level of complexity and addiction which keeps us from everything else in our lives.

Sometimes I see all of this as a myriad of distractions, keeping us from our core creativity. There is a lot said for a little solitude without distraction to stir up the creative juices. Technology has invaded our lives to such an extent that this solitude is more difficult to attain.

I often tell my wife I'd like to one day just toss out everytihng technological except for a basic phone, stock up on books, and go from there. I'm afraid this is becoming increasinly an impossibility.

Norman

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#15

Re: Moses, set-point? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>It turns out there's a religion gene, too. Check out the past programs, there are 3 or 4 dealing with religion specifically. Of course, this radio show is one of my favorites.

Pam


Philosophy Talk

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#16

Do you hunt with bow & arrow? Spears? :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#17

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Many good points made for sure. I think the biggest fault of it all is that for some reason Americans(and perhaps other countries as well, but I won't speak on them)really got hooked into over indulgence of comfort/luxury items. Seems they felt that these things would bring Happiness into their lives, and yet, truth be told, the items where/are the source of the Unhappiness.

I recognized as a teenager that we where way to dependent on electricity, and that if it where suddenly gone we'd be in big big trouble RIGHT NOW!

I also realized that if I didn't go out and buy that expensive item that I really didn't need then I wouldn't have to worry about paying for it. Funny thing is that I just read this same ideal in Walden" a few days ago. If Thoreau was considered a crackpot, well then, seems I'm in the same boat as he--which suits me just fine.

I own no cell phone and get along just fine. Are they nice to have, yeah, I'm sure they are, are they a necessity--not to me.

Sure the medical advances have been a true blessing and I have no kick with them. Heck, when I myself was born, from what I was told I weighed around 3 pounds, and I'm sure that the medical advances even in 1961 are the reason I'm even here at all.

This isn't no rant on my part, I'm just musing and grousing out loud.

I will confess to being highly dismayed and distressed by the average person today. To me they are lazy, fat and stupid, which, in this day in age there is no reason for, but it's their choice to be so and there is nowt I can do about it.

T.O.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#18

Re: Do you hunt with bow & arrow? Spears? :)

Mike Fitterling

>I could, if need be, and have in the past. Most of the skill is the same, and other than needing to be nearer your target with a bow, the stealth, quiet, listening, and patience is the same. Here in Florida, where I hunt, mostly thick brushy woods and swamp, when a shot appears it is usually in range of bow, shotgun, or rifle, and even spear. There have been a couple times when it was close enough for hand to antler combat! But that is a bit primitive, even for me! :)

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#19

Re: Do you hunt with bow & arrow? Spears? :)

lignator

>"hand to antler combat"

That's when you pull out your trusty pigsticker mortise chisel.

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#20

Not to mention the danger...

Alan DuBoff

>Mike wrote:

"There have been a couple times when it was close enough for hand to antler combat! But that is a bit primitive, even for me! :)"

I have heard of the danger of a deer hoofing humans to death in fear. If you grabbed one by the antlers I suspect they would get startled and hoof you and/or put up a pretty good fight.

I admire the bow, it shows way more skill, and presents more challenge, opposed to firing a gun.

I'd sure love to see someone wrestling with one, hanging on to their antlers, I suspect it would be entertaining until the deer pummeled the person hanging on.:-/

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#21

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

Dean Lapinel

>As usual Andres....well stated-

Dean

Re: Moses, Care to Expound?

#22

Cool.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>