Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Veritas dovetail saw guide

Posts

Veritas dovetail saw guide

#1

Veritas dovetail saw guide

Bill Leffingwell

>I am looking for first hand info on the Veritas Dove tail guide.I have project requiring a lot of hand cut, near perfect DTs(to go thru a very nit picking jury process)I can cut them freehand but for me it is a slow process. I've seen one of these guides and it looks good,but I'd like find someone has actually used on projects and get the real pros and cons.Any info would be greatly appreciated.

Bill

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#2

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

The Veritas dovetail guide will enable you to do one of the important requirements perfectly, that is, it will ensure straight saw cuts.

What it will not do is cut a uniform baseline, nor will it remove the waste cleanly.

It will also not ensure that you cut to the baseline and not over it.

Further, it cannot take responsibility for the layout, which includes the width of the apex of the tail.

All of these areas contribute to fine dovetails. A guide is not needed - and sometimes not possible - for some of these aspects. Perhaps you need to analise what area you are weakest in, and improve this with some added practice.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#3

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Bill Leffingwell

>Derek

Thanks for your response you confirm my thoughts.I've been making furniture using hand cut DTs for 15 years find my weakness is speed,and on most jobs very good is good enough,not this time however.I would have to repair the smallest error.If I can speed the process of getting a straight cut at the right angle it would reduce errors and time both in cutting and repairing.That why I'd like to find some input from an actual user.

Guess what I am looking for is a tool to improve speed and maintain quality.

Good luck and enjoy your summer weather

Bill

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#4

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

If all you are looking for is improved speed and accuracy of the saw cut, the Veritas guide sounds tailor made for you. It is very easy to use in the way you envisage. However ...

I bought one years ago and used it a little. It is beautifully made, robust and will do all it claims. But it lay on a shelf as I did not need it. I resisted selling it as this voice in my head said that I might need it for "perfect" saw cuts when a project demanded it. The fact is that I have still to find a project right for it, and it alone. I do a lot of boxes or drawers with really tiny dovetails, one's that are for show and require a very delicate cut. I try to go saw cut to saw cut. Sometimes I will use a Japanese saw because the wood is a little brittle, but otherwise I am fine with a Western saw. The cuts are "good enough" for me and I am quite fussy. So I guess it will come down to what is good enough for you and whether an adjustment of technique may be what you might otherwise seek.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#5

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Jim in VA

>Bill, If you decide you want one, I have one for sale over on the classified section.

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#6

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Paul Kierstead

>I had one and used it some (though not a great deal). It definitely helps with accuracy, but can't say much good for it on the speed category, unless you normally saw well wide of the line and pare in, in which case you might save time.

Since someone has one for sale, it won't cost too much to find out though.

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#7

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

Bill Leffingwell Richwood wv

>Just what I needed to hear.Years ago I bought a chisel sharpening guide tried it a couple times,put it a tool box and it's still there.I think Dereks advice is the answer "practice"Its been almost a year since the last dovetail session so I'll consider it as Spring Training.

I want thank everyone for the help.I've been on Badger Pond and here in the past, but I've been away for several years.I'm finally back.

Bill

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Meanwhile...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Bill,I'm a firm believer in cutting without a guide.I think using the guide just makes you less likely to learn sawing. My eyesight stinks,but because of practice I can cut straight lines as quick as I need to. However,if you need to cut alot of dovetails and wish to speed up the process try the bandsaw.David Charlesworth talks about the process in the latest Popular Woodworking issue.It seems he has the same problem you have. (not that good at cutting a straight line due to lack of practice) Have fun with it.---Jack

p.s. my apologies for the power tool reference. :-)

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#9

Re: Meanwhile...

Bill Leffingwell Richwood wv

>Jack

David Marks had a program where he demonstrated this technique,I tried it and it works but I didn't see that it was much better than the hand method,also my my bandsaw table doesn't tilt enough to cut the pins.I think if someone really spent the time practicing and had a table(or jig) to cut pins it could be a good alternative.I did find you still had to cut to the line which was not as easy as it seems(for me anyway)Maybe someone uses this method could give an opinion.Thanks for the suggestion.

Bill

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#10

Re: Meanwhile...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jack

Actually, I think that the Veritas guide is a good set of training wheels for someone that wants to learn to handcut dovetails. The magnetic block does not completely limit movement (such as with a mitresaw), and there is a lot of room to develop muscle memory. Don't forget - as I pointed out in my first reply - cutting straight is but one of several skills here.

Bill

Jack's suggestion of using a bandsaw has a lot of merit. You do not tilt the table to make the angled cuts - you build a sub-table (that goes on top of the table) that has the required angles.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#11

Re: Meanwhile...

Bill Leffingwell Richwood wv

>Derek

A good thought one could even put stops for pins and tails to keep from from sawing through the line (not much of problem,but good insurance)You know I've noticed here in the States many pieces of newer fine furniture have machine dove tails in drawers and sometimes in exposed areas. Maybe I am elitist, but why go to all the trouble to make something really nice and not go all the way.

Once again I like to thank everyone for the good info.

Bill

Gosh I hope I'm not too much of an elitist

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#12

Re: Meanwhile...

wilbur

>In order to cut 1:6 dovetails, you only need to be able to tilt your table by 9-10 degrees. Your bandsaw can't do that? If not, and if you really want to go the bandsawn dovetail route, you can build a auxiliary table that provide that angle.

But I agree that practice is probably the easiest way to go.

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#13

April Popular Woodworking- Bandsaw

David Charlesworth

>The huge advantage for me, is that the dovetails, which I prefer to cut first, always have perfectly square glue faces.

Here in UK we tend to use 5/16" quartered oak for drawer sides and it is a little more difficult to judge squareness over this thin stuff.

It is true that my handsawing is poor, entirely due to lack of systematic practice......... must have spent too much time concentrating on planes, chisels and sharpening.....

best wishes,

David

Re: Veritas dovetail saw guide

#14

Dovetailing thin stock

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I find it much easier to gang cut drawer sides, even 3/4" thicks sides. When cutting thinner stock the gang cut method helps keep everything square.

Stephen


img