Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

Posts

Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#1

Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

A. Sender

>I�m interested in making some single-iron wooden bench planes. Some folks argue convincingly that tapered irons work better, and that parallel irons lead to overly tightened wedges. Yet there are several companies making wooden planes which get rave reviews and are made with parallel single irons.

Can anyone tell me what the real-world effects or design considerations are for one vs. the other? Thanks!

AS

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#2

I can give you no help on this one...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I am a big fan of laminated blades on any tool. I think the tapered plane blades are great and all mine are with chip breakers (yes I said it) so they are double irons.

And this is where it gets difficult. I own a small (block plane size) beech coffin smoother made in England (from a box of English tools), with no makers marks on plane or iron. It is a factory made item and has a single iron. It is parallel, I have examined it and I can not see lamination, but I haven't given it the acid test to make sure.

I think the test will show that it is an all steel iron. It is the one of the finest wooden smoother planes I have ever used, not a real tight mouth but it sure does cut nice. I had to work over the bed and wedge ways, wedge and iron but mostly to remove rust and surface accumulations.

As for over tightening, I can't say, I think the wedge and blade may come out easier than the tapered double iron but that may be its size.

Also I make my toothing irons out of parallel blades, and for use in old planes I have to shim the bed to hold the iron because it is much thinner. Otherwise the tips of the wedge protrude below the sole of the plane, interfering with the planing process.

Stephen

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#3

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

Paul Kierstead

>tapered irons work better is not incompatible with rave reviews and are made with parallel single irons. Both statements maybe true without contradiction.

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#4

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

David Miller from Iowa

>It probably doesn't make that much difference - a lot of us over analyze the minutiae associated with planing. A skilled craftsman with decent wood and a sharp cutter can make a $10 plane work fine for most purposes.

That said, I am a fan of tapered cutters. I have examples of all the "premium" bench planes (bedrock, norris, LN, etc.), but I generally reach for the Ohio tapered blade models when engrossed in a project.

Probably just habit, I never did a comparative study.

David

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#5

Kanna?

wilbur

>"I am a big fan of laminated blades on any tool. I think the tapered plane blades are great and all mine are with chip breakers (yes I said it) so they are double irons."

Stephen, if I didn't know you better, I would have guessed that you were talking about Japanese planes. :@)

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#6

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>A parallel single iron plane is pretty easy to make and works fine. Noticing the difference between tapered or parallel irons is in the realm of minutiae. If you have a tapered iron use it. If I was building molding planes I would use the tapered iron just because they are now readily available. For my first single iron wood plane I would either use an old iron I have laying around or order a new iron from Hock and go to town on it.

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#7

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

ThomD

>Other than Japanese planes that are tappered in the reverse direction from what you seem to have in mind, I can't see any difference in tapered or untapered irons in wedged planes. I have both and I do not see any difference. Perhaps something goes askew if dimensions for one are applied to the other, thereby changing both the blade and wedge details. If everything within the plane is well blue printed, then the wedge does not require much tightening and the plane adjusts and releases easily.

Wedge hardness also maters.

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#8

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

A. Sender

>Are there any woods known not to work for wedges? Are there some which work with a tapered iron but not for parallel, or vice versa?

I've seen wedges made from maples, walnut, beech of course, ebony, rosewoods, goncalo alves, and purpleheart.

Do you notice a difference in wedge angles between your parallel and tapered single-iron planes?

Thanks to everyone for your responses, very helpful actually.

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#9

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

paul womack

>Some folks argue convincingly that tapered irons work better

Never heard that - can you cite?

BugBear

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#10

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

A. Sender

>Here ya go:

http://www.handplane.com/Forum/forum_entry.php?id=234

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#11

Re: thanks

paul womack

>

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#12

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Dear Anonymous,

I for one don't buy those arguments. It certainly is possible to build a fine plane with a parallel iron and without the problems suggested by the people in your link. I think the whole dynamic of stock, wedge and iron is much more complicated.

I will tell you this: the combination of beech wedge and stock and tapered iron (or double iron assembly that is as a whole tapered) has a wonderful action. It does four things well. It sets easily, it comes apart easily, and it adjusts easily both in and out. I have not read any writers on planes whom I thought were capable of analyzing all these complicated actions. We don't need to analyze because we have empirical evidence.

Go ahead and build a plane with whatever iron you have. If you later get a different iron, you can make adjustments to your wooden parts. We generally have to make adjustments when an iron is used up and a replacement has a different taper.

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#13

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

A. Sender

>Thanks for your comments Warren, I am pretty much convinced at this point that one can go either way without compromise.

Sorry about the anonymity, my name is Andres Sender, the �a Sender� is an unintentional byproduct. ;-)

Andres

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Planes

#14

Re: Parallel vs. Tapered Single Irons in Wooden Pl

Paul Kierstead

>Well, ain't that something. I just figured you were being excessively clever.