Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

shoulder planes

Posts

shoulder planes

#1

shoulder planes

John H. in Baltimore

>Hi everyone.

I'm been thinking about whether a shoulder plane is something I should consider using.

I probably wouldn't use a shoulder plane to trim tenon cheeks as I'm happy doing any trimming with a router plane.

However, I'm interested in using a shoulder plane to adjust tenon shoulders, I currently use either a skewed paring chisel to slice across the width of the shoulder or a wide chisel to pare (or chop) downward. I'm happy with my results, but sometimes it can be a slow process.

Are shoulder planes intended for trimming shoulders or riding against shoulders for trimming cheeks? My concern for trimming shoulders is that they would leave a ragged shoulder line that would be unsightly once the joint is assembled. Is this concern valid?

Thanks!

John

Re: shoulder planes

#2

Re: shoulder planes

Dean J in MN

>My concern for trimming shoulders is that they would leave a ragged shoulder line that would be unsightly once the joint is assembled. Is this concern valid?

Regardless of your tool of choice to trim a shoulder, you are working to a knifed line. That should mean no tearout. If you pare or plane below that line you've spoiled the fit anyway. :)

I trim shoulders with a chisel, my shoulder plane has been collecting dust for a few years now.

-Dean

Re: shoulder planes

#3

Re: shoulder planes

Hank Knight

>John,

Shoulder planes have a number of uses, but I think they were designed to trim tenon shoulders with very precise, square cuts registered against the tenon cheek - hence the name: "shoulder plane." IMHO, they are the best tool for trimming tenon shoulders. They are also useful for other things like trimming tenon cheeks, but there are other tools that do a very good job at these other tasks - but nothing does as good a job on shoulders as a shoulder plane.

My $.02. YMMV

Hank

Re: shoulder planes

#4

Re: shoulder planes

John H. in Baltimore

>Good point.

There is no replacement for a properly measured and knifed shoulder line!

Re: shoulder planes

#6

Re: shoulder planes

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>John said, " My concern for trimming shoulders is that they would leave a ragged shoulder line that would be unsightly once the joint is assembled. Is this concern valid?"

A shoulder plane will not leave a ragged shoulder line--it is exceedingly crisp. However, as the shoulder plane exits the cut, you are at risk of tearing a splinter off the edge of your rail or stile. This doesn't always happen, but with some woods and some grain orientations (cherry comes to mind), it's predictable. This is quite noticeable (to you), so it becomes important to clamp another stick alongside the one you're trimming, in order to support the edge grain.

This grain-support thing makes the whole process fiddly enough that it makes me look for alternatives, like chisels or practicing sawing. But a shoulder plane will make a perfect shoulder, with correct technique.

Wiley

Re: shoulder planes

#7

What Wiley Said

Hank Knight

>I agree that shoulder planes leave a nice crisp shoulder. For me knifing the shoulder line pretty heavily and planing to the line works best. As you approach the line, taking very fine cuts, the material begins to crumble away on the waste side of the line to the depth of the knife cut, leaving a perfect edge. In effect, the knife line is the show edge of the shoulder. Hope this makes sense.

Hank

Re: shoulder planes

#8

Re: shoulder planes

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>A quick cut with a fine cross saw on the end of the shoulder, down to the line, will prevent split out on the end of the shoulder on the far end.

Stephen

Re: shoulder planes

#9

Re: shoulder planes

John Hoffman

>Dean,

I am not getting how a chisel works for this application. Since the chisel is not as wide as the tennon shoulder aren't you having to pare more than one time and isn't this causing an uneven line?

Could you briefly explain how a chisel is used for this application. I would like to try it out.

Thanks

John

Re: shoulder planes

#10

Re: shoulder planes

Dean J in MN

>John --

Turn your thoughts on their side. Pare the shoulder parallel to the tenon rather than perpendicular as you are describing. I at times pare perpendicular, but the final touches are parallel to the tenon most of the time.

Hope that helps?

Dean

Re: shoulder planes

#11

One other thing.....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>A shoulder plane is a useful tool for other jobs than tenon shoulders. For example, cabinet doors that are rebated so that one laps over the other. I find that a shoulder plane is the exact tool to adjust the rebates in the final fitting. Another example is raised panels--a large shoulder plane is very useful for the final passes, if there is any imperfection off the panel raiser.

In short, a shoulder plane is a precision rebate plane, and as such has a number of good uses.

Wiley

Re: shoulder planes

#12

Re: One other thing.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thanks, Wiley. I think the thing makes more sense as a precision rebate plane than shoulder plane. This tool was on my wish list about 30 years ago, but somehow never made it to the top. Although I have made thousands of tenons, I must admit I do not know what "adjusting the shoulder" consists of.

I think I am more tempted by the Primus "Doppel-Simshobel", a double iron rabbet plane. However one can get by rather well with a wooden rabbet and a moving fillister.