Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What kind of saw made these marks?

Posts

What kind of saw made these marks?

#1

What kind of saw made these marks?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is the inside apron on a large 42" diameter center table. The apron is built up in brick segments and the outside has been smoothed off. However the inside has the saw marks. Now this table was made in about 1853 in Great Salt Lake City at the LDS Church Public Works by William Bell. No Bandsaws out here yet, well not in production anywhere else either.

So what made these saw marks. They are very uniform and the direction of the fibers indicate a back and forth action of the saw. Could it be an up-down sash saw? Or do you think this can be done by hand?

The spacing is uniform in places then gets tighter together then farther apart but they are fairly square with the straight top edge. The lower edge of the apron was also cut by hand as the angles change and are slightly undercut.

Stephen


img

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#2

Re: What kind of saw made these marks? 

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>


img

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#3

Pit saw

Don in Northern Arizona

>

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#4

Re: Pit saw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Don,

It is not a table 42' in diameter, even Brigham Young didn't have that many wives.

A pit saw was brought out in 1847 and was used to cut boards from local timber to make a skiff for exploring the Jordan River that empties into the Great Salt Lake. The skiff was the first wooden object made in Utah by White People.

Stephen

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#5

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

MikeW

>"Now this table was made in about 1853 in Great Salt Lake City at the LDS Church Public Works by William Bell. No Bandsaws out here yet, well not in production anywhere else either."

You're off a little in the date of the first bandsaws. Not that it may mean much in the overall issue of there in Salt Lake. First bandsaw was in 1807 or '08. First cast iron band saws being made were in France in 1866 whereupon Henry Disston bought a couple and brought them to America--and then they came over by the score for resale. Close to the circa date for the table.

However, scroll saws powered by treadle had been around for a couple/few hundred years. Some were quite large by today's standards.

Take care, Mike

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#6

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Newberry I believed invented the continuous band saw in 1808 but the technology for the blades wasn't developed until after the American Civil War.

I did not consider the scroll saw but that would work, although the apron is a bit tall, I am not sure if the scallops on the apron and the ends of the pendants were cut before or after the curve is sawn?

Stephen

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#7

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

Todd Hughes

>I can't see the marks to well but I imagine probably cut out with a mechanical sash saw in a saw mill. These saws often had multiple blades powered from either water or steam and cut in an up and down motion.

Guess could have been cut by hand using a frame saw but from i could see looks awful uniform...I think pit saws in the uSA during this time period was not the norm for stuff like this.....Todd

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#8

Re: Pit saw marks are angled

Dave Mount

>Not that a pit saw would have been used on something like a table, but just the same, the action was not perfectly vertical.

The consistency and right angle in these marks suggests that it was a saw in a fixture, not a hand held saw. However, the varying rate of cut suggests something that was hand fed through the device. Not enough of a historian to guess what type of fixture though.

Best,

Dave

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#9

Up and Down Sawmill

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree with you Todd. Usually with a pit saw the lines are about 70 degrees, not straight up and down. It would be hard to saw at 90 degrees. Also the marks are not so uniform either in spacing or angle. The up and down saw mill had a mechanical feed so that it moved a uniform distance for each stroke. There were up and down mills in America from the mid 17th century to the mid 19th century. Here in Pennsylvania we see this kind of stuff on 18th century buildings and occasionally on furniture, like a drawer bottom that is not planed onthe underside. Pitsaw marks are more rare as it was not long after settlement that sawmills went up.

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

"Up and down saw"

Jack Guzman from Maine

>There are several machines in the local historical museum(Willowbrook Village)that would make marks like those. Basically a blade held top and bottom and moved up and down like a scroll saw as the wood is fed through it.They have a wider blade than a scroll saw.One of them has a label on it calling it an "Up and Down saw" Unfortunately the museum is snowed in, so no pictures.---Jack

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#11

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>After careful examination of the apron, I was able to determine that the apron was constructed brick segment fashion and was cut out as ONE PIECE. I was astounded to not find a joint but the thing was cut out as a big donut. The apron is 2 5/8 inches tall so it could have been cut on a foot or water powered scroll (jig) saw.

Because it is a circle, we can eliminate the use of a sash saw, even a small one in a shop as there is no way to get the glued up ring into the saw.

Here is a pic of the apron:

Stephen


img

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#12

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This appears on the inside of the apron in one place. To me and a couple of people that have looked at it, it looks like several holes were drilled as a starting place for the blade of the saw on the inside of the large wooden donut apron.

It is wide enough to get a wider blade and because of the diameter of the table a wide blade up to 3/4" would cut the inside curve, but I have no evidence of the size of the blade.

The view is looking down on the edge of the apron with the table upside down.

Stephen


img

Re: What kind of saw made these marks?

#13

Walking beam saw?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Just another name for a jig saw or scroll saw with parallel arms. I recall seeing a huge one in a FWW article of many years ago that had arms more than 8' long and was used for resawing logs.

Bruce