Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

Posts

Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#1

Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

Brad in Ottawa

>I have used oil finishes in the past and take care to properly dispose of any oily rags. I have just put a finish on my new workbench base and wanted to know how long I should wait before putting the workbench top on the base? (The top would obviously be in contact with portions of the base.)

I used Tried and True and it is dry to the touch and has been curing for over two days. Is this long enough? I'm really anxious to get the top!

Brad

PS - I know others have had problems with Tried and True but I love this stuff! No worries about toxicity, pleasant smell and it looks great!

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#2

I've never used Tried and true, but

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I use a lot of Watco danish oil. 2 to 3 days is my general rule. Let's see the bench when you finish it.

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#3

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

Paul Kierstead

>I can't tell you a specific time, and my experience is with T&T Varnish oil, not Danish oil (i.e. this information may be useless). I have found with the varnish oil, you can kind of "feel" when it is really cured. When you run you fingers over the surface, it feels softer and a little rubbier as it is curing. Once really well cured, it starts to feel "hard", like glass. This is difficult to explain, but if you have an item well cured, run your fingers over it and you will see what I mean.

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#4

Thanks both!

Brad in Ottawa

>Turns out I needed to wait until at least today to put on the top. (I had to pick up some new dowels and I managed to pick some up at the LV Clearance sale.) I have been running my fingers over the finish and I felt it was pretty dry 20 hours later but I have heard of people waiting 20+ days for T&T to dry.

The top should be on in the next couple of days and the twin screw vise shortly after that. Translation Scott, give me 9 days and I should be posting pictures of the new bench and my reorg'd shop. The shop and the bench are not much too look at but I am really happy with the improvements both will bring!

Brad

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#5

Re: Thanks both!

Paul Kierstead

>Ah, yes. I think the 20+ day comments come from 2 results:

- Using the oil in enclosed spaces. I think long after it is "dry" it continues to give off some odor. I suspect most oils in enclosed spaces is a bad idea. I have a large chest, commercially made, at home that had some kind of oil finish; it still smells when you open it 6 years on.

- They put too much on, or don't rub off hard enough. You really really really need to rub it off *well* when they say. I think too many leave it be, or just give a cursory wipe off.

I have used the T&T BLO and Varnish Oil a fair bit and been extremely pleased with the situations where they were used (all chosen for compatibility, though).

Re: Danish Oil and Cure Time - Safety Question

#7

T&T products are quite variable...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...in their cure times. I've used T&T Danish, varnish oil and original and like them all, esp. the latter two. The most important thing is to use the thinnest application possible. This alone eliminates most of the waiting for these finishes to cure. The species of wood, ambient temperature, application temperature and relative humidity are all variables, of course, and T&T does seem a bit more fiddly and rangy than many finishes. Patience is helpful and prudent.

Like Paul K., I get a pleasing glassiness with the varnish oil -- not diamontine, but certainly not the amber greasy/plastic-y look finds in some oil finishes. My favorite is the 'original' with beeswax. This builds to a somewhite higher lustre than a low lustre matte, which is, to my eye and taste, nearly perfect. One it hardens you can knock it back a bit. I usually do.

The Danish Oil I've used several times but I usually stop at three coats to avoid excess (to me) lustre, but this can depend on species and degree of planing, scraping, and sanding. My goal is a richer, darker but nearly 'dry' look. Again, your taste may vary.

Although Tried & True are frequent choices, I still prefer Sutherland Welles sealer followed by low lustre poly tung for walnut and sanded-in Waterlox (used like an wiping oil finish rather than a varnish) on several other species.