There are some challenging magnifiers out there.
David Barnett - SW Florida
>Bill,
Many of the round magnifier lamps in the 4" to 5" diameters distort uncomfortably to the point of fatigue. Most are made of less optimal glass than crown glass, having a higher RI (refractive index) and greater dispersion. Crown glass is clear (unlike greenish tinted lenses) and presents less distortion when light rays pass through it at more optimal speeds than through other glasses. There is no doubt that crown optical glass is better and easier on the eyes, all other factors being equal.
Without addressing lens design factors, extra wide magnifiers can somewhat ease apparent distortion as both eyes are less stressfully involved. Full binocularity ameliorates the tendency of eye domination (and eye 'switching') in a wider lens and spreads distortion more acceptably over the interocular and interpupilary distance. Because you're really looking through both eyes at once, you get some of that stereo 3D-ness. So cool.
Now don't get me wrong. This isn't anything so optimal as separate optical paths like you find in surgical loupes or surgical Galilean stereo microscopes, but at low diopters such as '3' (1.75x), this isn't a big problem.
I'm very sensitive to distortion, and like you, find it terribly fatiguing. I can tell you that the O.C. White has never produced any discomfort, even after extended contiguous work sessions. The Aven does have some distortion, though it is low and for the most part, easily in the acceptable non-fatiguing range. If you were going to read continuously or analyze type on a large-format page layout, you might notice it. I can't say that it bothers me because I seem to easily adapt to this level. For most tasks it's no problem if not downright excellent. I use it over my Taig lathe when machining and it has such forgiving depth and breadth of field I forget I'm using it. It's a far greater blessing than any aggravation.
Anecdotally, when people unfamiliar with wide format magnifiers look through either, it's "wow", "unbelievable", and "I gotta get one of these." Some notice a difference between the two. Most don't. Most folks who've tried mine have used smaller round magnifiers with those fluorescent circles. These are a different animal altogether. They work. I've used them. I'd be grateful to have one if I didn't have one of these. I hope never to return to them.
I should mention that most of these 'rectangular' magnifiers are actually round lenses docked on two opposing edges then mounted in a rectangular frame. These heads look rather akward and clumsy, but believe me, they don't get in the way.
I should also mention that most merchants will let you return these if you are uncomfortable with them. My recommendation? The O.C. White hands down. Firstly, it's fifty bucks more, but for that fifty you get truly useful features. The mounting is better than the Aven, the lamps independent and brighter (the Gesswein catalog is WRONG in their description -- not independent lights*), the 10-diopter swing lens can be handy (though not necessary), and secondly, the distortion IS lower. When the price goes up again, then I'd say muy the Aven and try it out. Either way, both make fiddly work very doable and stress free. Sharpening is awesome. If your wife does any sewing or other craft work... well, maybe she'll let you borrow it now and then.
Hope this nudges you toward the edge, heh.
*Really, the independent lights aren't the issue I thought they might be. I find it entirely natural to place my hand briefly over one or the other to spot irregularities in surfaces, pop scribe lines, and so on, that I tend to leave both lights 'on' on both magnifier lamps.