Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Saw Sharpening Lamp?

Posts

Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#1

Saw Sharpening Lamp?

Tony - Memphis

>I've been interested in learning to sharpen my own saws. I have great up close vision, but even still, I feel like some help would be nice when looking at a 15tpi dovetail saw. I've looked at the visor things and the lamps. Thought I'd ask what other folks have used and like.

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#2

The pivot lamps are good

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

The pivot magnification lamps work well, and you can find them around fairly easily, but do look around, some places get a lot for them. Some of them are pure garbage also.

I've seen both good and bad ones, the good ones had better pivot mechanisms on them. If that doesn't matter, don't worry about it. Harbor Freight has a cheap one, I think.

My local Woodcraft had some in the isle last week when I was over there, but I didn't look too closely at them, so not sure about price/quality, but you can check that out possibly.

I use the OptiVisor with a 2.5x lens, most of the time. I have thought of getting a pivot lamp, just haven't seen the right one I like yet. I'm not fond about how the headband snags my hair/ponytail all the time, but oh well...:-/

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#3

Halogen desk lamp

Scott Burr in somewhat warn Ben Lomond, CA

>That pivits and swivles. Their small and put out great light.

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#4

In addition to what ever illumination...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>you choose, try putting a mirror opposite of where you work so you can see the off side. It can also be used to concentrate light where you are working. One of those with the magnifying mirror on one side works great to focus more light where needed.

Or you can do as I do and fill a 5" diameter clear glass globe with water and alcohol (to keep it from freezing) and place it in front of the oil lamp and I have a mercury glass reflector sconce placed behind the lamp to intensify the beam that is magnified by the sphere of water to a bright spot. I need all of the help I can get.

Stephen

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#5

Re: In addition to what ever illumination...

Dan Donaldson

>Some people have that new thing called 'lektrisity or something like that ;-)

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#6

Re: In addition to what ever illumination...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Whale oil lamps with their two wicks do put out a great light, having a bit of trouble getting a sufficient quantity.

I also use a camphene lamp, and although I have heard of them exploding, it has a small font, so it is fairly safe.

Coal oil is good but a bit pricey, I use grease lamps but I have to warm the grease before they will burn. The rush lights do give off a good bit of light, but tend to smoke.

Then I have to keep the pickwick and wick trimmer close to maintain the candlepower. (one candlepower=7/8" diameter Spermaceti Candle)

Stephen

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#7

My choice *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Tony, I really like my two extra-wide magnifier lamps, especially my O.C. White with independent light switches that allows the light to rake from either side. These happen to be on sale right now (only time I've ever seen these discounted. I paid fifty dollars more.) You can get it in black for the same price. I have the white. The 'crown optical' lens is astoundingly distortion-free with amazing depth of field. Everything's bright, clear and in focus. It is simply awesome. I forgot to mention that this model also comes with a swing-away 10-diopter lens, as well.

I also have a very good knock-off of the O.C. White made for Aven*. It lacks the crown optical lens, the independent light switches, the small 10-diopter lens, has 9w bulbs instead of 13w (still plenty bright), and is 100 dollars less than the other magnifier. Despite what sounds stripped down compared to the O.C. White, I'll have to say that it's an excellent value and I'm fine with either, although the O.C. White wins point for point. Oh... and you can cover one or the other lamps on the Aven easily enough for saw sharpening and so on. I usually leave both lamps 'on', anyway, on both magnifiers.

Another real plus with this style wide-view 3-diopter lamp is support for dovetailing and other such tasks for those of us with failing or presbyotic eyesight.

Because my diabetic eyes can use all the help I can give them, and because I already have special optics for engraving, stone setting and goldsmithing, I use low-power zoom stereo-microscopes on booms to sharpen smaller saws. My favorite is an old B&L stereozoom on an amazing articulated boom that allows me to put it right where I want it over any saw vise. I can sit straight and relaxed without having to bend over and it makes saw sharpening totally easy. Even the smallest teeth appear like a mountain range. On either microscope I use dual cold halogen fiberoptic light guides. I often use my engraver's ball as a saw vise, too. No, I'm not recommending anyone spring for this. It's totally over the top, but tres cool nonetheless. Here's the simpler boom scope with the 150w halogens in my 'old' shop. As soon as I get a new dSLR I'll post pics from my new place.

*http://www.gesswein.com/catalog/catalog.cfm?cat=16&sub=1&subsub=31&catalog=1&CFID=850018&CFTOKEN=899735


img

Prolite sale

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#8

If you are going to get one of those new fangled..

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>lights get one that is full spectrum, easier on the eyes and good for checking true finish color.

Stephen

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#9

I'll second that.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>I've used Ott TrueColor for all my bench work for years but there are other good brands, too. Both my magnifier lamps are daylight spectrum. Even the halogens on fiberoptics have daylight filter holders along with the UV and IR holders. Big difference. Only three lamps in my house aren't full spectrum and that's because I made those lamps with mineral shades (mica and resin) for a different effect. Oh... the refrigerator, pool and hot tub lights are the old-fashioned kind.

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#10

Re: If you are going to get one of those new fangl

Joel

>I'll third that. We replaced all the fluorescents in our shop and warehouse and showroom with full spectrum bulbs and it makes everything look better, easier to see, and taking pictures is easier too.

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#11

Re: In addition to what ever illumination...

Hank Knight

>And these options put out plenty of soot so you don't have to spend $$ on spray sight black. Ah, the old ways are srill the best!

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#12

Thanks!

Tony - Memphis

>Some good ideas. I'm anxious to get filing.

Tony

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#13

HOw is the lens on the cheaper lamp/lens?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, rainin' again

>I picked up a garage sale special, and the distortion is enough to make my head hurt; and the $70 lamps I've looked at aren't much better. How is the lens on the Aven/Gesswein? This might be worth saving up for.

Bill, eyes not diabetic, just middle aged

Re: Saw Sharpening Lamp?

#14

There are some challenging magnifiers out there.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Bill,

Many of the round magnifier lamps in the 4" to 5" diameters distort uncomfortably to the point of fatigue. Most are made of less optimal glass than crown glass, having a higher RI (refractive index) and greater dispersion. Crown glass is clear (unlike greenish tinted lenses) and presents less distortion when light rays pass through it at more optimal speeds than through other glasses. There is no doubt that crown optical glass is better and easier on the eyes, all other factors being equal.

Without addressing lens design factors, extra wide magnifiers can somewhat ease apparent distortion as both eyes are less stressfully involved. Full binocularity ameliorates the tendency of eye domination (and eye 'switching') in a wider lens and spreads distortion more acceptably over the interocular and interpupilary distance. Because you're really looking through both eyes at once, you get some of that stereo 3D-ness. So cool.

Now don't get me wrong. This isn't anything so optimal as separate optical paths like you find in surgical loupes or surgical Galilean stereo microscopes, but at low diopters such as '3' (1.75x), this isn't a big problem.

I'm very sensitive to distortion, and like you, find it terribly fatiguing. I can tell you that the O.C. White has never produced any discomfort, even after extended contiguous work sessions. The Aven does have some distortion, though it is low and for the most part, easily in the acceptable non-fatiguing range. If you were going to read continuously or analyze type on a large-format page layout, you might notice it. I can't say that it bothers me because I seem to easily adapt to this level. For most tasks it's no problem if not downright excellent. I use it over my Taig lathe when machining and it has such forgiving depth and breadth of field I forget I'm using it. It's a far greater blessing than any aggravation.

Anecdotally, when people unfamiliar with wide format magnifiers look through either, it's "wow", "unbelievable", and "I gotta get one of these." Some notice a difference between the two. Most don't. Most folks who've tried mine have used smaller round magnifiers with those fluorescent circles. These are a different animal altogether. They work. I've used them. I'd be grateful to have one if I didn't have one of these. I hope never to return to them.

I should mention that most of these 'rectangular' magnifiers are actually round lenses docked on two opposing edges then mounted in a rectangular frame. These heads look rather akward and clumsy, but believe me, they don't get in the way.

I should also mention that most merchants will let you return these if you are uncomfortable with them. My recommendation? The O.C. White hands down. Firstly, it's fifty bucks more, but for that fifty you get truly useful features. The mounting is better than the Aven, the lamps independent and brighter (the Gesswein catalog is WRONG in their description -- not independent lights*), the 10-diopter swing lens can be handy (though not necessary), and secondly, the distortion IS lower. When the price goes up again, then I'd say muy the Aven and try it out. Either way, both make fiddly work very doable and stress free. Sharpening is awesome. If your wife does any sewing or other craft work... well, maybe she'll let you borrow it now and then.

Hope this nudges you toward the edge, heh.

*Really, the independent lights aren't the issue I thought they might be. I find it entirely natural to place my hand briefly over one or the other to spot irregularities in surfaces, pop scribe lines, and so on, that I tend to leave both lights 'on' on both magnifier lamps.