Rasps
wilbur
>So if you needed to get a cabinetmakers rasp, which one would you get, if you couldn't wait for Auriou to start up their business again?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Rasps
wilbur
>So if you needed to get a cabinetmakers rasp, which one would you get, if you couldn't wait for Auriou to start up their business again?
#49 and / or #50
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>
Re: Rasps per David Barnett *LINK*
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Wilbur,
When the Auriou news first broke several months ago, David Barnett provided an extensive listing of alternatives, and on this very forum. Enough time has passed, this would be a good time to review his earlier post, see link below.
I would take a long look at two of the offerings by Dieter Schmid that David lists--the Milani handmade rasps and the Grobet/Vallorbe rasps. The magnificent quality of Grobet/Vallorbe files convinces me that they probably make a great rasp.
Incidentally, I think that Nicholson has been taken over and 'rationalized' by one of the big rationalizing companies.
Perhaps David Barnett could provide a little more commentary, if he has any new thoughts on the matter.
Re: Rasps per David Barnett *LINK*
Steve Hamlin
>In addition to David's list, for the short term at least, rasps in the same tradition as and the near equal of Aurious are available from Gaignard-Millon of Paris.
Cheers
Steve
Gaignard Millon rasps
Gaignard Millon
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Steve,
A little college French (+ babelfish) gets me through the basics. It looks like the 'fauteuil' rasp is the cabinetmaker's rasp. Is that right? However, I can't make out where they discuss the relative fineness/coarseness of the rasps--is it just inverse to length, where the 150mm is the finest and the toothing gets coarser as the rasp gets longer. Can you correlate the Gaignard tooth grading with Auriou's numbering system?
Wiley
I use Nicholsons... *LINK*
Scott Burr in somewhat warn Ben Lomond, CA
>No. 49 and 50. I think moved their manufacturing to Mexico and the quality has gone down hill. Look for the ones "Made in USA" and you'll be OK. I have 3 Auriou and their nice also, I'm not sure if the cost to performance is worth the cost compared to others. I'd be looking at thses if and when I need anymore.
Joels place
Re: I use Nicholsons...
john lucas
>Those look nice. I may order one. I've been using a Nickleson cabinetmakers rasp for years and just got some aurou this year. They cut different but I'm not sure any better for my needs. The shapes are different and that helps.
Re: I use Nicholsons...
Joel
>As far as I know (and I could be wrong) the 49 and 50 are still made in usa and someone told me that one guy has been making them for decades - he now works part-time as the demand is so small. Apparently while the rasps are made by machine the machine is so complicated and takes such skill they havn't figured out how to replace him.
ps - THe Gramercy line of rasps aren't bad either.
As a matter of fact....
wilbur
>I placed an order for some Gramercy rasps and rifflers last night, after some more Googling.
Re: As a matter of fact....
Joel
>We have the rifflers and "B" rasp in stock the rest are coming in a few weeks. (and I have to remember to get more handles made)
Re: Gaignard Millon *LINK*
Steve Hamlin
>Hi Wiley
Yes, the 'fauteuil' rasp is the cabinetmaker's rasp.
As I was just after detail rasps at the time, I just have the 6" fauteuil (cabinet) and �ffil�e (taper/modellers) and 5" feuille de sauge.
Here's a snippet from a Woodwork UK thread (have included a link to the full thread):
150mm R�pe fauteuil
Roughly the shape of an Auriou cabinet makers rasp
The closest equivalent I have is a 175mm grain 13 taper rasp.
I'd say the tooth pattern is slightly tighter on the flat face of the Auriou - so maybe the GM is closer to a 12?150mm R�pe �ffil�e
OK, this is an almost exact match for an Auriou 150mm grain 15 taper. Again, perhaps just adjust the grain by 1 - more like a 14 (but I don't one to compare it to)125mm R�pe feuille de sauge
This is by far the finest grained rasp I have - the above Auriou 150mm grain 15 taper is the closest.
The larger rasps do come in two cuts - fines and moyennes, though presume coarseness also size relatd.
HTH
Steve
http://trevera25.proboards85.com/index.cgi?board=hand&action=display&thread=1196945897
Re: Gaignard Millon
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Steve,
Thank you very much for the excellent detail. I think I'll try that last 125mm rasp--the extremely fine one--if I can get my order through online.
Thanks again, Wiley