Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Sharpening Handsaws?

Posts

Sharpening Handsaws?

#1

Sharpening Handsaws?

Charles Jackson III

>I can sharpen plane blades, and chisels. But I cant sharpen a handsaw I am wondering do you guys have any tips? I have two nice Disstion Crosscut and Panel Handsaws but I cant sharpen them. I am also looking for a rip handsaw.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#2

Re: Sharpening Handsaws? *LINK*

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Charles,

Not sure if you've tried and failed to sharpen a handsaw, or if you just don't know how. Perhaps this link will be of assistance.

T.O.


Sharpen a handsaw

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#3

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

Charles Jackson III

>Nope I aint really try, I have the files. I think I will give it a try tomorrow.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#4

Definitely do try, you won't be sorry

Alan DuBoff

>If you can sharpen and plane or chisel edge, you can sharpen a handsaw with only a little bit of practice. It will feel ackward at first most likely, but stick with it and after a few times you will start feeling comfortable with it most likely.

Good luck, and let us know how you do.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#5

Re: Definitely do try, you won't be sorry

Charles Jackson III

>Ok thanks I think I can do it.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#6

You might learn from this video *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Charles,

You might learn from this video on FWW in the linky.

I don't recommend the block on the file, but you should try it for yourself and see if you like it.

Larger saws are easier, so this will show you on a more difficult dovetail saw, in this case a small gent's saw.


Sharpening a Dovetail Saw

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#7

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

Adam Cherubini

>My advice is to start with a saw that's not too bad. Seems a lot of guys start with something really bad thinking they can't make it worse. Well you can. And working with a severly misfiled saw is advanced saw sharpening. So get a decent saw whose teeth are fairly regular and only a bit dull.

Here's my trick: count strokes. Saw sharpening isn't really like sharpening other tools where you stick with a certain grit until you get what you want. I think the beginner is better off taking one or two strokes (depending on how bad the saw is) on each tooth facing him. Flip the saw and do the other side. If the saw isn't sharp when you finish, do it again. This will keep the teeth regular. Try not to think about pushing the file to one side or the other at first. Let the tooth guide your file. Let your hands guide your work. Save your eyes for more difficult saws.

adam

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#8

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

John Vancil

>Charles

Tom Laws video available from Tools for Working Wood and others is very good. Cheers John

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#9

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

Alan DuBoff

>Adam wrote:

"I think the beginner is better off taking one or two strokes (depending on how bad the saw is) on each tooth facing him. Flip the saw and do the other side. If the saw isn't sharp when you finish, do it again. This will keep the teeth regular."

Adam,

There was a thread last week on sharpening, kinda, and I recommended just what you say above. Just take a couple strokes on each tooth to get a feel for it, don't even try to take too much off.

I always tell people to do this, just to get a feel for it, and to know that they will not destroy their saw if they take it slow. And cut with the saw to reassure yourself you haven't destroyed it.

I have seen people try to really get into the file the first time, and that is wrong, usually the teeth will become uneven when folks do that...best to start out slow, and take one's time. You'll have all the time in the world to remove more metal, but best to take it easy in the beginning, IMO.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#10

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

John Pappas

>Adam, I have not found the counting of strokes a satisfactory method. It's hard to restart at the right place if you take a breather, or have to move the saw in the saw vice. I have had more success following the advice from Leonard Lee's book on sharpening. The key is working in the right light so the flats created by the jointing process are clearly visable. It makes it easy to restart in the right place after a stop and if, for some reason, a given tooth needed an extra stroke or two, the flat will tell you that. Or perhaps a previous sharpening left a tooth a bit short. You know not to file that one at all.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#11

working the flats is only when you joint the teeth

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#12

Re: working the flats is only when you joint the t

John Pappas

>From Leonard Lee's book on sharpening.

"A saw should be jointed every time it is filed. I can hear the rustle of rising eyebrows out there, but keeping even tooth height is so basic to good saw operation that it should be constantly maintained. This is not a big deal. If a saw needs sharpening, it obviously has dull teeth. Passing a jointer over the teeth is not going to dull them much more, but it will ensure that they are all the same height. Besides that, any time you joint a saw you should only joint it until you just touch the shortest tooth. Any jointing pas that point is a waste of saw and a waste of sharpening time. Often, a single pass with the jointer is all that is needed."

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#13

And that is absolutely correct, but...

Alan DuBoff

>No question that jointing the teeth is the proper thing to do.

However, I feel that it complicates things for a person new to sharpening a handsaw. What I thought Adam was describing was to just take a pass or two to each tooth, and I find that is good for folks to get a feel for this technique.

Once you start jointing the teeth, filing to remove half the flat, using a small block on the end of your file, or other acrobatic endeavors, it seems to complicate things for a beginner.

Speaking for myself, I try to resort to the KISS method when getting people interested in and developing their saw sharpening skills.

You are correct though, the proper way is to joint the teeth.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#14

That is absolutely correct, and...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I think a beginner is probably not going to sharpen a sharp saw, they will choose a looser. Of course after hammering to straighten the old saw, it is then joined.

Now I have never joined a saw where all of the teeth had that little tiny shiny spot (flats) on its tip the same size. They vary, some have little tiny flats and others form a broad triangle (crosscut) or rectangle or square (rip). So one or two strokes will just not do for those.

I keep an eye on the shiny spot and when it is gone I am done with that tooth. I do count my strokes and keep them all the same length with each stroke. This gives me an idea when I am close, then a quick look to see if it needs more or I can go on.

When its all done, don't forget to whet.

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#15

Re: That is absolutely correct, and...

Charles Jackson III

>I think I got good results, my Disstion Crosscut handsaw is pretty sharp but I am getting tear out, I think I need to set the teeth.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#16

Re: tearout

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>If you are getting tearout from a crosscut saw it is probably because some of the teeth are higher than other teeth. This would require jointing the saw to correct it, then sharpening. Another cause would be not enough fleam angle. As the fleam angle decreases the saw becomes more like a rip saw and will crosscut faster but rougher. I was reading Tage Frid the other day and he states that he always uses a rip saw to crosscut because it will cut faster and still leave a smooth cut without tearout if the saw is jointed correctly. (Haven't tried that one yet ;) I ike the Pete Taran article on saw sharpening in the articles page here.

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#17

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Charles,,

As Mosses suggested....read Pete Tarans instructions and you will not go wrong. Once you learn how to do it as Pete instructs, then you will know enough about the basic techniques to then relate to what others are or will be telling you. And you'll also know the right questions to ask.

It can be a bit confusing to a beginning when lots of people are throwing saw sharpening terms at you when you have no idea what the terms mean.

It is probably true that if you can sharpen a chisel you can also sharpen a handsaw. Believe me, it's entirely two different things and much more. I have taught more than a few people how to sharpen a hand saw. Some picked it up right away while a few decided to not pursue it. And others just refused to give up and finally got it right.

It's like alot of things that are new to us. At first it might seem daunting but after we learn it, it seems simple and we wonder why we thought it was so difficult. Sharpening a hand saw is in fact simple, but be prepared to learn some basics before you give up on it. It is very rewarding to take a saw that will not cut and turn it into a saw that cuts better than new.

Good luck,

Marv

Re: Sharpening Handsaws?

#18

Re: working the flats is only when you joint the t

paul womack

>Often, a single pass with the jointer is all that is needed.

If I'm just doing touch up sharpening, I joint with an india "fine" stone!

BugBear