Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Forked Turn Screw

Posts

Forked Turn Screw

#1

Forked Turn Screw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Rather interesting name for a split nut driver or spanner.

Why can't one of the Tool Makers or Saw Makers, make the tools look like these.

The lower one was damaged (I doubt from a brass split saw nut) and resharpened. A thin ignition points file (do they still make those?) works well for enlarging and shaping the slot.

Stephen


img

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#2

They could.....but....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>it would cost too much to manufacture for practical purposes. Have you seen the one that Joel manufactures and sells for about ten dollars? It has a hex shank but it can be used in a brace with a chuck designed for round shanks. From a manufacturing standpoint, it is comparatively quite simple in design and easy to machine. I'm not sure why he uses the hex shank. It could be round, making the tool less costly to machine. It doesn't take much torque to turn a split nut.

Marv

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#3

Re: They could.....but....

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Marv,

You wrote:

'it would cost too much to manufacture for practical purposes.'

Practical purposes, how much do some of those new saws cost?

I would pay two or three times as much as what is available entirely based upon the looks.

Must be an historic aesthetic thing. And I don't have a brace that has a hex chuck.

Stephen

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#4

Re: Forked Turn Screw

ThomD

>Wonder why one would need a brace to do that kind of work. My feeling about the lower one is that it was modified out of an existing tool. If you are in Maine, then you are in tool barn country, find a flat blade deal that goes in a brace, some kind of spade drill, preferably one that is fairly short, then just a few second with a hack saw or grinder and Bob's your uncle.

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#5

I agree, it wouldn't cost much at all...

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#6

Depends

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>on how you define the word "much".

Talk to the guy who might be manufacturing the tool on a production basis and get a definition from someone who deals in profit margins. They'll easily define the word "much".

Marv

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#7

Re: They could.....but.... *LINK*

Joel

>Below is a link to a blog entry on wrote on why we designed our split nut driver the way we did. for 8.95 I think it's a good value and if you recall a thread on the subject a few weeks back cost seems to be an issue (and I certainly understand why) for an infrequently used tool. We designed our driver to fit in a standard 1/4" hex driver which these days is as ubiquitous as a 19th century brace and bit set was back then. A round shank would be cheaper but it wouldn't be as nice for hand driving.


Split nut driver blog entry

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#8

Just got one

David Miller from Iowa

>My pal Slav in Chicago has bunch of these for sale. Dunno how old they are, but I scored one from him last month.

Email if you wan Slav's contact info.

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#9

forgot pic 

David Miller from Iowa

>


img

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#10

Re: They could.....but....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Joel,

Thanks for that reminder.....

As a suggestion.....it might be less machining cost to add the hex shank by merely using steel hex stock/rod that is pressed into the body of the tool. Machining a hex shank is quite time consuming. As I mentioned, it takes very little torque to tighten or loosen a split nut. A press fit hex shank into a round hole would be adequate for it not to loosen with normal usage.

As for the split nut.....it would be better to have used a screw set design that doesn't require a special screw driver. I have a flush type design that accepts a regular flat blade screw driver and the end of the male screw is not seen.

Marv

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#11

Re: They could.....but....

Joel

>We looked at a lot of methods of manufacture and it was impressive the number of companies that didn't want to touch it with a 10 foot pole. But ultimately we are very happy with the result and happy we can offer it as such a low cost to our customers.

I looked at your saw nut design - I have a few historic saw nuts that are very similar. However the design has a blind tap on one side is more expensive to make. One of our competitors uses modern saw nuts like you describe (PAX) and I just don't like the look. I think I'm pretty typical and I think your average modern customer wants the look of the old traditional designs - and with our saws you should never have a problem with our handles coming loose for a long long time unless you want to disassemble it, and with our kits - playing with the saw nuts is part of the fun.

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#12

Re: They could.....but....

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Joel,

You Wrote:

' I think I'm pretty typical and I think your average modern customer wants the look of the old traditional designs -'

So why not an old traditional design for the split nut driver?

Stephen

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#13

Re: They could.....but....

Joel

>The average typcial user also doesn't use a brace and bit, and may not even have a brace and we wanted to make the modern incarnation of the brace and bit. and of course I think our version costs less than a proper brace bit version. which is important for a tool used so occasionally.

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#14

Re: They could.....but....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Joel,

The screw sets used on the PAX saws aren't quite flush, am I right?

My design can be made to fit flush or raised. The only difference with my design is, you can't see the end of the screw on the backside.

When considering the various steps when machining the two designs, the one you use and my design, are basically the same number of steps. Perhaps a little more raw stock would be used for mine.

Just seems to me, you would never lose a sale based on whether or not the customer can see the end of the screw. However, you might gain a customer if they don't have to buy a screw driver.

Marv

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#15

Re: Forked Turn Screw

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I suppose it would be due to limited demand that they aren't being made ;) It doesn't look like it would take all that much for a competent blacksmith to make one; there might actually be 20 or 30 people here that would buy one.

Re: Forked Turn Screw

#16

Re: They could.....but....

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>The working end of Joel's reminds me of the switch retainer driver for the older air cooled VW's. I bought one of them with a plastic handle back in the early 70's for about $25.