Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Posts

Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#1

Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I have a project with a lot of mortises to make, and I work using the drill press/clean out method. My trusty sharpened up Craftsman bench chisel isn't really up to the task for this work. I looked at the Sorbys at my local Woodcraft and they look like a good tool. I also know that the Two Cherries and Iles chisels are great, but I'm wondering if I need them being a bit of a beginner.

The things I'm looking for are: something that only needs minor work to get it going, something I can get quickly (why I like the local tool) and something I won't sell in a year to get something better.

I don't want to get a bad tool, but I also know that I may not notice the difference between a good tool and a really good tool.

I hope I don't set off any conflicts with this question.

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#2

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I will try and not stir things up too much. I mostly use old mortise chisels but I do have one new Sorby 1/2" mortise chisel and it is an excellent tool.

The profile of the section through the blade is rectangular (square) like the originals (ok this might stir things up). There is no relief through the blade which is what is desired to make a square mortise.

I store this tool seperately and protect all of its square sharp edges as they aid in cutting the wood and keeping things square.

Stephen

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#3

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Oh, why not stir things up, get your blood moving?

Someone on a UK site told me a month or so ago that the variable quality problems many in the US have had was due to some bad heat treating and that Sorby had resolved those issues. So, perhaps you'd want to buy new ones.

Pam

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#4

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Hank Knight

>I have a set of the Sorby registered heavy mortise chisels, the ones with the double-hooped handles. I've never been able to chop a good mortise with them. I've used them with the drill-and-clean-out method you describe, and they work O.K. for that. But I really think a good bench chisel works better for finishing drilled-out mortises since it is basically a paring job. I don't know what a mortise chisel brings to that task that a bench chisel doesn't.

If you want to get into chopping mortises from scratch rather than drilling them first, I recommend you try the Iles oval bolostered mortise chisels (a/k/a "pigstickers) from Joel at toolsforworkingwood.com. I have had good success chopping mortises with them where I failed miserably with the Sorbys. They're expensive, but you don't need but two, maybe three, in the sizes you use most often.

Sorby makes a lighter duty sash mortise chisel, but I've never used one, so I can't comment about them.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I got a 1/4" sorby years ago and I hate it. It just isn't built right for the task. Now all I use it for is for cleaning out 1/4"grooves.I tried english style oval bostered chisels I got on ebay and found a world of difference. This tool was designed with hand mortising in mind. Fotunately Joel(Toolsforworkingwood.com)started selling these that were made by Ray Iles.I got the two sizes I use most and never looked back.

My recommendation is to get a couple of these in the sizes you'll most often use and learn the best method for using them. I believe Joel's website has information on this.Mortising is a simple operation when you have the proper tools.---jack

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#6

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree with Hank that if you drill out a mortise first then a mortise chisel may not be needed or even be the optimum tool. Bench chisels might work better. Mortise chisels are designed to be used without drilling.

I can think of a number of different styles of Sorby mortise chisels and I'm not sure what ones you are looking at, Stephen. I have five boxwood sash mortise chisels that I have used professionally for about 20 years, and I am very fond of them. As Stephen S. recommends, I keep them in their plastic sleeves in a box to protect their side edges. I also have one of the HD registered mortise chisels, which I do not like. I do not like the shape of the handle or the hoop at the ends. The bolstered mortise chisels are nice but the bulk is not needed- Mortising quickly is more about finesse than brute force.

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#7

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I think I know the problem some people are having with the Sorby mortise chisel, besides the aesthetic of the handle, wait it has no aesthetic, it is terrible. As soon as I sufficiently distroy their handle I will replace it with one better shaped.

The problem is that it needs to be sharpened on all edges including the ramps of the bevel, which also pare off wood. Now I usually don't predrill as that takes too much time, I mark out with the mortise gauge the width, score the length and start the V chops in the middle and work to both ends. I use a very large maul and I am working in pine, which is easier but requires a sharper tool than hardwoods.

Most other mortise applications I use socketed sash mortise chisels and even good socketed firmers to chop my mortises. I also have a several old English oval handle bolstered chisels that work as well. Older tools can be more difficult to get all the edges sharp, but that does help.

Properly tuned the Big Sorbys will do the job but the handles are still ugly.

Stephen

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#8

They are!

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi Stephen,

I have three new Sorby sash mortice chisels, I mean those with the boxwood handle. They came well ground, hold up a good edge and are just fine whether you chop like a gentleman or like an animal :-) I have a Lie-Nielsen (mortice), a japanese and an old OBM too, but I prefer the Sorbys.

Just give up the drilling, it is a lot more fun to chop a mortice completely with a dedicated chisel.

Cheers,

Marc

Re: Are the Sorby mortising chisels good

#9

Lots of good information

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I read everything here, thanks for all the responses. I also did some searching and comparisons and it seems that the only mortising chisels that Woodcraft sells are Deep Mortising Chisels at about $70 a piece. The Iles chisels are rated as the best around and only $60-70 apiece. So, I think that once I see the Iles chisels back in stock (seem to be out on the smaller sizes right now) I might put in an order.

In the meantime, I'm still doing OK with my sharpened up Craftsman chisels. Got about half the mortises (16 out of 26) drilled and chopped today. 10 more tomorrow then I can start on rails and tenons. SWMBO is helping out doing the drilling so I can focus on the chopping/paring.

Plus I'm watching the flea markets.