Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Bench Pictures for Roderick

Posts

Bench Pictures for Roderick

#1

Bench Pictures for Roderick

Dan Donaldson

>Here are the bench pictures resizes a bit. I will just post the pics and let him annotate tham as he sees fir. I put them in a new thread rather than answering the original so they would not get lost off the bottom of the board.


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#2

#2 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#3

#3 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#4

#4 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#5

#5 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#6

#6 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#7

#7 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#8

#8 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#9

#9 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#10

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

Roderick Drumgoole

>Dan,

Thanks for posting the resized pics, you are very kind and considerate of the group.

When I first saw the pics, I ran back to the shop to see the bench again as your skills at resizing pics shows the bench from a different perspective than what I originally posted. Again, thank you!

Roderick

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#11

Bench Pictures for US

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Dan, Thanks for taking the time to resize these pics. This bench certainly deserves them.

I also strongly agree that this is most definately worthy of a position in the Shop Shots section.

Roderick,

- What's the dimensions of the legs and are they solid or laminated?

- Are you going the leave the underside open or fill it with shallow drawers?

-What type of glue did you use? How much? At least 3 gallons I bet.

-I'd also like to see pics of the underside of the top as well.

-Just as a matter of curiosity, how much $$$ do you have in this bench? Answer is optional of coarse. ;~)

Based upon what I see I'd say that you have right at a foot of overhang on each end, am I correct?

Now, not to be a wet blanket, but does anybody feel that there is any danger of sag occurring over time?

you said that you long admired the Dominy bench, and I'd say that you've done a fine job of recreating it. To say that I am envious of this bench would be an understatement as I think it is a magnificent piece of workmanship and Craftsmanship.

T.O.

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#12

No problem

Dan Donaldson

>I also wanted to see them larger.

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#13

Re: No problem

dave brown

>Awesome bench! Where did you get your vise screws?

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#14

Re: Bench Pictures for US

Roderick Drumgoole

>- What's the dimensions of the legs and are they solid or laminated?

5" x 3 1/2" (laminated)

30" length (including 2 1/2" tenons)

- Are you going the leave the underside open or fill it with shallow drawers?

Still thinking about the drawer option...probably not, as I would probably want it where one of the holdfast holes are located. I did, however make provisions for a sliding deadman by boring a slot under the edge along the length. My plan is to work the bench as is, and see if the sliding deadman will be something to add. Also, I did seriously consider installing a wagon vise (I think those rascals are neat) but after pondering, I didn't have the guts (skills) to pull it off - at least those were my thoughts. I will be adding some leather that I have just ordered to the vice.

-What type of glue did you use? How much? At least 3 gallons I bet.

One full gallon of Titebond (not sure if it was II or III), whatever the Big Box store had.

-I'd also like to see pics of the underside of the top as well.

I'll try! My digital photography skills are not where I would like. I'll try to show (don't know how successful I will be), that I did not spend much time on the bottom as there are still fore (jack) plane tracks that are clearly visible; however, it is relatively flat. I did, however concentrate on the areas where the leg tenons would meet the top and the area that has the groove for the sliding deadman - those areas were surfaced with the Try Plane. Without a doubt, the most important thing for me during the construction was to get major glue penetration on both sides of the laminations. So, there are still some visible glue lines under the top.

-Just as a matter of curiosity, how much $$$ do you have in this bench? Answer is optional of coarse. ;~)

Well let's see! The purpleheart came from eBay at a good price (the shipping of that heavy rascal was brutal, almost as much as the wood price). Total came to about $700 with the screws; if you include the niffty hand forge holdfasts add another $100. My first bench, which was all Poplar was about $325....it just depends on what type of wood you will use. I did price Maple as well...my cost would have approached the $1000 mark.

Based upon what I see I'd say that you have right at a foot of overhang on each end, am I correct?

Close! There is approximately 15" of overhang

Now, not to be a wet blanket, but does anybody feel that there is any danger of sag occurring over time?

I thought about that as well; if I were doing this bench again, I would seriously consider adding internal rods (maybe 3-4)for no other reason than to avoid what occurred to me during the final lamination with two big slabs - crown on one side and a cup on the other! This probably could have been prevented if I had the proper clamps and I had clamped the top with half of the clamps on top and half on the bottom. As for as sagging, Chris has a niffty chart in his book which refers to the "stiffness" of various woods; if you take a look, it show that Ash is quite 'stiff.'

you said that you long admired the Dominy bench, and I'd say that you've done a fine job of recreating it. To say that I am envious of this bench would be an understatement as I think it is a magnificent piece of workmanship and Craftsmanship.

Thanks....those words mean a lot to me being relatively new to woodworking coming from folks such as yourself and others on the forum who have many years under their belt.

Roderick

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#15

Re: No problem

Roderick Drumgoole

>Dave, If you scroll down several posts when I first posted, I talked about purchasing the screws. Here's what I wrote before:

purchased the screws from Stephen Fee whom Chris S. recommends in an earlier post several months back. Here's Stephen's email address:

sfee13@verizon.net

If I recall correctly, he told me that he turned the maple blank on his lathe, but threads/nut he did by hand with a very old tap & die.

Roderick

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#16

Re: No problem

dave brown

>Ahhh, I see. Sorry for asking you to repost info. What did they cost you? I know when he began making them the prices seemed a little steep to me.

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#17

Re: No problem

Roderick Drumgoole

>Without looking back in my checkbook (I purchased them 4 months ago), they were approximately $100 (may have been slightly more)which was worth it to me at least. I reasoned that for a 2 1/2" screw with a head that is roughly 3 1/2" at it's largest diameter (it tapers slightly)which is made out of maple at 18" in length that was turned by hand (after the initial cylinder on the lathe). Additionally, I could not have done it, didn't want the only less expensive option I knew at the time - metal screws - and most of all, I have always wanted a big bench with wood screws!

Roderick

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

#18

Re: Bench Pictures for Roderick

Dave Anderson NH

>Thank you for taking the time to send the pictures to Dan. They do much better justice to your efforts. Thank you too Dan.