Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.
James Watriss
>So, about a year ago I bought a brand new Sjoberg Elite, 8 footer. It's a pretty nicely put together bench, all... well, most things considered.
I've read varying opinions on the theory that you should finish both sides of a table top. Some folks think it's pretty unnecessary, and that it's overkill.
Well, I'm thinking it's not.
Sjoberg put an oil/wax finish on the visible surfaces, but the underside of the top is bare wood. It's a 3" thick top, 4" thick where the aprons are mounted. And, without really giving it much thought, I figured that much mass, that much thickness, would mean more stiffness, and more resistance to warping forces. Silly me. It's european Beech, which has healthy medullary ray structure, which means that if you put it in a bone dry environment, it'll dry out very well. And my shop is bone dry in the wintertime. Between New England winters, and the healthy heating system in the old building, there's very, very little moisture in the air.
The bench warped in both directions, and the direction would indicate that it's becuase of the underside drying out faster than the surface. It cupped, crowning on top. AND it bowed from end to end, again crowning on top.
Interestingly enough, the wood in line with the dog holes shrunk even more, which you can see in the photos. Those lines are low areas in the surface, as demonstrated by the remaining finish, and are evidence that the exposed end grain in the dog holes let more moisture off than the rest of the top.
I rough planed the surface, to let the bare wood breathe for a few weeks, before I try to flatten it.
There's a slight irony... the plane that I'm using is my old 5 1/2, which was also pretty bowed when I found it. As a result of all the lapping I had to do, the corrugations on the bottom are now tapered, and are thinner towards the front.
And, quiet gloat... in the background you'll see my NBSS tool chest.





