Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Posts

Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#1

Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

James Watriss

>So, about a year ago I bought a brand new Sjoberg Elite, 8 footer. It's a pretty nicely put together bench, all... well, most things considered.

I've read varying opinions on the theory that you should finish both sides of a table top. Some folks think it's pretty unnecessary, and that it's overkill.

Well, I'm thinking it's not.

Sjoberg put an oil/wax finish on the visible surfaces, but the underside of the top is bare wood. It's a 3" thick top, 4" thick where the aprons are mounted. And, without really giving it much thought, I figured that much mass, that much thickness, would mean more stiffness, and more resistance to warping forces. Silly me. It's european Beech, which has healthy medullary ray structure, which means that if you put it in a bone dry environment, it'll dry out very well. And my shop is bone dry in the wintertime. Between New England winters, and the healthy heating system in the old building, there's very, very little moisture in the air.

The bench warped in both directions, and the direction would indicate that it's becuase of the underside drying out faster than the surface. It cupped, crowning on top. AND it bowed from end to end, again crowning on top.

Interestingly enough, the wood in line with the dog holes shrunk even more, which you can see in the photos. Those lines are low areas in the surface, as demonstrated by the remaining finish, and are evidence that the exposed end grain in the dog holes let more moisture off than the rest of the top.

I rough planed the surface, to let the bare wood breathe for a few weeks, before I try to flatten it.

There's a slight irony... the plane that I'm using is my old 5 1/2, which was also pretty bowed when I found it. As a result of all the lapping I had to do, the corrugations on the bottom are now tapered, and are thinner towards the front.

And, quiet gloat... in the background you'll see my NBSS tool chest.


img

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#2

along the length 

James Watriss

>


img

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#3

cupped across the width

James Watriss

>Now, being a good, upstanding American woodworker, my tool kit is well equipped with a very well honed set of phrases and expletives.

I did use them all. In some cases, I tried multiple passes, and found that yes, the bench was still warped. In one or two spots, the laminations are starting to fail as a result. Namely, the apron, which is having a hard time holding onto the upper surface that has bowed away.

I ranted and raved, don't these stupid bench manufacturers know better, woodworkers should know more about finishing, and blah blah blah. The only instance where they had a really noticeable dumb idea is the end cap, which they simply bolted on to the end grain. Of course, the end grain shrank. And the bolts did their level best to keep the width of the bench the same. So there's a split where the top is delaminating near the end cap. I'll find a way to deal with this eventually.

In the end, sure it'd have been nice if they'd finished both sides, but in this extremely bone dry shop, I have a few other surfaces made of laminated wood that have split, or suffered some other moisture-loss related indignity. So it's not really fair of me to expect that this bench would be built for such extreme circumstances. It's frustrating, but it's a fact of life around here. The air dries out.

I'm a woodworker. I'd like to think that bench manufacturers would know better. They don't. Retail sales mean that manufacturers need to keep costs down, and that means that the wood probably wasn't fully seasoned. And it's beech, which isn't known for dimensional stability when it's not quartersawn. And even then, I'm skeptical about its stability when it comes to dimensions outside of the range of, say, wooden plane size.

But, I'm a woodworker. I know better. Benches move when the air dries out. It happens. That's life.

Luckily for me, someone down the hall has a time-saver.

Anyway, figured I'd share.

Moral of the story... thicker doesn't always mean more stable. Always remember to finish top and bottom of your table tops.


img

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#4

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Bummer, James. I recommend not finishing the interiors of case work; but for table tops I recommend either not finishing at all or finishing both top and bottom. I'd be tempted to complain to Sojberg, assuming they're the ones who finished the top.

Pam

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#5

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>How dry is your shop? I would tend to believe that the warping is not just due to only being finished on one side, but the wood adjusting to the lower moisture content. Depending on the growth rings the wood cups some even with equal moisture loss. So far as the end cap being bolted to the end of the bench, it should be held in place with a tongue or spline and the bolt holes should be oversized. It probably will help to oil both sides of the top, but I am not sure I would flatten it in the middle of the driest spell, as it will be shifting back in the summer. I would tend to live with the bench for a few years before doing anything too drastic to it ;)

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#6

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

James Watriss

>Yeah, I'm debating the virtues.

In essence, my main complaint is that there are times when I need to be able to laminate pieces of wood together, and it's helped in the past to be able to stack and clamp to a known straight, flat surface. The bench has traditionally been very useful for this... at least for me... so I need ot think of something to do about it.

This is the second winter for this bench, so I'm sure it's moved around a fair bit. It is disappointing, for sure. But on the other hand, I don't know any lumberyards that stock beech in bigger than 4/4, for this very reason. It's just not that stable.

I'll put it off for a while, as I have other things to do. But I think that at some point, I'm going to wheel the top down the hall and run it through the time saver. I'm sure that next summer, it'll do something else that's equally silly, and I'll have to flatten it again. If it turns into an exercise where I'm taking of 1/8" at a time, every 2 seasons, well, then I guess I'll have to ditch the bench at some point, sell it to some nice, ambitious young woodworker, for less than I paid, and let him or her learn to plane things smooth for themselves.

I'm disappointed, I thought about complaining to sjoberg. For any number of reasons. In the end, it's a commercial bench, built for economy of time and money, in the hopes of turning a profit. What that means is that by the time Woodcraft gets their cut, and the shipping companies get their cut, and the holding company that owns Sjoberg gets their cut, and the employees that ran the machines that built the thing got their cut...

This bench took second to Lie-nielsen in the FWW comparison a year and some ago. My guess, though, is that there are fewer middle men and corporate salary overhead issues to deal with in the L-N bench. So hopefully it's better made.

Moral of the story...

Beech may be the traditional material. But that doesn't necessarily mean that it's the best.

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#7

Oh, and one more thing...

James Watriss

>I have a feeling that Sjoberg uses very green wood. Recently I was using the bench to clamp up a very large frame, using the round dogs provided.

The bench had shrunk enough that the holes were now too small. I had to re-drill the holes I wanted to use. Not that I needed to hog out a lot of wood, mind you, but a quick pass with a 1" forstner bit meant that the dogs could once again slide into the bench top without being hammered in.

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#8

Re: Oh, and one more thing...

Ron Knapp

>Perhaps you should try some maple with the tap holes and save the effort of redrilling the top?? It would match your small toolbox

How you doing James?

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#9

Re: Oh, and one more thing...

James Watriss

>Good Ron.. been a while. How are you?

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#10

Re: Oh, and one more thing...

Ron Knapp

>Interesting problem with the bench. I decided to build one last year when I had access to a 30" planer. Because I wasn't sure what I wanted I decided to keep it fairly simple and if I really botched it up I wouldn't feel to bad about it.

It's 30" X 72" and I used eureopean beech for the top and legs and apron. As you know the usual way of glueing up the top is face to face leaving the edge grain for the actual top. I didn't have much time so I did mine edge to edge leaving the face for the top. I expected it to cause problems but so far it hasn't.

I did read somewhere about using a combination of tung oil and a little spar varnish mixed it and that's what I used on both sides of the top. Perhaps that is helping keep the top flat.

Looks like you have some work cut out for you getting it back into shape. Just what you need at this time. I'm taking a few classes at night up at Phil Lowes in Beverly. Perhaps I can stop by some time on my way up and see you.

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#11

Bummer!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>That's a reall drag to have something like that happen on an expenceive bench. Have you tried to contact them regarding this?

I guess this would be one reason to build your own.

Scott, wishing is shop was a little dryer...

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#12

Re: Oh, and one more thing...

James Watriss

>Sounds good, I'll drop you a line sometime soon.

Bench flattening is a hassle, and it's tedious, and like I said, I've been avoiding it. I'll use the time saver down the hall if it really comes to that.

That said, you're right, I don't have a lot of time on my hands, but it would be fun to go through the exercise of building a bench for myself. There's been a small but growing crop of Holtzappfel, and Holtzappfel/ Roubo hybrid benches popping up in here, and I must admit to a growing curiosity about the prospect of building a bench of my own. I haven't put pencil to paper yet, and I think I'll wait until the fire dies down a bit to see if I still think it's a good idea.

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#13

Re: Bummer!

James Watriss

>I thought about it. But really, it's wood. Wood does this. Beech especially does this, which is why noone around here stocks thicker than 4/4. And Beech will especially do this when you put it in a shop that is dead of winter bone dry.

When I build a bench in the future, I'll use something else like Ash, I think.

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#14

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>James,

We have a company within an hour's drive that makes glue-lams. Glue-Lams for those who might not get out much is a wood beam designed to span a large width such as a roof and they are arched. Now these guys know how to laminate and glue lumber so the finished product is stable. That company is where I'm going when I need a bench top. From what I can tell, they normally use Douglas Fir around here but googling I see that spruce is also used.

All this talk about building workbenches is getting me in the mood for a new bench. The bench I have is like 35 years old and wasn't built then as well as I now know how to build a bench. Glue-Lam will be my first choice..well, perhaps I'll change my mind when I see a price. I'm hoping I'll find a remnant or a piece of flawed glue-lam that they can't sell as a beam.

Marv

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#15

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Seems to me that, with the very rare exception, all the benches mentioned here are glue lams, just using wood rather than exotic plastics and other noxious, off gassing materials. Besides, I bet your bench doesn't need an arch.

Pam

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

#16

Re: Wood movement; Table and Bench tops.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Pam,

In the true sense you are right about most bench tops discussed here are glue-lams, but the point I wanted to make was I thought it might be cheaper and better to buy a chunk of an actual Glue-Lam that was made as a beam. I'm sure they use methods and materials that are held to a high standard considering what they are used for.

The arch on most Glue-Lams would not be much on an 8 ft. bench top. Might be unique to have a slightly curved front but I'd probably cut it straight just for practical purposes. Most of the larger Glue-Lams are at least 6 inches thick... 2 x 6,s.

They use kiln dried lumber and exterior glue and cured under high even pressure and the surfaces are sealed with some kind of clear sealer. I would think that the out-gassing would be limited once it's sealed.

Marv