Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

New Bench

Posts

Re: New Bench

#26

Re: More vise screws

Roderick Drumgoole

>No!! I didn't make the screws...I am much too young at woodworking (< 3 years) to have acquired those skills. I purchased the screws from Stephen Fee whom Chris S. recommends in an earlier post several months back. Here's Stephen's email address:

sfee13@verizon.net

If I recall correctly, he told me that he turned the maple blank on his lathe, but threads/nut he did by hand with a very old tap & die.

Roderick

Re: New Bench

#27

Re: NICE BENCH!

Roderick Drumgoole

>That is a very nice bench Roderick! Clean and simple.

Thanks!!!

Any particular reason you made it 10' long?

Yes...because that's what I wanted! My first bench, which was also my very first woodworking project about 3 years ago was based off of the Roubo bench in Woodworking mag. It was 8' long and 24" inches wide in which I always found myself wanting a few more feet as tools pile up quickly when I am focused on a project. After 6 months of using the bench, I realized how poor my skills was initially when building that first bench and I knew at some point another one was in the plans. Further, I don't care for "tool wells" and if I could have located 12' boards local to me, I would made it 12 foot. I have always been impressed by the Dominy bench.

Do you have rods going thru the top to hold it together?

No...straight lamination with glue only! Pretty much as Chris references in his book, I laminated in sections, 4-6 boards at one time until I had two massive slabs for the final lamination.

How's the top attached to the base?

Mortise and tenon(2 1/2" long), then pinned with 1/2" oak pins. During the dry fit, everything was so precise, it didn't lend itself for much lifting as all four legs wanted to come out of the mortise simultaneoulsy. After doing this for a few times to trim the tenons, the last dry fit was so snug that I left it as such, and pinned straight through the mortise and tenon. My original intent was to "draw bore" the joint just as I had done on the stretchers.

Did you handplane the top flat?

Yes, of course as I don't have any power tools and I wouldn't dare attempt to bring that massive slab to someone for sanding. Because I don't have very good clamps (pipe clamps), naturally as one clamps all along the length of the slab and only with clamps on the top, there is a chance that you will get a bow on one side and a cup on the other side. This of course means more planning than I originally intended. I removed probably about 1/4" off of the top.

Etc, etc, etc.

You will need to tell me what other info you would like, etc.

Has Chris contacted you yet? ;~)

Yes, we have emailed back and forth a few times, I think he is just as excited as I am about the bench. Because, I didn't have any experience with boring 2 1/2" holes in which I knew that my hand brace was out of the question, I consulted with him prior to construction. He suggested that I acquire a massive forstner (saw tooth) bit from Lee Valley, which I did and borrowed an electric hand drill. That was one part of the project that I disliked...drilling a 2 1/2" hole through 2" thick boards.

I hope I covered all of your questions, if not, just yell and I'll respond.

Roderick

Re: New Bench

#28

Re: New Bench

Dan Donaldson

>Very nice. My only problem is that if I had one that big, there wouldn't be any room for me to get into my shop ;-)

A hint for pictures: You can get a better view if you try to make the width somewhere around 600 to 650 pixels. If you are having trouble getting them that big and within the limits, there is some advice in the FAQ's (in the box at the top of the board.) If that still doesn't work for you, sned me the pictures and I will resize them for you. That bench deserves a good view ;-)

Re: New Bench

#29

Yes, please send to Don

Dave Anderson NH

>I agree, a bench that nice DEMANDS full sized pictures. I so really wish I had room for a 10 foot bench.

Re: New Bench

#30

Re: Yes, please send to Don

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Ditto what Dave said, especially the "DEMANDS" part. This bench certainly does DEMAND better pics.

I suppose you've got Chris knocking his head on his bench now. He no sooner puts out a book and POOF!! up pops this beautiful bench!

I wondered why the 10' foot length as I wondered if the work you did required that kind of length. I can certainly understand the the "because that's what I wanted" reasoning tho. ;~)

It will be interesting to hear as you use it what you like and dislike about it, and what you wished you had done differently--if anything.

Looking much forward to the bigger pics.

T.O.

Re: New Bench

#31

Re: New Bench

roderick.drumgoole

>All of the bench pics are enroute to Dan in three separate emails.

Roderick

Re: New Bench

#32

Re: New Bench

Verne in NJ

>Wow! I'm building a similar bench (with Chris S's encouragement and feedback) out of ash, but mine's only 6' long - like many others that's all I have room for. You said you don't have power tools - how did you surface everything? My benchtop is just over 3" thick and it is astonishingly heavy - how did you move the glueups around? What a great job you've done!

The wood screws look beautiful - I'm reusing a Veritas Twin Screw vise that was on my old bench.

My only quibble is that you should have extended the benchtop another foot. That way you could say in all truthfulness "It goes to eleven"

;-)

Re: New Bench

#33

Re: New Bench

Roderick Drumgoole

>You said you don't have power tools - how did you surface everything?

With a Try Plane!! I do have a pretty good lumber yard where I purchase lumber from that has a 36" Sander. I could have wrestled the massive slab with a few neighbors into the back of my pick-up truck, but that would have been more laborious work than I could stand. Then there would have been the return trip and more wrestling. Although the surfacing with a hand plane on ash is not the easiest task - especially when there is a nice crown in the center of the top - it is not impossible and that was my option of choice just as I choose to start woodworking with only hand tools. Read Chris's article in the latest PopWood on surfacing bench tops with a hand plane and that's fairly close to what I did. Further, as he suggests in the article, we are not talking about a "great" deal of skill to accomplish....I have less than three years of woodworking experience.

My benchtop is just over 3" thick and it is astonishingly heavy - how did you move the glueups around?

Be exerting shear will power!!! Seriously, I am a farily large man - 6'2" 280lbs - and I have two apprentices...one is twelve and the other is nine years old.

Hope this answers your questions, if not or you have more, just drop a line.

Roderick

Re: New Bench

#34

It's a beauty

GolfSteve in Calgary

>It's a beauty, Roderick, something you'll treasure every time you go to the shop.

Cheers,

Steven

Re: New Bench

#35

Re: Yes, please send to Don

wilbur

>Full size pictures, and maybe an entry into Shop Shots.

I used to say things like, "I'm jealous," but now I just get inspired.

Re: New Bench

#36

Re: So it doesn't Float?

Dean Lapinel

>Stephen,

It felt like there was a point to be made about "not floating". I'd like to learn what you had in mind.

Dean

Re: New Bench

#37

Re: So it doesn't Float? *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dean,

I started another thread about this, here is the link.

Stephen


Floating Nuts

Re: New Bench

#38

Holdfast holes

wilbur

>Roderick,

It looks like your bench has only two holes for holdfasts, and they're both pretty centrally located. How did you decide where to put the holes for the holdfasts, and why only two for a bench this long?

Re: New Bench

#39

Re: Holdfast holes

Roderick Drumgoole

>Actually, there are three columns that have holes in no specific pattern. However, in each column the distance between each hole is either 24", 12", or 6". The two holes where you see the holdfasts is about where I would commonly place them with battens while planning boards. A few things I learned from my last bench is that I dislike a lot of holes scattered on the bench (just a quirk of mine's), I need holes in various locations for other operations such as chopping mortises, holding boards for sawing on the bench - both rip and cross cuts, sticking moldings, etc. There are probably about eight holes on the bench currently, if more are needed as time passes, I'll add it to one of the columns attempting to keep the same spacing of either dimension mentioned above. Speaking of planning boards, I intentionally made the bench 2 inches shorter than my first bench so that I could really get over on top of boards and improve my skills at planning with just a planning stop; no holdfasts/battens. All in attempt to get faster at building projects.

Roderick