Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Flattening soles of wooden planes

Posts

Flattening soles of wooden planes

#1

Flattening soles of wooden planes

Mark Harrison -- Brisbane Australia

>I've been away for a while so I haven't been keeping up with the board in that time.

Anyway, I scored three ECE Primus planes on the weekend. The smoother (Pear body with LV sole), a German jack and the little bevel up block plane. All are extra minty and in the original box. Grand total of $145 USD! I would think that they are about 20 years old and scarcely used, if at all. The date I can deduce as it has a "Made in Western Germany" sticker on the heel.

For another $90 USD I also got the Ulmia four bar marking gage and the two bar marking gage! Also extra minty though no boxes. Now that I've had my drive-by gloat :-) the question.

The smoother does need to have the sole flattened. I have resisted touching it so far as I don't want to mess it up.

I have a nicely tuned Stanley 7 but I'm not sure how it will go on Lignum Vitae and I'm not 100% confident of my technique either. I also have (shudder) a power jointer. I suppose a cut of a fraction of a millimeter might be all it needs and then sand.

Any thoughts?

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#2

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Mark

I would do it the same way one does metal planes - use sandpaper on glass, or a scraper. Your choice.

Why not bring it over. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#3

Special tool

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>We woodworkers have a sophisticated tool for working flat wood surfaces: the plane. I would use a smoothing plane set very fine for working the bottom of the pearwood smoother. I think your #7 plane would be heavy and clumsy for such delicate work on a such small surface. Check with winding sticks and straightedge. Plane only the high spots and don't try to take full shavings and hope the flatness improves. If your smoothing plane is not up to this task you can use a card scraper, again working only the high areas.

The thought of using sandpaper on such a refined tool seems rather barbaric.

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#4

Re: Special tool

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The thought of using sandpaper on such a refined tool seems rather barbaric.

I don't feel this way, Warren. The advantage of sandpaper is that you can use it to find fine high spots. For this particular task, a wide and long and flat expanse of 180, 240 and 400 grit sandpaper, or a card scraper, will remove less wood with more control that a handplane. Once the plane is used again, the wood-on-wood will quickly (re-)burnish the sole.

This is how I maintain my HNT Gordon woodies.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#5

some authoities use sand paper

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>David Finck, author of the making wooden planes book and former student of Krenov, uses sand paper to adjust soles as needed. As a demonstration he did it on one of my home made planes.

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#6

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Mark,

Great score!

Couple of thoughts.....

First, let the planes acclimate for a while to where they're going to be residing, to give the wood a chance to acclimate and make a one-time adjustment before you start work.

Second, is the sole that needs to be trued convex (bellied out) or concave (hollow to the work)? If it is concave, lapping will work. If it is convex, then Warren's method is the way to go, using either a scraper plane or another smooth plane. Work from the "inside out", just as in edge-jointing. Hopefully, the smoother is the adjustable mouth kind ('reform').

Now if the sole is convex, and if you really and truly don't want to take a scraper or another plane to the sole of the ECE, then the option is to first make it a little concave--then lap it. You can make it concave by abrading only the center portion, knock that down, and then finish up by lapping. But a scraper plane works great for this purpose.

In regard to lapping, and long-term maintenance of woodies, I highly recommend using PSA microfinishing film on a granite plate. This abrasive does not spall off and get embedded in the sole, and the mylar film base is not 'plush', meaning that it won't round off (radius) the edges of the plane. It will leave the edges fairly sharp. Expensive, but it lasts a long time. Gives you a good long-term solution for keeping your woodies in good fettle. Make one pass on 30 micron paper, look at the sole, and you know its exact condition. Usually, all that is required is a light scraper pass on the high spots every 6 months or so (IME). The abrasive film on granite gives you a good diagnostic.

Wiley

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#7

Re: Special tool

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'm with you, Warren, using a plane to do most of the flattening job is about as good as it gets. Scrapers take care of the rest of it.

Pam

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#8

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I think the plane, card scraper, cabinet scraper, scraper plane is the way to go.

One problem with abrasives is that they can become imbedded in the wooden sole and can score your work.

That aside using an abrasive like sandpaper before using another edge tool is never a good idea. If you must sand do it after you have used all edged tools, lest they become dulled with the grit.

Stephen

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#9

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

ThomD

>I will use another plane, or sandpaper, or a scraper, or a japanese scraper plane. But I would try the darn thing first. If it is a jack plane the objective can be a number of things but it was normally at the coarser end. You may not need to do the sole, I have an ece jack, I think mine is the wedged one, and I don't think I messed with the sole. Of course it probably shouldn't do any harm to have a go, so long as you don't get all caught up in the idea it is a finishing plane and needs to take fine shavings, unless that's what you want it to do.

Sandpaper on a flat surface sorta seems like a hack's way, but it has better geometry for cutting flat so if you have a flat surface and some sandpaper, it can do a great job. Planes don't cut flat they cut curves of varying depth. Which won't hurt a thing with this kind of project, or as a means to prep for the sandpaper.

There is a lot of stuff about grit getting into the wood and messing stuff up for you. But a lot of those ideas came into the fold back when all you could get was garnet or SC paper. We have very durable papers these days.

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#10

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

Mark Harrison -- Brisbane Australia

>First, let the planes acclimate for a while to where they're going to be residing, to give the wood a chance to acclimate and make a one-time adjustment before you start work.

Actually I think you're onto something there. When I first got the plane and sharpened the iron the darn thing jumped and skipped across the wood like a boomer (Australian slang for Kangaroo) on speed. I checked the sole and sure enough there was a hollow in front of the mouth. Today that seems to have settled down and I can actually make the plane work. I haven't changed anything since writing last.

We are having a lot of rain at the moment (which is quite welcome as we were in the grip of one of the worst and longest droughts in recorded history) and I suspect that this may have have had something to do with this. I note that the inside of the throat has no no finish and is bare wood. When things stabilize I will put some Danish oil in there and see if that can make a long term difference.

I tried the Reform smoother on another board of Victorian Ash (Eucalyptus Delegatensis) that was on the shelf that I had dome some testing with earlier. This particular board whoops and swirls all over the place. The plane now just cuts through it all and produced the best finish I have ever got with a hand plane. This is particularly impressive when you look at how gnarly this particular board is. I could not get anywhere near this result with the Lie-Nielsen 164.

Feeling confident (or foolhardy) I took some River Red Gum (E. Camaldulensis) that is the gnarliest stuff I have ever seen. The regular curly board was great but there is another board that I have left over from my side table project that is so gnarly you can't even tell where the grain is going. Alas, it failed this test but I frankly would have been astonished if it had succeeded. I couldn't even get a good surface (unpredictable tear out!) with a card scraper in the past. This is the timber we invented sand paper for!

The other information also looks useful and I will use it later on.

I tried the little block plane today and I was truly surprised at the performance of this plane. I've been cutting chamfers on bed rails. The plan was to use this plane to take off most of the wood before finishing with the Reform Smoother. I found that I didn't really need to use the smoother in the end in most cases. The result with the block plane was good enough. I compared results with my Lie-Nielsen 164 and the result was better with the Primus block plane.

Overall, these planes may have been the best purchase I made so far. I'm even considering buying a Primus Trying plane now.

Re: Flattening soles of wooden planes

#11

Re: Special tool

Adam Cherubini

>I use a plane when there's a lot of material to be removed and I'm feeling impatient. In my experience the trick is avoiding snipe (yes, just like a power planer). If you have too much weight on your front hand as you exit the end of the piece you are planing, you can undercut. Now of course this is basic technique that all of us should have mastered. But when planing a wood plane, its an extra concern of mine.

One way around the problem is to chuck your long plane in the bench vise and push the shorter plane that needs the flattening over it.

Otherwise, I often use sandpaper. I think its a much more gentle approach. I sometimes use paper as fine as 400 grit, just to find out where the trouble is. If you sharpen with sandpaper and glass, this seems very convenient.

One thing I've found helpful is to periodically check your wood planes' soles. What I've found is that they are rarely flat and still seem to function just fine. This revelation has discouraged me from spending too much time and energy flattening soles.

Adam