Not for Beginners
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>The following is a rant and should be taken as such and is not for beginners but:
Just suppose how woodworker, 150 years ago measured angles and thicknesses? Well they would probably have a bevel gauge and a protractor and they would have had a ruler. Now with the gauge and protractor they could determine any angle quite accurately. It does require some work, setting the gauge properly then accurately determining the angle by direct comparison to the protractor.
With a ruler of course they could take measurements. Now almost all of the old rules I have seen are marked down to 1/16th inch, some ivory, brass or iron were marked down to 1/32nd of an inch and some even finer. Anything less than that was probably beyond the capabilities of most woodworkers in the past to measure. Thin measurements were compared to paper or a hair or other object which everyone could relate.
I bring this up when it comes to cutting edge angles. There is much discussion as to which angle is best for which purpose and people have gone to great depths and lengths and thinness' to come up with these figures. And while that is alright and a noble pursuit, I think that 150 years ago this was of little concern.
If the tool didn�t work and the craftsman with experience would know to change it to suit their needs. If the chisel was difficult to push through the wood because of a too steep angle, they knew to reduce the angle to make it work easier. And I think that this is the case in most instances.
Certainly planes were offered in different pitches and they knew what they needed but as to the angle with which they sharpened the blade that depended on a lot of things. The diameter of the grind stone and the subsequent hollow grind changed original factory angles. I am sure if they thought the angle was good they would replicate what worked. If it needed to be changed I am sure they did it without hesitation.
Now I have been doing traditional woodworking for 35 years and if I recall correctly I have never measured the angle of a chisel, plane iron or any other cutting edge tool. Why, I don�t care, when I get a �new� tool, I sharpen the blade at the angle that it came to me. If it is too steep after trying it out, I regrind it to a shallower angle and vice-versa.
Why, don�t I care and why do I think craftsmen in the past probably didn�t either, too busy building furniture. That is after what it is all about. Sure you need proper tools, sharpened correctly and you need some understanding of angles but if it is exactly 27� or precisely 28� for that perfect cut is like Diogenes looking for the honest man.
Wood changes, the plane might work well on one end of a board and not on the other. The next board will be different in some subtle way, so the �ideal� angle argument is irrelative. I am not stupid and neither were our ancestors, if something doesn�t work, we change it, I know if an angle on a chisel is too steep just by looking at the bevel.
Measuring and calculating angles may be alright as you are learning, we do have more time these days. If you are a tool maker then it is important. But if it gets in the way of getting anything done then it is a waste of time.
Stephen



