Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Not for Beginners

Posts

Not for Beginners

#1

Not for Beginners

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The following is a rant and should be taken as such and is not for beginners but:

Just suppose how woodworker, 150 years ago measured angles and thicknesses? Well they would probably have a bevel gauge and a protractor and they would have had a ruler. Now with the gauge and protractor they could determine any angle quite accurately. It does require some work, setting the gauge properly then accurately determining the angle by direct comparison to the protractor.

With a ruler of course they could take measurements. Now almost all of the old rules I have seen are marked down to 1/16th inch, some ivory, brass or iron were marked down to 1/32nd of an inch and some even finer. Anything less than that was probably beyond the capabilities of most woodworkers in the past to measure. Thin measurements were compared to paper or a hair or other object which everyone could relate.

I bring this up when it comes to cutting edge angles. There is much discussion as to which angle is best for which purpose and people have gone to great depths and lengths and thinness' to come up with these figures. And while that is alright and a noble pursuit, I think that 150 years ago this was of little concern.

If the tool didn�t work and the craftsman with experience would know to change it to suit their needs. If the chisel was difficult to push through the wood because of a too steep angle, they knew to reduce the angle to make it work easier. And I think that this is the case in most instances.

Certainly planes were offered in different pitches and they knew what they needed but as to the angle with which they sharpened the blade that depended on a lot of things. The diameter of the grind stone and the subsequent hollow grind changed original factory angles. I am sure if they thought the angle was good they would replicate what worked. If it needed to be changed I am sure they did it without hesitation.

Now I have been doing traditional woodworking for 35 years and if I recall correctly I have never measured the angle of a chisel, plane iron or any other cutting edge tool. Why, I don�t care, when I get a �new� tool, I sharpen the blade at the angle that it came to me. If it is too steep after trying it out, I regrind it to a shallower angle and vice-versa.

Why, don�t I care and why do I think craftsmen in the past probably didn�t either, too busy building furniture. That is after what it is all about. Sure you need proper tools, sharpened correctly and you need some understanding of angles but if it is exactly 27� or precisely 28� for that perfect cut is like Diogenes looking for the honest man.

Wood changes, the plane might work well on one end of a board and not on the other. The next board will be different in some subtle way, so the �ideal� angle argument is irrelative. I am not stupid and neither were our ancestors, if something doesn�t work, we change it, I know if an angle on a chisel is too steep just by looking at the bevel.

Measuring and calculating angles may be alright as you are learning, we do have more time these days. If you are a tool maker then it is important. But if it gets in the way of getting anything done then it is a waste of time.

Stephen

Re: Not for Beginners

#2

Re: Not for Beginners

paul womack

>Measuring and calculating angles may be alright as you are learning, we do have more time these days. If you are a tool maker then it is important. But if it gets in the way of getting anything done then it is a waste of time.

It's great for a master to say to an apprentice "this thick", "like this", and so on, suiting actions to words. The master could SHOW the apprentice a "steep" bevel and a "low" bevel, and all would be clear.

But when *we* exchange information in words and pictures, measurements are very helpful, giving us an agreed reference.

BugBear

Re: Not for Beginners

#3

Re: Not for Beginners

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>As Bug Bear observes it was easy for the master to say to instruct an apprentice by saying "like this", and showing the apprentice what a "steep" bevel and a "low" bevel, etc looked like.

Most of us will never meet in person with the tool between us so we need to use word which describe the particular angles.

But I think you have fingered why the original bevel-up planes were offered for so short a time period. Which equates to them not being a marketing success.

Because the bevel establishes the cutting angle, these planes need to be sharpened at a repeatible angle which is very difficult if done by hand

Ian

Re: Not for Beginners

#4

To elaborate

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Beginners are the very people that benefit from having a quantifiable reference to start with. By providing a target someone without experience can succeed from the start.

I am having this same issue with French Polish. The wetness of the rubber is the key to success. Now if there was a quantitative measure of how wet it should be I would succeed with the first try. As it is I am enduring endless frustration zeroing in on how wet it needs to be.

On the other hand if someone says I am successful at chopping oak with a 35 degree chisel then I will succeed at once if I sharpen at 35 degrees. As my experience progresses I may experiment with this angle once I have a reference with which to compare results.

When I began sharpening I made a target angle by cutting an angled notch in a piece of paper.

But, I could not agree more that too much analysis can get in the way of accomplishing something.

Re: Not for Beginners

#5

Re: Not for Beginners

BobStrawn

>I suspect that many woodworkers in the past knew the trick of flipping a blade to change bevel angle. No proof, but it seems like an obvious thing to try. I also suspect that the noticed the blade wearing out faster bevel up.

A low angle plane is only as low as the bed angle lets it be. A low bed angle gives thin support to the blade. In this case a ridged metal sole is more stable than a wooden sole. Low angle may have been a less generally acceptable option before metal planes became popular.

I suspect that a lot of woodworkers used rise over run for angle measurement in the deep past. It is a very convenient way to be very precise.

Bob

Re: Not for Beginners

#6

Chris Scholz

Re: Not for Beginners

Chris Scholz

>There was an old fellow in ancient China (around 500 BC) who summed it up as follows:

1) A master woodworker does not need to measure.

2) Measurement tools are useful for masters to teach less advanced woodworkers how to improve their skills. Many measurement techniques have ben propagated via songs and poems.

Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Re: Not for Beginners

#7

Re: Not for Beginners

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I can agree with this, but I have some slightly different reasons why I agree. I work in a technical field (programming) and every day I'm forced to make sure that everything I deal with is documented down to it's last detail. I am not allowed to move on a project until I have identified every facet of it. I think this style of thinking, since it is prevalent not just in IT, makes it's way into many peoples lives. So, we start thinking that in everything we do we must consider everything and understand it fully before we start.

I had to start forcing myself out of this mindset in order to make stuff and not just think about making stuff. I agree with several posters that listing the bevel angle is important, especially for beginners. However, when I learned that exactness isn't always so important, I felt a little freed. I wasn't so worried if I tipped a tool a little too far when sharpening. As long as it was near 25 degrees, it was close enough. 27 1/2 degrees or 24 degrees cuts pretty much the same. I'm positive that many pro sharpeners wouldn't consider my edges all that good, but I found what works well for me to get back to work. Ask me again in 25 years and maybe I'll say my edges are perfect.

Scrap wood is a good friend of mine. Want to know how the tool will perform, try it out first. Much of the knowledge needed to use a handtool is not in a book. These tools require us to use them for years and years and train our bodies and minds to use the correctly, change when necessary, adjust from time to time. Worrying too much about an angle or size can paralyze you from ever trying something.

So, don't worry too little, but don't worry too much either. Balance in everything, I guess.

Oh, I also look for people that I can work with in person to learn things. You go much faster that way.

Re: Not for Beginners

#8

Re: Not for Beginners

charlie belden

>Well there is the problem of Bevel Down. You want the back of the iron supported. In Bevel Down, that means the angle the bed/frog makes to the bottom of the plane is the angle you want for maximum support of the iron behind the cutting edge. A steeper bevel angle and you lose support behind the iron. A shallower angle and the heel of the iron makes contact, not the cutting edge. I doubt that old masters changed the bed angle very often, even in wood planes. Which may be why Bevel UP is used on bench planes - easier to adjust as needed.

I suspect that the need for numeric values of measurements came in when the person who designed the piece and all its details WAS NOT the person who would actually make the piece. When the designer and the maker are the same person, a story stick or two was the measuring tool - without any graduation marks - the piece needs to be "this long", "this wide" and "this tall". As the piece was made and things needed to fit in what was already done "slip sticks" did the job of identifying "it needs to be this long and this wide".

Specialization - designer, maker, tool maker, finisher, sales person - necessitates recordable, numeric values for measurements, especially when all that was no longer done by one person, or supervised by one person, but became tasks done by multiple persons, often in different towns, states, or countries.

When folks made their own handplanes and the local blacksmith provided the iron/steel parts, made to order with the end user having direct contact with him, "make it a little steeper - or shallower" worked. But when a guy in China is making something for you better have precise drawings and specs - and someone on hand to do QC.

It cracks me up when I see a dimension that has 5/32" or 9/64ths on a "measured drawing". Somewhere in the parts fabrication process, something is going to be off, even just a little, and during assembly, something's going to move or be out of square, or not quite straight. If you cut ALL the parts for the entire piece at the beginning, somewhere along the line something won't fit properly. It is, after all, wood, and wood moves. And humans are not precision machines - though we do have some pretty amazing abilities to discern things - get a teeny-tiny-minute bit of anything in your eye, or between your teeth and you'll know it's there.

I think it's turning tools that repeatability of bevel angles have value. A turning tool's cutting edge will see more wear in 10 minutes than bench chisels or plane irons will see in months, if not years. And because they rely on "rubbing the bevel" to control the cut, a consistent angle, sharpening to sharpening, makes for better muscle memory use - and better, consistent results. That's the theory. I don't know for sure because I sharpen without worrying about the theory - and quickly adapt to how the gouge or chisel is working - this time.

But for the "28 Degrees Is Best" vs the "26 Degrees Is Best" folks - have fun "discussing" the merits and shortcomings of each. Ifit works for you then that's what's best - for you. Screw what anyone else thinks - unless . . .

Re: Not for Beginners

#9

Re: Not for Beginners

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I do agree with you, Stephen, not so surprising since I also have spent my life doing this kind of work. I often find myself measuring something for the first time just to be able to answer a question on this forum. But I'm not sure this is the best approach for everyone. I might give different advice to a 17 year old considering an occupation as a craftsman than to a 60 year old who sat at a desk for 40 years.

In the long run an intuitive approach, resulting from much experience gives the best results. Given enough practice one will know what angle to sharpen or how much shellac to use for french polish. In the short run people want a recipe for success, the "cookbook approach" as my calculus teacher used to say. As others have mentioned, it is easier to relay quantitative information in a forum like this.

Re: Not for Beginners

#10

Carpenter's Measure

patrick gibbons, houston, tx

>The practice of using so-called carpenter's measures involves referring to a measurement as either scant or full. Thus 3/16" full would be maybe 7/32" or 13/64". Conversely, 3/16" scant would be 1/32" or 1/64" less. Picture one carpenter instructing another to cut him another piece of the molding, but this time only 1 foot 3 and 1/2 inches scant to fit the space where it's going to be applied. While this is not bevel angles, the philosophy applies. Plane pitches were expressed as common, York, middle and half. This probably had more meaning than 45, 50, 55 and 60 degrees and, I would suspect, be considered more of a range than an exact degree. As an example; York pitch is about 50 degrees. Boards themselves were referred to as scantlings or timbers, etc., and had meaning as to size in the woodworker's mind. If I were to tell you to build something out of two by lumber you'd instantly picture in your mind's eye what I was talking about. Others have argued that we use exact degrees to communicate our meaning to each other. This is in great part because the terms of the past, which had built in tolerances to their meanings, are no longer familiar to us.

Re: Not for Beginners

#11

Re: Not for Beginners

Jeff S.

>You mean that Goddard and Townsend built furniture to a degree of craftsmanship that is rarely equaled today without electron beam microscopic blade edge analysis, or a +/- .0002"/ft. Starrett straight edge , or a grade A granite surface plate, or 5-Axis blade sharpening guide, and in workshops that were subject to outdoor weather fluctuations?

I'm aghast! :-)

Re: Not for Beginners

#12

Wetness of the rubber...

James Watriss

>Thought I'd throw this in, speaking of quantifiable measurements.

When I do french polishing, I'm usually wearing latex gloves. (I put them on, then go wash them under the sink to get rid of the powder.

A few things on french polishing:

-seal the grain. I use a sludge of boiled linseed oil and pumice powder to seal and scour the surface. Then wipe down with a cloth that's dampened with linseed oil to get rid of the excess pumice.

-A good heavy base coat helps a LOT. I just slop on a coat that has a heavier cut than normal.

-wetness of the rubber... when I can dab the back of my latex glove, and watch it flash off within a second or so, that's usually good. One thing to remember though is that this is achieved both through less wetness, as well as more alcohol in the shellac. (I don't know what you know and don't know, so forgive me if I'm walking down.)

-use a little oil. Sometimes the rubber doesn't move as smoothly as we'd like. A few drops of raw linseed oil, or pure mineral oil, will help a lot. I doubt that the mineral oil bit is traditional, but I know I've heard about the linseed oil routine.

-If you have a big enough surface, you should be able to keep working for a while at a time. But with smaller surfaces, you really can only go for so long.

email me if you have more questions...

Re: Not for Beginners

#13

Ditto what everyone else said

James Watriss

>I guess I'm probably one of the biggest culprits in here lately, with a recent chisel sharpening post. I threw a lot of numbers out, try this angel, try that angle, and the unwritten subtext should have been. "Here, start with this, then try that, and keep experimenting."

That said, had he not been able to come in here and say "I was sharpening at 27 degrees, and the blade folds when I try to cut oak," I wouldn't have been able to say "Well, 27 degrees is too thin for oak."

All measuring systems are inherently arbitrary, but consistent, agreed upon systems to describe a given dimension. Story sticks and curve cutting patterns and the like are inherently more accurate, and easier to use, because there's no math involved. "Measure twice, cut once," is probably a saying that's born o the use of rulers. Story sticks, either you hit the funny mark, or you didn't.

But it's hard to describe a story stick length in here.

Re: Not for Beginners

#14

Go ahead, James, give it a try....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Not for Beginners

#15

It's a smidge more than a good loaf of rye bread

James Watriss

>I guess what I SHOULD have said, is that it's hard to describe the length of the story stick, without using one of those universally agreed upon, but still arbitrary measurement systems.

There's really nothing galactically significant about inches, meters, french inches, or any other given unit. So once in a while, if I have something that just has to be evenly spaced... say, stretcher mortises, Or maybe an inlaid line that needs to be some random distance in from the edge... I'll grab a scrap of wood that looks to be about the right size, and use that to space my marks with. I had one guy at school ask me how far up those stretchers were, and I held up the scrap and said "about that far."

His response?

"yeah, but really... how far is that?"

So I made up a name for that unit of measurement. Surprisingly enough, none of his teachers had ever introduced him to such a unit as an Anglo-French Monkey Wangle.

Needless to say, I was honored to be there to inform and educate, and bring another poor soul out of the darkness of ignorance.

: )

Re: Not for Beginners

#16

Re: Not for Beginners

Charles

>The short answer is that to a whole lot of people woodworking consists of producing a pile of practice boards used in the process of tuning their tools to some absurd degree of perfection that they don't know what to do with once it has been achieved.

Re: Not for Beginners

#17

I certainly thought...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>that I would get a lot more grief on this post than I did, and I am pleasantly surprised. Also at the number of folks that took a look.

I did have the advantage of a fairly traditional apprenticeship learning from European trained craftsmen. I also had access to good information and guidance during my early years.

Those old terms need to be preserved, people need to know that something is shy, proud or flush, a joint that pinches a hair, a hand, a span, a cubit. A furlong, a chain, a rod, perch or pole.

How big is a story pole? How much is a pennyweight? A hundredweight? A Bushel, a Peck, a Gill? These are wonderful and very descriptive terms that puts things in historical context.

Stephen

Re: Not for Beginners

#18

Re: I certainly thought...

Larry Williams

>Well Stephen, I've been out of town. I don't have much problem with most of what you said but I believe you have one historic fact wrong. 150 years ago very few craftsmen had access to anything but common pitch planes or 47 1/2� in Great Britain. Traditional pitches in bench planes were compromised out of existence with the introduction of double irons. With the possible exception of a couple Slater infills, I've never seen a double iron plane at the steeper pitches other than a couple craftsman made planes. I believe the steeper pitch Slater planes I've seen were made from kits the company offered but I can't say for sure.

Re: Not for Beginners

#19

Re: purpose

paul womack

>I think my hobby is tool restoration and tuning; do you have an objection to that, Charles?

BugBear

Re: Not for Beginners

#20

Re: It's a smidge more than a good loaf of rye bre

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>One old term I remember from my teen years is an "RCH". Being a teenager, that one for some reason stuck with me and I've used it many times over the years.

Being the gentleman that I attempt to project here in this forum, if you are not familiar with the acronym, I must refrain from using the descriptive words of definition for fear of being blipped.

Marv