Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

Posts

Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#1

Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I was making a firewood rack, and I wanted to put two boards across the top in such a way that I could remove them (during knockdown) but would keep the legs from flexing out. I decided to try dovetailing these top rails onto the legs - the shape of the dovetail wouldn't let the legs bow out. They were pretty big, so I tried my LN Independence, but the wood pinched the blade (too thin of a kerf for this stuff). So, I grabbed my Disston panel rip saw, put the boards down on my saw bench and knocked out the cuts. It was surprisingly easier than I thought, even though cutting the angle of the pins was tough - it takes some work to get your body to doing things right.

On the downside, I was only using fir 2x4 material. I used 2x6s for the lower rails and i wanted to attach them to the legs with keyed M&Ts. I left over an inch of extra wood on the tenons but when I started to chop out the mortise for the keys, I split out everything to the end of the tenon. Sharpening didn't help at all. guess that wasn't good wood for that use.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#2

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can fin

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Stephen,

Did you clamp the tenon before chopping the mortice for the keys? I always put a clamp across narrower boards when I am choping the mortice to prevent chipping, which it does in most cases.

Stephen

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#3

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can fin

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen Kirk wrote:

------------------

They were pretty big, so I tried my LN Independence, but the wood pinched the blade (too thin of a kerf for this stuff).

------------------

I find that can be caused by not enough set. As the timbers get larger, the more set that is required, IME.

You could add a touch of set for that application, usually you should have enough depth with even a dovetail saw, which has about 1 3/4" of depth on the blade, but that will depend on the actual size of the joinery you're using. Some people don't like the idea of re-setting the saw to a larger kerf, but I suspect that might take care of your problem. The other choice is use your other saw for that type of application, it seemed to cut fine.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#4

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can fin

MikeW

>I suspect the wood was wooley enough for the fibers to grab the blade with the amount of set on a smaller saw. That and the amount of saw dust built up into the cut grabs the blade.

Main thing aside from the lesser set is the compacted saw dust that fills the gullets and pushes up into the kerf during the cut. A deep enough tenon saw with few enough teeth per inch and even with 3-4 thou of set per side and the problem wouldn't have made itself evident.

Using a panel saw on tenons is a time honored tradition. While I might start a cut on larger/deeper tenons (one with 9-10 ppi) with a larger tenon saw, I still finish it with a small (usually 18") panel saw. Tis how I was taught.

Chopping key holes in softwood tenons might be problematic. I would typically use a brace and bit to predrill the key holes out followed by paring cuts to take them to final shape. However, with softwood you might still knock the end of the tenon out tightening the key upon assembly unless you leave quite a bit of length to the tenon beyond the key or put a cross dowel through the tenon just to the outside of the key through the width of the tenon.

Take care, Mike

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#5

I agree - Big saws rock!

Hank Knight

>I made a stand for LOML's garden composter last weekend out of 4X4 pressure treated pine. I cut the lap joints with a big old Disston 6PPI rip saw. Worked great.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#6

Re: TMT on pine or fir 2x4's

James Davis

>Because pine or fir boards are normally straight grain you need to try and place this tenon were there are knots for more strength and with more length area on the end of the tenon say 4" to 6" of extra board or just use a hard wood like oak. When you work on your tenons if are you going through the face of the board with a vertical key try to use a tapered peg or wedge with about a 6 to 10 degree taper and on the mortise hole try to file it or put a convex curve on both sides this will help with keeping the wood for splinting out. When going through the top with a tusk key make sure to cut the front side of the mortise at a angle taper as well. In either case make sure you predrill the mortise before you just start chopping them out. Doing that in oak or any other hard wood is just fine but in soft woods like pine or fir on a inside mortise can spell disaster. However when doing the tenons I just use a saw for the shoulders and chop the rest out with a chisel along with parring them flat instead of going to a wood plane. JD


img

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#7

Re: TMT on pine or fir 2x4's

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Neat. Kind of hard to see in the pic, but that looks like a nice knockdown stand for your planer. That's pretty cool.

I'll keep these tips in mind when I try this again.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#8

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can fin

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>We actually had drilled them, but just paring back to the line split it out. I even freshly sharpened the chisels which helped a little, but not enough.

I think I'd just have to strengthen up the wood behind, perhaps with a dowel through it.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#9

Re: I agree - Big saws rock!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Yeah, cutting big joints with a big saw is just satisfying, somehow.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#10

Re: TMT on pine or fir 2x4's

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Looks to me to be a spring pole lathe. Could you post a bigger pic of it James, and tell us the story behind it?

T.O.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#11

Caution...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>"I made a stand for LOML's garden composter last weekend out of 4X4 pressure treated pine"

I was under the impression that PT lumber shouldn't be used in this application. The chemicals in the lumber would contaminate the compost ewwww...

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#12

My findings...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I feel the LN DT saw looses it at anything over 1.5" Too many teeth in the wood to cut effenctly. This is where a big back saw comes in very handy.

Re: Cut dovetails with the biggest saw you can find

#13

Re: Caution...

Hank Knight

>Scott,

I didn't think of that. The composter is one of those modern 'lectric ones made of insulated plastic with a motirized stirrer. It catches the compost and the liquor in a plastic bin. I think the bad stuff in the PT pine will be sufficiently isolated that it won't bother the compost. But I'll keep an eye on it to make sure. Thanks for the heads-up.

Hank.