Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Using the Great Big Blade

Posts

Using the Great Big Blade

#1

Using the Great Big Blade

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I would like to thank Mr. Watriss for his post below on the Spokeshave thread for his wonderful and insightful discussion about the under-appreciated tool, the great big blade, the Drawknife.

I have seen people who know how to use these tools use them like masters bow a Strad and it is a sight to behold. While I am not sure I approach their talent I do consider myself proficient at using the drawknife.

It can be undaunting to remove so much wood at one time but when you get a feel for this fine tool it will increase your confidence and reduce your rough out time.

Bevel up, bevel down, works both ways depending on the grain.

How many use drawknives and what are your techniques?

Stephen

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#2

I have noticed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>the difference in my body language and even state of mind when using a drawknife for roughing out and for smoothing.

Roughing: short, choppy strokes, occasional karate grunts, a rather abrupt state of mind. The correct music would probably be punk rock, but certainly something jangly.

Smoothing: long, rather gentle strokes, slow movements, often a good deal of skew. Correct music: one of the more lilting classical pieces.

I don't play music in the shop, so the music in question is in my head rather than actually playing.

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#3

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I have a drawknife in the cupboard, that came from my grandfather's place, after he died. It scares the heck out of me, so I've never sharpened it. It seems a tool for working green wood, which is something in short supply in my world, and so I'll keep it for later. Well away from the curious hands of MY grandchildren for now.

But I'm glad I have that, and many other tools that came from there, but are hard to use frequently in suburbia.

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#4

In search of the "Great Small Blade"...

Alan DuBoff located in NorCal

>Stephen,

I have been so frustrated with drawknifes, as I can't seem to find what I'm looking for. Tons of nice vintage drawknifes around also, but I have never found exactly what I'm looking for. I have a decent perfect handle drawknife, it's ok, but too big. I have a decent 8" english drawknife, it's so-so.

I have a few different knifes, but all seem to be too big, even the 8" blades seem quite a bit bigger than I envision in my mind, and I started to make a few different styles. All of the ones I can see working are very small blades, 2" - 4" with small handles, for finer work I would want to do, like tool handles. I like non-round handles with soft edges.

I was also thinking that a small drawknife as I describe could be good for saw handles also, but I don't have one small enough to test that theory. I seem to resort to using a shave, mostly an old 151, but I have a couple others.

2 distinct cuts I find myself doing with the drawknife, the first is a much stronger attack, with a steeper approach into the wood, trying to hog off material. The other is in pulling the blade along the surface and working a very small spectrum to take smaller shavings from the top surface, and this action is well suited for a shave. The later is one I would like the small drawknife for. I just haven't found the right one yet for the work I have in mind.

At one of the smithys I frequent occasionally, we use a small aprox 5"-6" drawknife that was made from a old farrier's rasp, it works pretty good, for knife and tool handles, and to date is one of the better ones. Still I have wanted one smaller. Here's a pic of it at the first link, and another that is a little bit smaller which is not finished, but it is about 5" as you can see in the picture, also made out of an old farrier's rasp.

http://softorchestra.com/smithy/ardenwood/drawknife.jpg

http://softorchestra.com/images/drawknife.jpg

This also got me to thinking about something even smaller, and I made this one out of an old coil spring, but it is not done either. All of this has been work in progress to try to create a tool that I can see as being useful, one that is not readily available or that was made by any previous toolmakers. Kinda like a small blade with extended handles, a mini-drawknife. But this is not it yet...*wink*

http://softorchestra.com/images/smaller-drawknife.jpg

I think I would like a wider blade on this last one, and still shorter yet. I think 2" - 2.5" will be good, about the length of a plane iron.

I also tried to forge some old thickness planer blades from an old 24" Oliver thickness planer. Unfortunately that idea didn't work out very well and I discovered that forging HSS steel is NOT easy...and it was cracking and slivers were flying around the smithy, finally I gave up and resorted to some 5160 which is fairly common junkyard tool steel.

I saw someone mention a drawknife digging in and cutting past the line, and it seems to me when I get that, the drawknife is not sharp enough, and I keep trying to get some bite, which eventually really grabs and digs in past the line...uncontrollably...like all edge tools, drawknifes really need to be sharp, IMO, and you can really fudge a piece of work up quick if not...at least I can.

I'm still on the quest for the perfect mini-drawknife for what I can envision in my mind, haven't got it crafted though...*sheepish grin*


img

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#5

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I just had to say something in this thread. The draw knife is my favorite tool. Your subject line reminded me of my "Great Big Blade". It's a Snow & Nealley with a 14" blade. It's also a thick blade. This knife doesn't come out of the cupboard very often, but when I get stuff that didn't split very nicely & has a lot of material that needs to be removed, I clamp it in the leg vise and have at it with Mr. Gazunga, on the skew. It's hard for the wood to say "no" to this Bangor Bad Boy.

Generally draw knives lend themselves to wholesale wood removal, but as has been pointed out, they are capable of some of the finer work as well. I have an old 8" one that has had the blade ground way down. I reserve this old guy for tight curves, such as the divots on the sides of shield shaped Windsor chair seats. The combination of bevel down and the short length of the blade behind the cutting edge lends itself to good control on cuts in concave geometry. This knife is the one that started me thinking about antique tools as a scarce remnant of the past. Tools get used up as they are put through their paces and I try to use this one gently.

greg

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#6

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Stephen,

I find myself using mostly smaller drawknives, 6" to 8" blades. I find I have more control and power if I keep my elbows tucked close to my sides. I almost always use my drawknives bevel down, but then I sharpen with little back bevel.

As everyone else has mentioned, the tool must be sharp. When hogging off a lot of material, I try to use as much of a slicing action as possible. Another technique that helps in hogging is to chamfer both edges to the proper depth then use the edges for a depth gage and remove the material in the middle. This also reduces the width of the cut you remove with each stroke, so you can increase the depth of cut.

For fine work where the body of a spokeshave would get in the way, there are 4" drawknives with black, round handles that were made by C E Jennings (I think) that I find to work really well.

Jim

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#7

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

TiO

>Count me in as a drawknife fan. Bevel up and bevel down both work for me. If one doesn't feel right I switch to the other.

How do you replace a handle on a drawknife? In particular, what do you do with the sharp tang end? I assume they've been peened over and so some type of reconstruction is necessary before the new handle can be cinched down. Do you regrind a new tapered point that can be repeened? I'd probably know the answer if I went ahead and tried it, but I always like to ask questions first.

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#8

Re: Drawknives and what I've learned about them

Dave Mount

>Compared to others in this thread, I suspect my drawknife experience is more limited, but I thought I'd post a few things that might help other rookies move up the curve faster than I did.

It's clear that, just as in the spokeshave thread, what you do with the tools greatly influences your preferences. I come from the perspective of getting into green woodworking, and I'm usually working on a shaving horse.

I have two main drawknives that I use, both 10". One is an older Witherby with a curved blade and cranked handles (the handles point downward when the blade is held level with the bevel up). The other is a not-as-old Greenlee with a straight blade and handles in the same plane as the blade.

I'm "bi" when it comes to bevel up or bevel down -- depends on what I'm doing. When I'm reducing rivings into straight blanks, I work bevel up. If I'm making cuts that are not strictly parallel to the grain (e.g., an inside curve, or shaping the outside of a hewn bowl), I work bevel down.

When I first got my drawknives I noticed the difference in their handle orientation, but I didn't appreciate the significance of it, and I hadn't seen anything about it in the reading I did (or if I did, it didn't sink in). But once I started using the knives, the difference became clear. Used bevel up, the Witherby, with it's cranked handles, presents its handles in a very comfortable position, angled downward. If I use the Greenlee in the same way, the handles are pointed right at me, which is not comfortable -- you have to hold the handles much tighter to apply the same force to the cut. If I flip both knives to the bevel down configuration, the situation is reversed, and the Greenlee (straight handles) are pointed comfortably downward and the Witherby's are more pointed at me. So now I keep both by me and choose between them primarily based on whether I'm working bevel up or bevel down (or, of course, which one's sharper if one is getting dull. . .).

The difference between curved and straight blades is a horse apiece as far as I'm concerned. I like the feel of the curved blades a little more when I'm using them, but the straight blades are easier to sharpen. Pick your poison.

Perhaps it's because I do a lot of work bevel up, but I think it makes a huge difference to put a slight rounded backbevel on a drawknife. It makes it much more controllable, and it makes sense when you consider how the angle of the hands are used to steer a drawknife. Because a backbevel increases the overall bevel angle, this also argues for a lower angle on the primary grind. I think Dunbar recommends 20 degrees for the primary bevel, plus a small backbevel. I don't think many drawknives come with a bevel this low -- mine sure didn't.

I haven't done much with drawknives in dry wood, I generally use spokeshaves for that. I have a feeling working in dry wood might alter my opinions about several things regarding drawknives.

Best,

Dave

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#9

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

Ron in Kokomo

>I like to make chairs and stools. So I use three different drawknives.

If you want to really be wowed.. watch a guy like Brian Boggs use a drawknife. Amazing!

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#10

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

David Miller from Iowa

>Like several other posters, I am a big fan of the drawknife and I have...well, many more than I actually use. When "newbies" come to the shop I put a 1x6 piece of clear pine in the vise and, with a sharp blade, a good skewing action and using the grain, I can take 3+ inches off at a time - doing this makes really cool shavings that my kids used to use for art projects.

That said, I rarely try finesse cuts unless the tool has a depth gauge (i.e., is a spokeshave).

Ebay ruined antique stores and flea markets for finding planes, but I can still find all the braces, hand saws and drawknives I want in the wild.

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#11

"Duuude... Mister Watriss is my FATHER."

James Watriss

>"Mr. Watriss?" Man, I'm only 33...


I think everyone has pretty much covered the basics already. Bear in mind that some drawknives have their handles oriented for bevel up work, adn some for bevel down... one of you guys seems to have figured this out already, but it is the way they're made. The backbevel, or knife grind sharpening method is great for bevel up drawknives, to help keep the knife controllable, so it doesn't just dive right in uncontrollably.

Note... this also works very well on the wooden bodied/bevel up spokeshaves. The gospel according to Boggs, passed on through me. A wooden spokeshave is basically a drawknife with a depth control. Without the backbevel, the wood will keep you from diving in too far, but the blade will still keep the body snugged up to the work as it tries to dive in. As a result, it's hard sometimes on a curved surface to exit cleanly. Not all the time, but sometimes. I've noticed my woodie takes much thicker shavings in the center than it does on the ends, and I have a feeling that's why. I've dubbed the edge a bit, but because I have so many other shaves in the tool chest, I don't use the wooden one for finishing much. I have a feeling that one day soon I'll have the time to tinker with the blade, and find out for final and for sure that the wooden spokeshave is a much cooler tool than I've given it credit for to date. (And I already think it's pretty cool.)

Another thing to keep in mind... the tangs for the handles are often much softer, so you can bend them a little bit if the handles are out of whack in one direction or another.

With this in mind, someone mentioned new handles... I would think the tangs would be pretty easy to work. I'd almost be tempted to try to burn them in like you would with a chisel handle. If push comes to shove, I'd file em back until you got the caps off and either peen em over when the caps were reinstalled, or maybe even put threads on the tang, and use that to hold the cap on. or braze the caps back on. Or, go for pure unction and function, and use 5 minute epoxy.

As for me, I have an old witherby that I got in an antiques shop in Corning New York, that is stamped by former owners... the NYC RR Co. My first drawknife was actually a Pfeil/swiss with bulbous handles, which seems a very close cousin to an old Pexto I picked up on the Bay. I use em when I can... I'm trying to weed through all the stupid little piss ant jobs around the shop so I can get into some chair making again, and play with those tools some more. I really can't wait.

Oh, and for the record... if they're well sharpened, to an appropriate pitch, drawknives work just as well on furniture grade hardwood, so or those of you who really feel froggy, I'd say give a drawknife a whirl next time you're roughing out a cabriole leg. They do have a well earned reputation in greenwood... and a lot of chair making used to be done in greenwood... but that doesn't mean that a good sharp tool doesn't have a well earned place when you're doing other work, as well.

And a last thought that just occurred to me:

I remember years ago when I thought these things were holy terrors. I took a look at the handles, my mind did the math, and it looked to me like you were supposed to just grab a hold and yank the thing so hard you'd sever your lower GI tract. Ugh! I'm happy to report to the unconverted that this is not, in fact, the case. With a board in your vise, pointed more or less at your sternum, and with the blade held at a shearing angle, there's so much more to that tool than meets the eye.

So many of our edge tools are basically variations on the same theme. A straight edge, with a back and a bevel. But it's so easy to get bogged down in planing, chopping, and paring. A little bit of a backbevel on a drawknife gives you something you can actually steer through the wood, and it's more intuitive and dynamic than you'd think. These scary-looking tools evolved into their historical form for a reason. A good long blade gives you something that you can use for a combination shearing, SLICING cut... something it's hard to do effectively with most other tools. You can do it a little bit with a plane, but the rest of the plane does so much to control the blade that it's really a wholly different sensation.

Brian Boggs really messed me up. I've sat through his lectures, and listened to him talk about the physics of curl formation, and how as the chip forms, the surface of the wood actually compresses forward a little bit, so a good sharp 'knife will make a curl that, as it forms, actually supports the wood ahead of the tool, preventing tear-out. It's hard to explain in prose, and only moderately easier to explain in diagram form. But it made sense. I took his class after graduating the 2 year program at NBSS, and he really gave me a whole new appreciation for edge geometry as it relates to woodworking, and how the wood reacts. I listened to his lectures on why he designed his shave horse the way he did, and why he designs chairs the way he does... I've been a convert to woodworking for years, and he really opened my eyes... again.

I was up at Lie-Nielsen not too long afterwards, and had the pleasure of meeting Chris Schwartz and Thomas Lie-Nielsen. Brian Boggs came up in conversation. I mentioned the class, and how much fun it was, and how much I learned. They both looked at me, and at each other, and said "Yeah. He's pretty much the smartest guy we know."

I can't stress enough, for those of you who have been reluctant. Give the drawknife a try. Play around with tuning it up, and with back beveling it a little bit to give you more control. Play with skewed cuts. Don't jerk the knife towards you. If it's sharp, and the edge is properly shaped, you should be able to slide it pretty gracefully along the wood, and make curls. And you should be able to steer it in and out of the wood, hogging off wood with an action that's half cutting, and half splitting. Grab a 2x4, grab a scrap of something, and play. Go for straight, go for curves. Make a mess, and see what this tool can really do, and see for yourself that it's really not for Seppuku. And it'll give you a whole new respect for what a plain, sharp edge can really do.

There's so much more to working wood than flat, straight, and dovetails.

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#12

Darrell in Oakville

Re: drawknives

Darrell in Oakville

>Jim pretty much says it all...

I had a bunch of woodworkers (local WW club members) over to my shop recently for a hands-on night with hand tools. Most of these guys know hand tools exist but they aren't really *into* them. I opened some eyes when I showed them how a drawknife works. You're right about the Fear of the Vicious Tool, Jim. Once I showed them how to skew the tool and peel off shavings with a slicing action, a whole lot of lights came on. They all gave it a try, and managed to reduce a hunk of air dried ash to shavings in short order.

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#13

Re: drawknives

Bob Hackett

>I am presently caretaking more than my fair share of these handy beasts.I don`t know if it`s a case of me adopting them or the other way round.

They range from a small "carvers drawknife" with egg shaped handles to a real rough and tumble monster made from an old planer blade that was used as a bark spud prior to comin` my way.I also have a mint Greenlee with folding handles still in the box.I found that the folding handle sort only make sense if they`re the type that DON`T fold to protect the edge.That way you can fine adjust the angle of attack of the edge while still havin the handles in your favored position.

For awhile Gordon and the folks at the dump used to save all the rusted up,no handled ones for me and drop em on me 1/2 dozen at a time.Said I was the only person they knew who was crazy enough to try and fix em once they got that bad.

BTW-a coin makes a good backer when you`re installin new handles.Just center it over the end of a pipe and hit it with a ball peen hammer to give it enough dish.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

#14

Re: Using the Great Big Blade

DCharles

>Has anyone found that draw knives vary in the hardness of their cutting edge? Of four I have picked up recently a Greenlee and a Sargent could be sharpened with a file, whereas a Swan and a Witherby have laminated edges of harder steel that can't be sharpened with a file. Any reason for the difference - are they for different uses (perhaps green wood vs dry wood)?