Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

Posts

What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

#1

What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Similar to the post below on L-N paring chisels but, on an older very wide and thin pre-cyro paring chisel (perhaps a Sorby), what is a good angle to try? Larry Williams in his video says, "An acute angle". Mr. Webster says anything less than 90 degrees is acute.

I tried something less than 20 degrees and it wouldn't cut anything. I will use it to trim off the proud portions of dovetails in walnut and other hardwoods.

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

#2

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

Dean J in MN

>L. Lee says in summary -- as low an angle consistent with edge retention. So, if you had edge failure at 20, a bit higher. Repeat until they hold an edge as long as you are comfortable. Anything else is just a guess for your wood, steel, use habits, etc.

-Dean

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

#3

One data point

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Doug,

I use 25 degrees (+ or -) with my Japanese chisels. Why? Because I freehand sharpen, and my hands know where 25 is. And it's a comfortable angle for lots of blades and lots of purposes.

Wiley

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

#4

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Doug

As Dean reported of Leonard Lee - in theory as low as the steel will manage without either chipping or failing in some way.

This is lower for O1 (20-25 degrees on average) than for A2 (minimum recommended is 30 degrees).

In practice my (O1 or similar) Bergs are 20 degrees and they hold up well in hardwood. These chisels are only ever pushed, never struck, so the forces on the edge are lower than if I were using them like mortice chisels.

The Blue Spruce detail/paring chisels are A2 steel and ground at 30 degrees. They hold and maintain a very sharp edge. So as low a bevel as possible is not necessary to pare endgrain.

The reason I decided to (with some trepidations) get A2 chisels was because most of my Japanese chisels are honed at 30 degrees and are sharp, sharp, sharp! The Iyoroi bench chisels are 30 degrees while the slicks/paring chisels are 25 degrees. The Koyamaichi dovetail chisels, which are struck through hardwood endgrain, are 30 degrees. Why higher angles here since they are HCS? Probably because the cutting edge is a thin layer of very hard and brittle steel (supported by a softer shock-absorbing layer).

Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

#5

Re: What is an acute angle for a paring chisel?

David Charlesworth

>I like to grind my chisels fairly low and then adjust the honing and polishing angle to suit the work and timber. I keep these two bevels very narrow so it is quick to change them, and this can often be done on coarse stone only.

In general I feel that very sharp i.e. well polished, bevel and back, is more important than angle.

My Japanese paring chisels are polished at 32 deg and my L-N at 33 deg. These angles are a guide for medium to dense hardwoods. Japanese craftsmen workinging in softwood might polish at 27 degrees or lower. It is interesting that so many old texts suggest very low angles for cast steel chisels, I wonder what timbers they were working.

best wishes,

David