Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

In praise of LV spokeshaves

Posts

In praise of LV spokeshaves

#1

In praise of LV spokeshaves

Dave Mount

>Just finished shaping the legs and rungs for 4 ladderback bar stools. These parts were rough worked green last spring and I'm just now getting around to finishing them off.

Every time I use my set of LV spokeshaves I just marvel at them. I have several vintage Stanley shaves which I use primarily for green wood, but when it comes to finishing dry wood, they just aren't even in the same universe as the LV shaves. In fact, I generally don't use the LV shaves on green wood because their mouth is so tight it's hard to really hog off wood. But when that wood is dry, and for finish work, they are just fantastic. When working from octagons down to rounds as I was here, I set the straight shave for a more aggressive cut and get close. The concave shave is set for a fine cut and is used for the final shaping. Used this way, the concave shave will naturally kind of slide arond and find and remove the high spots (as in ridges). I really don't see the need for a special radius scraper after this, you can get the so close with just the shaves. Maybe my standards just aren't set that high. For this project, the convex shave is only used on a couple inside curves on the bent rear posts, but does a great job too.

I got my set of three shaves when the concave came on the market and LV was selling the set of three for something like $150 USD. One of the best values I've ever gotten with respect to what I paid compared to the superior performance I've gotten from the tool. To be fair, I've never used any other high end modern shaves, but it's hard for me to imagine how they could be much better.

No affiliation, just a very pleased owner.

Best,

Dave


img

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#2

Useful testimonial, Dave

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>I've got (I blush, but hey, they were mostly $1 each) about six spokeshaves, mostly Stanley with one (ugly alert) bright green Kunz and a no-name light shave. As I prepare my wish list for the money from my consulting gig, I've been contemplating the set of LV shaves and wondering if they'd be redundant. Sounds like not.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#3

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

> One of the best values I've ever gotten with respect to what I paid compared to the superior performance I've gotten from the tool

At that Dave in my opinion is the whole crux of the matter. In this day an age of high priced junk, getting something that is actually worth our dollars[which equates into our Time/Lives, as we trade our Time/Lives for dollars] is so rare that when it finally happens we just cannot get over it. Now, tell the truth, did you feel when you first got them that they where over-priced, but got them anyhow?

Those stool parts are looking nice, make sure to show us the completed product. Are these a commission set or own use? Perhaps a snowshoe web seat?

T.O.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#4

Re: They are really pretty sweet

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I don't use mine as much as I'd like, but they are a real upgrade from the yard sale variety, usually. I have the Low Angle, the straight and the convex shaves, and would think that a few more would do me well, were I able to get to the shop more frequently right now. A couple of built myself tools would be pretty nice to have in the shrine.

Off into the pending rain to help LOML with a swim team project...

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#5

I'm kinda the oppsite...

Scott Burr in fridgid Ben Lomond, CA

>I use the LV for the heavy work (without the shims installed) then finish up with LN Bogg's. The LN's have a very fine mouth and take exquisite shavings.

Both are fine shaves and do a great job IMHO.

Oh Yea, nice spindel work and a good pile of shavings too!

Let us see the stools when their complete OK.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#6

Nice fruit from your labor!

Alan DuBoff

>Stools look good so far! Not that I'm checking out your stools, but you were showing...(that sounds odd;-)

I want to make a shaving horse, and have been thinking to incorporate both a shaving and stitching horse in one.

Are you going to weave the seats?

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#7

Not redundant at all...

Scott Burr in fridgid Ben Lomond, CA

>As Glenn stated these are a giant step above yard sale finds. Use the old for heavey/rough work and use the LV (with the shims) for fine work.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#8

Shave comparison

Walt Turpening

>Nice work. I had on my Christmas list a LN 4 1/2 plane and an LN Boggs flat shave. Alternate on the list was the LV shave. My super wife got me both the LN tools.

As a chairmaker making my own designs I use shaves to shape the ends of bench, stool and chair legs and shape most of the arms on arm chairs, rockers and settles. I use my Stanley 151 or 53 to hogg most of the shapes then finish shaping with the Boggs shave. I have an older Veritas Boggs concave shave that is smaller than the LN versions. I prefer the LN Boggs better for my large hands.

The Stanley 151 is a good workhorse and is nicely improved with a Hock blade. The thicker blade closes the mouth a bit. I have used the 151's for about 25 years of that time 10 years making chairs professioinally. Keeping them sharp and tuned is no different than your other edged tools.

The Stanley 53 is an old discontinued one that has an adjustable mouth that was found on a Stanley tool listing. It is ok but blades are hard to find.

A LN Boggs round bottom is on the list for next year.

Walt T.

Benches, Stools and Chairs

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#9

Re: Thanks and plans for seat

Dave Mount

>Thanks for the kind words. Making a bunch of round sticks is not much of an accomplishment though. . .

In answer to some of the questions:

These are keepers not commissions. SWMBO has (understandably) grown tired of the Borg stools we currently have at the kitchen bar. It's hard to imagine finding someone who would be willing to pay what these chairs would cost if I would try to pay myself a decent wage. There's a lot of parts to make and they aren't that fancy. I think to make money selling chairs you not only need to be very fast, but you need to make "fancier" chairs that seem less ordinary and more worth the price of a hand made piece.

With regard to the seating, I'd prefer hickory bark, but SWMBO doesn't want that. I guess it will be fiber rush instead, similar to the pic below, which is a seat from a previous set of chairs.

Best,

Dave


img

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#10

Re: First frame-up

Dave Mount

>Chairs are less intuitive than regular flatwork (for me, anyway), so I push one chair all the way through to a finished frame before making any holes in the rest of the parts. It's less efficient, but there's so much work in the parts, I'd be really angry if I did them all at once and screwed something up. So, today I framed one up, shown below. The back splats are just hardboard patterns so I could get a sense for how it'll look. These patterns are too short and consequently don't give enough sag to the back, I'll have to make a longer set. The real ones will be QS oak from the same tree, but the stock for those is still in the freezer. Because the splats are easiest worked and bent green, I rive out blanks when I have the green log, then put them in the chest freezer until I'm ready to work them. Not only will SWMBO be pleased to get have the stools, but I'll get bonus points for freeing up freezer space.

As it sits it looks awfully busy, like something a kid made from tinkertoys. I decided to go with a lot of rungs because the posts are parallel -- with no splay in the legs, it needs lots of joints to resist racking. When the seat is on, I think it will yield a different impression.

Best,

Dave


img

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#11

The Seat

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Make sure you put a good finish on the fiber rush so it will last.

The traditional finish is hide glue size followed by shellac.

I add some glycerin to the hide glue size to make it flexible, followed by shellac.

Stephen

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#12

Re: hide glue sizing

Dave Mount

>Hello Stephen--

The seat in the picture was finished with shellac only. I'd never heard of the hide glue sizing step, maybe I'll try that this time. I assume you thin it out pretty far?

Thanks for the tip.

Dave

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#13

Re: hide glue sizing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dave,

Shellac is a great finish for real cattail rush and is usually all that is needed. Fiber rush needs some help as it is twisted paper. The thinned out hide glue size (25% glue / 75% distilled water) and a few drops of glycerin, will strengthen and harden the fiber rush while at the same time keeping it flexible.

Makes it last much longer.

Stephen

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#14

Re: Freezing?

Eric in Los Gatos

>Hey Scott,

Up off Skyline where we have great view of BL it's 37 and dropping. We know from recent experience that it's not really freezing until the rain turns white and piles up in your driveway.

Eric, up on the ridge

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#15

38 degrees in Santa Rosa/Seb. today

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>Not cold by Minnesota or Maine standards, but that cold rain down the neck gets to the bone really fast. Got a fire going in our uninsulated house.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#16

And

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>LOML comments frequently that most chairs are made for people taller than her (5 foot nothing), so multiple rungs might be nice for folks of different leg lengths to have somewhere to rest their feet.

Looking forward to seeing the final chair.

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#17

Re: OR

Marv

>Short people can use the rungs like a ladder...

Marv

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#18

Re: Shave comparison

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>If you're in business, the business should be buying tools, not Santa super wife; unless, of course, you just like to pay more in taxes.

Pam

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#19

Re: First frame-up

Kevin Adams

>Hi Dave--

Those are going to be some good looking chairs! I built my first post and rung a few months ago in a class with Dave Fleming up in Canada. We used real rush (Dave harvests it himself), but for future chairs I'll probably use hickory or fiber rush. That was a great tip from Stephen on sizing the fiber with thinned hide glue. Have you ever tried sea grass before? That would be another option I might try.

What method do you use for installing the back slats--bend them in place or install them already bent/dry? I used the latter method, which obviously means that you have to follow a different order when assemblying the chair frame. I believe John Alexander and Drew Langsner bend them in place, whereas production chairmakers like Brian Boggs put them in dry. What size are your slat mortises--3/16" or a full 1/4"?

Thanks and please show us some more pics when you get them done.

Kevin

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#20

Re: Shave comparison

Alan DuBoff

>Walt,

Your reply gave me some comfort, I currently only have a few shaves, and a 151 is the one I primarily use. I also have another, that I picked up at a flea, but it doesn't have the dual adjuster like the 151, which I use and like.

I've been pondering if I should get the LN or LV shaves, and from your message I gather I would be fine with what I have and complimenting it with the LN shave(s).

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#21

Gotta remember to change my tag...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond, CA

>As the weather changes. ;^) It was a fun drive through the white stuff last week!

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#22

Nother option...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond, CA

>Put shelves on them to hold WW mags and catalogs.

Lookin good Dave!

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#23

Re: First frame-up

Dave Mount

>Hi Kevin--

I got started following Drew Langsner's book, so most of my techniques are rooted in his. The back splats are 3/16", as are the mortises. I bend them in place using the chair as the form. One down side to this is that you have to put wedges in the mortises to take up the gaps created when the splats dry and shrink. The ladderback chairs I've made are surprisingly comfortable. A while back I had a spell of back issues and the (regular size) ladderback chairs were by far the most comfortable chair for me to sit in (in fact, I'm sitting in one as I write this).

Best,

Dave

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#24

Re: First frame-up

Kevin Adams

>Hi Dave--

Thanks for your reply. I agree that these chairs are very comfortable (almost surprisingly so). I have made several Windsor and Welsh stick chairs and I've become very fond of the simplicity of the ladderback.

BTW, I had read both Alexander's and Langsner's books and thought about bending the slats in place like they do. When I took the class with Dave Fleming, he explained that most production chairmakers will install the slats already bent. This obviously means building the front and back sections first and then attaching the sides vs. the opposite way for Drew. Dave Fleming does all his drilling on a low bench (vertical vs. horizontal in a vice like JA and DL). He explained that it is quicker to make a chair this way and easier to put it together. In addition, we used 1/4" slats, which Dave said were more substantial than when you had to bend in place. Interestingly, he indicated that he agreed if you relied on wet/dry joinery (which we did--I didn't use any glue!), it was actually stronger the way Drew does due to the interlocking joints vs. stress direction (front-to-back has more stress than side-to-side). Hope this makes sense, but if not, let me know.

Good luck on the rest of the chairs. BTW, did you take a class or did you just follow along with Drew's book?

Kevin

Re: In praise of LV spokeshaves

#25

Re: First frame-up

Dave Mount

>I've never taken a class, I just self-taught using Langsner's book. I have to say that book was one of the best instructional woodworking books I've ever read -- I was completely new to green woodworking when I started my first set of ladderbacks and they came out quite nicely. At no point in the process did I feel unsure of what I was doing (though I was constantly checking back with the book as I went).

I finished framing the whole set of bar stools today. I did use Langsner's technique of interlocking the side and front/rear rungs by nicking part of the side rung when cutting the mortises for the front/rear rungs. It amazes me how strong the ladderback chairs are for how light they are. The finished chair can't weigh more than 4 or 5 pounds even with the seat material.

Best,

Dave