Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Mutt plane . . .

Posts

Mutt plane . . .

#1

Mutt plane . . .

steve mackay

>Finally had a few minutes to tear it down. Weeeeeeeeeeeell . . . Everything but the body is stamped. Adjuster knob, lat lever, frog. And whats written on it is just stamped in, not cast. Just " MADE IN USA " & theres a " 3 " stamped in what might be a circle, then " 11 " ( also in a circle ) behind the frog. Entire length is 9 1/4" x 2 1/4" and the iron is 1 3/4". Actually this is kinda nice 'cause I'll get some use out of a short #3. Any leads oh Great Ones ?


img

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#2

Re: Mutt plane . . .

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Everything but the body is stamped.

That thing is one step abobe garbage IMO. I'd put it back together and use it for a decoration/paperweight/neighbor loaner tool/parts donor in a crisis.

Who the fool was that thought those stamped sheetmetal frogs where I'll never know, but he sure wasn't thinking very clearly.

T.O.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#3

Re: Mutt plane . . .

Rob Brophy

>Hey Steve...is that a tin frog? Could be a 'Par-Plus' brand? or 'Diamond'? Dunno...just guessing here.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#4

Agreed, but . . .

steve mackay

>Christmas present from BIL so its here and here it stays and gets love'n. Just wanted to patronize him a bit with it's history if I could find it. Never know . . . the next one he drags in might be a #1. ( sigh )

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#5

Yup . . .

steve mackay

>tin or steel stamping. Your right . . . pretty chintzy.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#6

Re: Agreed, but . . .

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Yes Steve, you are correct in thinking, afterall, BIL didn't know any better, and he certainly meant well. Clean it up, sharpen it up, make some curlies, love it, and use it as a conversation piece with him to educate him on what's a good 'un and what's not. I'd hate to see him pay more then $1 for this kind of plane as they are certainly not worth much more then that.

T.O.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#7

Re: Yup . . .

Rob Brophy

>Don't get discouraged Steve, the next one he finds may be a gem.

If the opportunity presents itself, drag out a good plane and show him the 'features' of a quality tool..rosewood, brass etc. A little information can go a long way.

Rob...whose dear old Mum can now spot a Bedrock from ten paces

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#8

Re: Yup . . .

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>There is a point that I keep forgetting to mention about tools just such as these, and that is that you have to have the junkers around to truely appreciate the good quality ones. In other words, how can you appreciate beauty you don't have ugly to compare it too?

Too illustrate, to fully appreciate just how handsome I am, first look at Ernie.

HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! HA! HA! HA! Been a long time since I've given you a poke in the eye eh Ernie. :~)

T.O.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#9

Got the same problem

Bob Hackett

>My youngest dragged one just like it home and presented it to me for my birthday.

I plan on using the base as a start for a small infill with his help,a learning experience for us both.Along the way he gets to find out what a GOOD plane looks(and acts) like and maybe we`ll end up with something he will be proud to hand down to HIS youngest after I`m gone.

Wish I could be of more help with the brand but...

Mainely,Bob

Those stamped tin frogs sure are OOOGLY aren`t they(scarey too)

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#10

Who Pulled your Chain?

Ernie Miller

>I may resemble that remark but you don't have to pointit out. I have been playing in the shop but my tool will not be finished intome for the contest. But ohwell at least I got some shop time

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#11

To my ( small ) mind . . .

steve mackay

>, since Dad is a tool & die maker, I'd have thought the tooling to form the stamped-out frog would have been more than just casting them. I'm sure I'm wrong on some cosmic business cost/profit level but . . .

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#12

Re: Yup . . .

Tony Zaffuto

>Don't feel bad, I got one of those "Par-Plus" goomers in an opportunity box at an auction and I had to pay for it (really after the SW 5-1/4). Got it about 4 or 5 years ago and still haven't tossed it out. I've been toying with the idea of making some sort of infill out of the thing.

T.Z.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#13

Re: Who Pulled your Chain?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Sorry Ernie, I wasn't trying to "point out" anything thing. I was merely trying to gen up some good natured jabbing. Guess I missed the mark. Rest assured that it won't happen again. Humor is fast going out of my Life.

Good luck with your tool contest entry, I'm sure it'll be something for the others to contend with, and cause the judges much agony in trying to decide a winner.

Todd O.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#14

Re: To my ( small ) mind . . .

Marv

>Steve,

I bet if ya painted it John Deere green it'd look beautiful don'tcha think?

Marv

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#15

If saws, why not planes?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>Maybe we need to start a new trend, painting little farm scenes on the sides of planes, distract folks from messing up good Disstons. Some of these "engineered for low price without regard to usability" planes might be perfect.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#16

Ahhhhh, the rarest of rare planes . . .

steve mackay

>The John Deere Grand Detour Special Edition ! Closes out on Da' Bay for $ 3000.00 ! Then I could afford that #1 !

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#17

Thats what I'm think'n. Got plans ?

steve mackay

>

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#18

Re: Thats what I'm think'n. Got plans ?

Tony Zaffuto

>No plans, justbeen having the plane on a shelf staring at it. Don't feel it will be a difficult project except for the decision of whether to have an adjuster or not. As I said, I've had this plane for several years pondering what to do with it.

Since yours was a gift, if you are like me, you immediately get some sort of attachment (more or less depending upon the who the giver is) to the tool. I still have a few items that my now deceased Father gave me some 30 years ago (seems like yesterday).

For the life of me, I can't understand why a manufacturer would develop a plane like this and cheapen one aspect so much like the pressed-steel frog. Other parts of the plane are not all that bad.

When I get started I will post pictures of the Pickle-Puss, but that may not be for six months or years!

T.Z.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#19

Re: Got the same problem

Tony Z.

>To Bob and Steve,

This morning I dug out the ole' Pickle-Puss plane and disassembled it. Think I will have the inside of the body behind the mouth milled flat and perpendicular to the sole to start with and while I'm at it, will have the insides of the sides milled square. This will give me a good surface to mount my stuffing too. Shouldn't be too time consuming either (This won't directly cost me as I employ several machinists and tool makers). Haven't thought of how to do the front just yet.

T.Z.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#20

Found a couple sites . . .

steve mackay

>that show construction ( one with pretty good drawings ). 'Bout half of the articles deal with making the body ( dovetailing the metal, etc. ) wich won't have to worry about. Not that I'd be trying to get around pinning through the sides but the crazy thought occured to use the tote mount and screw to mount the infill. Or would that start defeating the point of infilling ? ( Just ideas bouncing around in an empty skull. )

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#21

Re: Found a couple sites . . .

Tony Zaffuto

>Well Steve,

I just came upstairs from the shop to sit and ponder the same issues about the Pickle-Puss. I thought the same about usung the tote hole, and I've come to the conclusion that it may not be the best idea. So, I'll cross-pin the stuffing. As I said earlier, I'm going to mill the inside of the body parallel to the sole and the insides of the sides square. Basically, I will mill the entire frog mounting surface level to the remainder of the insides.

All in all, this shouldn't be a difficult project to do. The plane body has quite a bit of heft to it--far more than a Stanley Handy-Man that I was comparing it to. Still can't imagine why this company decided to build a relatively decent plane with a crap, pressed-steel frog.

T.Z.

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#22

Before you mill

Bob Hackett

>you may want to look at the mouth blocks that most infill makers afix to the body.

Also,if you mill the inside of the body you`ll lose some of that weight that makes a difference to you now.Maybe better to bed the infill with epoxy,like matching a rife barrel to it`s stock.

One of the reasons Joe and I liked the wood screws holding the stuffing in was that we knew that with our combined luck we were bound to crack the cast iron while trying to peen the rods enough to make a seamless fit.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Mutt plane . . .

#23

Re: Before you mill

Tony Z.

>Points well taken. The Pickle-Puss plane has pretty large blocks in its castings. I may just remove the lugs and lightly touch the body to make the stuffing easier. I'm also toying with the idea to just mill a new frog and by-pass the infill stuffing.

T.Z.