Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sharpening Plane Irons

Posts

Sharpening Plane Irons

#1

Sharpening Plane Irons

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I am wondering how you all sharpen your molding plane irons? I use a flat stone for the back (the ruler trick doesn't work here) and slips for the curves.

I have encountered a couple of profiles for which I have no matching slip so I use a shaped piece of wood with sandpaper held to the profile of the wood .

The only problem areas I have are on the inside sides of beads or inside angles of moldings. Anyone else have this problem?

What are your methods?

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#2

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

Dean J in MN

>I use a flat stone for the back and slips or sandpaper glued to various dowel diameters to work the bevel. Can be slow going if you need to a lot of work to the edge shape, restoring a old plane for example. In that case I think the method Don M. shows in his video -- using a flex tool grinder -- while not traditional is a reasonable solution. However, for honing and re-sharpening I find the slips and dowel/sandpaper to work quite quickly.

-Dean

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#3

Fine jeweler`s files

Bob Hackett

>

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#4

Caution, this involves killing electrons

Neal in San Jose

>I have an old Dremel tool, and picked up some rubberized abrasive wheels in various shapes for it. That works VERY well on odd shapes like molding irons and hollow chisels for my hollow chisel mortiser. I got an assortment of the abrasive wheels on the 'bay for something like $10 plus shipping for 50 wheels. I'm still using the first ones, so I figure I have several lifetimes' worth. In the assortment there are wheels, points, tapered cones, etc. Just check out the 'bay for Cratex abrasives, or Google Cratex. I just tried Google, which took me right to their website, and a similar assortment is less than $50 if you don't want to go the Ebay route.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Cut the profile

Jim in Burlington On

>I try and cut the profile with the plane in soft clear pine. Then I load the profile up with green compound and polish away.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#6

Which video?

Tony - Memphis

>I have a couple of old molding planes I would like to get back in working order. Who's video is that you are referencing?

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#7

Re: Which video?

Dean J in MN

>Traditional Molding Techniques: The Basics

Don McConnell

C&W and Lie-Nielsen carry it.

-Dean

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#8

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

paul womack

>From memory, carefully honing moulding plane irons with slips was a job often given to apprentices, and woe betide the boy that didn't retain the profile. Time and care were the only "secrets".

Also from memory, one old catalogue listed (with its moulding planes) a service where the blade could be sent back to the maker for regrinding.

BugBear

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#9

Thanks!

Tony - Memphis

>

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#10

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use a set of three slip stones for concave irons. Coarse India, Fine India, and Arkansas. I would not want to be without the coarse slip stone. Even though the irons are laminated and somewhat soft behind the steel, it is too much work to do this with a fine slip only.

I do not have any planes with inside corners, and I don't think I would want any. I don't think one can get as crisp a corner on a molding with a complex molding plane as one can with separate planes. It is just too hard to get that perfect inside corner on the iron without wearing down the corner of the stone. The stone's corner would wear down faster.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#11

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

Bob Hackett

>Unless that corner was part of a fine diamond file.

Look on the dreaded ebay under jewelry or lapidary to find such beasts.

MB

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#12

Re: Cut the profile

ThomD

>That would work in some cases where the profile is simple, since the contour planed will come out tighter than the blade, but it won't work on all linked shapes. And it would require some "english" either way.

The big deal is that if you have made the plane yourself you have a pattern of the blade. If not you can make one either by projecting the profile to whatever the angle is. Or do it in CAD. If you have a pattern then you can always check for distortions.

Also choose stock carefully, and don't sweat it too much. They aren't 4/10ths finishing planes.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#13

Grinding Molding Plane Irons

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If there are 'mother planes' for making molding planes, are there 'mother plane iron grinders' for making molding plane irons?

Which came first the plane or the iron?

Stephen

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#14

I'd doubt it...

John in New Mexico

>But I'm no expert. I'd think the "Mother" wheel would wear far too quickly to make many identical irons. Much easier to cut/grind to a line in some layout dye.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#15

The plane comes/came first

Larry Williams

>The plane is the template for the iron. Install the iron and scribe the profile from the sole. Simple, direct and accurate. There's a reason old irons are usually numbered or marked in some way and that's because they were made to match a specific plane.

If I had a lot of free time, I'd like to watch someone do something like draw the iron with CAD, tilt it, print it and use that for a template. I don't see how this would possibly be any more accurate than scribing from the sole of the plane but I'm willing to bet it would take a lot longer. At one point I was getting pretty comfortable with my CAD program but it's been a while since I did much with it. Maybe my reluctance to even consider CAD as a good option is a reflection of my competence with CAD but I think scribing from the sole is a better way to do this.

Re: Sharpening Plane Irons

#16

Re: Cut the profile

James Watriss

>Just be sure to cut something a little shallower than the profile in the pine. Cutting the profile with the plane will give you a shape that matches the shape cut by the iron at the given bedding angle (50-somethign degrees, normally.) But when you hold the iron at the desired sharpening angle (30-ish degrees) they won't match up. A round profile you won't be able to get the points of the iron. A hollow you won't be able to get the very crown of the bit. So there's some fudging to be done here. For the round, you can move it around, and get the whole edge touched up, but for a hollow you'll need a wider channel so you can get the thing all the way in there. And once in a while, you'll still need your slip stones or a dowel and some really rough sandpaper to regrind.