Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Posts

Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#1

Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>And something tells me that I won't turn this into a day job :-)

This is a backsaw that I bought a long time ago at a LV tent sale. It was called a "dovetail saw" even though it is has crosscut teeth, and it was sold at half price because it had uneven tooth set. The saw comes from France (I wonder who manufactured it...). 16 TPI if I measured well.

Since the set was uneven, I "reset" the teeth with a small hammer on an anvil (is that a no-no?). Then on to jointing, setting, sharpening and whetting. The Stanley 42 is at the limit of how small teeth it can set, and the fine teeth make it hard to follow your work. I still don't need eyeglasses, but this pushes the limit of how small I can see. It would have been a lot easier to track the progress had I had some of that black spray Tom Law uses... A saw vise would have been nice too...

In the end the saw cuts better than ever, the set is perfect width wise (blade doesn't bind yet has no slop in the kerf), with just a hint of unevenness (or it may be the sharpening itself, I went by eye and switched hands when doing the second side, with nothing to guide me).

Quality of cut is a bit rough, but being the only western crosscut saw that I own I have nothing to compare to.

It was a fun and instructive exercise, Next time I'll try a saw with teeth I can easily see :-)

DC

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Sounds like you did great Denis. I've sharpened a couple saws and decided that was one job I will farm out.I was only capable of sharpening saws with large teeth. I can't see well enough to do anything but guess with backsaws of 12 tpi or more. I've heard that once you get the hang of(assuming you have good eyesight)it gets easier.---Jack

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#3

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today... *LINK*

Marv

>Denis,

Not bad for your first time. The proof of the pudding is always in the eating, right? In your case, the proof of the sharpening was in the sawing.

Generally speaking, bending saw teeth opposite of their set is a no-no. Larger teeth would probably break. The proper way to reduce over-set is to file the teeth until the set goes away or is reduced. But what the hey...the results is what counts.

When you file the other direction, you should turn the saw around, not change hands.

If you are serious about learning all about sharpening saws WC has Pete Taran's treatise posted in Articles. His is the best I've run across and easy to understand. I suggest, to reduce confusion, stick to following Petes instructions until you become well familiar with all the basics and have experienced some successes before taking advice from others who use different methods.

Marv


Sharpening for Beginners

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#4

If you don't have black sight, try these!

Alan DuBoff

>Denis,

Two things will work if you don't have the black sight which Tom Law recommends on his video.

1) black marks-a-lot. You can clean up the residue if any is left on the teeth with denatured alcohol.

2) candle. hold the blade and move it over the flame to blacken it from the soot of the candle. I like this method, although a bit messier, as it's more earthy.

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#5

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Peter Evans

>There is one point Pete Taran makes in passing, in the shaping section, and this I believe should be in bold type and repeated in a highlight box or something, it is ... (drum roll) ...

"... you need to look at each pair of teeth as you file, and slightly press the file toward the tooth with the larger flat."

This should also be repeated in the Filing section of his article, _especially_ for cross cut saws. If nothing else, helps avoiding the dreaded "cows and calves".

For us visually challenged old f***ts, magnification (experiment to find a type that works for you) makes a huge difference; I find the clip on (to your prescription glasses) variety works well, and makes it easy to get back to normal vision. Take a saw to the shop and try on different magnifications to ensure you retain adequate focal length.

Cheers, Peter in Sydney

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#6

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Marv

>Hi Peter,

Boy, you have that right! I totally agree... Preventing cows & calves or big-tooth, little-tooth syndrome is the most difficult aspect of hand sharpening handsaws, especially when filing crosscut teeth. Not nearly so much when filing rip teeth. Shaping is actually filing rip teeth both for rip and crosscut but with crosscut you take it a step farther and add the fleam or bevel angle after shaping. Even those who have sharpened for years will sometimes have the cows & calves problem.

Peter, what is your method of correcting this problem once it happens? It's a common ocurrance for anyone who has sharpened more than three crosscut saws. It's good that you emphesized the issue. A whole article could be written about it.

Marv

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

#7

Re: Well, sharpened my first saw today...

Peter Evans

>Marv

I don't have a solution except to walk away from the saw for a while to recover my equilibrium. The person who taught me to sharpen saws doesn't look at the saw as he sharpens, most of the time. Then again he has been doing it for a long time; me only a few years and after my sight went south.

I really stuffed up the first few inches of my mitre box saw. Luckily near the handle so I just left it. Thinking about it, I guess there would no alternative to jointing down quite a bit and starting again. What is your solution?

Cheers, Peter in wet Sydney