Folley Filer
ThomD
>Anyone out there using one of these to file their saws? I see them for sale in the usuall places, sometimes quite cheap. Lots of cool gears. Are they good for anyting? Can they cut saws as well?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Folley Filer
ThomD
>Anyone out there using one of these to file their saws? I see them for sale in the usuall places, sometimes quite cheap. Lots of cool gears. Are they good for anyting? Can they cut saws as well?
Re: Folley Filer *LINK*
Alan DuBoff
>Thom,
I have a Foley filer, but don't use it. I bought a bunch of Foley gear, you can get it cheap if you're patient, but the most useful piece to me is the retoother. In fact, I recently bought some ratchets so that I can pair some up with the Foley equipment I want to sell, using the ratchets as a leader. It's the ratchets that are the most valuable, and none of this stuff works without them.
I file my saws by hand, and I prefer that. The filer works better on larger teeth, and tends to have problems with the smaller ones used on the dovetail saws. I have a full set of ratchets for myself, the most valuable being the 16 ppi, since Foley doesn't sell those anymore. They do sell a 15ppi, but Foley gets $70/each for the ratchets...and I bought a few from them. 16 ppi is the smallest teeth they will do, but I think you can do higher if special ratchets were made, I think they can be milled fairly easily, just haven't had a need to find out. I am fine with 16 points myself, and about as fine as I like to file, but have files a couple at 20 points. I use 2.5x magnification for about 14 points and smaller.
I picked up a 2nd retoother, since that is the valuable piece to me. I bought it for $25, plus about another $25 for shipping. He was never used and still had the wire tag wrapped around it.
While this is not needed to make saws, it really helps a lot, and if you have never tried to shape teeth by hand, it takes patience. I can do it ok now by hand, but prefer the retoother, it works much better in it's crude Rube Goldberg style. All the Foley equipment is Rube Goldberg at it's best. It appears designed by a real galoot...
I would be interested in selling my filer possibly. Would toss in 3 or 4 ratchets, but in the larger sizes, and one carrier. With the carrier and ratchets you could find other Foley equipment *EASY* that they will work with, just check out ebay, few folks buy the stuff.
You can see the filer at the linky.
My Foley Equipment
I found some pics of the retoother *LINK*
Alan DuBoff
>Thom,
Check the linky to see the teeth the retoother cuts, I found some pics of an old Patterson 12" saw I re-toothed. This saw had a tooth line that looked like a roller coaster, you can barely see in one pic where I marked the blade with a black marker to joint it evenly.
This turned out to be a favorite saw of mine, it's fairly old as the maker was only in business from 1863-1866, and was located in San Francisco. Could be the only west coast saw I own...there wasn't many saw makers on the west coast. Wonderful saw, I think the plate is about .023" - .025", I mic'd it out once but can't remember exactly.
Retoothing a saw with the Foley retoother
Foley Saw Tools
David Miller from Iowa
>In the last place I lived (2000-2006) my neighbor across the back fence had a Foley set up from the 1950s maybe - all the jigs and ratchets and everything. He filed saws as a second income until he retired about 1990. I gave him a few saws that needed retoothed and they came back far better than I could do by hand - machine precision. Except on the first batch I gave him he wrote my name in big letters on blade with a vibrating engraving tool - he always worked for tradesmen, never collectors, and that was standard to keep them straight in his shop and the tradesmen liked their names on the saws on the jobsite. I put a stop to that pretty quick.
He came over to my shop a lot and would always pick out a saw and volunteer to tooth it. He wasn't a collector, but he knew his saws and would always grab my best ones. I had a huge Bishop Cincinatti rip saw (Bishop moved to Lawrenceburg in 1899) that had a broken tooth and he wanted to retooth it so I said sure. The blade was probably 9" wide at the handle. The next time I saw it, it was 5" wide at the handle. He said that early Bishops were brittle and he kept breaking the teeth with his electric powered Foley saw set, so he would just retooth it and start again. He probably spent 4 hours on the saw and thought he was doing me a favor, when he just ruined it.
I kept my mouth shut. Live and learn. His eyesight has gone bad and he doesn't use the thing. I offered to buy it and he is still thinking about it. I don't think he will part with the setup in this lifetime.
Bottom line is that Foleys are great when you need a to regulate a saw, but for sharpening just use a file. Foleys take off way too much metal unless you are retoothing to a different size tooth or grinding back to repair a broken tooth. If you are doing those two things Foleys are great, otherwise file it yourself or send it to someone who hand files.
David
Funny you mention the power setter...
Alan DuBoff
>David,
I was laughing hearing you talk about the power setter, because I was once going to use it and was having a hard time figurin' out if it was accurate or not, and ended up setting by hand. However, Leif Hansen of Norse Woodsmith, suggested the power setter is useful if you have to set a lot of saws at once. So, in a production type environment I guess it would be ok. I am not sure...I like to work on one saw at a time, to date, so only ever have one saw to set.*grin*
The Foley stuff is pretty nostalgic though, and even the manuals are a hoot, the ones I have remind me of Ward Cleaver of the "Leave it to Beaver" show during the 60s. Pics of guys wearing slacks while sharpening...they're a real kick...
I agree with you, I think most of this stuff is fairly useless with the exception of the retoother, it is worth it's weight in gold for anyone working with either new or old saws.
I'm told that Adria has their teeth cut on their blades with some modern laser/water process, which is supposed to be state of the art, but the Foley retoother seems to produce good results and is readily available on the used market cheap. Just buy some 1095 Spring Steel from McMaster-Carr and go to town.
What Foley did was sell a bunch of equipment and classes on how to use it, and the person would go into the sharpening business. Most folks did this on some type of credit program, as there is a lot of flyers with so called "discounts" and credit programs to either try-and-buy or get it now and pay next year...so Foley seemed to be good at marketing, and as such were successful in selling this stuff. They do sell some parts for the stuff and have been in business for many years, so they must do something right. It left a lot of these people to go out of business, since most of them were not business people, but trades people that did the actual sharpening. I believe why a lot of these folks failed...many people have made good professions out of it though, so there is some merit I 'spose.
It's really nostalgic equipment. The retoother is VERY handy if you're a saw maker, restorer, or just a user that likes to find and fix up saws on the cheap. I might use it today in fact...but will set, and sharpen by hand.*grin*