Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Core material for veneering--need help

Posts

Core material for veneering--need help

#1

Core material for veneering--need help

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi All,

I am planning a desk. The desktop will be veneered over its entirety--top, bottom, and edges--with approx. 3/32" thick veneer. I will need either a 5/8" thick or 3/4" thick core, to veneer over.

I don't want to use solid wood for the core, due to the likelihood of seasonal movement. Right now, I'm thinking either marine plywood or Baltic birch (B/BB grade) ply. I have read on SAPFM that mdf makes a good core. Any opinions/experience among you as to what would make a good core?

Looking for help from those who have done it, as I have never used veneer other than in small scale applications like banding and pictorial inlays.

Wiley

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#2

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Hi Wiley,

I'm in search of an answer too, as I will be doing a lot more veneering in the near future (gotta use that 1000 or so sf of veneer I have stashed...)

There is one craftsman in my area who does veneer a lot. He has a 5' x 10' heated hydraulic press, a vacuum veneer press (for curved work), a dedicated veneer power saw, a "sticher" to create large sheets from small veneers flitches, etc. And he works for high end customers exclusively. The members of our local association visited him a few times. Here's what I recall him saying about the choice of substrate...

Solid wood is out for him. He's doing woodworking for a living and doesn't want to have to deal with wood movement. Besides, some of his designs would not permit the use of solid wood.

MDF is out too, because in his experience it doesn't hold veneer strongly enough. He's has instances where after the glue dried he could pull the veneer off like is was masking tape. Seems that the MDF is too smooth and kind of waxy on the surface.

Baltic birch he'd love to use. But in his experience it has become near impossible to get sheets that are flat and remain that way.

So his material of choice is... Sit down first... Particleboard...

In his experience, the material is just rough enough (almost as if the surface was done by a toothing plane, that's my interpretation here), it is dead flat and will remain that way if well supported, and the bottom line for him is that he's never had any returns. He does not use the big box PB though, he orders it from outlets that cater to professionals.

Somehow the thought of making fine furniture based on a particle board core repels me, so that's why I'm interested to hear what others have to say...

HTH,

DC

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#3

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>It is hard to believe anybody would use anything but solid wood core and call the product period furniture. I think anybody who has restored damaged furniture would be repulsed by the thought of trying to repair something that was made of plywood or particleboard or mdf. It sounds like once its damaged you just put it out at the curb and buy something else.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#4

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Pretty much agree with you Warren...

Something I don't know, and have been a bit shy about asking, what kind of substrate did Ruhlmann and other past masters use?

DC

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#5

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

ThomD

>I used to have a press that we did about a 100 square foot at a time on.

Anywho. The one thing that stands out to me about your question is that your veneer is on the thick side, nearly what Krenov called "real veneer". If you were using standard veneer flitches which are paper thin, then using a dimensionally stable substrate would be fine. You can without a doubt do it anyway, but don't completely discount that he wood may have a life of it's own. If you were to choose a solid wood material for your substrate that has similar movement characteristics to your veneer, it shouldn't give you any problems that a solid wood board wouldn't give you, and I thought we knew how to handle those. Of course some veneer designs depend on the stability of plywood to be viable, in which case you are back to the plywood.

Baltic birch is wonderful stuff, and I love to use it. It is stable enough to make clock movements out of so you shouldn't find it a problem for your use.

Marine ply is a far wider catagory. You have the north american stuff made out of D-Fir, if you can find it, not suitable, as a first choice. You have a variety of comodity grade product made out of various wood. Some are light and chippy like ocume, would work. Some are oily. Some like Meranti, very heavy and solid.

There is nice stuff out there that is incredibly cheap, and is an exterior grade of marine ply. Usually just as nice (though grade wise it doesn't have to be). The glue is often the same as the glue used in Marine ply, though by standard it doesn't need to be as heavily applied. It gets used in lots of boat projects and would suit any interior job also. With this kind of stuff, it often comes down to what you can get. Unless you buy something like Brunzeel, your local supply can be highly variable. All suitable for your task probaly, but not something you can take a name brand recomendation on.

Keep in mind that a 3/4" panel is nearly twice as stiff as a 5/8".

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#6

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

ThomD

>"Something I don't know, and have been a bit shy about asking, what kind of substrate did Ruhlmann and other past masters use? "

I'd be willing ot bet he used a solid wood for his stuff. It's pre second world war isn't it?

One does have to take reality into account. My dad has a very high quality German grand piano. It is veneered all over with probably some euro walnut, and it has come off over many parts of the instrument. My dad made every effort to keep the instrument properly hydrated, but it is one thing to stop the soundboard from cracking, and another to keep a moist boundry over the instrument's total skin. Ruhlman may not have been designing for modern day forced air heat. I wonder what the difference is if one heated with radiant floor heating as far as the destruction of our handiwork is concerned. Another question might be what Wendell Castle did when he built his Ruhleman knock-offs.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#7

MDF is fine, Wiley.

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Wiley,

Anything you mention there should be fine - the thickness of the veneer is a trifle thick at 3/32 but it should work OK. It's about as thick as the laminations/veneers in the ply, so essentially you'll be turning a 5-ply board into a 7 ply board. This will limit your available width to about 48" as each layer of the ply has the grain at 90* to each other.

MDF's a quite common veneering core and may work better in your application.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#8

Just read the other responses - keying on MDF

Andrew F in Australia

>The MDF does have a wax finish so you need a glue that is designed to adhere to the MDF - a cross-linking PVA is common here, but you've many options.

To key the MDF, just drag a saw blade across it like a gigantic scraper. If you're worried about damaging the saw, use a flea market cheapie, a hardpoint $2- tenon saw from the local cheapo shop or a hacksaw blade.

Nothing wrong with using particleboard either.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#9

flakeboard connections/attachments

Adam Cherubini

>I would worry about the connections when you get into these sorts of materials. We sort of know what to expect with wood. Maybe MDF is a reasonable substitute, but the folks at IKEA go to great lengths to connect flake board to other stuff. Yes, they also have other concerns, but i don't see them screwing hinges into that stuff. Particle board is also really heavy and prone to sagging.

In terms of veneer holding, it may be best. Then again, this fellow's experience may be based on contact cement. I'm not picturing the "high end" cabinetmaker who uses flake board hammer veneering. I've never peeled anything high glued together "like masking tape".

Speaking of which, I really recommend hammer veneering the old fashioned way, Wiley. I had a great experience with it, its not that hard. I too was using 3/32 or so material. It worked great. Everything that can go wrong does go wrong every time you do it, so you learn quickly!

Adam

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#10

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>I vaccuum veneer with MDF. That's for worktable tops, etc.,--not for reproductions.

Then took a class last year with Steve Latta. He feels customers who buy his repro's would not be happy to learn MDF is the substrate. So he makes up his own plywood, crossbanding layers of thick veneers until he has the substrate thickness needed--3/32" should work fine for this. Then finish veneer both sides.

If it cracks someday, so be it, but he hasn't had any problems, as I recall.

Isn't 3/32" a little thick for finish veneer? Aren't surface checks possible with that thickness?

Best, Ted

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#11

Commercial experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>there used to be an architectural plywood plant near by. (Oh, did I get some nice seconds and overruns from them when they were in production).

They laid up over MDF, fir or luan plywood or rarely lumber core. Lumber core consisted of a lumber core, a cross band of thick ply and then the face ply. The only problem with the MFD is that these panels weighed a ton.

All "Baltic birch" is not created equal. These is some crap coming from China that is wet and it does turn into potato chips as it dries. If it is not in 5' wide sheets it is not the real stuff. the real stuff stays flat in my experience.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#12

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Paul Kierstead

>I recently read "The Complete Kitchen Cabinetmaker" (Robert Lang) and it recommends furniture grade particle board. Watching Darryl Kiel's videos on veneering, he also recommends particle board.

It still sounds awful to me, it would certainly seem that it is often the substrate of choice outside of magazine articles. Clearly, one does have to take account of joinery; you're gain in stability allows some new things, your loss in joinery flexibility may remove some possibilities.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#13

Re: Commercial experience

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>I'm using 1/2 inch ( 16/32)Baltic Birch purchased from a reputable supplier.

It is in the standard 5 ft. X 5ft. sheets and has 9 plies.

I then apply 3/32 in. veneer to both sides with regular PVA glue ( vacuum press) and this brings it up to 22/32 in. or very close to 3/4 of an inch in thickness.

Norman

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#14

Gluing to MDF

Steve Elliott

>At my current shop I'm regularly hot pressing veneered panels for custom furniture. We use MDF but sand the original surface first, which solves the adhesion problem mentioned by Denis.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#15

Re: Gluing to MDF

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Interesting, I was thinking about that option...

How is the MDF sanded, on a wide belt machine? And what grit is used?

Thnx,

DC

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#16

Update and a bit more info

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Thank you for all the comments! My heart reflects Warren's sentiments, but my head is saying that the crotch walnut veneer is going to come apart with any wood movement in the core. This veneer is the wonderful wood that Thomas Stockton was kind enough to contribute to Benefit Auction a few months back. Maybe there's a way to use a wood core so it won't destroy the veneer skin....

Lemme back up for a second. The starting plan is to butt up and edge-join 4 panes of the crotch walnut in the center of the desktop to reproduce the cross-section of the tree it came from. The veneer is end grain up. That center panel would be surrounded by flat-sawn bands of ebony and either birds-eye maple or satinwood. So grain-match seems about impossible.

The only natural wood core approach I have heard of is Rob Millard's method of sawing up flatsawn pieces small enough to rejoin them in quartersawn fashion--I have only read a brief reference to this and don't know enough to discuss it intelligently. I believe Warren's restoration work may have taken him into many examples of veneered period furniture, and perhaps he might comment on what he has seen.

The 3/32" thickness is off the bandsaw, has very fine saw tracks both sides, and would probably finish to a fat 1/16" (I'm guessing).

The desktop would be supported by a stout hardwood web underneath, so rigidity is not crucial, but more rigid is better than less rigid I would think (?). The desktop does need to have screw-holding ability, if conventional attachment is to be used, which is what I'm thinking.

I would like to share with you some additional feedback I received offline from a source close to the making of high-end veneered furniture. One is that Baltic birch tends not to be flat--I dunno, perhaps it all depends on the original supplier, since accounts are differing on this point. Also that mdf has to be keyed to take glue (as stated by someone above), plus if screw-holding is important, it's out. This person said that commercial particle board is a good substrate, but with a HUGE emphasis that it has to be a particular commercial grade, and not what is at the Borg. Marine ply (no voids) was cited by an experienced person on SAPFM.

In mulling all this over, I'd like to find out more about Mr. Millard's method, if anyone is familiar with it. This would be about a 20" x 36" top, so collecting a bunch of scrap and orienting the pieces to glue up into a quartered substrate seems very doable. Couple of things I don't understand about this approach though, even in principle: Would the quartered grain be horizontal? I would think so, so that the top would float vertically rather than horizontally. But then, how is the end grain oriented in the glue-up?

Adam, thank you. Does hammer veneering involve tape or no-tape?

Any and all your further impressions and opinions will be greedily seized upon, since I don't know jack about this, and need education.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#17

Widebelt Sanding

Steve Elliott

>We use a widebelt sander that cost something like $100,000 and is computer-controlled. One of the reasons we sand is to calibrate the MDF core to a uniform thickness so that the panel can be sanded again after veneering. For calibration our usual grit is 80 or 120, depending on which belt is on the machine. After veneering we use all three belts on the machine, a 120 crossgrain belt to remove the veneer tape, then 150 and 180 grits using segmented platens.

The same surface condition can of course be achieved by much less expensive methods. The main difference is speed.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#18

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Sgian Dubh

>Undoubtedly a couple of the best grounds for veneered work that has to live in contempoary houses with all their climate control are MDF and chipboard, aka particle board. They're both relatively dimensionally stable and void free. Plywood, blockboard, lumbercore et al do suffer things like voids, ripples and bumps, particularly at the economy end, and these imperfections can telegraph through to the surface. All of these materials are less stable and flat than either MDF or chipboard.

The drawback with both chipboard and MDF is their tendency to sag under load, and they're both quite heavy. MDF for example weighs something a bit shy of 50lbs per cubic foot. There is another version of fibreboard known as LDF (low density fibreboard) that is substantially lighter.

Chipboard accepts glue on the face well without further preparation. MDF, as others have suggested can actually be a bit too smooth, but I think the main problem with it is a hint of waxiness. This is easily fixed with some sanding or scoring. For small panels it takes very little time to wrap a bit 60 or 80 grit paper around a cork block and sand the panel in two directions. A toothing plane does a similar job, and as Andrew suggested a saw dragged across the surface will do it too.

I can't recall experiencing a veneer adhesion problem with MDF prepared in this sort of manner over a period going back to the 1970's.

As to your other concern about using non-traditional materials for reproduction furniture I won't offer an opinion, although I do of course have one. However I think you need to consider the period the furniture was made in in its entirety. What sort of environment was your original piece likey to have been made in? How dry would the wood have been? What kind of conditions would the original experience in service over the seasons? What kind of MC values would the original have experienced in service?

Puzzle your way through those sorts of questions and then ask yourself the same questions about your reproduction piece, the dryness of the wood you'll make it with, the species, the workshop conditions and the final in service conditions, etc. After you've done all that, make a judgement and go with it. Slainte.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#19

Re: Core material for veneering - sandply

Barry Va Beach

>Wiley, with hammer veneering you can either tape the veneers together before you apply them to the substrate ( I try to remember to put some glue on the edges while taping ) or you can lay down one peice, and when it is dry, clean up the edge with a shoulder plane and apply the next peice. As to cores , I have used a cheap plywood that Lowes or Home Depot, don't remember which, which is called something like Sandply or Sandeply. It is extremely light, and the face side has a very slight amount of texture and it worked great with the last peice I did. One final suggestion, if you are going to apply solid wood lipping, apply it first, then plane it smooth then apply the veneer on the whole panel including the lipping - I did a desktop and some side panels and the seams are invisible. Barry

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#20

Re: Update and a bit more info

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think that with any veneer the surface is more vulnerable to damage, so repair and maintenance has to be considered. Even with a completely inert substrate the veneer can come loose or chip, be bumped, have something fall on it etc. It can also buckle or crack from weather changes while the substrate is immobile. If the edges have to be veneered, as with plywood or particleboard, they are even more vulnerable. Just try to imagine what you would do if something heavy crashed into the corner of your desk and you were left with an area of crushed mdf that you had to rebuild before you could even think about repairing the veneer.

The beauty of the solid wood core and hide glue system is not that it is immune to problems, but that repair is straight forward. On a badly damaged piece, the veneer can be removed, the substrate repaired and the veneer put back. If there are cracks or chips they can be filled in or reglued. If there are bubbles they can be flattened.

There are plenty of 17th and 18th century veneered pieces around today. It is true that many have had restoration work done over the centuries. But the original work was done in such a way that repair was reasonable.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#21

Re: Update and a bit more info

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If you are interested in making a solid wood core for your project, and it is of a reasonable size you can use the suggested method of cutting up similar wood so it is all quarter sawn. It should be oriented so the rings are vertical and the individual pieces no wider than 3 inches.

Tooth the joints in between and glue together with hide glue, it won�t creep. Then after it has dried plane the surface flat on both sides, tooth and apply the veneer using what ever method you are familiar. Veneer both sides.

Many old pieces from England the Continent and America were veneered over quarter sawn chestnut and I have seen white oak substrates. They are cut up into narrow boards, usually about 3 inches and glued together. I have seen one or two that were tongue and grooved. I have also seen them with no attempt to orient the grain but they are usually smaller pieces. The breadboard substrates produce an altogether different problem.

The thicker veneers from the past would not tend to telegraph the substrate grain but over the course of time everything moves. The advantage is that the quarter sawn wood substrate will be about as stable as solid wood can be and the hide glue, substrate and hide glue all move well together. And as has been pointed out it will be easy to repair in the future.

Stephen

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#22

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

Tony - Memphis

>I've used big box mdf on many projects. I use Unibond 800 glue. I've never had any issues with adhesion, or any other issues for that matter. I have used platens and clamps and a vac bag too. I recently built a dresser and used 3/4" Baltic Birch (or at least what my supplier was calling Baltic anyway) and it worked fine too. I only covered one side of it since the inside was hidden. Turned out real nice. Those were big panels (for me).

Tony

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#23

Baltic Birch

Paul M.

>Since this is the hand tools forum after all, I gotta point out that it's disgusting to work with MDF with hand tools. I prefer to work with Baltic Birch if I need to make a substrate for veneering over MDF. Yes MDF has additional stability and other benefits, but I don't own a tablesaw and I don't plan on owning one anytime soon.

I can get a good sawn edge with Baltic Birch straight from my Ryoba saw so that I can glue solid edge to it. If I need to work it a little, then a couple of passes with a hand plane work just fine too.

So if you have a tablesaw, use MDF. If not, stay away from that crud.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#24

solid core by Krenov

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Wiley,

Krenov describes his method of making a solid wood core covered by his 1/16" 'real veneer' in whichever book has the spalted maple cabinet.

Also, ask yourself if the corners and edges of your desk shouldn't have more than 1/16" to bang against. Again, the same Krenov chapter shows how he puts same board solids along the edges.

Re: Core material for veneering--need help

#25

Re: solid core by Krenov

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Tom,

Thank you very much--I'll go find that book in the bookcase. To check on how he makes/orients the core, and also on the solid edging.

Wiley