Update and a bit more info
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Hi All,
Thank you for all the comments! My heart reflects Warren's sentiments, but my head is saying that the crotch walnut veneer is going to come apart with any wood movement in the core. This veneer is the wonderful wood that Thomas Stockton was kind enough to contribute to Benefit Auction a few months back. Maybe there's a way to use a wood core so it won't destroy the veneer skin....
Lemme back up for a second. The starting plan is to butt up and edge-join 4 panes of the crotch walnut in the center of the desktop to reproduce the cross-section of the tree it came from. The veneer is end grain up. That center panel would be surrounded by flat-sawn bands of ebony and either birds-eye maple or satinwood. So grain-match seems about impossible.
The only natural wood core approach I have heard of is Rob Millard's method of sawing up flatsawn pieces small enough to rejoin them in quartersawn fashion--I have only read a brief reference to this and don't know enough to discuss it intelligently. I believe Warren's restoration work may have taken him into many examples of veneered period furniture, and perhaps he might comment on what he has seen.
The 3/32" thickness is off the bandsaw, has very fine saw tracks both sides, and would probably finish to a fat 1/16" (I'm guessing).
The desktop would be supported by a stout hardwood web underneath, so rigidity is not crucial, but more rigid is better than less rigid I would think (?). The desktop does need to have screw-holding ability, if conventional attachment is to be used, which is what I'm thinking.
I would like to share with you some additional feedback I received offline from a source close to the making of high-end veneered furniture. One is that Baltic birch tends not to be flat--I dunno, perhaps it all depends on the original supplier, since accounts are differing on this point. Also that mdf has to be keyed to take glue (as stated by someone above), plus if screw-holding is important, it's out. This person said that commercial particle board is a good substrate, but with a HUGE emphasis that it has to be a particular commercial grade, and not what is at the Borg. Marine ply (no voids) was cited by an experienced person on SAPFM.
In mulling all this over, I'd like to find out more about Mr. Millard's method, if anyone is familiar with it. This would be about a 20" x 36" top, so collecting a bunch of scrap and orienting the pieces to glue up into a quartered substrate seems very doable. Couple of things I don't understand about this approach though, even in principle: Would the quartered grain be horizontal? I would think so, so that the top would float vertically rather than horizontally. But then, how is the end grain oriented in the glue-up?
Adam, thank you. Does hammer veneering involve tape or no-tape?
Any and all your further impressions and opinions will be greedily seized upon, since I don't know jack about this, and need education.
Thanks again,
Wiley