WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Posts

Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#1

Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Years ago (might be something like 15), I bought a crosscut backsaw at a LV tent sale (I miss those, they were a lot of fun). The saw was half-price because it had "uneven tooth set". I've never used it much because of that, and did not know how to correct the problem (I just used other saws instead).

Last year I brought it to the sharpening service where I get my power tool blades sharpened, and the man did sharpen it (on a machine I guess), but gave me the saw back without doing anything about the set...

Since then I got the Tom Law video, and I just acquired a new old Stanley 42 saw set (with box and manual), plus two files from LV. So I'm all set to try my hand at sharpening the saw, except for one thing...

The files I bought are 4" extra slim and 4" double extra slim. The first one is stated for 15 TPI and the second for 22 TPI. My saw is 16 TPI, so I'm not sure which one to use. The gentleman at the LV store suggested using the finer one, but I'd like to confirm with the experts here first before attempting my first saw sharpening...

TIA,

DC

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#2

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Dean J in MN

>Use the one which, when placed in the gullet, only drops in half way (or a little less). That way you can rotate the file and have fresh edges. If you use the smaller file you will "wear out" the face such that you can't use all three pairs to sharpen. That is my general rule of thumb anyway...

Dean

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#3

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Hi Denis,

Like Dean said, as a general rule, and this goes for all tooth size, use a file that has a width of no less than twice the height of the teeth. Going the way, you don't want a file that is much more than twice the height of the teeth. For your 16PPI teeth, choose the file that appears to have the sharpest corners. You want the gullets to be as deep as possible on those small teeth.

When you set the teeth, adjust the saw set so it barely bends the teeth. You only need a few thousands on each side of the blade. Most saws that I acquire will usually have way too much set. The best way to reduce the amount of over-set is to file the teeth deeper and then reset them if necessary. If your saw set is a Stanley 42X, the plunger will be a little too wide for 16PPI, so be careful that it doesn't bend a tooth next to the one you want to set. I have two 42X,s. I have filed one of them narrower for the smaller teeth.

Good luck,

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#4

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Pardon my ignorance, but what's the difference between the 42 and the 42X?

IIRC the box mentions 42. And it can to up to 16 TPI (or is it PPI).

Thnx,

DC

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#5

Plunger adjustment

Alan DuBoff

>The 42X has an anvil adjustment that moves vertical, and why most people prefer it. The new sets made by Somax are also good (Tools for Working Wood), the blue one will work fine for small teeth like you're filing. See image below for details of the 42X. If you file the plunger a bit narrower as Marv suggested, you can use the 42X on just about all saws, since it has such a wide range of adjust ability.

I don't know where you got the tooth sizes for the files, but I usually use a 4 double x for a dovetail saw at 16 points, I believe.

I'm linking to an image of a 42X from Pete Taran's site, Vintage Saws.

Enjoy, there's nothing quite like a sharp saw, it always puts a *grin* on my face anyway...


img

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#6

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Denis,

Look inside the handles, you should see the model number. The box will only show the number 42 but the actual model number includes either an X or a W on Stanley saw sets that are designed for the kind of teeth you are working with. IMO the 42W is a very poor design. The 42X can be adjusted down to almost zero set. It will have an anvil that is tapered and slides up and down by turning a thumbscrew at the bottom. And it has a clamping device that presses against the blade just before the plunger or hammer bends the tooth as you squeeze the handles. The 42W doesn't have this feature.

I see both of these saw sets being sold on eBay all the time. Sellers will not always know what they are selling and won't point out what the number really is. The two saw sets are quite different in design. Once you know the difference, you don't need to know the model number to see the difference.

The number you see below the handle on a regular saw indicates PPI (points per inch) They didn't stamp that number below the handle on backsaws. But when you count teeth using a ruler, you count from one inch mark to the next inch mark and that will give you PPI. If you want to think of it as TPI (teeth per inch) it will always be one tooth less than the PPI count. Don't ask me why this is, it's the way all saw makers count teeth. So if you count the teeth on your 16PPI saw, you should have 16 points from mark to mark within one inch on your ruler. If it is in fact 16, it will also be 15TPI.

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#7

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Alan DuBoff

>Marv said:

---------

"If you want to think of it as TPI (teeth per inch) it will always be one tooth less than the PPI count. Don't ask me why this is, it's the way all saw makers count teeth."

This is a problem with the internet, you're giving advice but not exactly sure why???? I'm good at that also, not to worry...LOL!

The reason is if you take any given inch and measure the tooth count from line to line of the inch, you will get ppi (points per inch) as you described. tpi, is teeth per inch, and when you start on the first line, you don't count the first tooth, you are essentially at your starting point, or 0 for tooth count. When most saw makers refer to points, they are referring to ppi most times, at least I do.

This is how I understand it anyway.;-)

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#8

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Denis,

I suggest you stick to your Stanley 42X, if that is what you have. My experience with a Somax is less than satisfactory. They come in two colors, a tan one and blue one. Both have the same anvil that numbers from 4 to 12. My experience is, it will put too much set on small teeth even set at the lowest setting of 12 even though the plunger is made for the smaller teeth. It might have been the particular tool I used and maybe they all aren't that way, but I'm sticking to my Stanley.

If your saw set is a 42W, I found that it wants to slide up on the tooth as it tries to bend it. This is very annoying. You have to always be mindful of pushing downward as you squeeze the handles. I hated it and will never use one again. The only good thing about it is, I can throw it a long ways down the hill in front of my house.

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#9

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Denis,

Which saw set does the manual cover, the 42 or the 42X? Both perhaps? Any chance of getting a photocopy of it?

Also, for clarification purposes somebody said that you'd want the file that has the sharpest point to drop into the gullet, but it is my understanding that true saw files are actually rounded at the apex of the faces to prevent making a sharp bottomed gullet that would create a fracture/stress point. Am I wrong about this?

I bring this up as I said for clarification purposes to prevent somebody from using what we commonly call a "3 cornered file, which would be incorrect--if I am correct.

T.O.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#10

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Todd,

For clarification purposes....saw files are never actually "sharp" on the corners. They will cut metal along the corners of the file. What I was meaning to point out is, for the smaller teeth you want as small a radius as possible but not sharp. The bottom of the gullet should definitely have a radius.

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#11

Pretty much what I said.....

Marv

>I could have gone into the history of saw making but I felt it best to at least simplify the difference between PPI and TPI.

Actually, I don't count the last tooth when counting TPI. But that's probably about as unimportant as the rest of the explanation.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#12

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, it is a 42W (or SS), same as this one:

http://www.jztools.com/tools/42w_sawset_box_a.jpg

I can see what you say about the plunger riding up, it does it without having a blade with it. I'll pay close attention to that...

I'll try working on the saw tonight if I have the chance.

Thanks all,

DC

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#13

Don't forget to Whet

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#14

Re: Don't forget to Whet

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>By that, I assume you mean lightly rubbing a stone on the side of the teeth after sharpening, to remove the burr?

Or am I out to lunch?

DC

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#15

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Denis,

As Stephen said, don't forget to "whet" after setting. Tom Law shows you what whetting is but doesn't say much about it.

I call it jointing the sides of the teeth after setting. Some people might use a file but I prefer a hard stone such as silicon carbide. Jointing the sides of the teeth is for removing a small burr that will occur during sharpening but more importantly, it is to make all the teeth the same amount of protrusion that is accomplished while setting the teeth. The saw set will not set all the teeth exactly the same. Do both sides, but very lightly. It only takes a couple of swipes. Slide the whet stone from toe to handle. Having all the teeth even will give you a smoother sawed surface from the git go.

Another reason for jointing or whetting is when your saw might cut to one side or the other and not want to follow a pencil line on it's own. When this happens, joint the side that the saw is cutting away from the line. If it's cutting to the right for example, joint the right side of the teeth.

When your saw is following a pencil line without you have to force it, it is filed correctly.

Have fun,

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#16

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Jointing the sides of the teeth is for removing a small burr that will occur during sharpening but more importantly, it is to make all the teeth the same amount of protrusion that is accomplished while setting the teeth.

Interesting that you should say this as last week when watching St. Roy he, during on of his many tangents was talking how John Fox had recently taught him how to "file into his saws", which I believe was for the purpose of eliminating the burr.

He also mentioned that John had re-taught him how to sharpen his chisels. Seems Roy always used to work up to the wire edge then break it off, but John said No, no, no. Roy alluded to how much sharper his chisels where using Johns method.

Thanks for the file clarification, and Thanks to you and Stephen for bringing up the Whetting step, as I'm sure that step gets heavily overlooked.

I was unaware that the saw set wouldn't set each saw tooth the same. Why is that?

T.O.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#17

Now you got me curious

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>What is the method John uses for sharpening his chisels?

DC

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#18

Re: Now you got me curious

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I have no idea Denis. I know who John Fox is from the WW'ing mags, I know he was on St. Roy's show not to long ago, and I heard Roy mention how thanks to John he sharpens his saw and chisel differently now.

Perhaps you can peruse thru the Woodwrights video links on the computer and find the shows that John was on and find out, tho there is no guarantee's that these subjects where discussed on the show itself.

Perhaps even a Google search for John Fox might turn up something.

T.O.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#19

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Marv

>Todd,

You asked:

I was unaware that the saw set wouldn't set each saw tooth the same. Why is that?

Keep in mind we are only talking about a few thousands of an inch when we set teeth, especially on backsaws.

In order to consistantly set each tooth the same the plunger would have to contact the tooth in exactly the same place each time and each tooth would have to be exactly the same width and depth. The spring back of each tooth would have to be the same and the amount of squeeze we exert on the handles would have to be the same. Some teeth might have a burr behind it as it is pressed against the anvil. Lots of little variables that can cause a tooth to be set a little differently. To be truthful, it's really not all that critical unless you are trying for as good as it can get. The burrs that occur will get rubbed off in a short time with use. The main reason for jointing is to get each point even with the other so you will have a smoother cut. The worse burrs aren't at the tip of the tooth. The worst ones are down along the front cutting edge of a tooth. Before I joint the tips of the teeth I first deburr lower down on the cutting edge, using a round slip stone, working from the toe end toward the handle. For the smaller backsaw teeth I use the edge of a flat stone.

As for filing the opposite direction to prevent burrs, not a bad idea, but I've gotten so used to filing the other way, in the direction the tooth is bent away from me, it would feel awkward to do it any other way. Yes, it is like honing a chisel by pushing away from you. For a chisel it just seemed to be the natural way to do it.

Marv

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#20

But somehow that wasn't what I read...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

If you want to know what you said, you can go back and read it, where you actually said, "Don't ask me why this is, it's the way all saw makers count teeth.". I was only explaining to him *why*, as I thought he, or others who might not know would then understand what the actual difference is.

Sometimes it's not what a person says, but how they say it, and telling someone not to ask why does not give them much information to go on. Since you didn't want him to ask you, I thought it would be good to at least offer a reason why tpi is different than ppi, it's a common question amongst woodworkers.

Your use of a "regular" handsaw, which I've mentioned to you before, has me curious where you reference that from? I consider my backsaws to be regular handsaws. I certainly don't consider them to be irregular at all, yet that is the context I derive from your message.

Cheers,

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#21

Re: But somehow that wasn't what I read...

Marv

>I think I clearly explained the difference between PPI and TPI. It didn't require redefining using different words. I still don't know why the saw makers stamped their saws to relate to PPI when most people will think in terms of TPI. It's more natural to think "teeth per inch", that's why people get confused with it. My guess is, most people who have read these posts are still confused.

Regular saws versus other saws.....I explained that in an email to you. If you prefer to think of your backsaws as regular saws, you certainly have my permission. No problem....

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#22

That's ok, I don't need permission, AFAIK

Alan DuBoff

>Marv said:

---------

"If you prefer to think of your backsaws as regular saws, you certainly have my permission."

---------

Thanks, I do appreciate you offering your permission, although I don't think I need it to use my own tools, thankfully.

Have a nice day.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#23

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Thanks for the explanation Marv, and truth be told it is all as I suspected--but thought I'd ask anyhow--just for clarification/verification purposes.

T.O.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#24

Re: That's ok, I don't need permission, AFAIK

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I think you are both at a tie right now for distance, but it is difficult to estimate the height of the arch with this media.

Re: Sharpening a saw - Which file?

#25

Someone wanted the manual?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>It's actually a foldout that ends up too large for the scanner, so I scanned it in four parts. You can find them at:

www.famillechenard.com/stanley42

Check the file size carefully, there are two sets, one full file size and the other compressed to a more reasonable size (those have a "c" before the dot in the file name), about eight times smaller.

Moderators, if this is not allowed, my apologies.

DC