Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Evidence of Toothing

Posts

Evidence of Toothing

#1

Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is an interesting table, it was made in 1852 or 1853 by the Church Public Works, Great Salt Lake City, Utah Territory. It was made by a cabinetmaker William Bell. English trained he built or was in charge of having built a great deal of furniture out here, most of it for Brigham Young.

I am making a reproduction of this original and in the course of examining the original I made some interesting observations. The curved parts were cut with an up down sash saw, I'll post on that later.

What is of interest is the evidence of toothing in preparation for joints other than veneer. Well here is the conformation of its use. There are no other mechanical connections, no pegs, nails, screws, &c.

The toothing pattern is coarse about 30 tpi but it was intentional. It is one of three foot piece that are attached to a base of a center table.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#2

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Sorry Stephen, but I don't see it. Probably right in plain sightt, just don't know what I'm looking for.

T.O.

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#3

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Todd,

Here is another picture. What you are looking for are the score marks on the underside of the lower apron on the base of a center table.

They are just under the foot piece at the top of the picture.

I hope this helps.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#4

Yup, see it now, pretty cool.

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#5

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

Interesting, and curious if you could elaborate a bit on the toothing observed on this piece?

I have read in the past that often furniture makers would use toothing when they veneered, similar to how stone masons will trowel the mortar when they lay stone, I 'spose, that the hide glue would have a good surface to adhere to. And I have read an article in a magazine once that suggested this toothing was added by some makers intentionally, even though they didn't veneer it.

I was just curious what your thoughts were on why the toothing is there, if there was any other veneer on the piece anywhere, and what the overall quality of the workmanship is on the piece.

Would love to see more pics of the piece.

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#6

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Because the joint is unreinforced with pegs it is a butt joint and the originating craftsman (Wm. Bell) used a toothing plane or other device to put a tooth or key to the pieces for the feet.

Here is a photograph of the entire foot and underside of the table. Because I can only post one pic at a time, I will also post a drawing of the table.

This supports other uses for a toothing plane than veneer.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#7

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is a drawing I did a number of years ago of this table. It has a 42" round table top.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#8

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

Your post was timely for me, and I had been thinking of doing something to the bottom of the legs on the workbench I'm building as to prevent it from sliding around on the hardwood floor it will reside on. I was thinking to just saw lightly on the bottom to create a serrated bottom just ever so slightly. A toothing plane would be the tool for that, rather than using a saw. In reality I could just rough it up and it will probably work fine, but the toothing plane for this task intrigues me.

However, since I don't have a toothing plane, I think that settles it for me...LOL!

It is good to know for the future, if I do find a toothing plane, or make one from a plane I have, I 'spose you only need to file some teeth into the bevel of the blade, or is there anything else unique about the toothing plane blades?

Nice looking table, BTW, looking forward to seeing progress as you work on this. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#9

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Alan,

The teeth are formed on the flat part of the blade and the bevel cuts them into sharp points. The blade is also held perpendicular to the sole of the plane and it scratches the fine grooves into the surface.

You can use a rasp to roughen or key the surface and I do have a cabinet scraper with a serrated blade that works well.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#10

Serrated Scraper Blade, didn't think of that!

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

Yes, I used a rough rasp, trying to not rasp but just mark the bottom, that is how they are now. It didn't work quite as well as I liked as it was difficult to hold onto the end of the rasp, even with part of the tip wrapped. This was on hard maple.

I'm not sure why I hadn't thought about a serrated scraper blade, that seems like a better solution for me, as it's way easier to make one, and could stamp teeth on one easily. Although 16 ppi is the best I can get on the Foley, I could joint the teeth down half way and file in between each one to give 32 ppi. Very close to the 30 you've shown.

(Alan exits stage left, heading for the Foley retoother...;-)

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#11

Re: Serrated Scraper Blade, didn't think of that!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Alan,

I just took a scraper blade, softened it by annealing then filed in the teeth to a very fine tooth pattern (45 tpi) so it is very fine scratches. I also put a bevel on the opposite side of the serrations then harden the scraper blade again by quenching.

Good luck with your Foley maching.

Salaman says in his book that the blades were available in fine, medium and coarse with no further details.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#12

Re: Serrated Scraper Blade, didn't think of that!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is a closeup of the blade in situ.

Stephen


img

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#13

Re: Evidence of Toothing

paul womack

> similar to how stone masons will trowel the mortar when they lay stone,

AFAIK they do that so that it's easier to "move" the mortar. A flat contiguous sheet of mortar is quite hard to knock a block into.

BugBear

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#14

Re: Evidence of Toothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Paul,

There is a method of spreading hide glue onto large surfaces using combs. The notches in the comb do the same thing as a notched trowel by putting a uniform amount of glue to a surface, it is then rolled or screed smooth.

Stephen

Re: Evidence of Toothing

#15

Re: Evidence of Toothing

paul womack

>There is a method of spreading hide glue onto large surfaces using combs. The notches in the comb do the same thing as a notched trowel by putting a uniform amount of glue to a surface, it is then rolled or screed smooth.

Ah! I think there are TWO techniques being discussed.

Notched spreaders have a built in depth control, and give a uniform layer. The target is a uniform layer, at least on a macroscopic scale.

But bricklayers (etc) use a simple trowel to make a ridged (mountainous?) bed of mortar. It's then quite easy to push (force/tap) the block down to a desired level in this bed. It's very difficulty to force a block down into a level(ish) bed of mortar, since you'd have to force all/any excess mortar right out the side of the block.

BugBear