Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Posts

Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#1

Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Paul Erickson

>I have been reading with envy the talk of using SYP for work benches, but so far have not been able to find a local supplier. I had thought of using Douglas Fir, but some recent comments about splintering over time has caused me to look for a possible alternative. To thoes who have had bad experiences with Fir, is it possible that continued maintance over time might overcome those problems? Any other thoughts on species available here in the Pacific North West???

My current budget will not allow for a hard maple, which it one of the reasons SYP is attractive.

Thanks in advance.

cheers, Paul

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#2

Douglas fir

Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA

>First, a message about standards across time. My grandfather's bench, which I inherited, was two Douglas fir 2x12s, laid flat and held together with cleats, with a single planing stock consisting of a piece of Douglas fir 2x3 or so, pushing up through a tight mortise in the benchtop. He made more furniture using that bench than I have yet in my life. Wish I'd inherited the planes he used on that bench, but oh well.

Douglas fir varies quite a bit. The coarser and more irregular the grain, the more likely it is to splinter. If your lumberyard permits (or tolerates) cherry-picking, look for the tightest, straightest grain you can find. When we were redoing the framing in our kitchen and laundry this Spring, I reluctantly put some studs into the wall that would have made great benchtop stock (no time, and nowhere to store wood, or they'd have disappeared from the kitchen project).

The fir that Grandpa used for the leg vise is still splinter-free, 80 years or so after he built the vise, and he (and I) put quite a bit of use into that vise (it's currently resting, until I get back to shop remodeling this Spring [I hope, but we're {this is husband-speak for "LOML"} now talking bathroom remodel], when the screw will be resurrected in an angled leg vise).

While I haven't tried this, I would expect periodic treatment with oil or Watco to keep splintering to a minimum.

Doug fir is one of the great woods. It's listed as only moderately durable in the weather, but I've got a chunk of 2x4 that's been lying on the ground next to a gate in the backyard, where it's periodically used to prop the gate open against the closing spring, for 34 years, and it's still sound - and not very splintery at all. We visited a museum in timber country a year or two ago, and the docent, who'd grown up there 70-75 years back, said they used to fell a Doug fir tree across a ravine if they wanted to make a bridge, and it wouldn't break when it hit, even though most of the length would be unsupported (being over a ravine and all). And vertical grain Doug fir (granted, expensive, though cheaper than many hardwoods) can be stunningly beautiful for certain furniture.

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#3

Corrections

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Relevant to Paul's question: I referred, above, to "...a single planing stock..." I meant "a single planing STOP."

Not relevant: My name line refers to "sunny Sebastopol," which it was a few days ago. Today, as my wife would say, it's raining cats and cats, all of them in a bad mood. I say to myself, "we need the rain," and we do - even our best reservoirs are only at 70% of capacity - but I wish that it rained as in Camelot. Whine whine whine.

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#4

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I think Doug Fir would make a fine bench.

There is a header in my garage shop over the door frame. Doug fir. When I hung shelves from it some years back, I remember that driving nails or screws into it, after it had been in place for 30 years, was a major chore. It had hardened that much.

Douglas fir intended for joists, and sold in 8", 10" or 12" nominal widths should be clear and straight, and ripped pretty easily into the thicknesses you want to laminate into your bench top. This is the strategy that Chris Schwartz recommends in his methods with SYP.

I built the $175 weekend bench back some years ago, intending to use it to build a better one as I got time. I still haven't taken the time. Building furniture is more fun.

And, 50 miles south of Bill, in the rainy Bay Area, the shop is miserably cold for an evening's play...

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#5

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Marv

>Hi Paul,

Douglas Fir can be some good stuff to work with,,,,but, not all of it. Lumber being milled now days is coming from smaller and smaller trees. This means lots of sap wood. If you can find some kiln dried heart wood, thats the stuff to use for a bench. If you start with wet green Doug Fir, it will shrink alot.

Or, if you aren't in a hurry, go ahead and find some good green heart wood with fine grain and stack it in a dry place so that it gets good air circulation around each board. Let it set there for a year. Most of the shrinkage will take place during that time.

Sometimes you can find some dry Doug Fir at HD.

Marv

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#6

As Bill and others said...

John in New Mexico

>It all depends on the quality and grain of the douglas fir. I worked for a couple of years at a bench of very indifferent fir (and construction) and received many wicked splinters from it, often from a hard piece of grain spalling off the surface and getting jammed under a fingernail while picking something up off the bench. Tighter grained fir did not seem to do this though. I believe my current bench, bought by my mother years ago from a junk store, has a pine top. Maybe spruce. In any case, I'd say you don't need a hardwood top. Use the best available lumber at hand, selected as best you can to avoid splinters and warping, and get to work (that's what its for after all).

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#7

Good point about the green wood

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I should have thought to mention that, too. Most fir, except vertical grain, is sold green, and, at certain seasons of the year when the building is running fast, my local lumberyard's wood gives the impression that the tree from which it was cut was felled yesterday. Makes for easy nailing of 16d nails, but it does shrink. Well-stored - good, level supports, some weather protection - for a while, though, it should be fine.

You can tell green wood by the weight, of course, and also by the temperature - the really green stuff feels distinctly cold when you pick it up, probably from the water evaporating on your hand.

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#8

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Marv

>Paul,

I know some people will gag at this suggestion, but if you are concerned about splinters, seal the top surface with a few coats of Polyurethane or clear epoxy. Probably only need one coat of epoxy.

Marv

Stephen, good idea, don'tcha think? *grin*

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#9

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Eric in Los Gatos

>Warning - Slight Hijack

First, interesting comments about SYP.

As a possible alternative I found some really nice looking kd hemlock studs at a local lumber yard. I don't know anything about hemlock. Any thoughts?

Eric in the stormy Santa Cruz Mountains.

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#10

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Paul Erickson

>Thanks for the replies. Looks like I will be sorting through the Fir pile after all.

Thanks again for the time and attention.

cheers, Paul

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#11

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Depends on what you're building.

Studs are cut for that dimension. And often include the heart/pith. I used them for the $175 Build your bench in a weekend bench, with a laminated plywood top. Studs were for the base.

What Chris recommends is using joist material, sold in 2x10 or larger material, better grade, and cut to the size you want to use for your top. Hemlock wouldn't be my first choice for a trophy bench top, but it works fine for the 'beater bench' I've been using for the last 6 or 8 years. And it came from the Orange Borg...

Keeping the shop dry in Contra Costa County...

Re: Alternative to Southern Yellow Pine?

#12

Late repply

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Hi Paul,

I'm building mine out of DF. My local hardwood supplier had a sale on kiln dried 4X6 12' long beams. I picked up 3 to cut in half to make my top out of. Stright, tight grain and no defects.