Douglas fir
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>First, a message about standards across time. My grandfather's bench, which I inherited, was two Douglas fir 2x12s, laid flat and held together with cleats, with a single planing stock consisting of a piece of Douglas fir 2x3 or so, pushing up through a tight mortise in the benchtop. He made more furniture using that bench than I have yet in my life. Wish I'd inherited the planes he used on that bench, but oh well.
Douglas fir varies quite a bit. The coarser and more irregular the grain, the more likely it is to splinter. If your lumberyard permits (or tolerates) cherry-picking, look for the tightest, straightest grain you can find. When we were redoing the framing in our kitchen and laundry this Spring, I reluctantly put some studs into the wall that would have made great benchtop stock (no time, and nowhere to store wood, or they'd have disappeared from the kitchen project).
The fir that Grandpa used for the leg vise is still splinter-free, 80 years or so after he built the vise, and he (and I) put quite a bit of use into that vise (it's currently resting, until I get back to shop remodeling this Spring [I hope, but we're {this is husband-speak for "LOML"} now talking bathroom remodel], when the screw will be resurrected in an angled leg vise).
While I haven't tried this, I would expect periodic treatment with oil or Watco to keep splintering to a minimum.
Doug fir is one of the great woods. It's listed as only moderately durable in the weather, but I've got a chunk of 2x4 that's been lying on the ground next to a gate in the backyard, where it's periodically used to prop the gate open against the closing spring, for 34 years, and it's still sound - and not very splintery at all. We visited a museum in timber country a year or two ago, and the docent, who'd grown up there 70-75 years back, said they used to fell a Doug fir tree across a ravine if they wanted to make a bridge, and it wouldn't break when it hit, even though most of the length would be unsupported (being over a ravine and all). And vertical grain Doug fir (granted, expensive, though cheaper than many hardwoods) can be stunningly beautiful for certain furniture.