Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

Posts

Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#1

Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

Stuart Hough

>Chris, I an really impressed with the Holtzapffel bench design. I would like to buid one for my shop, but I also like the thought process behind the $175 workbench. My query is this...will SYP work for the Holtzapffel? Will SYP be rigid enough with a top thickness of 3". Also, what edge thickness were the boards you used to laminate the top( yours look to be approx. 2" in the picture)? The reason I ask is that I have found a really good price on SYP 1x4x8's that are S4S and very straight, with the grain oriented properly, and had a flash that I could use them to build the top. I am thinking I can go to 3.25" for the thickness if my choice of wood will flex too much. Lastly, will holdfasts such as the Grammercy brand work in a top that thick?

I appreciate your advice on this. This will be my biggest undertaking so far, and I don't want to mess up and waste a bunch of money on the wrong material. Thanx!

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#2

rigidness of SYP

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the modulus(stiffness) of SYP is similar to maple. At 3" you could hold up a truck.

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#3

Re: rigidness of SYP

Stuart Hough

>Thanx, Bill! I'd hoped it would be a viable choice> I appreciate your post.

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#4

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

Dean J in MN

>Bill answered the wood question -- I can try on the holdfast. I have a 4" thick hard maple top and the Gramercy holdfasts work just fine.

-Dean

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#5

Yes, yes and yes

Christopher Schwarz

>Sorry to be slow to respond.

An SYP top of 3" thick will work for a Holtzapffel-style bench (6'-long with an unsupported span between legs).

The ash boards I used were indeed about 2" thick for my lamination. But I've made many tops with SYP laminations that are 1-1/4" thick. The e-value of SYP is quite good, so I think it's clear sailing ahead.

Chris

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#6

Thanx to all

Stuart Hough

>for your responses. I'll hopefully get started this weekend. I'll probably use the Veritas twin screw vise, because I can get that pretty quick. On another note, What wood species is best to use if I make my own screws and blocks (nuts)? That is if I can find a way to cut the threads. The idea of making all the parts myself really gets my juices flowing. Thanx again!

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#7

SYP ??? Please....

HC Sakman

>

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#8

Re: SYP ??? Please....

Martn from Granbury

>Southern Yellow Pine...

One of four resinous species of pine, found in the southern coastal plain. Shortleaf, longleaf, loblolly or slash.

Of the four, loblolly and slash are mostly planted today.

Longleaf is prized, and is often reclaimed from old floor joists during building tear downs. It is not planted as often (except in quail habitat) due to its prolonged (7-10 years) "grass" stage. It is susceptible to brown spot needle blight, but this can be stopped with prescribed burns. It grows in nice, park-like stands. If I owned 100 acres, I would plant longleaf.

Martin, former forester (sigh)

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#9

Re: rigidness of SYP

paul womack

>the modulus(stiffness) of SYP is similar to maple. At 3" you could hold up a truck.

And of course beam stiffness is proportional with the SQUARE of thickness, so if the cheaper material allow you to afford more thickness, it might well be a stiffness "win"

BugBear

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#10

Re: maths!!

paul womack

>I was mistaken;

http://nika.frontier.iarc.uaf.edu/~cswingle/archive/get.phtml?message_id=7134#message

Stiffness varies with the CUBE, which only reinforces (hah!) my argument.

BugBear

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#11

Link to an SYP Holzapffel building site  *LINK*

Don in Northern Arizona

>


Building the Holzapffel Workbench

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#12

Re: rigidness of SYP ( the Viagra factor)

Marv

>

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#13

Re: Link to an SYP Holzapffel building site *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Don,

I've seen that on Wiktor's Fine Tools site, but the builder used bolts, unlike the joinery that Chris showed in the mag/book-cd.

I have a lot of pics on my site also, although I'm not finished with mine either, I do have more pics and am farther along and hope to get finished with the face vise soon. You'll see that I replaced the QR which Chris used with a Emmert Clone. I think even Chris is curious how that will work out to have a non-QR vise on the end, but I think it will work out ok...I'll see...it operates smoothly, and while standing at the front I can spin the handle pretty quick. I primarily wanted to have the other ability of the pattern maker's vise, for positioning, rather than it's primary function being the end vise functionality.


img

Yet Antoher Holtzapffel Build

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Wooden screws

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Stuart,I have some wooden vise screws that were made by Howard Card. He used beech on all his screws. I built smaller screws for a bench fixture out of hard maple.I've heard that most hardwoods will make decent screws.I would avoid stuff that is brittle or stringy.Good luck with your bench. It sounds like a fun project.---Jack

Re: Chris Schwarz, your advice needed.

#15

Re: Wooden screws

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Jack,

I also own several screws that Howard made, mine are all rock maple, I have two on my bench and I bought two extra "just in case".....I'm so glad I did buy the extra ones...

Howard no longer makes screws I was told,

take care,

Jim