Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Chester Co Chest

Posts

Chester Co Chest

#1

Chester Co Chest

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Finally got the feet and back on this thing and put in its place, a place where it is very hard to photograph it. It weighs a ton w/o dust panels.

Reproduction of 1725 piece in Winterthur collection, except mine has better feet. I may line and berry the top drawers some day. Walnut with burnt umber mineral pigment stain and varnish. Secondary woods poplar, white pine, yellow pine and hemlock.

While I am on the subject, what use are dust panels other than to make something even more heavy?


img

Re: Chester Co Chest

#2

Re: Chester Co Chest

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Nice Chest. Until the introduction of central heating, life was much more dusty and dirty than today. A lot of soot from grease lamps, fireplaces, stoves, oil lamps, candles and the dust that blows in the house.

The dust panels did and still do keep the textiles and clothing from becoming covered with dust and soot. Although the problems are not as common today. The dust panels also discourage insects and vermin from getting into the drawers.

Stephen

Re: Chester Co Chest

#3

Re: Chester Co Chest

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Dang Bill!!!, that is a magnificent piece of work!! Very very well done Sir.

I'm not a big fan of such dressers just to stow my skivvies in, but I certainly can, and do appreciate Fine Craftsmanship, of which, this is a perfect example. Very Impressive indeed.

T.O.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#4

Re: Chester Co Chest

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Nice job, Bill. You did a nice job on the stock selection and feet and the moldings look good, too.

I think the old one is missing its original bracket feet. I think what you see in the museum are the stiles from the side frames continuing to the floor and to which bracket feet were fastened originally (even with the edge of the molding). You can see a picture of this kind of construction in the Pennsylvania spice box book on page 16 with some discussion. It looks handsome with your turned feet also.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#5

Re: Chester Co Chest

Wiley Horne

>Bill,

That is just magnificent! The piece itself is full of grace, and your craftsmanship is perfection to these eyes.

I am particularly astounded at the double-beaded case, and how well that is done--and how difficult it must have been to execute. And really, any detail that the eye picks up looks 100%. But beyond the details, the overall impression is harmony and completeness.

I am curious how it is that you settled on the Chester Co. period as your favorite. I find the early settlement of Pennsylvania to be one of the most interesting parts of our Country's history.

Wiley

Re: Chester Co Chest

#6

Re: Chester Co Chest

Dave Mount

>Hi Bill--

Beautifully executed as, I have come to understand, per usual. Finding the wide stock to have all the fronts and panels be one piece gives it a great look.

Best,

Dave

Re: Chester Co Chest

#7

needs shoe polish!

Adam Cherubini

>Looks great Bill congrats. Just kidding about the shoe polish. Leave that finish alone it looks great as is.

I'm not sure about the dust panels. IME, they sorta help the drawer runners stay in their dadoes. In the case of a full dust boards, that's just simpler. I'm not totally convinced they really are for dust. I'd like to see an early (contemporaneous) document call them that. Exactly how much dust get inside a piece of furniture anyway?

Adam

Re: Chester Co Chest

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Very Nice

Jim in Burlington On

>Hi Bill,

Looks like a very nice chest. Personally I think the feet could be even larger. Really enjoy the different look that it has.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#9

Mythology

Jeff S.

>I am with you, Adam. I think that there is more lint-sourced dust inside a chest from clothing being moved about than soot from kerosene lamps or dust from broomed floors entering around the gaps of a drawer.

I think that "dust panels" serve more to keep clothing from getting entangled with the drawer above (preventing drawers from opening). Though.... there have been occasions with dust panels, where I have had a drawer jammed in place and it would have been nice to have been able to remove the drawer immediately above and addressed the cause.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#10

Re: Mythology

Adam Cherubini

>It may also have been a security issue. Oe unlocked drawer would provide access to the drawer below it.

Frankly, I have some amount of trouble with this. I mean, it sounds very stupid, but then we have to ask, why did they lock their drawers at all? Its very typical for high style and even some country pieces to have locks.

I think the answer is that their homes were awash with strangers, business partners, and servants and slaves and other peoples' servants and other peoples' slaves. And the disparity between rich and poor was so great and here they all were in this house.

I've written that the function of fine period furniture was as much to impress as provide convenient storage. If you buy that and and the lock story, the picture that emerges in my mind is that their houses were much more like a store at the local shopping mall than a comfortable private nest for family and friends that our houses are. Their ways and lives were very different from ours.

Adam

Re: Chester Co Chest

#11

Now THAT'S fine woodworking.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>That is so easy on the eyes, Bill. Everything about it; the wood, the workmanship, proportion, detailing and finish seems so right. The drawer front boards really look delicious. Nice rich figure but not 'too anything'. I'd be immensely satisfied to have built that. Or to own it.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#12

Wow

Ron in Kokomo

>That is absolutely gorgeous.

Nice work Bill

I think the answer about dust panels and security issues is the most likely.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#13

How I "settled" on Chester Co style

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>As many have commented, the proportions of this piece are pleasing. That is not my doing; I just copied them. While I am not talented at figuring out proportions I know them when I see them. Anyway, I build what I need, and/or, like the looks of and can use. The piece before this was a VA spool bed, and before than a Krenov wall cabinet and next will be a Federal cabinet and some sort of slant top desk. Among these projects are laundry room cabinets and closet doors. It should be apparent by now that I don't have a settled style, or some might even say "taste".

Re: Chester Co Chest

#14

thanks for information

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The guide had no clue as to the ugly feet on the museum piece. What you say makes sense as to why an otherwise elegant piece would seem to have ugly feet.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#15

Re: Chester Co Chest

Ace Karner

>I downloaded the pic so I could enlarge it and examine it closely, that is some wonderful workmanship on a beautiful chest. Kind of work that I hope to do some day.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#16

what he said

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>As usual, Wiley says it so much better than I could have. This is excellent work Bill. Thanks for sharing it.

Anyone who tries to design their own furniture should be forced to look at stuff like this first and ask themselves if they really think they can improve on it. The decision to make reproductions is almost always a wise one.

Tom

who has come up with one or two fine designs in dozens of attempts

Re: Chester Co Chest

#17

Re: Chester Co Chest

Stuart Hough

>Bill, Beautiful work! Absolutely gorgeous! We all are impressed!

Re: Chester Co Chest

#18

Re: Chester Co Chest

Dean J in MN

>Fantastic work Bill!

As to dustboards -- In dovetailed cases, "full dustboards" do afford a solution to cross grain issues with drawer runners. The full dustboards I've seen (and built) are thinner than the drawer blade, so don't add too much to the weight of the case. However, with either a web frame, or a frame and panel side (like your chest) I'm not sure as to the advantages of a dustboard as both of these constructions also minimize the cross grain question.

-Dean

Re: Chester Co Chest

#19

Eclectic is all the "style" you need, Bill

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>as long as you keep producing work of this quality. Outstanding craftsmanship!

Bruce

Re: Chester Co Chest

#20

If you have a ferret...

Don in Northern Arizona

>dust panels are useful when the ferret gets into a chest of drawers. I have a colleague who had a ferret that used to regularly get into a chest of drawers of hers which did not have dust panels. There was no way she could catch him as he slithered up and down from drawer to drawer. She simply had to leave a drawer open until he finally decided to come out, usually at dinner time.

Don

Re: Chester Co Chest

#21

Probably true for hamsters too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the family stories from my childhood involved the hamster that disappeared into the sofa for three days, only to emerge unscathed but a bit hungry.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#22

Re: Chester Co Chest

Paul Kierstead

>Wow, very impressive Bill. I showed to my girlfriend as an example of what furniture is supposed to look like. She also commented it was "very very beautiful". I really like the style you choose too; lots of details, but still not ostentatious; a very fine blend and extremely well executed. An inspiration.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#23

a keeper, for sure!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That girlfriend is a keeper. Now slowly introduce her to the tools that will be required and the lumber stash to lay in and all will be well down the road if you travel that far.

Re: Chester Co Chest

#24

hungry?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Had it been my sofa it could have lived on popcorn (plus??) for quite some time.