Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

grits

Posts

grits

#1

grits

Dan Collins

>I am a recent convert to using sandpaper to sharpen chisels and plane blades. Acually I'm not a total convert because I use the sandpaper up to 1000 grit, then I often make a few passes on a 6000 grit Norton waterstone, then a final swipe or two on a leather strop. Although I have no microscopic comparisons, the blades often feel sharper after using the 1000 grit sandpaper than they do after using the 6000 grit waterstone. Does anyone know if the "grits" measurement is the same for sandpaper as it is for a waterstone, i.e., is a 1000 grit piece of sandpaper the same as a 1000 grit waterstone? I use a fixed honing guide. My waterstones are flat and I put the sandpaper on a flat piece of marble, so all things being equal, I would think that the 6000 grit waterstone would yield a much sharper blade than a 1000 grit piece of sandpaper, but at least according to my fingernail test, the 1000 grit sandpaper usually feels sharper. Any idea why?

Re: grits

#2

Re: grits

Ron Bauman

>It could be that you are making a microscopic serrate edge with sandpaper, which will sometimes be a better cutting edge than one smooth plane. Just a guess and remember I've been wrong before.

Re: grits

#3

Chris Scholz

Re: grits

Chris Scholz

>Dan,

Most certainly you are trying to compare apples and oranges. Even if the average (or is it median? it is really not clear what exactly the 'grit size' means) particle size is nominally the same, two abrasives can result in a very different surface quality.

What sounds like a trivial task (measure the size of abrasive particles) is indeed rather complicated and prone to error. It is extremely difficult to measure the size of a huge amount of small particle sufficient accuracy, precision, repeatability and reproducibility. In my opinion many of the numbers published are to be interpreted as 'guesstimates' than statistically defendable scientific values. Keep in ind that just one particle out of 10,000's that is 'too large' can screw up your edge.

The European FEPA compliant abrasives have bounds on how much the particle size can vary around an average (median?) value, with the US CAMI compliant abrasives and waterstones all you can do is hope the vendor has a sufficient process controls and the batch-to-batch variations are within reasonable limits.

In my opinion the best strategy is to learn how your favorite abrasives work for your specific workflow and not to worry about the numbers too much.

You might also try our DiamondSandpaper that eliminates all the issues many people face with rounding over the cutting edge when using a strop.

Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Galoot-Tools

Re: grits

#4

that would be my guess

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Also, the abrasive particle size of various abrasive formats is not directly reflected in their quoted "grit size", ie all 1000 grit is not equal. And if you are using silicon carbide for the sheet abrasive, it readily crushes to something smaller than what one starts out with, where as the water stone continually renews the abrasive surface.

The luster of the abraded edge will tell you something about effective particle size of the abrasive. If the 6000 produces a more shiny surface it is making smaller scratches.