Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Posts

Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#1

Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Howard M

>I�m deciding between buying the Lee Valley MK II power Sharpening System and the Worksharp 3000. I�ve heard good things about the Worksharp but have not seen any head to head comparisons.

Can anyone tell me why I might want one over the other?

Thanks

Howard

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#2

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Howard

Having used neither .....!

The Worksharp can work up to a 2" blade width. The machine is, therefore, and Stanley planes such as the #4 1/2, #7, etc all of which have a blade width of 2 3/8".

It uses a few fixed angle settings. These are fine for chisels, BD plane blades. It is not suited to BU plane blades where the microbevel is required above 35 degrees (mostly one would need a 38 and greater degree microbevel. I use a 50 degree on my smoothers).

The simplicity of the machine sounds very appealing - it reminds me of a cranked pencil sharpener... stick it in and whirl the handle. There .. done! I have also heard good things about the edges created for chisels. Tony Z will has written a few good responses here already. So I guess it depends what you want to use the machine for.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#3

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Tony Z.

>Thought I would weigh in since I've had the WorkSharp for about 3 months now. For narrow blades and chisels I really like it. It worked wonders for me getting my narrow bladed plow planes to do what they're supposed to do. For wider blades and chisels, I've found myself gravitating back to free-hand and occassional jig sharpening methods, on my oilstones.

I've never really found the four set angles or the 2" width limitation to be much of a hindrance. What I find to be a major shortcoming, is the life of the abrasive paper. I've used a variety of methods over the years, from Scary Sharp, to waterstones and oilstones. The WorkSharp is a motorized Scary Sharp method. You can't skip grits otherwise you will leave scratches on the bevel (I absolutely do not use the machine to flatten the backs--too easy to slip up and make a bumble-neck!). Again, where I found the machine to be very useful is for those tasks where I've had issues--those narrow plow plane blades for example. Other users with less sharpening experience will find the WorkSharp to be very useful and will give a competent edge, but sooner or later, you will want more out of the edge!

T.Z.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#4

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Paul Kierstead

>I absolutely do not use the machine to flatten the backs--too easy to slip up and make a bumble-neck!

That right there is the exact reason I sold my LV power sharpener MK I. The single biggest PITA is flattening back. I don't find touching up bevels to be any great bother by hand, and grinding a bevel has a ton of options, especially if you do micro-bevels. So I hated using the machine for the one thing I really wanted to shorten and thus got rid of it. I now use some very coarse diamond stones to start the flattening process.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#5

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Tony Z.

>I have never found flattening a back to be overly burdensome. It's a fact of life for any new or vintage tool and is the first task I do.

With the WorkSharp, you have a rotating sandpaper disc that you must lower the chisel or blade onto. I am enough of a "doofus" to not trust my ability to precisely lower onto that spinning disc. I tried it one time and before I could say "aw sh_t" I had majorly eased one side of an almost flat back.

As I said earlier, for someone fairly fresh to our game, the WorkSharp will seem like a God-send. For me, with narrow chisels and plow plane blades, it works very, very nicely. For changing the angle of a bevel, it also works nicely, although I have finished the sharpening with conventional hand sharpening after the initial shaping. I have heard, although I have not tried it, that the perforated disc and sandpaper work very nicely for free hand sharpening a turning gouges.

One point I haven't mentioned, is that I still own the machine and am not considering selling it! I am not one to let unused power tools take up valuable space in my very much space limited shop (hand tools are a different matter--it makes perfect sense to have 3 Stanley 45's for example).

Tony Z.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#6

Flattening is exactly the same as the Veritas...

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#7

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Paul M.

>I have the LV sharpener, and I've messed up backs with that one too.

The solution I found:

1) Put on a thick construction leather glove on my right hand

2) Place back of iron onto the abrasive with the tool rest removed and the motor *OFF*.

3) Turn on switch with free hand, being careful to keep good hold with glove on iron while keeping free hand out of possible launch zone

4) When you can feel it getting warm through leather glove, turn off motor with iron still held to abrasive.

5) Cool iron in convenient water jug.

6) Inspect and repeat.

A thin iron gets hot really quick, so hence the need for the glove. I haven't launched an iron yet, but I'm always aware of the possibility. Once I started using this method, I haven't rounded another corner.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#8

Why don't you...

Neal in San Jose

>I have a Lap Sharp, and I place the blade in position on the stationary wheel and then step on a pedal that starts the machine. I have a similar pedal that I use for some corded tools that works well. Would it be possible to do that with the WorkSharp? It would alleviate the "place the blade on a spinning grinder" errors.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#9

Re: Why don't you...

Tony Zaffuto

>Too many steps in the process! I've thought of similar methods to address it, but in the end, flattening is a necessary first step in preparing a chisel or blade. Do it right the first time and its done.

So far I've found a place for the WorkSharp in my shop and a need for which it works well for me. I've found a few places where it is lacking. As I said in my first post, I've had the machine now for about three months. I don't know if I made the statement on Woodcentral or on another forum, but at the price point of the cost of the WorkSharp, I would like to see more flexibility.

T.Z.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#10

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Paul Kierstead

>That is pretty good to stop dubbing the corners, however you still run a serious risk of getting more cut on the "near" side (the one facing into the rotation) and ending up with a convex back.

I'm not saying it can't be done right -- it clearly can -- but it is excessively tricky and the system is sufficiently aggressive that an error can be pretty big and nasty.

Like most things, some will love it, some not so much. I fell into the latter.

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

#11

Re: Worksharp Vrs. Lee Valley machine

Paul M.

>I agree. I don't love this thing at all for flattening backs. But luckily, this is only something you do once, and it sure beats using a waterstone for this tedious operation. I was just showing how I've figured out how to speed up a process I detest. ;-)