We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>What is the best spokeshave to use for shaping Cabriole legs? Wooden, metal, Veritas, Lie-Neilson, etc. I have a Stanley #53 and it is great for light, narrow work but not heavy, wide surfaces - the throat continually plugs with shavings. What would you use?
>So maybe I'm not the right guy to make recommendations. I only have three or four spoke shaves, and, beautiful as they are, they are all light work, finish tools. Every time I try to crank them up to heavy cuts, they clog the throat, and have to be reset.
So maybe it's the wrong tool for wide, heavy cuts. Maybe a drawknife. Maybe a rank-set plane. Perhaps a rasp, or one of those cheese grater, auto body looking tools that Microplane sells. Chisels. Carving tools. Something aggressive.
But then, I don't do cabriole. That's for someone else to accomplish. Doesn't work in my abode.
>Well, I can't say what the best is, as I haven't tried them all, but I have an old Stanley 151 that works very well. You can get them cheap and they are easy to find (ebay). I recently added a Hock iron and that made it work even better. I made a Lee Valley from a kit and it works really nice, but I use it for very fine cuts only.
>Within the last two years I've made two cherry tables with cabriole legs, and my Lee Valley flat and round shaves performed very well. I have a Lie Neilson which also works well, as well as several anteek Stanleys, but the Lee Valley shaves work so well and are so easy to adjust, that those are the ones that jump into my hand when I need a shave. Be aware that they work best on straight-grained wood. Knots and tricky grain will try your patience.
>Theoretically the #53 should be able to be adjusted for course cuts or fine cuts. I keep mine set pretty wide for working with green straight stock, so I can only tell you that I think it should be able to be fussed with enough to make it work on dry hardwood cabriole legs.
A clogged throat means you're taking too big of a cut for the opening. Scary sharpen the blade, and open the throat while pulling the blade back enough to remove chatter. I have never been able to get away with just adjusting the throat- I have to change the depth of cut along with it. Hold the thing diagonally while cutting- and try pushing it while holding it firmly in the middle with your thumbs and index fingers. There's got to be a way to make that guy work...
You might be expecting to remove too much material for a spoke shave. Have you given any thought to trying a draw knife- a really sharp one, and used bevel down around the curvy parts? Not all draw knives lend themselves to this usage (Handles in the same plane as the cutting edge are best for this). Haven't had a draw knife clog yet!
Between Lie-Nielson's and Lee Valley's, the Lie-Nielson will clog more, because it has a narrower throat (the Lee Valley is by no means wide-wide open & comes with shims to narrow it down). The radiused sole ones (either make) might be the best choice for cabriole geometry. (BTW, the radii on these spoke shaves are minute- you almost need to lay a straight edge on the LN to see it; Lee Valley's is a little more obvious.) You'll like owning either make or model- they're premium tools. But I wouldn't expect better performance than a #53 while taking a lot of material off. I consider mine more like little smoothing planes for small & mobile geometry.
So go ahead and buy a new shave, but don't let that #53 off the hook so easily.
I can't recommend the LN for coarse work. They have a very fine mouth and take a very fine shaving (they excell in finishing work). It states on their web site they are made only for fine work.
>For coarse work, I think you'd be pretty well served with a drawknife. That said, at North Bennet, we do a lot of work with 1" chisels, too. It's the same idea as the drawknife, but I think part of the reason that opted for that one is that Brian Boggs hasn't taught them how to tune up a drawknife yet. Basically, it's like any other bevel tool... but then he does a very mild knife grind (convex instead of concave) at the very edge of the back (flat) of the blade. The idea is to make the knife a little more maneuverable. This is advice I rec'd from Brian in a class, and I can say that I've seen him work with a drawknife firsthand... he's able to hog off massive amounts of material, or take very fine shavings. You'd be surprised... it's really impressive. Pfeil makes a pretty decent drawknife for not too much money, and it's small enough and controllable enough that I think it'd serve you pretty well.
Second bet would be the Lee Valley low angle spokeshave. I know it's not the favorite around here, everyone loves the fancy rounded handle versions. Tip 2 from M. Boggs. Low angle spokeshaves work essentially like drawknives, only with a depth adjustment. And the throat on that spokeshave, unlike any of the other ones mentioned, is actually adjustable... or removable, if it comes to that. So you can use it as a drawknife if you wish. to adjust the throat, loosen the screws, lay the shave on the bench, and rock it gently forward. That will push the plate up ever so slightly, and then tighten it down. Alternately, put a piece of masking tape or two on the tail end of the blade to accomplish the same sort of tilt.
Third? for rough work, get something decent and file out the throat a little bit. This is only if you're bound and determined to have a dedicated rough work/stock removal spokeshave.
Well, actually my third choice would be to make a wooden one with either the Lee valley Kit or the bigger of the 2 Hock blades, in tandem with the article in the first Charlesworth Book. The man knows how to make a spokeshave, I'll give him that. And it took me only a few hours to make, with hand tools and a drill press. Fourth choice would be modifying an existing spokeshave, but I hesitate, because if I were to go that route, chances are I'd buy something cheap that wouldn't perform very well anyway, and by the time all the fussing is done, you'd have been better off buying and learning to use a drawknife.