Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...
Don McConnell
>Alan wonders about:
"Would be interesting to date the backsaw, and when they started to add strong folded backs to the blades to strengthen them."
This has emerged as a contentious issue - and I probably would be smarter to stay away from it. But, I guess I'm willing to delve into, at least briefly, as I think it an important one.
Specifically, the issue boils down to the problematic question as to whether Joseph Moxon, in his _Mechanick Exercises_, ca. 1680, mentions "back saws" or not. In the bulk of his text, and in the primary "joinery" illustration, Moxon clearly equates the "Tennant-Saw" with a bow/frame saw. Part of that text reads:
" ... The Office of the Cheeks made to the Frame-Saw is, by the twisted Cord and Tongue in the middle, to draw the upper ends of the Cheeks closer together, that the lower end of the Cheeks may be drawn the wider asunder, and strain the Blade of the Saw the straighter. ..."
However, the very next sentence reads: "... The Tennant-Saw, being thin, hath a Back to keep it from bending."
As I said, this is very problematic, and several explanations have been put forth in an effort to resolve the fact that the two sentences appear to be describing different types of saws.
One explanation has been that Moxon may have meant that a back was affixed to the web of the bow saw in order to stiffen it. This makes no sense to me. He's already described the purpose of the frame as stiffening the blade, so a back would be redundant. Additionally, if the web were relatively narrow, any back affixed to it would severely limit the depth it could cut. This seems completely impractical for largish tenons.
Another explanation has been that the second sentence was simply a different description of the frame saw. Again, I find this untenable, as he had already clearly described the tensioning effect of the bow saw, and a differing description of the same type of saw is completely redundant. And unnecessarily confusing.
Another explanation has been that Moxon simply didn't intend what the second sentence appears to mean. This, to me is the most problematic explanation of all. While the alternative is that these two sentences appear to be confusingly describing two different types of saws, this seems less problematic, to me, than assuming that Moxon didn't mean what he wrote.
So, I feel that this is the earliest known mention of a back saw, though I can't really explain the dichotomy between the two sentences. Though, the latter sentence may simply have been added as an afterthought, if Moxon were familiar with back-type tenon saws and belatedly realized that he'd made no mention of them.
In any event, the first uncontested (as far as I know) mention of back saws is to be found in Richard Neve's _The City and Country Purchaser's and Builder's Dictionary_, 3rd edition, 1736:
"The Tenon-saw, or Tenant, used
for fine Stuff, with a Back to it; So
call'd from being used to make Te-
nons for Mortises."
So, to recap, I think there is reasonable evidence that back saws were around as early as 1680, and strong evidence supports their existence by 1736.
Though you didn't ask, I have also been interested in the earliest mention of back saws other than tenon saws. The earliest mention we've found, so far, of a "duftail saw," is from Nov. 9, 1749. This in a Thomas Maule advertisement in the _Pennsylvania Gazette_. Maule also ran an advertisement in the same paper on December 25, 1750, which mentions "tenant," sash and dove tail saws.
The earliest mention of a carcase saw that I've found, so far, is the 1800 Christopher Gabriel inventory.
I want to publicly thank Brian Welch for tracking down the Neve mention, as well as the Maule ads in the _Pennsylvania Gazette_." I don't know if he follows WoodCentral, or not, but I wanted to make sure to give credit where it's due.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR