Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

Posts

Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#1

Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>I was trying to figure out how long ago the Handsaw handles were closed, and/or when the current saw handle started to take shape. Several of the old English saws that I own have very distinctive shape to them, with the lower section resembling a lamb's tongue.

These are in fact, some of my favorite saw handles, and the English had such nice handles, and certainly what I consider some of the finer craftsmanship in toolmaking for the 19th century which many of my handsaws are from.

The lamb's tongue in itself is intriguing, and I have to wonder if the term has roots in saw making or carving, I had once seen it described as such on an ebay auction a couple or three years ago, oddly enough for an American made backsaw (Wheeler, Madden, & Clemson) which incorporated that. I have searched around, and nobody can trace roots to anything, although some blacksmiths believe that there was something to do with a lambs tongue that was forged, possibly when the vikings reined...

Anybody have any history in old books, I've seen Moxon mentioned in Irv and Don's "Handsaw Makers of the U.K.", but in the context of recommending toolmakers in the late 17th century. Anyone know any history on the closed handle that was so popular in England? Especially who originated the London Pattern handle, it most often has the lamb's tongue on it, a couple pic'd at the linky.

I grabbed a few of the saws I have which fit into this category, but one saw has slotted screws so is newer, possibly close to the 20th century. See linky...would love to see any pics anyone has of English handles, for backsaws, or other, but I'm primarily interested in backsaws myself.


img

Photomentary, click here

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#3

Re: Bad Link?

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

Server took a hit last night in the storm. Should be back up now, and stay up...:-/

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#5

Re: Ye Haw! It's back...(err...maybe not)

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

I think it's down again, and I suspect one of the disks is going out, after it took a hit last night.

Unfortunately I'm not at home right now, so can't look at it and can't access it...:-(

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#6

Some saw pix for Alan...PIX *LINK*

Rob Brophy

>Hi Alan,

I can't offer any info about saw history, but here are a few old gems I've pulled from the Niagara area flea markets (none more than five bucks)....

...this one was made (or just sold) by Gabriel/London around 1800 according to smart Galoots on the OTL



...a selection of 'as found' beauties...


...a nifty backsaw by Sykes with a brass back and steel saw nuts...


...a couple early Beardshaw saws...


...my favorite two dollar saw...


Hope this helps...Rob


A few more saw pix

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#7

Nice Early Saws!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#8

Re: Nice Early Saws!

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Got to agree with Stephen, very nice collection of old saws! Are there any that you have that you simply won't use due to age/rarity?

I am just now beginning to more appreciate old saws. There's just no bottom to the slope I swear.

Thanks for posting all the pics of yours, I know it took some time to do it.

T.O.

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#9

Chicken Neck

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I noticed on the medallions that the heads of the eagles on the early ones are pointing up, exactly like the early U.S. military brass buttons.

The later eagles on the buttons have a more angled neck called a 'chicken neck' because of its right angle, introduced later in the American Civil War.

Stephen

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#10

Re: Ye Haw! It's back...

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

It seems ok now, but there have been continual problems with the DSL at our place with this storm. Hope your power and net connection have been ok up in the hills...you guys usually get hit much harder.

I think it's ok, but I tossed another drive in my server as I saw some disk errors. Also took the opportunity to backup the configs, mail, and web content...:-/ If it does go, I can rebuild it pretty easily now. I'm hoping I don't have to, but we all know how that goes.

Hopefully it's ok now, this stuff takes away from my shop time! *grin*

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#11

Re: Some saw pix for Alan...PIX

Alan DuBoff

>Rob,

Wonderful saws! That $2 Beardshaw is the dank, I really like that handle, very unusual. Gives me some ideas to consider if I want to venture into that style.

Oddly I did stumble onto some info about the handles while digging through my stuff. In a copy of an article from a March 2006 publication in The Chronicle of the Early American Industries Association. I got the copy from Simon Barley, he is/was doing a study on Sheffield saw makers, I believe, and Simon knows quite a bit about old saws from the 18th and 19th century. This is primarily on American saws though, but it does note that the wood was much nicer on the English saws. This is what I like myself, you will often see handles with quarter sawn beech that contains nice ray fleck in it, I like that a lot. American handles mostly were poorer quality wood, and a thicker more durable finish on them. Some feel like paint to me, although some English saw do as well. AFAIK, Disston used Apple on most handles, with the exception of a few he used walnut on circa 1855, as noted in this article. I have never seen a Disston saw with a walnut handle on it, that I would keep.;-) The more modern handles that were beech which Disston used was not the quality of English handles, it was crap for the most part.

Oh, I just thought of something Simon had told me previously, and that is that the backsaws that have a larger bevel on the bottom of the back, those are most likely prior and up to 1850, then after that they changed to a smaller and less labor intensive bevel. Maybe to save manufacturing time???? (just speculation). There is also changes in the fonts used for stamping that can be used to date saws, but I don't know the specific fonts that well.

In this article they refer to the lamb's tongue as the lower carved base, and both the inside of the cheek and the top of the carved base as the upper and lower ogee curve respectively. They also show the Disston and McNeece handles with no lower carved base, and note it. That is to be expected, Disston was running the handles through machines, not rasping them. They don't say about the origin and don't refer to it as a lamb's tongue...:-(

I also really like the large arch'd horns that Sheffield saws are noted for, such as the top one on your web page. I also very much like the larger and more droopy cheeks, not sure if those are older or not, it's often more common on panel and full size handsaws, most likely as there was more area to work with on the cheeks due to the size of the saw.

Thanks for posting the great pics, I'll try to get some other pics of the saws I have that might be of interest, some of the ones I have found locally are American saws (Disston and similar) although I do prefer English saws, I have a hard time passing any of them up...I took a picture of my saw tills (LOL!) when I was digging through some...I am slightly embarrassed to say that this is not all of them..these are only vintage ones...(yikes!) See attached pic...(there is 3 Disston No 70s in the foreground;-)

I'm just finishing up a Holtzapffel bench that will go in that corner, I need to move all that wood out of there, that's my new hand tool shop! ;-)


img

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#12

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...

Don McConnell

>Hi Alan et al,

You have raised some intriguing questions - for which I only can offer some tentative and sketchy possibilities.

As far as I know, the earliest representation of a closed ("D") saw handle, dates from 1691. It appears in a Swedish book about shipbuilding, which has line drawings comparing English woodworking tools with those used in Sweden. (A. C. Ralamb, _Skeps Byggerij_ [Shipbuilding], 1691, Stockholm.). This is the representation of the English hand saw:


As you can see, there is neither a flat-bottom to the handle nor a lower carved base in the lamb's tongue form.

A similar illustration can be found in the trade card, of Plymouth (England) carpenter, joiner, and tool dealer, William Emmett, believed to date from 1731. It can be found, online, in a pdf file on the Davistown museum website:

http://www.davistownmuseum.org/PDFs/Vol8_AmToolmakers.pdf

Scroll down to page 25 for the image.

Next, is an illustration of a saw from the trade card of London planemaker and tool dealer, John Jennion. The card probably dates from 1732 to 1757, but the illustrations may, in fact, be from a slightly earlier era:


While some flourishes begin to show up on this handle, it seems generally similar to the previous examples, and still does not have the two features you asked about.

These three illustrations, I believe, begin to give us a pretty good idea as to what closed saw handles looked like during the last decade of the 17th century and the first two decades (plus) of the 18th century. Suggestive, I think, that the London pattern flat-bottom handle with a lamb's tongue lower carved base had not yet emerged.

The earliest saw, that I currently know, which exhibits the flat-bottom feature, is a tenon saw, marked "White," which Gaynor & Hagedorn show in _Tools: Working Wood in Eighteenth-Century America_, c. 1993, p.84. They characterize it as likely mid-century:


This saw was probably made by John White, whose (firm's) working dates are thought to be from about 1720 to 1780, in London. In addition to the flat-bottom, it also exhibits a "lower carved base," but I would characterize it as representing "scrollwork," rather than a lamb's tongue.

Which brings us to a broken hand saw (also shown in Gaynor & Hagedorn, p. 83), probably made by Birmingham saw maker, William Smith, whose working dates are thought to be circa 1718 to 1750:


This, as far as I'm currently aware, is the earliest saw to exhibit both the flat-bottom and the lamb's tongue version of the lower carved base.

It would be helpful to know more about the differences between Birmingham and London saw makers in that period, but, based on these two saws, I'm inclined to think that the White saw is a littler earlier than the Smith saw, which, based on Smith's working dates, would indicate that the White saw *may* be a little earlier than mid-century.

In any event, it would seem that the type of closed saw handle under consideration may have emerged sometime between the early 1730's and 1750. Though that is certainly subject to revision with additional data.

As to the term "lamb's tongue," I have no idea whether it would have been applied to this type of lower carved base during the eighteenth century. Stopped chamfers often ended with a diminishing reverse-curve feature, commonly referred to as a lamb's tongue. I haven't done the research to determine how far back that usage goes, but I think it is not a recent development. Since both decorative features could be similarly described, this terminology may have some merit.

Hope this helps a little.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#15

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...

Alan DuBoff

>Don,

Good to see you around, hope all has been well. You have helped a lot, because I just don't have much information on saws and/or saw making, so I was just digging like a chicken scratchin' in the 'coop.

Don wrote:

---------

This, as far as I'm currently aware, is the earliest saw to

exhibit both the flat-bottom and the lamb's tongue version

of the lower carved base.

---------

This piece so far is about the most helpful to try to date the origin and/or when it started to take hold. 1718 - 1750 is as much as anyone has to go on. Oddly, one of the things I had been thinking before is in your book (well, either you or Erv), in the introduction it does reference Moxon in regards to recommending carpenters and joiners buy their saws from some eight ironmongers shops in Foster Lane, London.

This is an interesting aspect in itself, in how it relates with this information you have provided in your response here on WC. Interesting in the sense that it would appear that London had already started to be the "ironmonger" marketplace towards the end of the 17th century, and the handles may or may not have started to take shape at this point, I am figuring that they were not, but since Moxon was recommending them, and the dates you have for Sheffield are similar. It seems it was Sheffield as I recall where toolmakers would specialize and offer services, as sub-contractors. Did this take place in London also? While London is known for "spring steel", Sheffield seems to be recognized as one of the great ironmonger marketplaces. IOW, a toolmaker would specialize on handles, or another on sharpening saws, or blades, or a guy would specialize in chisels, or other. Somewhere between that 1680 time, and 1718 - 1750 that you have listed above seems to when it starts appearing. Since it is called the London Pattern, I think it is worthy to note that it most likely started in London, but it certainly didn't take long to spread to, or dominate Sheffield.

Those 8 dealers that Moxon listed could have evolved the handle as such. Although you have the 9th dealer (listed as elsewhere in London) listed that seems to have started business in 1665, I think it's safe to believe that this was at the period the handle was possibly starting to evolve.

Also interesting to note Sheffield, as you date them to initiating an iron industry around 1650. Saw making seems to have been clearly evident by 1747, around the same time the saw above is dated, and the flat portion of the handle must have come from London Pattern due to the name.

It seems that the only better way to date any of this would be to find actual saws. If this could be drawn back to any of those 9 ironmongers of London who were in business from aprox. 1670-1745, did in fact produce the London Pattern style handle.

I especially like the details in the handles, such as the 2006 article I site refers to the small step as the "clip at ogee curve" at the front of the flattened section. I also noted they refer to the small tiny horn which is placed between the larger horns as a "nib" for both top and bottom of handle where the lower base arches up, or two horn arches down in the front, often resembling a W (To me that's the mark of the Wenzloff;-). That is the first I have seen those referred to as nibs, like the front of the saw blade nib.

I also like the heavy chamfer around the front of and around the bottom of the cheek, which they note in that article as being on older saws. Have you seen that Phil Baker article I reference?

Also interesting you mention the stop chamfers, because Chris Schwarz mentions in his book about the ramp being done with a chisel, traditionally. So clearly, craftsmanship was taking shape on saw handles in the early 18th century.

Now the $64k question. Anyone have any saws from any of these makers to compare? I know, probably ulikely as it would date the saw to almost 300 years, I don't have that old. I would love to see a 300 year old saw intact, I believe it is possible to find them. That would be a true gloat.

Henry Perris (or Pettis)

Anthony Poole

Thomas Benford (or Penford)

Mary East

Benjamin Bound

Edward & William Martin

John Garrard

Michael Plumber

Thomas Fowler

Lastly, could Mary East be one of the early women ironmongers of our time? In computers, Grace Harper was quoted with using the therm "bug". Maybe Mary East was responsible for fleam or something...??? LOL! (just kidding;-).

Thanks for reply, as always Don. I wonder if Joel has anything to add?

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#16

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...

Alan DuBoff

>Don,

One other note, I think it is interesting that the large handsaw you picture as possibly one of the earliest saws to exhibit the London Pattern style (flat area and carved lower base) has a large back on it. A most unusual saw, and maybe how backsaws came about???

Would be interesting to date the backsaw, and when they started to add strong folded backs to the blades to strengthen them.

Regards,

Alan (ironmonger in training;-)

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#17

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Alan,

At the recent conference in Williamsburg, the subject of 18th centruy toolboxes and tools was discussed. In talking about "Gents" toolboxes the subject of London ironmongers came up. According to Jane Rees (co-auther of the several books about English tools), the modern equivilaent of an ironmonger is a hardware store. They were buying goods wholesale from the manufacturers and selling retail to tradesmen.

In the case of the Benjamin Seaton chest, most of the tools were purchased from the planemaker and ironmonger Christopher Gabriel.

The subject of early saws was touched on and one of the things I found interesting was the development of saws with respect to the material used for the blades. Because the economic production of steel was not perfected until well into the 18th century, saws manufactured before then were sometimes made of iron as well as steel. Maybe Don McConnell could supply some dates about steel production. Because steel was not widely available during this period, if a saw was no longer useful as a saw it most likely would have been cut up into scrapers or otherwise re-used. It was suggested that that is the reason so few examples of 17th and 18th century saws have survived.

Jim

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#18

Re: Nothing like modern technology...

Alan DuBoff

>Scott said:

----------

To eat up shop time eh!

----------

No kidding...but I have the server out of the way, and it did turn out to be a disk. No good deed is without punishment though, and I got to fight with a permissions problems on the mail server.

With that done, I can think about making some sawdust this weekend!*grin*

We could use some of our Cali weather back though...

A friend of mine always says that global warming doesn't always mean it's gonna be warm!;-) I hope the wood fibers don't freeze up on my project, although I wonder if that would make the wood hand plane better??? gd&r

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#19

Tale of the lamb's tongue a old wive's tale?

Alan DuBoff

>I wanted to follow up with some information that was sent to me from Simon Barley, who I mentioned in this thread.

Simon asked around and none of his associates have heard the term lamb's tongue used in reference to the carved lower portion of the closed handle, although Simon reminded me that sash planes had a similar profile to them. Maybe it's an old wives tale? Either way I like the reference.

There is another handle that Simon has found referred to by more than one saw makers, notably in the 1830s, Spear and Jackson made a less than top quality saw line they termed "Lupton", and later Thomas Turner used the same "Lupton" name on their 6th quality saws. This is not a typo, he mentioned there were 6 quality levels of Turner saws evidentially, and there was 5 better than the Luptons. Turner's reference was later though, somewhere around c1890. Unfortunately, even with all the research that Simon has done, he hasn't been able to find any other reference or pics of what the Lupton handle was.

These nicely hand carved lamb's tongue handles were at the opposite end of the spectrum, IMO, and I would imagine that many of the top of the line saws had them, from various makers, or other hand carved work, or that beautiful work on Rob's $2 Beardshaw.

I think I've learned a little more in pondering this stuff, in comparing my own, talking with other saw makers, and other research, along with Simon's help over the past couple years...to me the significance is that the English saw makers evolved much of the handles as they are today, both open and closed handles. To me the late 18th century up to the late 19th century is the pinnacle of handcrafted saws. After that point in time, when the 2nd phase of the Industrial Revolution took hold, electrically powered machine changed not only saw making, but most crafts, for the long term.

I really associate handsaws with the 1st ("phase") industrial revolution, and the older English certainly seem to be the roots of the modern handsaw as we know it.

Now day's, handsaws seem niche, and in fact might be one of the reasons I'm attracted to them...;-)

Now I wonder where that heater is to thaw out some of my wood, so that I can work it...*grin* (we ain't in Cali anymore Toto!;-)

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#20

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb...

Don McConnell

>Alan wonders about:

"Would be interesting to date the backsaw, and when they started to add strong folded backs to the blades to strengthen them."

This has emerged as a contentious issue - and I probably would be smarter to stay away from it. But, I guess I'm willing to delve into, at least briefly, as I think it an important one.

Specifically, the issue boils down to the problematic question as to whether Joseph Moxon, in his _Mechanick Exercises_, ca. 1680, mentions "back saws" or not. In the bulk of his text, and in the primary "joinery" illustration, Moxon clearly equates the "Tennant-Saw" with a bow/frame saw. Part of that text reads:

" ... The Office of the Cheeks made to the Frame-Saw is, by the twisted Cord and Tongue in the middle, to draw the upper ends of the Cheeks closer together, that the lower end of the Cheeks may be drawn the wider asunder, and strain the Blade of the Saw the straighter. ..."

However, the very next sentence reads: "... The Tennant-Saw, being thin, hath a Back to keep it from bending."

As I said, this is very problematic, and several explanations have been put forth in an effort to resolve the fact that the two sentences appear to be describing different types of saws.

One explanation has been that Moxon may have meant that a back was affixed to the web of the bow saw in order to stiffen it. This makes no sense to me. He's already described the purpose of the frame as stiffening the blade, so a back would be redundant. Additionally, if the web were relatively narrow, any back affixed to it would severely limit the depth it could cut. This seems completely impractical for largish tenons.

Another explanation has been that the second sentence was simply a different description of the frame saw. Again, I find this untenable, as he had already clearly described the tensioning effect of the bow saw, and a differing description of the same type of saw is completely redundant. And unnecessarily confusing.

Another explanation has been that Moxon simply didn't intend what the second sentence appears to mean. This, to me is the most problematic explanation of all. While the alternative is that these two sentences appear to be confusingly describing two different types of saws, this seems less problematic, to me, than assuming that Moxon didn't mean what he wrote.

So, I feel that this is the earliest known mention of a back saw, though I can't really explain the dichotomy between the two sentences. Though, the latter sentence may simply have been added as an afterthought, if Moxon were familiar with back-type tenon saws and belatedly realized that he'd made no mention of them.

In any event, the first uncontested (as far as I know) mention of back saws is to be found in Richard Neve's _The City and Country Purchaser's and Builder's Dictionary_, 3rd edition, 1736:

"The Tenon-saw, or Tenant, used

for fine Stuff, with a Back to it; So

call'd from being used to make Te-

nons for Mortises."

So, to recap, I think there is reasonable evidence that back saws were around as early as 1680, and strong evidence supports their existence by 1736.

Though you didn't ask, I have also been interested in the earliest mention of back saws other than tenon saws. The earliest mention we've found, so far, of a "duftail saw," is from Nov. 9, 1749. This in a Thomas Maule advertisement in the _Pennsylvania Gazette_. Maule also ran an advertisement in the same paper on December 25, 1750, which mentions "tenant," sash and dove tail saws.

The earliest mention of a carcase saw that I've found, so far, is the 1800 Christopher Gabriel inventory.

I want to publicly thank Brian Welch for tracking down the Neve mention, as well as the Maule ads in the _Pennsylvania Gazette_." I don't know if he follows WoodCentral, or not, but I wanted to make sure to give credit where it's due.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Closed Saw Handle and tales of the lamb... *LINK*

#21

small correction

Don McConnell

>Just wanted to set the record straight concerning the earliest mention, that I'm privy to, of a carcase saw. Rather than it being in the 1800 Christopher Gabriel inventory, it is in the inventory, done in 1797 by Benjamin Seaton, of the tools in his chest. Sorry about the confusion.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR