What is up with this? *LINK*
David Miller from Iowa
>Isn't this just a brass repro someone made using the original as a pattern?
Why is it in demand?
brass router plane on ebay
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What is up with this? *LINK*
David Miller from Iowa
>Isn't this just a brass repro someone made using the original as a pattern?
Why is it in demand?
brass router plane on ebay
Re: What is up with this?
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>Unless I'm ignorant of Stanley's practices, the seller may be misrepresenting a bit - he implies that it's a factory product. I just went out and measured my slightly newer one, and the base dimension quoted is exactly the same, which implies that it's not a patternmaker's knockoff using an original as the pattern (since a casting from the original would be slightly smaller). Would be interesting to put a magnet next to it and find out if it's just brass-plated.
Re: What is up with this?
Luban White
>Have seen one just like it recently at work... solid brass afaik. No other info for you other than the fact its not a one off.
I can take magnet to it if you're eager to know for sure.
Re: What is up with this?
Todd Hughes
>The only reason it sold this much is because of one bidder with 0 feedback bidded it up to the reserve price, other wise it would probably have sold for $20 which was the highest price anybody else bid.
Is a plane made by a pattern maker or foundry man using an original stanley for a pattern. These things are pretty common and i have seen more then a few, often they will be presented as a rare factory bronze experimental plane or some such crap. I have a brass one as well as one cast in aluminum which is a bit more uncommon. Besides routers I have seen entire bench planes made up. Even though more uncommon then a factory plane they normaly don't sell for a premium over the factory ones.
Ebay auction is a good example of it you don't put the bait in the water you ain't going to catch no fish .....Todd
Re: What is up with this?
Marv
>Often times an auction of this kind is bid up by a shill, a friend of the seller. And it isn't surprising for the shill to have zero feedbacks.
On another note, how is it possible for a tool of this kind to be authenticated, or does it come down to just a guessing game...buyer beware kind of thing? How can you look at a picture of this plane and conclude for sure that it's a knockoff? Is there anything specific that can be pointed out for us dummies?
Marv
Re: What is up with this?
Wiley Horne
>Hi Marv,
On the 'knock off' issue....Patrick Leach has made quite a study of things Stanley, and he states flatly in "Blood and Gore" that Stanley never made a yellow-metal No. 71, and that the ones you see are made by patternmakers, using an original Stanley as a pattern. Patrick and Todd are on the same page of the hymnbook about this.
For reference, go to www.supertool.com, click on Stanley Blood and Gore, and then look up No. 71.
Wiley
Re: What is up with this?
Marv
>Wiley,
Very informative.....I see now how one in the know can easily tell the difference between a true Stanley and a knockoff in this case. Stanley just didn't make the #71 out of brass or yellow metal.
In all fairness to alot of sellers on eBay, alot of them find old tools at estate sales and go by what someone who they think knows everything about tools tells them. They know not what they do....
Marv
I agree Marv,
Wiley Horne
>my experience with Ebay sellers is that they are trying to make an honest living, but many are selling tools they don't know much about. You can tell, because many times someone will write in a question, and the seller will very confidently give them an answer that is just plain wrong (Yep, this Yankee brace has nice wooden grips).
This particular seller may have been told wrong, or more likely may have just jumped to his own conclusion that he had come across this incredibly rare and valuable tool. Who knows, maybe someday the market for patternmaker copies will be comparable to that for the originals.
Wiley
Re: A bit OT......
Marv
>Wiley...
LOL...I remember that auction for a yankee brace. I used to take the time to send a seller a message and correct them...but in my old age, I find I have better things to do. Everyone in the world knows that the No.2101 brace has composite handles and are deemed unbreakable. As far as I know Stanley continued with that type handle after buying out Yankee North Bros. I have a small collection of them, the "BEST" brace ever made. Did I say "BEST"?
Marv
Shills
Todd Hughes
>I don't think in this case it was shill bidding. If you look at the bidd history you will see where one other bidder did $20 then the 0 feedback guy got in and bid a bunch of times till he hit the sellers reserve of $99.
A shill is used to run up other bidders bids , the idea is not for him to win the item unless maybe the seller thinks it is going to low. If the shill was used he would have stopped as soon as he outbid the other bidder,in this case no need to "Protect" the sellers because he had a $99 reserve. The winning bidder didn't know the reserve price and that was why he had to bid so many times to find it....Personaly I think when you see somone bid this many times in order to hit a reserve or to outbid sombody it sort of shows they are either not an experanced bidder and don't know what they want to pay or are an emotional bidder that just has to have somthing and keep bidding just a little bit more to do so.....Todd