help selecting marking gauge
jon gaynor
>Gents,
Can I get some feedback on selecting a high quality knife-type marking gauge? I'm attending a joinery class. I have been warned off Crown. Thanks for additional ideas.
Jon
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
help selecting marking gauge
jon gaynor
>Gents,
Can I get some feedback on selecting a high quality knife-type marking gauge? I'm attending a joinery class. I have been warned off Crown. Thanks for additional ideas.
Jon
Re: help selecting marking gauge
paul womack
>Can I get some feedback on selecting a high quality knife-type marking gauge?
I would buy an old "pin" marking gauge that seemed OK, and convert it.
Changing to a knife is quite easy to do quickly, and rather satisfying to do well.
For some reason knife type marking gauges AKA cutting gauges are much rarer than the pin type.
BugBear
Re: help selecting marking gauge
Steve Hamlin
>Hi Jon
Suggest look for one with a clamping mechanism like Paul's pic.
I know of gauges by Les Outils Cullen Tools and, of course, Colen Clenton which fit the bill. (No doubt there are others)
The problem with wedged gauges such as the Crown, is that unless the wedge's mortice is tapered/reamed (depending whether square or turned wedge) to match the wedge, then either the angle at which the blade presents is not parallel to the stock or it is free to deflect during use.
I am not aware of any so tapered, though it isn't difficult to do - just means a thicker wedge is needed.
The other objection that your tutor may have had to Crown is cutter steel quality - though replacing the cutter with a shaped jigsaw blade or similar is easy enough.
Cheers
Steve
Re: help selecting marking gauge
Tony - Memphis
>Well, its not a knife, but is sort of, but I like the wheeled type from Lee Valley. It feels good in the hand (mine anyway) and it cuts real well. I do think it is a bit harder to get a good deep cut with it though not enough to make a big difference. I own a crown too. Mine works just fine. The cutter is way too soft, but you can harden it up a little (maybe I got a bad one?). I made mine round instead of pointed. I also modified it to fit my grip better (was inspired by seeing what Phil Lowe had done to his when I took a class at his place once). You could always make one too! And don't forget Ebay.
Tony
Re: help selecting marking gauge *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>My favorite guage is by Kinshiro, although he's mostly retired and you have to wait.
I use one of these...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>Also a LV wheel one too.
Re: help selecting marking gauge *LINK*
charlie belden
>Glen-Drake Tite-Makr (tm).
The link below - and the next page - shows it and why it's my recomendation for a marking gauge.
charlie belden
http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/MT/MTprimer10b.html
Wow, you people are good
David Miller from Iowa
>I just use a regular pin gauge, but I filed the pins into a chisel shape. The accuracy of that tool far exceeds my skill to saw to the line.
Now if one is building a collection of gauges just for the sake of it, that is another story altogether.
David
Re: help selecting marking gauge
David Charlesworth
>BB,
Very nice job. Did you tap the stem or use an insert please?
David
Re: help selecting marking gauge
paul womack
>Very nice job. Did you tap the stem or use an insert please?
chuckle. I thought the insert was nicely visible in the photo, just above the blade.
BugBear
Re: help selecting marking gauge
paul womack
>My favorite guage is by Kinshiro, although he's mostly retired and you have to wait.
Price:US$ 188(Shipping cost:US$ 22)
(helpless laughter)
BugBear
Re: Wow, you people are good
paul womack
>I just use a regular pin gauge, but I filed the pins into a chisel shape. The accuracy of that tool far exceeds my skill to saw to the line.
Yep, a tip publicised by David Charlesworth.
But I find shaping and honing a removable blade easier than working on a small round pin; the large curve I can put on the blade also (IMHO) makes the gauge "run" nicely, albeit with a slight tendancy to follow the grain.
Since I'm normally using is to mark cross grain or end grain, this tendancy is not (in practice) an issue.
BugBear
Re: help selecting marking gauge
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>Bugbear,
In the thread to which you linked above, you made reference to "...a 3/16 BSF thread..." From my automotive days, I understand references to British Standard Fine threads to refer to the Whitworth thread pattern and matching spanners (with their bizarre references to at least two different sizes of bolts for any given spanner, depending on whether the thread is coarse or fine). So: is the Whitworth pattern still in common use there on the little island, has the term transferred to a newer thread pattern, or are you just a true traditionalist?
Bill, who was pleased to give his brother a full set of Whitworth wrenches for Christmas one year, thus enabling said brother in his fantasies about MG-TDs and Jag XK120s.
Insert
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>I can't speak for David Charlesworth, but I thought the insert was a pressure foot, and I remember thinking, when I saw the picture, "Wonder if he used one of those thread-into-the-wood inserts, and, if so, how he did it without splitting the wood?" Very clever solution on your part, BB - one I need to keep in mind for other projects.
And once you mark your line with a $188 gauge
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>you use one of those saws from your $4,000 saw kit to cut the line...
Re: And once you mark your line with a $188 gauge
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>OK, laugh on, but all the cost is in the blades, and the result is superior. I've wasted at least $300 on various gauges trying to find such superior operation, now I've got to sell them. Penny wise, pound foolish.
Pam
Oh, yeah, and I only paid about $150 plus S/H.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>
Re: And once you mark your line with a $188 gauge
Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario
>I bought the same one Pam (I think on your recommendation),
I Love it!
Hmmm, now for the penny wise part, what can I sell...
:-)
Take care,
Jim
Re: And once you mark your line with a $188 gauge
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Sounds like you lucked out, didn't have to go through those years trying this and that. I have to say that there's not one really bad one in my collection, but sure would be nice to have that time and money back. Whenever I think about acquiring a tool set, I bemoan the end of apprenticeships, during which you at least have the opportunity to try many tools with expert direction.
Pam
Wiley probably recommended this one, too.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>
fair comment - apols to you and DC
paul womack
>
Re: help selecting marking gauge
paul womack
> So: is the Whitworth pattern still in common use there on the little island, has the term transferred to a newer thread pattern, or are you just a true traditionalist?
The latter; since I buy second hand stuff, and like it, I have rather a large accumulation of old taps, old dies, old nuts and old bolts, so I used them...
BugBear
thus ensuring
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>that a future buyer will conclude that this is one of those rare cutting gauges made by Morris Garages (or possibly Morgan) mechanics for use in making repair parts for the chassis. I can picture the eBay ad now...
No apology needed
Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA
>you were just more clever than I would have been.