Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

Posts

Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#1

Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Below there was a discussion of bench flatness and its importance in planing thin lumber. I am smitten by English style drawers with their thin sides, which involves planing thin drawer sides- 1/4 to 3/8".

I stick this thin lumber to a piece of 3/4" plywood with double sided tape. Usually a piece on the trailing end of the board is sufficient. The thick plywood is fixed to bench in the usual way. I am usually planing with the long grain of the bench. What ever flatness the bench is works to make adequate drawer sides and the thin stuff is nicely immobilized by the tape against the force of planing. I have planed stuff 1/8" thick with this arrangement. Because the tape is pulling against the planing force, the thin piece is in tension, not compression and it does not buckle like it can with an end stop.

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#2

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatne *LINK*

MikeW

>Hi Bill,

Yes, a planing board is a great accessory to a bench--and it doesn't have to be used on a bench that isn't flat for the reasons you give.

though I too use one, I don't find flex an issue and have an end stop on mine.

Below is a link to Chris S's blog concerning a planing board.

Take care, Mike


George Ellis' planing board

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#3

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatne

David Charlesworth

>Bill,

That is a good method.

Sometimes I use a couple of drops of super glue gel, as this is thinner than tape and can easily be fractured to retrieve the stuff.

It also works for planing home made inlay lines. The trick here is to fix two about 2 inches apart, so that the plane can be kept horizontal.

I take a shaving off each one alternately.

best wishes,

David

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#4

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatne

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

That reminds me. Today I was planing sides that were 9mm thick - a tad under 3/8". One of the nice things about boards this thin is that, when you need to remove a little tearout and you want to plane just over the spot, you can bend the board slightly to raise that area. Then it is a simple matter of planing a slight crown.

(Well I don't know if that is verboten. I just do it :) )

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#5

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatne

paul womack

>Yes, well...

The point is that the surface on which the workpiece lies must be "flat enough". If one chooses to use a (sufficiently accurate and rigid) planing board, the flatness of the bench becomes irrelevant, since the workpiece is now constrained by the planing board, not the bench.

For small work, one might find flattening a planing board less arduous than flattening a large bench.

BugBear

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#6

tell me more....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I like this idea. Quicker than getting the backing peeled off the tape. Do you put the glue on a "waste" end of that to be planed, or is that unnecessary? I have not used this adhesive in this sort of application, but I use it for sticking down hinges to scribe them. Will the adhesive break and not pull wood slivers out of the thin stock?

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#7

help me to understand importance of flatness

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Why is bench/board flatness so important in planing thin stock? I would suppose the most common thin stock planed would be a drawer side, say 20" long. My planing board is an arbitrarily chosen piece of 3/4' plywood; whatever is at hand at the time of need. And I plane this side with a 12" long plane.

Case 1 Planing board ( or bench) is 0.010 high in the middle of this 20" length. I would presume the plane would follow the hump more or less. So, I suppose that something between 0 and 0.010" more could be removed from the middle of this drawer side than from the ends. Actually I think I would tend to plane a taper, which would be untaperd when I reversed the piece to plane the other side.

Case 2. Planing board is 0.010 low in the middle. To some extent the plane is going to bridge over this hollow and the middle of the drawer will be between 0 and 0.010" thicker in the middle.

After assembly of the drawer it will be suspended over yet another board of some sort ( in my case another piece of plywood nearly the depth of the drawer and planed to yield about 1/32" clearance in the drawer opening. It is common for me to have to plane a few more shavings from the front, or rear, of a drawer during fitting, I suppose because the case is not perfect..

I can't see how substrate flatness, be it bench of board, will affect drawer construction or fitting.

Now I just finished a bunch of boxes and trays for Christmas presents whose board thickness is 5/16 to 3/8". These are dovetailed affairs. Again I don't, and didn't, see any impact of the flatness of my plywood piece clamped to a bench that assuredly is not flat.

Admittedly, if the lack of flatness was well beyond 0.010" I can see problems. In that case I select another piece of plywood.

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#8

Re: help me to understand importance of flatness

Paul Kierstead

>Admittedly, if the lack of flatness was well beyond 0.010" I can see problems. In that case I select another piece of plywood.

I don't understand your question. You clearly agree that if it isn't flat there is a problem, the only difference would be to what tolerance you have arbitrarily decided is good and what someone else has arbitrarily decided.

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#9

Re: help me to understand importance of flatness

wilbur

>One other thing to consider about the flatness of the planing surface and thin stock is that the stock may flex to accommodate the hollow or bump, so that you may not get the result you expected, much like how you're supposed to joint one side of a board flat before feeding it through a planer.

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#10

Re: tell me more....

David Charlesworth

>Bill,

No, probably/certainly some damage, so I ensure excess length so that the damaged ends can be rejected.

I like the hinge idea! I have used same technique for very small inlay.

David

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#11

Don't follow

David Miller from Iowa

>Wibur - don't follow your assertion that one should joint an edge before using a "gasp" power planer (confession - I have one of these).

In those "rare" (ahem) instances where I use the monster (I might be one the wrong forum here) I do the edges after power planing - with a hand plane (back on the right forum again).

Doing the edges prior to table sawing is common.

David

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#12

Re: Don't follow

wilbur

>My fault -- by "side" I meant "face". I was referring to the need to make sure one face of a board is flat before putting it through a planer, otherwise you'll have a curved board with parallel faces.

And I have a powered planer, too. Actually, it's a jointer/planer combo machine.

Re: Planing thin lumber on bench of unknown flatness

#13

Re: flat

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I think we might be missing the point on bench flatness. A person who first picks up a hand plane and puts it to use may be in for an eye opener. I can't really remember the exact first time I tried to use a hand plane, but I remember the feeling of wondering what in the world all the romantic talk about planing was about. The thing wouldn't take a shaving without terrible tearout, it would shave some sections of the board and not others, etc. etc. ad infinitum. The point is that using a plane is a skill. You have to understand certain concepts.

1) The iron has to be sharp. I remember thinking that people who talked about shaving with a plane iron were pulling my leg. As a matter of fact, they were serious.

2) The iron has to be held rigid in such a way that it doesn't move in the plane. This means a flat solid surface under the iron; as the iron bites into the wood there is a downward pressure on the iron. If the iron moves from the pressure it will dig into the wood, taking a deeper cut than intended, causes tearout and various other frustrations.

3) The bottom of the plane needs to be a flat plane. If it is bent one way or another the iron will not make a steady contact with the board, causing it to remove wood in some areas and not in other areas depending on where pressure is applied on the plane.

4) The wood has to be supported on a flat surface. If it is not, it will cause the same issues as having a plane that is not flat on the bottom. The plane will remove wood only in the high areas and not in the low areas. If the board is not on a flat plane, it will not be made flat.

So these are the basics of planing. If these four areas (did I misss anything?) are not covered, the plane will not work well. And this is where we run into the problem. We have all sorts of questions now. For instance, how sharp is sharp enough? How do you explain this to someone in a book, or while telling them? How flat is flat enough? This question applies to the bottom of the plane, the bench, and the work. How do you explain to someone how to support a board in such a way that it is "flat" and the plane will function well? Obviously what is "flat enough" for some people will not be enough for others. My goal is to never stop learning throughout my life. I think when someone stops learning they get a feeling of being useless.