WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

More bench discussion *LINK*

Posts

More bench discussion *LINK*

#1

More bench discussion *LINK*

Alan Schwabacher

>I like the way Chris Schwarz's workbench book engaged me in a discussion of features, and reasons for the features of benches; I'd like to continue that discussion.

One bench that meets most of the criteria, though it breaks many of the rules, is John White's bench, linked below. It is held together with screws, though it takes wood movement into account to avoid loosening up, and is built of framing lumber even more frugally than the Nicholson bench. I've not used one, but it's pretty solid, though clearly not the the degree specified by Chris.

Most of the attention to this bench has been to the two embedded pipe clamps used as a tail vise. This seems functional, but with the thin top would seem to limit the extent to which the top can be used as a flat reference surface. Incidentally, in the video he clamps down a small tabletop over a gaping hole for surface scraping. I presume that for planing he would have replaced most spacer blocks to help support the work.

I'd like to point attention to White's planing beam. I think this thing looks great -- much better than a sliding deadman. Interestingly, it requires an overhang of the benchtop over the legs, but then pays you back for that in workholding because the back edge of the planing beam is flush with the benchtop edge.

I think the biggest difference between White's solution and Schwarz's ones is that White is interested in holding the work, but does not appear to think it needs to be locked down quite as firmly as Schwarz does.

While the design is strictly utilitarian, and will not appeal to many, I'm curious what people think. I want something resembling the planing beam in my next bench. I was figuring on a heavy top. Maybe I'll make the legs flush on one side with an overhang on the other, so I can try both to see which side I prefer.


Video of John White's Bench

Re: More bench discussion *LINK*

#2

Re: More bench discussion

James Watriss

>I do like that the book has kicked off this discussion.

I do like the frugality of the bench. This is a key thing for me, because I don't like the idea of spending an arm and a leg to get started in woodworking. I've spent too much, and sold too much.

I think the planing beam is in part a solution to something that you pointed out, that the work may not be held as tightly by just using pipe clamps. I'm not trying to light a fire here, I have a feeling that the clamps will do a really good job. If the work isn't held as tightly, at least the beam will keep it well supported. That said, I think a sliding deadman or board jack would do just fine for this. I think the level he added is a neat trick, but I have to say, I think it's a bit much. I just reference with my fingers for the whole edge to be about the same amount over the top of the bench. And the level may be accurate, but that doesn't say anything about whether the top of the bench is level.

I dunno. I think it's a great concept. But it looks like it'd be kinda springy to me, instead of solid. I'm not saying it'd loosen, just that if a 280 lb bruiser like myself got up and jumped on it... well, if it didn't break, it would certainly wiggle. I don't think that's the be all and end all test of a bench's usefulness. Nor is it a complete deal breaker. But I do think it's noteworthy that we didn't see him throwing a heavy jointer around while planing, and there wasn't any BANG CRASH style brutality involved. He used a scraper and a block plane.

Not saying it's a bad bench. I'm just being a natural skeptic. It's a great concept, but one that could be easily beefed up a little.